Cake or Icing

Which is the best part?


Results are only viewable after voting.

MGGA

New member
Oct 21, 2020
288
670
0
Which is the best part? Don't say, "both." You're not funny.
 

Atrain7732

New member
Dec 11, 2009
3,782
7,018
0
Cake not even close

Down here in SE FL Publix makes a mean cake. Their icing is good as well but almost too rich.
 

drawing_dead

Active member
Nov 21, 2005
863
1,362
88
cake
buttercream/Crisco icing suuuucks. only icing that is acceptable is the lighter Cool Whip based versions.
 
Dec 1, 2020
1,733
1,383
47
Icing easily. One year when I was a kid I told my mom just get me a can of icing, no need to make a cake lol
 

IdaCat

Well-known member
May 8, 2004
68,840
33,166
113
I usually scrape off most (or all) of the icing from store bought cakes. It's just overly sweet cheap sludge only applied for cosmetic purposes. Canned icing is ****.

The most consistently good store bought cakes I've found were in Europe.
 

Rebelfreedomeagle

Well-known member
Feb 24, 2017
2,529
4,627
113
Cake. People keep making fancy cakes and loading them up with so much icing that I scrape most of it off. I
 

roguemocha

New member
Jan 30, 2007
12,943
6,587
0
Both are pretty disgusting and overwhelming. I don’t like sweets so I don’t get how people can eat more than a bite of that sugary garbage. I’d rather have another plate of food, which is what I do when it’s dessert time for the family.

#TeamSavory
 

Glenn's Take

Well-known member
May 20, 2012
12,473
14,646
113
I hear ya. Really the only day of the year I actually crave dessert is Thanksgiving, because I need my pumpkin pie (and pecan pie if someone brings one).

Past that, I do enjoy dessert but rarely seek it out
Chips are a different story. Those are my weakness.
 

BlueRaider22

New member
Sep 24, 2003
15,562
9,058
0
I hear ya. Really the only day of the year I actually crave dessert is Thanksgiving, because I need my pumpkin pie (and pecan pie if someone brings one).

Past that, I do enjoy dessert but rarely seek it out


I'm like this as well. I do love chocolate though......not chocolate cake, not really brownies, but plain chocolate or the occasional candy bar. I do like pies.....pumpkin is awesome and most fruit pies are great too.

I really don't like ultra-sweet things. Icing/frosting, candy corns, jolly ranchers, white chocolate, suckers, etc.......yuck.
 

HagginHall1999

Well-known member
Oct 19, 2018
15,812
28,208
113
Do yourself a favor, pickup one of these bad boys.


The answer is cake and it is by a mile. I'm not even a huge fan of cake or sweets in general.

When I do have them...litterally a few times a year, my favs are key lime pie, lemon meringue, the tortuga and a jello cake.
 

Bigblue2023

New member
Jun 22, 2019
2,236
6,984
0
Cake by a long shot. This question is an accurate portrayal of your level of maturity. Icing is for children…