As someone who attended private schools from 1st grade through college and who sent three kids to private schools from K through grade 12, I don't know very much about teacher unions, and I have a few honest questions:
1. Can a public school teacher choose not to belong to his/her union?
2. If the answer to the above is yes, are there social consequences for that teacher from his/her peers who are union members?
3. Are there school districts without teacher unions?
4. When a school district must make budget cuts and lay off staff, how can the union look at parents and kids and taxpayers in the eyes and say that it is okay protect a long-time teacher with poor performance reviews while letting go of a highly effective and dedicated newer teacher earning less salary?
5. Since public school districts operate as a tax-funded monopoly where parents often have no realistic educational alternative for their children, what controls are in place to prevent a teacher union from prioritizing its members' demands over the public’s financial and educational interests?
6. Due process is needed to protect against arbitrary firing, but the legal cost and time required to dismiss an ineffective tenured teacher union member often results in the district taking the path of least resistance and keeping that teacher in the classroom. At what point does protecting an ineffective union member’s job security become secondary to the educational needs of the students in that classroom?
I think you should take these questions to your next school board meeting. Seriously, they'd probably love to discuss this with you... they should WANT to discuss this with you. If not, well then find some new school board members with your next vote.
I am also a private school person, K-12 myself, my kids are attending private. I don't believe because the teachers in private schools don't strike that they care more about their students than a public school teacher.
Why should I care though? Well my tax dollars are funding public schools that my kids will never attend... and I'm ok with that.
What is the average salary for a teacher in the state of Illinois?
Do you find this to be fair compensation?
Do you believe compensation directly affects an employees outcomes? i.e. low pay equals low output, higher pay equals more productivity
We know some facts...
75% of schools in Illinois don't have the full resources they need with many districts reporting they are operating at less than 65% of their adequacy and resource needs.
The fed is not supplying as much to the public education sector as it has in the past.
Covid relief funds (ESSER) are gone.
Does this mean we should withhold teachers salary needs, or demands to try and supplement funding inadequacies within the districts?
Would we allow this in the private/corporate/non-education areas? example: Healthcare, Banking, or industrial
What is the solution without taxation?
Do you agree that educating children should be the burden of the state/federal government?
Do we restructure public schools/education to a corporate capitalist model, or at worst a similar structure to that of private schools, and force them to provide for themselves? Would this work?
Edit: Because this is where I was leading with the last questions... Does the state of Illinois currently have too many public districts, most especially in the rural/non-urban counties?
Just trying to discuss, I'm not criticizing you and hope you can understand and see that. I find your questions genuinely good, and wish more folks would ask them to their school boards often...