Best steak you’ve ever had

Drcats2025

Heisman
Nov 13, 2012
7,928
15,699
63
Being the fata** I am, let’s talk food. I love a good steak, and personally have a 2 way tie for my favorite. Shades cafe in middlesboro Kentucky has a fantastic ribeye; much better than the faux Kobe beef ribeye I had at Malone’s for 3x’s the price. My other favorite is the bison ribeye from Ted Montana’s. Good lord that was amazing. For the price, hard to beat a good pan seared steak made from home, though, and I almost always go ribeye.
 

BlueRaider22

All-American
Sep 24, 2003
15,562
9,058
0
Pappas Brothers Steakhouse in Dallas.

I’ve eaten at Malone’s, numerous Ruth’s Chris, Jeff Ruby’s, Tony’s, and many other high dollar places across the US. All are great....especially if you’re not paying.
 

Drcats2025

Heisman
Nov 13, 2012
7,928
15,699
63
It's hard to screw up a good steak. Really. Start with a good cut Tbone at room temp. Smear it in extra virgin. Sprinkle some kosher salt both sides. A little coarse ground black pepper. Put it on the grill. I like to add a bit more olive oil during the cook. Maybe just a bit more kosher salt. This is the best steak way. Period. People who swear by filet mignon are on the right track, but few of them know it's nothing more than the circle part in the middle of a good t-bone.
It’s been a while since I’ve had a nice t-bone, as i almost always go ribeye. You now have me wanting one.
 

It'saDoneDeal

All-Conference
Jul 24, 2007
19,233
4,379
113
Never found a restaurant steak that can compete with doing it at home. Best steak I’ve had was a perfect reverse sear a few years ago: consistent pink through the middle, crunchy crust, was awesome. Slightly below that I’d go with a sous vide.
 

Drcats2025

Heisman
Nov 13, 2012
7,928
15,699
63
Never found a restaurant steak that can compete with doing it at home. Best steak I’ve had was a perfect reverse sear a few years ago: consistent pink through the middle, crunchy crust, was awesome. Slightly below that I’d go with a sous vide.
Sous vide? Sounds fancy. Tell me more.
 

ImUTGagain

All-Conference
Sep 14, 2010
2,337
3,102
0
Never found a restaurant steak that can compete with doing it at home. Best steak I’ve had was a perfect reverse sear a few years ago: consistent pink through the middle, crunchy crust, was awesome. Slightly below that I’d go with a sous vide.

But with sous vide do you get the crust that a good sear makes? Or sear then sous vide? I'm asking....
 

cricket3

Heisman
May 29, 2001
18,990
19,410
113
Malones ribeye is $45 including a side and salad, so the best steak you’ve ever had was $15? You can’t even get a ribeye by itself for $45 at a real high end steakhouse.
 

Rupp'sRunt

Heisman
Apr 19, 2008
14,675
20,094
0
those damn sweet potatoes too....
All the sides are pretty ******* good. Salads are a little overrated. Always wanted to get the seafood tower but I'm not dropping 87$ on an "appetizer". Usually just get an extra beam and coke for dessert while my family eats the sweets. I'll take the alchy buzz over a sugar rush.
 

Insurance Junkie

Redshirt
Apr 21, 2011
418
37
0
But with sous vide do you get the crust that a good sear makes? Or sear then sous vide? I'm asking....

You have to cast iron the steak to get the sear after being in the sous vide for 45 mintues at 129 degrees for the perfect medium rare. It is the best steak by a mile you can make at home. Never overcooked.

Go to Amazon and get one for $120. Anova is the one i got with the blue tooth. I can turn it off from my phone.

I was impressed with the steak, but really chicken is what makes having a sous vide worth it. I don't care how you cook chicken almost everyone technically over cooks it. Not with sous vide. Perfect every single time.

No i was not paid for this glowing endorsement. Have owned it for about 45 days and use it 5 times a week for something.
 

Drcats2025

Heisman
Nov 13, 2012
7,928
15,699
63
Malones ribeye is $45 including a side and salad, so the best steak you’ve ever had was $15? You can’t even get a ribeye by itself for $45 at a real high end steakhouse.
The one at shades is like $23, wise guy. Also the one I got at Malone’s was a faux Kobe beef steak that I ignorantly paid like $60 for.
 

Rebelfreedomeagle

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2017
2,529
4,627
113
Meat eaters are the Hitlers of the animal kingdom

As for me, I give Tony's the win over Ruth's Chris. Both are stupid expensive but damn good. I didn't even put any ketchup on them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tinker Dan

ImUTGagain

All-Conference
Sep 14, 2010
2,337
3,102
0
You have to cast iron the steak to get the sear after being in the sous vide for 45 mintues at 129 degrees for the perfect medium rare. It is the best steak by a mile you can make at home. Never overcooked.

Go to Amazon and get one for $120. Anova is the one i got with the blue tooth. I can turn it off from my phone.

I was impressed with the steak, but really chicken is what makes having a sous vide worth it. I don't care how you cook chicken almost everyone technically over cooks it. Not with sous vide. Perfect every single time.

No i was not paid for this glowing endorsement. Have owned it for about 45 days and use it 5 times a week for something.

Ah I see. So its seared after. Anything go into the pan with the steak after the sous vide process?

Never had steak prepared this way but as you mentioned its great for chicken. Had the application applied to chicken many times...
 

BernieSadori

All-American
Nov 16, 2004
30,278
8,935
0
Hard to say "the best". I think atmosphere has a lot to do with how good we sometimes perceive the food to be.

Having said that, my personal favorite was at Ramsey's Steakhouse in the Paris hotel. 24 oz. bone-in Rib eye.
 

Insurance Junkie

Redshirt
Apr 21, 2011
418
37
0
Ah I see. So its seared after. Anything go into the pan with the steak after the sous vide process?

Never had steak prepared this way but as you mentioned its great for chicken. Had the application applied to chicken many times...

It is odd when you pull the steak out and it looks like a piece of rubbery meat (no pun). After you sear the steak mushrooms with butter in the steaks juices is tops.

I failed to mention you need a vacuum sealer ($50 a walmart) as you seal the meat and place it in the water in the bag.

All I can say is the sous vide is the single best purchase for $100 I have ever made. Have you ever wanted a good steak but not wanting to fire up the grill b/c it is 10 degrees outside? Problem solved.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlbanyWildCat

BBdK

Heisman
Sep 21, 2003
159,783
74,127
0
Yeah, that's false. I'd cook circles around you and anyone else that's posted so far in this thread. Better stick with Claims, bub.



I have a Big Green Egg & and an Anova...and cook a very nice steak -- but not dumb enough to think I can match an 1800 Degree Broiler and the quality of beef the best steakhouses hand pick...not to mention their aging processes -- and any home cook that thinks they can is dumb.




You're a simpleton. Don't fret, there are TONS of them around here.
 

BernieSadori

All-American
Nov 16, 2004
30,278
8,935
0
I have a cast iron skillet, Jeff Ruby's rub, and butter. While it's a fine steak to eat at home somehow it's no match for a 1,800 degree broiler.