Collins has to go

lunker35

Sophomore
Jan 1, 2010
5,678
164
62
I’m not going to knock the kids, but he recruited all of them. He’s had ample time and the development and product he’s put out has been horrific. That was an abortion of a game topping off truly miserable season. They’ve been unwatchable for years now. We need change....
 

NUChicago

Junior
Aug 23, 2001
3,683
248
63
I’m not going to knock the kids, but he recruited all of them. He’s had ample time and the development and product he’s put out has been horrific. That was an abortion of a game topping off truly miserable season. They’ve been unwatchable for years now. We need change....
Before the game I thought we would have lost today or tomorrow, so it is what it is. As for Collins, it's been 8 years and the team is awful.
 

GatoLouco

Sophomore
Nov 13, 2019
5,636
116
63
I said in the beginning of the season 7 wins was the expectation. Above would be over achieving, below would make me swing to the camp of CC has to go now and not by the end of next season.

Well here we are. Not going to happen, no AD, buyout, etc. But I wish it did
 
Aug 31, 2003
14,966
440
83
I was happy with the final three games of the regular season.

We finally have seniors next season. Collins deserves to sink or swim based on what happens next season.
 

SDakaGordie

Sophomore
Dec 29, 2016
2,359
162
53
Let’s just remember that we haven’t had a decent point guard since McIntosh. Amazingly, given the poor results, Collins has a few potential good ones in the mix next year.
 

lunker35

Sophomore
Jan 1, 2010
5,678
164
62
I was happy with the final three games of the regular season.

We finally have seniors next season. Collins deserves to sink or swim based on what happens next season.
I found myself being miserable watching the vast majority of our games this year. That’s multiple years in a row now that this has happened. My 6 year old twins have started rooting for the opponents because “Northwestern never wins”. Things have to change. All the other sports at this school can achieve success. We can’t be this consistently awful.
 

TheC

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
19,102
1,171
62
I found myself being miserable watching the vast majority of our games this year. That’s multiple years in a row now that this has happened. My 6 year old twins have started rooting for the opponents because “Northwestern never wins”. Things have to change. All the other sports at this school can achieve success. We can’t be this consistently awful.
That’s the bottom line. With a couple of exceptions, it just hasn’t been any fun to watch NU games the last few years.
 
Aug 31, 2003
14,966
440
83
That’s the bottom line. With a couple of exceptions, it just hasn’t been any fun to watch NU games the last few years.
And changing coaches guarantees that for a few more years. I'm willing to keep the coach for one more year and see what he can do next season when he finally has seniors.
 

TheC

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
19,102
1,171
62
And changing coaches guarantees that for a few more years. I'm willing to keep the coach for one more year and see what he can do next season when he finally has seniors.
Just delaying the process for another year.
 

NJCat

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2016
21,327
1,502
113
And changing coaches guarantees that for a few more years. I'm willing to keep the coach for one more year and see what he can do next season when he finally has seniors.
A sign of insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results......
 

SDakaGordie

Sophomore
Dec 29, 2016
2,359
162
53
That’s the bottom line. With a couple of exceptions, it just hasn’t been any fun to watch NU games the last few years.
Really - that’s the bottom line? It’s not fun to watch? Give me a break, and give the coaches and players some credit. We are so much more athletic than years past, and at a level that’s much closer to most teams now. We are trying to play the game that recruits want to play, and we’re competitive in way more games than any time in the last 34 years I have been watching. We just aren’t quite as talented basketball-wise up and down the lineup, and that has overall consequences that aren’t always pretty or “fun”. But our enjoyment factor is not the bottom line. This is still college athletics, and that means something to NU and many of its supporters.
 
Aug 31, 2003
14,966
440
83
Just delaying the process for another year.
We've had one coach EVER who took us to the Big Dance. And that was after inheriting a complete rebuild from Carmody. He built that team.

We have no seniors this season. Let's see what he built next season. We DID improve this season from the last; we doubled our conference win total from last season.

I don't understand why you're so EAGER to give up on these players, who did improve this season, and GUARANTEE a rebuild next season with a new coach.
 

NJCat

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2016
21,327
1,502
113
We've had one coach EVER who took us to the Big Dance. And that was after inheriting a complete rebuild from Carmody. He built that team.

We have no seniors this season. Let's see what he built next season. We DID improve this season from the last; we doubled our conference win total from last season.

I don't understand why you're so EAGER to give up on these players, who did improve this season, and GUARANTEE a rebuild next season with a new coach.
It's been 8 Years, and just 2 wining seasons. The last 4 years NU finished 10th, 14th, 13th and 12th. All of the players have been Collins recruits, coming off the unicorn NCAA season you reference. NU has the facilities to compete now, just doesn't have the players or the player development you expect of a B1g 10 program. And that is on Collins and his staff.

I would not be surprised for the new AD to find some arcane recruiting infraction or the Vassar law suit to fire him for cause and avoid the huge buy-out........
 
Aug 31, 2003
14,966
440
83
It's been 8 Years, and just 2 wining seasons. The last 4 years NU finished 10th, 14th, 13th and 12th. All of the players have been Collins recruits, coming off the unicorn NCAA season you reference. NU has the facilities to compete now, just doesn't have the players or the player development you expect of a B1g 10 program. And that is on Collins and his staff.

I would not be surprised for the new AD to find some arcane recruiting infraction or the Vassar law suit to fire him for cause and avoid the huge buy-out........
I HAVE criticized Collins in the past (especially about the Vassar situation). If he doesn't win next season with HIS seniors, then I'll be calling for his head, too. That would mean that this rebuild has failed.
 

jensberg

Sophomore
Jul 28, 2006
2,928
122
63
He should be gone and yes many of the players will leave as well and we will have a few more years of terrible records but at least if we change the future might be better with Collins it won't
 

NJCat

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2016
21,327
1,502
113
I HAVE criticized Collins in the past (especially about the Vassar situation). If he doesn't win next season with HIS seniors, then I'll be calling for his head, too. That would mean that this rebuild has failed.
Fair enough.
 

NUCat320

Senior
Dec 4, 2005
19,469
495
0
Let’s just remember that we haven’t had a decent point guard since McIntosh. Amazingly, given the poor results, Collins has a few potential good ones in the mix next year.
Imagine where this program would be with Lathon!

😂🤪😂🤪
 

GatoLouco

Sophomore
Nov 13, 2019
5,636
116
63
There’s a very good chance the bottom of the conference gets better next year even if overall the conference doesn’t. Probably doesn’t bode well for us with our dubious progression.

Let’s assume CC is gone and multiple players leave. Which we don’t actually know they would. I’d now prefer to start rebuilding next season. Instead of burning another year just to have to rebuild anyway. It seems, like Thanos, inevitable given the body of evidence.
 

IdahoAlum

Freshman
May 29, 2001
3,832
85
0
I think we all know Collins isn’t going anywhere with no AD and a huge contract commitment. But if the team continues to struggle next year and the fans and boosters pull the plug, the new AD will have no choice to make a change.
 

Styre

Senior
Oct 14, 2004
7,732
403
83
There’s a very good chance the bottom of the conference gets better next year even if overall the conference doesn’t. Probably doesn’t bode well for us with our dubious progression.

Yup. People are touting our recruiting class, and it is very good by our standards, but Nebraska, for example, has a better one that includes a five-star recruit. So there's no reason to just assume they'll remain in the basement.

The team has improved from "barely better than Nebraska" to "solidly better than Nebraska and competitive with Minnesota for 12th place when Minnesota loses its best players and quits on the season." Great?
 

SDakaGordie

Sophomore
Dec 29, 2016
2,359
162
53
We only have 80 years to teach us that it’s a bit hard to recruit at NU. Let’s just slot someone else in here; things will of course change for the better.

If his 3 top 150 incoming recruits all decide to decommit, and/or we lose Nance and Kopp, I’ll come over to the fire Collins side.
 
Jun 18, 2005
4,040
135
0
Really - that’s the bottom line? It’s not fun to watch? Give me a break, and give the coaches and players some credit. We are so much more athletic than years past, and at a level that’s much closer to most teams now. We are trying to play the game that recruits want to play, and we’re competitive in way more games than any time in the last 34 years I have been watching. We just aren’t quite as talented basketball-wise up and down the lineup, and that has overall consequences that aren’t always pretty or “fun”. But our enjoyment factor is not the bottom line. This is still college athletics, and that means something to NU and many of its supporters.

I get that you’re probably the most pro Collins guy on this board right now (totally fine) and I find merit in some of the points you’ve made, but this one really misses the mark. This team is not fun to watch.

The starting lineup has players with multiple seasons of experience, yet puts up 46 points when their season is on the line against a depleted Gophers squad. How could anyone enjoyable that?

You say you’ve watched 34 years of Northwestern basketball, but as for watchability, I’d much rather observe the gritty, defensive minded teams of the early Collins years. Same goes for the late era Carmondy teams that were near the top of the BIG in offense. How about Brydsong’s 1993-94 group? That team was much more satisfying than the current product out there.

Shoot, I might even prefer one of Bill Foster’s teams with Rex Walters or O’Neil’s NIT run (which says alot because I find little redeeming about that man) over the 2020-21 version of Northwestern basketball. Those squads were less talented top to bottom, but they played a more pleasant brand of basketball.
 
Last edited:
Aug 31, 2003
14,966
440
83
Yup. People are touting our recruiting class, and it is very good by our standards, but Nebraska, for example, has a better one that includes a five-star recruit. So there's no reason to just assume they'll remain in the basement.

The team has improved from "barely better than Nebraska" to "solidly better than Nebraska and competitive with Minnesota for 12th place when Minnesota loses its best players and quits on the season." Great?
Competitive with Ohio State and Maryland, too.
 

lunker35

Sophomore
Jan 1, 2010
5,678
164
62
We only have 80 years to teach us that it’s a bit hard to recruit at NU. Let’s just slot someone else in here; things will of course change for the better.

If his 3 top 150 incoming recruits all decide to decommit, and/or we lose Nance and Kopp, I’ll come over to the fire Collins side.
Oh stop looking back. What we have now is far different than anything anyone else ever had. Hell I hated Carmody but he was playing with different tools.
 

NJCat

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2016
21,327
1,502
113
The team has improved from "barely better than Nebraska" to "solidly better than Nebraska and competitive with Minnesota for 12th place when Minnesota loses its best players and quits on the season." Great?
"Solidly better than Nebraska" who NU barely beat with a bucket in the last 3 seconds at home after leading by 16 points.........
 

SDakaGordie

Sophomore
Dec 29, 2016
2,359
162
53
I get that you’re probably the most pro Collins guy on this board right now (totally fine) and I find merit in some of the points you’ve made, but this one really misses the mark. This team is not fun to watch.

The starting lineup has players with multiple seasons of experience, yet puts up 46 points when their season is on the line against a depleted Gophers squad. How could anyone enjoy that?

You say you’ve watched 34 years of Northwestern basketball, but as for watchability, I’d much rather observe the gritty, defensive minded teams of the early Collins years. Same goes for the late era Carmondy teams that were near the top of the BIG in offense. How about Brydsong’s 1993-94 group? That team was much enjoyable that the current product out there.

Shoot, I might even take one of Bill Foster’s teams with Rex Walters or O’Neil’s NIT run (which says alot because I find little redeeming about that man).
Thanks for the reply. My point was really that being fun to watch is not the criteria to judge them. I totally agree it’s not fun overall to watch the last few years, and we’ve had some good moments in the past that you point out. But I don’t agree that not being fun to watch is an outright indictment of the coach or players / is the key lens to view things. In my view, we are closer to achieving success than what we all think. For example, shots we take now are often rushed because guys don’t get the ball quickly in the right spot. If we can get some guys to distribute the ball better, things can improve a lot quickly. And things generally must get worse before they get better, especially when you are trying to make long lasting, real change (i.e., play like the big boys play and find the guys that can play that way).
 

Styre

Senior
Oct 14, 2004
7,732
403
83
"Solidly better than Nebraska" who NU barely beat with a bucket in the last 3 seconds at home after leading by 16 points.........

Again, I mean in the standings. But no, it isn't reassuring that as soon as 14th-place Nebraska stopped playing like crap they almost beat us.
 

SDakaGordie

Sophomore
Dec 29, 2016
2,359
162
53
Oh stop looking back. What we have now is far different than anything anyone else ever had. Hell I hated Carmody but he was playing with different tools.
I just don’t buy that facilities are a top determinant as to where a basketball player chooses to play. Look at Duke. There are many reasons we still / always struggle to recruit.
 

lunker35

Sophomore
Jan 1, 2010
5,678
164
62
I just don’t buy that facilities are a top determinant as to where a basketball player chooses to play. Look at Duke. There are many reasons we still / always struggle to recruit.
Facilities and institutional support. We have/had that now more than ever.
 

Gladeskat

All-Conference
Feb 16, 2004
116,627
1,823
113
A sign of insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results......

No, it isn't. It's just a grossly overused quote falsely attributed to Einstein that has little to do with diagnosing insanity. Diagnostic symptoms of insanity can include repetition of nonsensical comments but don't include any expectation of results. The quote, stated differently, first arose out of Al-Anon and Narcotics Anonymous meetings. That may be true for substance abuse but not insanity.

Sorry for going "Sheldon" here, but the constant use of this fake quote on diagnosing insanity bugs me.

I'd give CCC another year. That might be insane, as would having Ryan Young repeatedly play PG, but to expect any sort of result is not a part of a diagnosis.
 
Last edited:

NUera

Redshirt
May 29, 2001
6,387
31
35
A sign of insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results......
That’s the story of NU hoops. Ditch the academic standards and level the playing field or keep banging your head against the wall.
 

Sec_112

Sophomore
Jun 17, 2001
6,600
199
63
I'm at the point where I don't blame anyone who wants Collins gone. But it's a moot point.

It's a bad situation that could be made worse under these circumstances:

a) I REALLY don't want any coach who's desperate enough to take a job without an AD in place.

b) I'd HATE to see a new coach brought in by some silly committee.

You want to see the NU program take another step back. These far-fetched circumstances would scream "the old NU."

Get the new AD in here, and don't harness that person with any restrictions. Give him/her a clean slate.