Beamer has made a name for himself with those not on this board

bayrooster

All-American
Aug 21, 2003
14,250
6,997
113
Could simply be a reflection of the writer's opinions and expectations of the two programs. Heupel has done well - at a program that is top 15 in the nation in overall wins. Beamer has done not-quite-as-well - at a program that is, well, us.

Imagine, for example, if Beamer had coached at Vandy the last 4 years and achieved identical results. He would, undoubtedly, be universally touted as one of the best coaches in America and probably would have swept all conference and national coach of the year awards last year. In that way, I guess we can take some solace that he isn't #1 on this list.
While we're making fantasy arguments (those of us in the real world know Beamer would never have identical results at Vandy)... if Beamer had got us 10 wins in ANY season while our head coach "he would, undoubtedly, be universally touted as one of the best coaches in America and probably would have swept all conference and national coach of the year awards."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Uscg1984

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
1,900
2,524
113
While we're making fantasy arguments (those of us in the real world know Beamer would never have identical results at Vandy)... if Beamer had got us 10 wins in ANY season while our head coach "he would, undoubtedly, be universally touted as one of the best coaches in America and probably would have swept all conference and national coach of the year awards."
Yep, I think so too.
 

kidrobinski

Senior
Jul 27, 2004
662
607
93
He was punked in the bowl game. 🙂
Lol. The officials were allowing Goodfella Fatmanito to get away with what other teams had been penalized throughout the year for, and in some cases having allowed the offense to just snap the ball. If that’s what you want to call punked, be my guest. Ashamed to be a gamecock is not particularly admirable in my view.

We left nine points on the field, hence the loss.
 

Gamecock Jacque

Joined Dec 20, 2020
Jan 30, 2022
4,413
4,387
113
Lol. The officials were allowing Goodfella Fatmanito to get away with what other teams had been penalized throughout the year for, and in some cases having allowed the offense to just snap the ball. If that’s what you want to call punked, be my guest. Ashamed to be a gamecock is not particularly admirable in my view.

We left nine points on the field, hence the loss.
You're conveniently leaving out that he also acted like a child in front of the whole world.
 

Gamecock Jacque

Joined Dec 20, 2020
Jan 30, 2022
4,413
4,387
113
:)

Risk-adjusted returns (ala Sharpe Ratio) consistently has shown that teams with top-10 recruiting classes (e.g. BAMA, UGA, etc.) achieve high win percentages (0.870+) with low variability (yielding high ratios -- e.g., 2.5-3.0).

At the elite schools, "finding the right coach" is more a function of "don't F this up."

We don't have that luxury -- especially in this NIL environment.
It's one thing for the program to have middling results. It's quite another to actually aspire for middling results. Yeah, we wouldn't want to F that up would we?
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
7,188
7,506
113
Can you elaborate? Stats were almost dead even across the board and they did come in #20 in the country.

My impression was that we didn't have a versatile back to replace Rocket which turned us into a one-dimensional offense.

As a result, Illinois D was able to contain Sellers and forced him to throw it around more than desired.

On defense, we were simply missing key guy and couldn't get the pressure we had throughout the season.

We'll have to see if the staff has been able to fill some of these holes in a few weeks.
The Sellers we saw in that game was not the same player we saw vs. UPC or even against Missouri and certain other opponents. The coaches wanted him to refrain longer from running when the call was a pass. If anything, because of the Sanders factor, he needed to be more unabashed. You'll never convince me that Illinois on a neutral field should have been a loss when UPC in the Valley wasn't.
 

kidrobinski

Senior
Jul 27, 2004
662
607
93
You're conveniently leaving out that he also acted like a child in front of the whole world.
Not leaving out anything; Beamer’s actions didn’t bother me. I believe the only observers that saw it as childish are those who believed the storied South Carolina program deserved better than the likes of Shane Beamer and will use any opportunity to sniggle like children themselves.
 

Cobie

Sophomore
Jul 2, 2025
243
109
43
The Sellers we saw in that game was not the same player we saw vs. UPC or even against Missouri and certain other opponents. The coaches wanted him to refrain longer from running when the call was a pass. If anything, because of the Sanders factor, he needed to be more unabashed. You'll never convince me that Illinois on a neutral field should have been a loss when UPC in the Valley wasn't.

No doubt they game-planned Sellers differently than if he had been playing in the playoffs and that was probably smart.

Again though, I think not having Rocket as a weapon in the backfield was a pretty big deal as well.

Those two played off each other all season and were 80-90% of our offense.

There was little upside to have Sellers running around like a bat out of hell tryiing to earn Cheez-it bowl trophy.

On defense, did any of the 6 who ended up in the NFL draft play in that game?

Good Big Ten teams typically bring strong fundamentals.

They did just that and we didn't have the SEC-level skill players playing in that game to overcome.

Bama got beat in a similar fashion a couple of hours north.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski

Cobie

Sophomore
Jul 2, 2025
243
109
43
It's one thing for the program to have middling results. It's quite another to actually aspire for middling results. Yeah, we wouldn't want to F that up would we?

What does this mean Botman? Explain how we are aiming for "middliing results."
 

kidrobinski

Senior
Jul 27, 2004
662
607
93
Has always been the qbs fault amongst the savvy non-football people. Blake Mitchell. Jake Bentley. Stephen Garcia. Jason Brown. The poor guy from Colorado St that came in here and was pulverized every game; I truly admired that guys toughness. Even Spencer Rattler lol; the only guy tougher than the Colorado st guy. Now it’s Beamer, because apparently we think someone may make fun of us. A stout lot. And savvy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cobie

Lurker123

All-Conference
May 4, 2020
4,035
3,395
113
Not leaving out anything; Beamer’s actions didn’t bother me. I believe the only observers that saw it as childish are those who believed the storied South Carolina program deserved better than the likes of Shane Beamer and will use any opportunity to sniggle like children themselves.

I would disagree. Spotrscenter covered it. Sports illustrated wrote an article afterwards calling him a meme. Maybe its more than just some posters who hurt your feelings.

 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: kidrobinski

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
7,188
7,506
113
Not leaving out anything; Beamer’s actions didn’t bother me. I believe the only observers that saw it as childish are those who believed the storied South Carolina program deserved better than the likes of Shane Beamer and will use any opportunity to sniggle like children themselves.
Nope, not in my case. The past had nothing to do with it. This stood alone.
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
7,188
7,506
113
No doubt they game-planned Sellers differently than if he had been playing in the playoffs and that was probably smart.

Again though, I think not having Rocket as a weapon in the backfield was a pretty big deal as well.

Those two played off each other all season and were 80-90% of our offense.

There was little upside to have Sellers running around like a bat out of hell tryiing to earn Cheez-it bowl trophy.

On defense, did any of the 6 who ended up in the NFL draft play in that game?

Good Big Ten teams typically bring strong fundamentals.

They did just that and we didn't have the SEC-level skill players playing in that game to overcome.

Bama got beat in a similar fashion a couple of hours north.
I don't give a crap how Bama lost, but how do you think THEIR fans felt about it? I know, you don't care how their fans felt about it, either. You'll have a hard time selling how they game-planned Sellers as "smart". Hayuhl, we had a winnable game to play. All that matters is the game at hand.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bubba Fett

Cobie

Sophomore
Jul 2, 2025
243
109
43
I would disagree. Sports illustrated wrote an article afterwards calling him a meme. Maybe its more than just some posters who hurt your feelings.


Take off your dress, Lurker. It's going to be OK.

No one remembers/cares about some benign exchange between a couple of college football coaches over half a year ago.

This world found a way to move on. :)
 

Cobie

Sophomore
Jul 2, 2025
243
109
43
I don't give a crap how Bama lost, but how do you think THEIR fans felt about it? I know, you don't care how their fans felt about it, either. You'll have a hard time selling how they game-planned Sellers as "smart". Hayuhl, we had a winnable game to play. All that matters is the game at hand.

I just don't think you have Batman running around the field all day when Robin is nowhere to be found.

That's a crappy risk/reward situation.

The better angle would have been to hammer them on defense but we were at half mast.
 

Gamecock Jacque

Joined Dec 20, 2020
Jan 30, 2022
4,413
4,387
113
What does this mean Botman? Explain how we are aiming for "middliing results."
Someone mentioned being happy with 7 win seasons a damning assessment. You disagreed. And now you're asking for someone to explain how 7 wins is middling? We will continue to observe this soft-shelled skull creature. In the wild. 🙂
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
7,188
7,506
113
I just don't think you have Batman running around the field all day when Robin is nowhere to be found.

That's a crappy risk/reward situation.

The better angle would have been to hammer them on defense but we were at half mast.
You and I are in a "never the twain shall meet" situation. I suspect it won't be the last time. I thought then, think now, and will continue to think that the loss was unnecessary and even embarrassing.
 

Cobie

Sophomore
Jul 2, 2025
243
109
43
Someone mentioned being happy with 7 win seasons a damning assessment. You disagreed. And now you're asking for someone to explain how 7 wins is middling? We will continue to watch this soft-shelled skull creature. In the wild. 🙂

You prolly need to go back and read that exchange for mental clarity.

Jacque - Any shot you or Stock could become the de facto BOTs for exchanges? You're definitely one of the sharpest of them all and I typically enjoy your one-line zingers. Or maybe you and Stock? Stock is almost always of good cheer.
 

Cobie

Sophomore
Jul 2, 2025
243
109
43
You and I are in a "never the twain shall meet" situation. I suspect it won't be the last time. I thought then, think now, and will continue to think that the loss was unnecessary and even embarrassing.

I think it's just a sign of the times honestly.

We grew up in an era when teams/players put 100% effort into a game regardless of the circumstances.

Today's game is more about risk analysis/what's best for the team versus fan satisfaction.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski

Gamecock Jacque

Joined Dec 20, 2020
Jan 30, 2022
4,413
4,387
113
You prolly need to go back and read that exchange for mental clarity.

Jacque - Any shot you or Stock could become the de facto BOTs for exchanges? You're definitely one of the sharpest of them all and I typically enjoy your one-line zingers. Or maybe you and Stock? Stock is almost always of good cheer.
But we're all the same person according to you. 🙂
I'm in good cheer. I rarely take internet forums all that seriously. You disqualified yourself from intelligent exchanges with "new age" OL schemes lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Cobie

Sophomore
Jul 2, 2025
243
109
43
But we're all the same person according to you. 🙂
I'm in good cheer. I rarely take internet forums all that seriously. You disqualified yourself from intelligent exchanges with "new age" OL schemes lol.

You certainly are.

Both you and Stock likely reside in Botman's Prefrontal Cortex -- a region of empathy.

BOTs like Lurker (snarky & grudgy) likely reside in the Amygdala borough of his brain.
 

kidrobinski

Senior
Jul 27, 2004
662
607
93
  • Like
Reactions: Cobie

kidrobinski

Senior
Jul 27, 2004
662
607
93
Someone mentioned being happy with 7 win seasons a damning assessment. You disagreed. And now you're asking for someone to explain how 7 wins is middling? We will continue to observe this soft-shelled skull creature. In the wild. 🙂
And continue to be baffled, apparently.
 

Tngamecock

All-Conference
Sep 10, 2000
29,257
2,213
113
Illinois has Brett B as its coach…..their curse has been realized. 125-80 record. His ceiling has been reached and he aint getting better. He’s fat, boring, moves no needle, and is in the Mark Stoops hierarchy of coaching.

We lost in a bowl game…that sucks but these aren’t your daddy’s bowl games these days with opt outs and transfers. The day is coming where players start opting out of playoff games.
 

Go Gamecocks

Senior
Jan 19, 2021
831
731
93
...but these aren’t your daddy’s bowl games these days with opt outs and transfers.
That ship has sailed.....the FSU v UGA debacle was clear evidence.

Pretty sad....win the bowl game and then ask who'd we beat? Same with losing....who'd we have xfer/opt out?

Even the final season rankings are skewed...those are not the same teams that played 12 reg season games. ☹️
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
7,188
7,506
113
Illinois has Brett B as its coach…..their curse has been realized. 125-80 record. His ceiling has been reached and he aint getting better. He’s fat, boring, moves no needle, and is in the Mark Stoops hierarchy of coaching.

We lost in a bowl game…that sucks but these aren’t your daddy’s bowl games these days with opt outs and transfers. The day is coming where players start opting out of playoff games.
Let's just do away with all postseason games when that happens and go back to the polls.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tngamecock

Piscis

Senior
Nov 30, 2001
23,454
977
113
Let's just do away with all postseason games when that happens go back to the polls.
Bowl games are only played to make money (tv money almost exclusively) for the bowl and the city hosting the bowl. Unless it is a major bowl, the teams and the schools generally lose money by going. They no longer have any real importance. Even the "extra bowl practices" thing has been made meaningless with the new relaxed restrictions on organized offseason "workouts".

FCS teams nor the NFL have any sort of ridiculous post season exhibition games. If teams in those leagues don't make their respective playoffs, their seasons are over. FBS football should follow their lead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KingWard

bayrooster

All-American
Aug 21, 2003
14,250
6,997
113
Even the "extra bowl practices" thing has been made meaningless with the new relaxed restrictions on organized offseason "workouts".
And the transfer portal. How would extra practices benefit the players who may be transferring before the next season (or those who may be joining from the portal). Without the majority of starters committing to at least 2 seasons, there is no benefit from "extra practices" while preparing for no-name bowl games.
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
7,188
7,506
113
Bowl games are only played to make money (tv money almost exclusively) for the bowl and the city hosting the bowl. Unless it is a major bowl, the teams and the schools generally lose money by going. They no longer have any real importance. Even the "extra bowl practices" thing has been made meaningless with the new relaxed restrictions on organized offseason "workouts".

FCS teams nor the NFL have any sort of ridiculous post season exhibition games. If teams in those leagues don't make their respective playoffs, their seasons are over. FBS football should follow their lead.
I have come to the same conclusion; been driven to it actually.
 

Lurker123

All-Conference
May 4, 2020
4,035
3,395
113
Hasn't been that long ago when it meant something.

Kinda hard to believe that Jadeveon's last game was a bowl game before any NIL $$ was around.

I stubbornly still watch the bowls. Transfers or not, I just still do. As one fanatical watched even the "tiny" bowls, I can agree on the dwindling interest.