Daily Collegian Article On Starrocci Allegations

dicemen99

Well-known member
Nov 15, 2005
2,886
1,910
113
I have plenty of opinions on much of this. But personally, it’s not a topic I look to discuss publicly with a bunch of more or less anonymous old dudes (like myself).

Does that make me better than those that do? Certainly not—but it does help describe the uneasiness I feel reading some posts in this thread.
I am in complete agreement on this.

Syd has made herself fair game with her public posturing. But commenting or speculating on their relationship is too much for me.

I think some may be doing this to avoid putting Beau in their crosshairs or something of the like (maybe??), but it is not necessary.
 

mvattivo

Member
Jun 23, 2005
15
35
13
I am in complete agreement on this.

Syd has made herself fair game with her public posturing. But commenting or speculating on their relationship is too much for me.

I think some may be doing this to avoid putting Beau in their crosshairs or something of the like (maybe??), but it is not necessary.

It has been *mostly* very predictable. Most non-PSU fans are trying to make this as big as possible, in hopes that it ruins the thing that they can't beat otherwise. Most PSU fans are downplaying it or pushing the negative onto the Bartletts (Trust me, I think Syd deserves much of what has been given). It's just business as usual.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WexfordWarrior
Jul 26, 2014
8
31
13
There is one thing I would change immediately for any PSU wrestlers entering the locked doors of the Lorenzo wrestling center. I would put a locker with 50+ small doors, individually keyed, that cell phones had to be locked in upon entrance.

This would allow the Coaches to take away any opportunity for pics to be taken without their permission, going forward inside Lorenzo. Cael preaches staying off social media, and this would help prevent another issue down the road. Just my 2 cents.
 

AgSurfer

Member
Aug 9, 2013
51
135
32
There is one thing I would change immediately for any PSU wrestlers entering the locked doors of the Lorenzo wrestling center. I would put a locker with 50+ small doors, individually keyed, that cell phones had to be locked in upon entrance.

This would allow the Coaches to take away any opportunity for pics to be taken without their permission, going forward inside Lorenzo. Cael preaches staying off social media, and this would help prevent another issue down the road. Just my 2 cents.
Just like where I work except if you get caught taking photos with a cell phone, you will get a very unpleasant visit from the MIB.
 
  • Like
Reactions: creamery freak

JoeBagobagels

Member
Jun 24, 2025
28
51
12
Can you list a couple of the "many high profile false allegations"?
Trevor Bauer, Brian Banks, Duke Lacrosse.


High enough profile for your. Bauer lost tens of millions of dollars. Banks did five years in prison. The Duke lacrosse team went through hell.

Then we have Amber Heard : https://www.nbcnews.com/pop-culture...d-defamation-trial-summary-timeline-rcna26136

Now imagine if you're some poor regular Joe with a public defender? Banks did five years. My case was a quick investigation that was BS. My wife's case of a false report to CYS was debunked by a police visit.

If they go to the media and social media first without a criminal report, it is almost certainly BS.
 

McScoreley

Member
Oct 31, 2021
36
123
33
Off the top of my head, the current punter for the KC Chiefs when he played at San Diego State.
Brian Banks is the most notorious case as he served 5 years in prison, the woman admitted on the record (when he was wearing a wire) she lied for money but yet she faced no repercussions.

Duke Lacrosse obviously, season was shut down and multiple players who weren't even at the scene of the alleged crime were charged with jail time hanging over their head.

Shawn Oakman got accused right before the NFL draft, he was a projected 1st rounder (in the very least, would have gotten drafted somewhere to get a 7 figure guaranteed payout) He went undrafted, trial took years to go to court, the evidence of his innocence was so overwhelming it took the jury 45 minutes basically to return a not guilty verdict. Despite him still training hard, his chances of ever making the NFL is gone forever.

There have been other high profile cases that never resulted in charges but damaged reputations: Patrick Kane, Derrick Rose and I'm missing a lot I'm sure but right now: Shannon Sharpe and Zion Williamson.

I say all that to say this, there are more unreported SAs than fake reports, way more. I will never ever support something like "jail time" for fake reports unless it's for egregious level of lying and hard proof of it (like Brian Banks) Even cases like Shawn Oakman and Matt Araiza, I'll err on the side of caution for a he said, she said case that heavily favors the accused (Shawn Oakman) and bad testimony that borders on lying (Matt Araiza, who left the scene of the alleged SA before anything happened) The last thing we need is for victims to think there's any chance of them going to jail if they can't prove they got assaulted.

But on the flip side, innocent until proven guilty is how we operate in the courts in the US .... but not the court of public opinion and Carter will deal with that for the rest of his career at this point regardless of what happens.
 

js8793

Member
Dec 4, 2018
21
90
13
Trevor Bauer, Brian Banks, Duke Lacrosse.


High enough profile for your. Bauer lost tens of millions of dollars. Banks did five years in prison. The Duke lacrosse team went through hell.

Then we have Amber Heard : https://www.nbcnews.com/pop-culture...d-defamation-trial-summary-timeline-rcna26136

Now imagine if you're some poor regular Joe with a public defender? Banks did five years. My case was a quick investigation that was BS. My wife's case of a false report to CYS was debunked by a police visit.

If they go to the media and social media first without a criminal report, it is almost certainly BS.

I say all that to say this, there are more unreported SAs than fake reports, way more.

@McScoreley said it perfectly, so I'm just quoting him.
 

Dren007

Member
Feb 19, 2012
12
33
13
So, what happened to the liars that brought false allegations? Why wouldn't they then be punished for ruining the lives of others.