Does Pope deserve another year?

Does he deserve another year?

  • Yes

    Votes: 53 29.0%
  • No

    Votes: 130 71.0%

  • Total voters
    183

mash_24

Heisman
Sep 26, 2011
8,468
25,606
108
He at the very least deserves the rest of this year to see if he can turn things around. But that’s gonna take some serious changes made to the way he’s doing things. Then I think an evaluation can be made. But we’ve regressed from what gave us some success a couple games ago. I’m not sure if Pope has the conviction to do what’s necessary. Times getting short. We can’t afford any more embarrassing losses.
 

NoDef

All-American
Sep 1, 2001
5,112
7,026
113
In previous eras, 2 years wasn't enough time to evaluate. You can literally rebuild in 1 year now, so 2 years is plenty to determine the trajectory of the program. Pope has until the end of this season to turn it around on the court and start having some recruiting success...at least for me. I'm not the one making the decision, so Mitch will probably give him another contract extension after the season for all I know.
We have football teams needing 22 players that have turned it around faster. With the most money in college basketball you would think you can find four kids to make you competitive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: W1LDCAT22

CatsDomain

Sophomore
Oct 15, 2023
83
135
33
I lean toward giving him a 3rd year to get things headed the right direction. He obviously loves UK, played on a championship team and knows basketball. There's obviously some kind of disconnect inside of this team. They don't seem happy to be playing and don't seem to play for each other. The lack of effort is embarrassing! Nobody can figure it out including Mark Pope. Can he turn it around? Only time will tell.
 

JPFisher

Heisman
Jul 24, 2013
6,411
11,864
113
As it stands right now? No.

Pope knows this and I think that's part of why he's been short with reporters this year.

This team has underperformed about as bad as Cal's teams and should've shown some signs of life today, but didn't. Having no answers coming out of a break doesn't look good.
 

KyCPA2000

Senior
Nov 24, 2007
914
987
93
I don’t understand the argument that Pope deserves another year. Why? The only argument is that Mitch Barnhart won’t fire him. Do you think boosters will become restless and demand change?

We have no high school recruits. None of us seem to want most of the players currently on the team to return next year so either Pope brings back players that aren’t living up to expectations or he has to start over again. What would even be our hopes and expectations of another year of Pope? It seems so pointless and depressing.
Because he had one one year that exceeded expectations and now one below expectations. Third year tells the tale.
 
May 27, 2007
31,129
23,961
113
Pope has never won a conference title, never won a conference tournament and never won a tournament game before coming to UK. He was only considered an up-and-coming coach because he played here.

Do you need to have any of that to be considered up and coming?

I mean to me up and coming just means that you've demonstrated the ability to do something with your coaching. Maybe it's about doing the most with little so you still haven't won anything but you've shown with a more talented roster that you could get at UK, maybe you'll be better.

I think that's what they saw in Pope.

Pope could only do so much at BYU.
 

UKortho

All-American
Oct 13, 2015
4,516
8,385
77
My opinion only, to not get another year:

- Miss tournament
- not have an easy excuse(à la Lowe’s shoulder gives out entirely/Oweh tears his ACL/etc).

That may be enough with this mega NIL roster.

But the ending is what everyone remembers since we all get so invested into every game.

home v Vandy
At A&M
Home v Florida

SECT

If he loses 4 straight there, which isn’t hard to fathom, it’s over.
They could easily go 1-5 counting the SECT.
 

senonesy

All-American
Nov 30, 2017
3,950
7,995
113
It’s interesting, innit? We think Pope is such a great guy but you have to ask yourself: why would you put yourself and your family through so much pressure from an increasingly angry fanbase? For money? Glory? Is it really worth your and your family’s sanity?
Maybe because he isn’t going to give up after a sweet 16 and 14 games? Jeez.
 

bbnkat02

Heisman
Nov 14, 2017
46,033
68,134
113
Deserve another year?

I mean I dunno. Maybe see how this one ends up playing out.

But at the same rate you can Pope and who are you getting exactly? We will be in the same place we were in two years ago lol.

Not saying that's a reason to keep Pope............just that this notion of people knocking down the door to come here and coach just isn't happening.

I think the list is smaller due to you can now win a title just about anywhere thanks to NIL. But it's not like it's a bad list.

I think Pearl would love to do it.
I think coaches like Otz at Iowa St might like a shot at a running a big time program.
I think there's a world you can convince a guy like Golden (if he continues to do well) to come here.

The problem lies in we want "program guys" and well, they just don't exist anymore or aren't very good.

Pelphrey sucks
Pope is struggling
Woods was awful

Donovan and Tubby were really the two only successful Pitino guys.
 

UKortho

All-American
Oct 13, 2015
4,516
8,385
77
Do you need to have any of that to be considered up and coming?

I mean to me up and coming just means that you've demonstrated the ability to do something with your coaching. Maybe it's about doing the most with little so you still haven't won anything but you've shown with a more talented roster that you could get at UK, maybe you'll be better.

I think that's what they saw in Pope.

Pope could only do so much at BYU.

The coach he replaced did better- the coach that replaced him is doing better. Nothing in his past said up and coming.
 

UKortho

All-American
Oct 13, 2015
4,516
8,385
77
I think the list is smaller due to you can now win a title just about anywhere thanks to NIL. But it's not like it's a bad list.

I think Pearl would love to do it.
I think coaches like Otz at Iowa St might like a shot at a running a big time program.
I think there's a world you can convince a guy like Golden (if he continues to do well) to come here.

The problem lies in we want "program guys" and well, they just don't exist anymore or aren't very good.

Pelphrey sucks
Pope is struggling
Woods was awful

Donovan and Tubby were really the two only successful Pitino guys.

NIL and transfer portal. You can build a contender easily at UK.
 

bbnkat02

Heisman
Nov 14, 2017
46,033
68,134
113
Turn out the lights. It's over. The feeling (most) of us had was correct, Pope wasn't the hire but UK media did their propaganda to keep us from marching on the ADs office back in 2023.
Nah, Mitch screwed us by not firing Cal's *** immeadiately in February when Cal met with Arky.

We could've then gone after May and been the Number 2 team in the country right now. Muck Fitch!
 

Eagles_Ball_69

All-Conference
Dec 19, 2003
2,869
3,678
82
As someone who isn’t sure, so I’m not trying to be an *** here but honestly curious about discussion — what does the season have to look like for Pope to NOT get another season?

If we miss the tournament?
If we lose every single game?
What’s the cutoff that says enough is enough?
I’m in the same boat. What about a 6-12 SEC record? Surely that does it, right? I get the Cal haters (I wanted him gone, badly, but prefer to not think of myself as a hater) point to 2020-21 but that year just shouldn’t count. It was so trash. That would be the worst year since…without looking…Eddies last? Pitinos first? Some SERIOUSLY different circumstances for both of those.
 

UKCowboys

All-Conference
Oct 14, 2019
1,302
2,218
113
It shouldn't be just a yes or no question. If those are the options, yes he does. I would have checked ask me when the season ends if that had been an option
 
  • Like
Reactions: MegaBlue05

bbnkat02

Heisman
Nov 14, 2017
46,033
68,134
113
I’m in the same boat. What about a 6-12 SEC record? Surely that does it, right? I get the Cal haters (I wanted him gone, badly, but prefer to not think of myself as a hater) point to 2020-21 but that year just shouldn’t count. It was so trash. That would be the worst year since…without looking…Eddies last? Pitinos first? Some SERIOUSLY different circumstances for both of those.

That year absolutely counts. Period. Other teams did well in that year. No excuses.
 
May 27, 2007
31,129
23,961
113
I think the list is smaller due to you can now win a title just about anywhere thanks to NIL. But it's not like it's a bad list.

I think Pearl would love to do it.
I think coaches like Otz at Iowa St might like a shot at a running a big time program.
I think there's a world you can convince a guy like Golden (if he continues to do well) to come here.

The problem lies in we want "program guys" and well, they just don't exist anymore or aren't very good.

Pelphrey sucks
Pope is struggling
Woods was awful

Donovan and Tubby were really the two only successful Pitino guys.

I agree. The program guys makes this become a bit more problematic.
 

megablue

Heisman
Oct 2, 2012
14,243
14,079
113
It’s interesting, innit? We think Pope is such a great guy but you have to ask yourself: why would you put yourself and your family through so much pressure from an increasingly angry fanbase? For money? Glory? Is it really worth your and your family’s sanity?
No ... it is not worth it.
 

Tri-Countycat

All-Conference
Jul 1, 2025
512
1,031
93
Nate Oats recruiting: come to Alabama, I’ve won the most SEC games the last four years, two SEC tournaments, Two regular season titles, a final four and an E8. Plus gonna get paid and I can’t get people to the league.

Pope recruiting. Come to UK because we have A great fan base and I know what it means to wear UK across your chest.

Pope is cooked bad.
 

Farsight Clone

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2025
1,029
1,977
103
I think if Mitch does not retire, he gets at least one more year.

If we hire one of Mitch's cronies as AD, he has a 50% chance to stay for next year.

If we get a new AD outside of Mitch's grasp, Pope won't be here next year.

Remember Mitch didn't Fire Cal after his 9-16 year and he hated Cal. Imagine what he would allow Pope to do.

The only way I think Mitch fires Pope is if he does not win 1 SEC game.

The only way Pope is gone next year is if Mitch retires, get a new AD outside of Mitch's influence or if he decides to step down.

--

I voted no because of bad coaching consistencies. All of the coaching errors from Cal, I thought would be remedied but its nearly the same but with worse players. Not to mention probably going to lose on Stokes and Collins. (not chandler)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skyguyb27

KyCPA2000

Senior
Nov 24, 2007
914
987
93
I’m in the same boat. What about a 6-12 SEC record? Surely that does it, right? I get the Cal haters (I wanted him gone, badly, but prefer to not think of myself as a hater) point to 2020-21 but that year just shouldn’t count. It was so trash. That would be the worst year since…without looking…Eddies last? Pitinos first? Some SERIOUSLY different circumstances for both of those.
2020-21 absolutely counts. UK wasnt the only program going through a pandemic.
 

Eagles_Ball_69

All-Conference
Dec 19, 2003
2,869
3,678
82
That year absolutely counts. Period. Other teams did well in that year. No excuses.
Sure, if you have an agenda it counts. If you any sort of perspective at all, it just was what it was. Cal did a terrible job, no doubt. But that BS shouldn’t count for anything for anyone in the record books. Just a ridiculous season.
 

Eagles_Ball_69

All-Conference
Dec 19, 2003
2,869
3,678
82
2020-21 absolutely counts. UK wasnt the only program going through a pandemic.
Pay attention. It shouldn’t count for anyone. Use all caps next time too, doesn’t change anything. Cal did a crap job. Still doesn’t change the fact that was just a stupid season. Guys being forced to sit. Games canceled. Just dumb. Say Cal did a trash job, he did. But don’t spew this “only coach to win less than 10 games” or “sub .500” crap. It’s disingenuous.
 
Jul 30, 2024
4,404
7,861
113
Pay attention. It shouldn’t count for anyone. Use all caps next time too, doesn’t change anything. Cal did a crap job. Still doesn’t change the fact that was just a stupid season. Guys being forced to sit. Games canceled. Just dumb. Say Cal did a trash job, he did. But don’t spew this “only coach to win less than 10 games” or “sub .500” crap. It’s disingenuous.
I’m glad you agree that specific context matters. Remember that next time you compare Utah Valley State efficiency numbers to a major conference or disregard injury effects on games.

2021 was on Calipari — just like every other year with increasing lack of hope. Calipari and Pope can both be falling short and we can acknowledge where both did good and did bad. End of Cal sucked. Last year, Pope did better than expected given context. This year, he’s eroded all the equity he built and now we have little hope. All of that is true.
 

UKortho

All-American
Oct 13, 2015
4,516
8,385
77
Pay attention. It shouldn’t count for anyone. Use all caps next time too, doesn’t change anything. Cal did a crap job. Still doesn’t change the fact that was just a stupid season. Guys being forced to sit. Games canceled. Just dumb. Say Cal did a trash job, he did. But don’t spew this “only coach to win less than 10 games” or “sub .500” crap. It’s disingenuous.

No, it’s not. The pandemic/rules weren’t only contained to Lexington. Did you not watch Boston kill us all year?
 

bbnkat02

Heisman
Nov 14, 2017
46,033
68,134
113
Sure, if you have an agenda it counts. If you any sort of perspective at all, it just was what it was. Cal did a terrible job, no doubt. But that BS shouldn’t count for anything for anyone in the record books. Just a ridiculous season.

Well, the sport disagrees with you and I'm sure Baylor would heavily disagree with you.
Pay attention. It shouldn’t count for anyone. Use all caps next time too, doesn’t change anything. Cal did a crap job. Still doesn’t change the fact that was just a stupid season. Guys being forced to sit. Games canceled. Just dumb. Say Cal did a trash job, he did. But don’t spew this “only coach to win less than 10 games” or “sub .500” crap. It’s disingenuous.

Lol. Had to reply twice to it? It's not disingenuous. The record stands. This is UofL where we ignore what record books say.

So you're fine with saying Cal did a trash job but not the numbers? Wild. Must've been the kid that hid the report card from mom and dad huh?
 
Sep 6, 2025
109
176
43
Joker got a 3rd year, but I wonder how much winning against Tennessee for the first time in 20 or 30-something years saved him from getting canned his 2nd year?
By all accounts, the Tennessee win got Joker one more year. It was good to break the streak but IIRC it cost us getting Mike Leach, which sucked.
 

Anon1751521769

Freshman
Jul 3, 2025
67
76
18
It’s interesting, innit? We think Pope is such a great guy but you have to ask yourself: why would you put yourself and your family through so much pressure from an increasingly angry fanbase? For money? Glory? Is it really worth your and your family’s sanity?
I read this in a British accent 🥴