Come on home...

WVUFanForever

Redshirt
Oct 1, 2004
13,368
20
0
Another banner thread from the resident dumbass....

Boy...if you are going to troll, pick up game ***** cus this is weak.


What a **** lmao
 

Chris from WV

Redshirt
Jul 5, 2002
626
26
0
If people were honest, I think more and more WVU fans/alumni would be favorable to Rich coming back if they thought he would be able to win again.
 

xWVU2010x

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2006
138,425
4,629
0
If people were honest, I think more and more WVU fans/alumni would be favorable to Rich coming back if they thought he would be able to win again.
He wouldn’t win, that’s the biggest problem. People act like Brown didn’t have a better resume coming from that level of football. 10 win seasons in FCS, Sun Belt, etc means nothing for a coach’s P5 outlook. It has been 10 years since his last flirtation with P5 relevance, his last great season at WVU might as well have happened in a different sport given the landscape changes since.
 
Last edited:

WVUFanForever

Redshirt
Oct 1, 2004
13,368
20
0
Then you are an *******. What a stupid mf statement.
You are the *******

His record at Michigan 15-22.

He last 3 years at Zona 17-21....get your dick of out his ***.....you would be crying at the top of your lungs to fire Brown with his marks.
 
Last edited:

Rootmaster

Redshirt
Apr 16, 2011
9,238
31
0
He wouldn’t win, that’s the biggest problem. People act like Brown didn’t have a better resume coming from that level of football. 10 win seasons in FCS, Sun Belt, etc means nothing for a coach’s P5 outlook. It has been 10 years since his last flirtation with P5 relevance, his last great season at WVU might as well have happened in a different sport given the landscape changes since.
Your opinion is just...your...opinion.
 

westsiderSJHS77

Redshirt
Aug 9, 2008
2,800
1
0
Rich may of had to tone down his coaching style from his “spot the ball” hustle to the line way of doing thing when he first showed up at WVU. Cussing a player out for not giving the ref the ball, taking the ball and kicking it up into the stands and making the player run up and get it would not work with this new age of players.
 

gardeneer

Redshirt
Jun 19, 2002
2,708
16
0
Rich burned bridges and then went on to unimpressive stays almost everywhere else he went. There are too many other good coaches out there who don't have his baggage and poor record. This obsession with a particular coach is bordering on idol worshipping. He'll never be back here, thank goodness.
 

WVU-SE

Redshirt
Sep 14, 2006
6,815
3
0
If people were honest, I think more and more WVU fans/alumni would be favorable to Rich coming back if they thought he would be able to win again.
Too big of an "if" in my opinion to take the risk. Need to find a quality replacement if we go that route, but that isn't it...
 

Rootmaster

Redshirt
Apr 16, 2011
9,238
31
0
Rich may of had to tone down his coaching style from his “spot the ball” hustle to the line way of doing thing when he first showed up at WVU. Cussing a player out for not giving the ref the ball, taking the ball and kicking it up into the stands and making the player run up and get it would not work with this new age of players.
New age of players are wokesters.
 

Rootmaster

Redshirt
Apr 16, 2011
9,238
31
0
Rich burned bridges and then went on to unimpressive stays almost everywhere else he went. There are too many other good coaches out there who don't have his baggage and poor record. This obsession with a particular coach is bordering on idol worshipping. He'll never be back here, thank goodness.
This lack of acceptance of the fact that Rich should come home is the kind of thinking that has made the state vibrant, growing, prosperous and great lol.
 

muthed

All-Conference
Aug 25, 2018
3,273
1,886
0
Rich burned bridges and then went on to unimpressive stays almost everywhere else he went. There are too many other good coaches out there who don't have his baggage and poor record. This obsession with a particular coach is bordering on idol worshipping. He'll never be back here, thank goodness.
But Rod is still a fairly Rich man I would guess.
 

locustwv

Redshirt
Aug 23, 2012
7,330
33
0
I loved Rich as our coach, but I do think he got crazy lucky with Pat White, Steve Slaton and Owen Schmitt.
 

xWVU2010x

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2006
138,425
4,629
0
I loved Rich as our coach, but I do think he got crazy lucky with Pat White, Steve Slaton and Owen Schmitt.
And a perfect storm of CFB not yet taken over completely by the SEC and a not as bad as advertised but still very beatable Big East.
 

spartansstink

Redshirt
Sep 24, 2005
3,374
0
0
This thread perfectly demonstrates the pathos of the people here - anything good that comes to us is directly the result of sheer luck while every failure is self-inflicted and unforgiveable.
 

xWVU2010x

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2006
138,425
4,629
0
This thread perfectly demonstrates the pathos of the people here - anything good that comes to us is directly the result of sheer luck while every failure is self-inflicted and unforgiveable.

Acting like CFB, and WVU’s situation now vs when Rich was here are not completely different is incredibly naive. He was the right coach for that time, he is not the right coach 16 years later while playing from behind most of our conference rivals and NIL being a major recruiting factor with presently an offense that is also yet to surpass 20 points in a game vs FBS competition.
 

Rootmaster

Redshirt
Apr 16, 2011
9,238
31
0
Acting like CFB, and WVU’s situation now vs when Rich was here are not completely different is incredibly naive. He was the right coach for that time, he is not the right coach 16 years later while playing from behind most of our conference rivals and NIL being a major recruiting factor with presently an offense that is also yet to surpass 20 points in a game vs FBS competition.
Your opinion only. Means nothing.
 

ThePunish-EER

Freshman
Aug 19, 2005
13,313
59
0
Your opinion only. Means nothing.
I don’t know why people are still sore over Rodriguez leaving. He left for a better job opportunity. Most people in his shoes would’ve done the same. While he may not have left the right way or right time for the program, people forget why he did what he did. He was promised a lot of things when he turned down Alabama, and he claims WVU did not honor those handshake agreements. Whether anyone believes him or not, the fact remains there was obviously tension and disagreement between Rodriguez and the WVU AD. It’s been 16 years. It’s time to move on. We all learn from experiences and gain wisdom with age. It’s time to forgive and forget. That said, I think if the time is right for both Rodriguez and WVU, then we should consider bringing him back. WVU football has not been remotely close to anything he built here since Rod left.
 

xWVU2010x

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2006
138,425
4,629
0
I don’t know why people are still sore over Rodriguez leaving. He left for a better job opportunity. Most people in his shoes would’ve done the same. While he may not have left the right way or right time for the program, people forget why he did what he did. He was promised a lot of things when he turned down Alabama, and he claims WVU did not honor those handshake agreements. Whether anyone believes him or not, the fact remains there was obviously tension and disagreement between Rodriguez and the WVU AD. It’s been 16 years. It’s time to move on. We all learn from experiences and gain wisdom with age. It’s time to forgive and forget. That said, I think if the time is right for both Rodriguez and WVU, then we should consider bringing him back. WVU football has not been remotely close to anything he built here since Rod left.
We won an Orange Bowl 2 staffs removed from Rod and were a terrible personal foul call away from the Big XII title game long after his time. The Neal Brown years are the only time this program has been objectively bad for a sustained period of 4+ years under a coaching staff since the 70s, we don’t have to go dumpster diving for a coach who is also 0 for 2 in breaking 20 points against D1 competition this year because he was great for a short period of time with a QB he initially had on the bench behind Adam Bednarik well over a decade ago.
 

ThePunish-EER

Freshman
Aug 19, 2005
13,313
59
0
We won an Orange Bowl 2 staffs removed from Rod and were a terrible personal foul call away from the Big XII title game long after his time. The Neal Brown years are the only time this program has been objectively bad for a sustained period of 4+ years under a coaching staff since the 70s, we don’t have to go dumpster diving for a coach who is also 0 for 2 in breaking 20 points against D1 competition this year because he was great for a short period of time with a QB he initially had on the bench behind Adam Bednarik well over a decade ago.
The recruitment of Austin, Geno, and Bailey were coming off the heels of 3 straight 11 win seasons and 3 straight 9 win seasons under a former Rodriguez assistant. Those 3 players and others were responsible for that Orange Bowl. To think WVU football has been on the Rodriguez level since he departed is insane. The results show this. And also, Pat White was a true freshman. It’s not exactly crazy that he started on the bench behind Bednarik to begin the season. We can agree to disagree on bringing Rod back.
 

xWVU2010x

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2006
138,425
4,629
0
While your emotions don’t like Rod, his overall HC record shows he’s not a joke or loser
It kind of does since he left the Big East and played in conferences that would be more in line with the Big XII he would have to coach in. He is 58-57 (30-48) as a power conference coach following his departure from WVU. He is also 6 years removed from “big boy” football.

Basically your entire argument hinges on the hope that he will be able to replicate 2005-07 despite him not showing the ability to do that anywhere else in 16 seasons. This is worse than the calls to hire Terry Bowden when Rod originally left. At least Bowden had an undefeated season in a serious conference to point to.
 

xWVU2010x

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2006
138,425
4,629
0
The recruitment of Austin, Geno, and Bailey were coming off the heels of 3 straight 11 win seasons and 3 straight 9 win seasons under a former Rodriguez assistant. Those 3 players and others were responsible for that Orange Bowl. To think WVU football has been on the Rodriguez level since he departed is insane. The results show this. And also, Pat White was a true freshman. It’s not exactly crazy that he started on the bench behind Bednarik to begin the season. We can agree to disagree on bringing Rod back.
Lol jfc those were Stew’s recruits that he was able to bring in and retain their commitments despite a massively disappointing 2008 season basically on the promise of running a pro style spread, which RR would have explicitly not offered. Bailey actually was a freshman 2010, are you going to say Grier came here because of Rod also?
 
Last edited:

ThePunish-EER

Freshman
Aug 19, 2005
13,313
59
0
Lol jfc those were Stew’s recruits that he was able to bring in and retain their commitments despite a massively disappointing 2008 season basically on the promise of running a pro style spread, which RR would have explicitly not offered. Bailey actually was a freshman 2010, are you going to say Grier came here because of Rod also?
So your argument is the record doesn’t influence recruiting elite players? Why haven’t we been able to find them lately? Maybe because we aren’t winning? You think Tavon, Geno, and Stedman would’ve signed today? You think the program winning 60 games over a 6 year stretch had nothing to do with getting them? You think Stewart didn’t recruit under Rodriguez staff and it didn’t help him get Geno, Stedman, and Tavon? You’re blinded by hurt emotions because Rod left and unwilling to acknowledge facts.
 

xWVU2010x

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2006
138,425
4,629
0
So your argument is the record doesn’t influence recruiting elite players? Why haven’t we been able to find them lately? Maybe because we aren’t winning? You think Tavon, Geno, and Stedman would’ve signed today? You think the program winning 60 games over a 6 year stretch had nothing to do with getting them? You think Stewart didn’t recruit under Rodriguez staff and it didn’t help him get Geno, Stedman, and Tavon? You’re blinded by hurt emotions because Rod left and unwilling to acknowledge facts.

By this logic, surely RR did great at the winningest program in CFB history… oh wait
 

ThePunish-EER

Freshman
Aug 19, 2005
13,313
59
0
It kind of does since he left the Big East and played in conferences that would be more in line with the Big XII he would have to coach in. He is 58-57 (30-48) as a power conference coach following his departure from WVU. He is also 6 years removed from “big boy” football.

Basically your entire argument hinges on the hope that he will be able to replicate 2005-07 despite him not showing the ability to do that anywhere else in 16 seasons. This is worse than the calls to hire Terry Bowden when Rod originally left. At least Bowden had an undefeated season in a serious conference to point to.
So you think Rod played weak opponents in the Big East? Why did that Big East do so well in the bowl games against the other top conferences? Why did Rodriguez and WVU beat the SEC champion Georgia in the Sugar Bowl? Why did Rodriguez WVU team beat the Big 12 Champion Oklahoma in the Fiesta Bowl? How did that happen? Or did you choose to ignore those facts?
 

ThePunish-EER

Freshman
Aug 19, 2005
13,313
59
0
By this logic, surely RR did great at the winningest program in CFB history… oh wait
Well, they were improving each year under Rodriguez. You can look it up. Michigan was impatient and demanded immediate results. Rodriguez won at Arizona. You can look that up as well
 

xWVU2010x

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2006
138,425
4,629
0
So you think Rod played weak opponents in the Big East? Why did that Big East do so well in the bowl games against the other top conferences? Why did Rodriguez and WVU beat the SEC champion Georgia in the Sugar Bowl? Why did Rodriguez WVU team beat the Big 12 Champion Oklahoma in the Fiesta Bowl? How did that happen? Or did you choose to ignore those facts?

Why did literally every Big East program from that era who went to other power conferences fall into the middle of the pack or worse? It’s one thing to get extraordinarily fired up for a bowl game, it’s another to compete at that level week in and out for a full season.