College Playoffs

HuntinAces

Joined Sep 9, 2014
Sep 9, 2014
1,428
667
113
There was faint hope winning out would catapult us into the 12 team playoff.
Obviously crushed and gone.
However, next year we move to 24 teams.
If it were 24 teams this year, do you think winning out would have us in? If so, do you think we would deserve it? Does that change your current opinion on moving to a 24 team playoff?
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo

Harvard Gamecock

All-Conference
May 5, 2014
3,470
3,184
113
 
  • Haha
Reactions: I4CtheFuture

I4CtheFuture

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2024
2,264
2,095
113
1) Yes
2) Yes - wins over ranked UF, TN, and #1 UGA + Clemson would be hard to argue against.
3) No - looking forward to it.
 

I4CtheFuture

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2024
2,264
2,095
113
The Arkansas game was a red line. Does South Carolina deserve being in the playoffs with losing to Arkansas late in the season on their resume? I would say no.
It could be argued both ways. - What if Arkansas wins out? - Then all of a sudden that loss doesn't look quite as bad.
 

Deathstar

Senior
Sep 6, 2026
761
580
93
Maybe it’s better that we found out that we don’t belong now against the second worst team in the SEC, rather than blundering into the playoffs and playing like we did in the one SEC Championship game we played in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 92Pony and Uscg1984

HuntinAces

Joined Sep 9, 2014
Sep 9, 2014
1,428
667
113
1) Yes
2) Yes - wins over ranked UF, TN, and #1 UGA + Clemson would be hard to argue against.
3) No - looking forward to it.
I’ve resigned myself to the fact, the only hope we will have of sniffing a natty is in a 24 team playoff.
Personally I’m looking forward to it because when top tier bowls started to lose their luster/meaning it was time for change.
 

Psycock

Joined Jan 20, 2001
Jan 29, 2022
1,226
1,358
113
Glasses can be half-full or half-empty. Wins over Florida, Tennessee and Oklahoma look better than at the time we won those games. Kentucky is good but not Top Ten good. Mississippi St. was good when we played them then they crumbled after they lost Kamarrio.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
765
322
63
There was faint hope winning out would catapult us into the 12 team playoff.
Obviously crushed and gone.
However, next year we move to 24 teams.
If it were 24 teams this year, do you think winning out would have us in? If so, do you think we would deserve it? Does that change your current opinion on moving to a 24 team playoff?
Yep. If we were to beat UGA and Clemson, we would probably be in next year. Why? Because the committee now takes into account things like you're entire first string was not available for the ARK game. Although, if we beat UGA and Clemson, they probably would have us in either way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HuntinAces
May 27, 2012
1,261
836
113
Not making 24 team playoff could possibly be the end for Beamer. As mentioned, 3 or even 4 loss team could make playoffs. IMO, without Briles, odds are he will not meet expectations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HuntinAces

HuntinAces

Joined Sep 9, 2014
Sep 9, 2014
1,428
667
113
Yep. If we were to beat UGA and Clemson, we would probably be in next year. Why? Because the committee now takes into account things like you're entire first string was not available for the ARK game. Although, if we beat UGA and Clemson, they probably would have us in either way.
Personally, I feel injuries will have less of an impact on the committee when the field expands
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,167
3,731
113
I find it very sad that gamecock nation's greatest hope for getting into the playoff isn't that the team will play great, win a lot of games and deserve a spot, but that the playoff will expand until the field backs up enough to take us in.
 

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,876
3,741
113
Not making 24 team playoff could possibly be the end for Beamer. As mentioned, 3 or even 4 loss team could make playoffs. IMO, without Briles, odds are he will not meet expectations.
I think one of the (few) real benefits of a 24-team playoff is that it will finally provide a real and objective standard for most P4 teams' expectations for a coach. We can all start being honest and agreeing that going 6-6 or 7-5 with a trip to the Beef-O'Brady Bowl or Pinstripe Bowl was not a "met expectations" kind of year and shouldn't earn bonuses for the coach. Like basketball, the measure for most coaches will be how many playoff trips they made during their tenure. For the blue bloods, of course, they will expect to not only go every year, but to win a couple of games when they get there. But for a school like Carolina, our AD will have to decide if making 2 or 3 trips in a 5 or 6 year stint meets the expectations. Going 0-fer in 5 or 6 seasons probably won't.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HuntinAces

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,167
3,731
113
I think one of the (few) real benefits of a 24-team playoff is that it will finally provide a real and objective standard for most P4 teams' expectations for a coach. We can all start being honest and agreeing that going 6-6 or 7-5 with a trip to the Beef-O'Brady Bowl or Pinstripe Bowl was not a "met expectations" kind of year and shouldn't earn bonuses for the coach. Like basketball, the measure for most coaches will be how many playoff trips they made during their tenure. For the blue bloods, of course, they will expect to not only go every year, but to win a couple of games when they get there. But for a school like Carolina, our AD will have to decide if making 2 or 3 trips in a 5 or 6 year stint meets the expectations. Going 0-fer in 5 or 6 seasons probably won't.
There are 67 P4 teams. 24 teams is 36% of P4 teams. I know a couple G6 teams will get a sympathy invite, but that still means 33% of P4 teams will be in the playoff. ADs and fan bases will have to come to an honest assessment of what they really are as a football program. They will have to decide if they really are in the top 1/3 of P4 football programs and set expectations accordingly.

Historically, South Carolina is not in that top 1/3. Does Donati place the expectation of SC being something it has never really been on the head coach? I am not sure it would be fair for a coach at SC to be judged against that standard.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 TheBigSpur Football South Carolina is No. 21 and that gives the Gamecocks a needed boost
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Football CFP Chair Hunter Yurachek explains why South Carolina is still ranked after blowout loss
  3. 03 GamecockCentral Football Everything Georgia HC Kirby Smart said about South Carolina before Week 12 matchup
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Basketball Three burning questions ahead of South Carolina's matchup with Elon
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Football Recruiting South Carolina football's team recruiting ranking following ratings updates