Doubt creeping in...

xxxbobxxx

Sophomore
Mar 12, 2005
10,806
163
43
Not exactly sure what the plan would be based upon what I think I see..which is almost all of our guys have a slow first step defensively....which gets us behind the 8ball as soon as the opposition player puts the ball on the floor....then we are immediately trying to help...and sometimes leaves big holes in the defense......Do not know the answer to this ...but also on the flip side, offensive side of the ball we do not have anyone who can put the ball on the floor and break a defense down.....so we seem pretty darn defense-able on offense........in summary it seems to be a lack of 1,2 and small 3s on this roster....for almost 3 years now. While the damage was done inside by MSU it was the ability of their point guard to set up the offense in such a way that they got the looks inside they wanted. I think this roster weakness also really hurts us in last possession situations where we have trouble getting a good shot

Disagree. Plenty of 2 & 3s that prefer to spot up shoot. Missing slashers. Ball handlers. And for those shooters to actually make the baskets.
 

Medill90

Junior
Jan 30, 2011
6,910
321
0
I don’t have any insight as to what he did but I can tell you that I was working out at home in Glenview when I ran into a person I have know casually for about twenty five years, who is about as close as anyone can be to Chris. He volunteered that Lathon, who Chris was very high on had his scholarship pulled because of a very big mistake by the young man. Chris was very disappointed, but Northwestern has standards that many other schools do not and he just could not be allowed entrance with this hanging out on him.

I also have some info, strictly from the internet, on the 2019 class. Jared Jones’ high school McEchron, Georgia won the City of Palms holiday tournament down here at Florida SW Collge in Fort Myers. This is a big tourney with national TV coverage on ESPNU. Jones, who is 6/9, was all tournament and got rave reviews from the so called experts down here. A recruiting coup they are calling it down here. I suspect he will report directly to Brian James, who has worked endlessly with Derek Pardon.

The same recruiting site says Buie is the best guard in the New England prep school league, and Robbie Beran, from Richmond and one of the top ranked players in the country (76) is the best of the group and will start at the four spot next year. He is 6/9 and filling out at 210 plus.

They are also hard on the trail of another two guard or maybe a combo type of guy, who can also play point guard.

The net effect boys is don’t hold your head in the mud to long, the coaching staff is digging deep for players.

NU has offered two '19 pgs

Blough is the most recent and he's getting a ton on interest.

I do think NU offers pgs something no other team does. All they have to do is watch part of a game.
 

NUCat320

Senior
Dec 4, 2005
19,469
495
0
I don’t have any insight as to what he did but I can tell you that I was working out at home in Glenview when I ran into a person I have know casually for about twenty five years, who is about as close as anyone can be to Chris. He volunteered that Lathon, who Chris was very high on had his scholarship pulled because of a very big mistake by the young man. Chris was very disappointed, but Northwestern has standards that many other schools do not and he just could not be allowed entrance with this hanging out on him.

I also have some info, strictly from the internet, on the 2019 class. Jared Jones’ high school McEchron, Georgia won the City of Palms holiday tournament down here at Florida SW Collge in Fort Myers. This is a big tourney with national TV coverage on ESPNU. Jones, who is 6/9, was all tournament and got rave reviews from the so called experts down here. A recruiting coup they are calling it down here. I suspect he will report directly to Brian James, who has worked endlessly with Derek Pardon.

The same recruiting site says Buie is the best guard in the New England prep school league, and Robbie Beran, from Richmond and one of the top ranked players in the country (76) is the best of the group and will start at the four spot next year. He is 6/9 and filling out at 210 plus.

They are also hard on the trail of another two guard or maybe a combo type of guy, who can also play point guard.

The net effect boys is don’t hold your head in the mud to long, the coaching staff is digging deep for players.
I really like your optimism about the recruits, but it sounds a lot like what we expected from Kopp and Nance (combined 8.3 ppg, 3.8 rpg, 2.1 apg on 39% shooting in 30 mpg) 12 months ago. Stepping in as a freshman is *hard*.

Also, based on your description that you ran into your acquaintance at your home while working out, I have surmised that your home is a gym. I hope you offered him something from the juice bar.
 

mikewebb68

Senior
Oct 24, 2009
9,811
501
113
Don't know why people think it was so easy to recruit a PG that would have gotten splinters in the bench waiting behind BMac for his turn. Kids who are good want to actually play..

As for Lathon, it should not not be rocket science to figure out what he did. And the fact that he only received ONE offer to play with his resume-- from an abolutely desperate dumpster fire of a UTEP team-- should also let you know all that you need to about the seriousness of what he did...
 

mikewebb68

Senior
Oct 24, 2009
9,811
501
113
Only because I get sooooo much **** around here, I started raising all these concerns long ago. Not happy about it, but just saying, cuz some folks mocked me terribly.
And we still will, until the long-term stats prove us wrong, like for the foorball team this year when they only won 4 games... oh wait. So far CC has done what no other basketball coach has done here far earlier that I expected him to, so so far, so good.

The real season has barely begun, so I am not willing to write it off just yet. And you shouldn't either, given the lesson you should have learned from football...
 
Sep 9, 2015
1,980
330
83
Uhhh guys this was only our 2nd game where we looked over matched. I swear reading this thread makes it look like we need to totally revamp the program.

Collins better stick with man 2 man. That's the best defense there is. We have the athletes to play it.

Freshman will be freshman unless we get a 1 and done. Kopp has looked extremely promising. We knew (at least should have... Some people had inflated expectations) Nance would need some polishing and was a high potential developmental prospect. I still believe he is. Greer actually has come out more solid than I expected for moving up a class he's played really well. We have also have 3 pretty good recruits waiting.

Just compare this loss to Oklahoma last year. Great team and future nba player who has a super hot game. Pardon played some perfect D and (a couple times by Benson) and he just hit the shot. Pardon did the same thing a few times. Good offense just beats good defense on a play to play basis.

Our transfers are getting a lot of crap but Turner played well yesterday and I don't get all the hate towards him. He distributes decently. Unless we had a really good PG I don't see all the yelling about need a PG he's distributes fine. If he didn't we would be seeing Greer pressed into action a lot more. Taylor I more so understand the frustration because he hasn't beem hitting shots as much as expected, but he is our third leading scorer behind law and pardon. My problem with Taylor his he fades a little and doesn't square up enough and step into catch and shoot opportunities. When he squares up and steps into confidentiality I haven't seen one miss.

We all know how good Pardon and Law are so I won't rehash that. Ash is obviously injured which sucks for a guy who's best pro was how athletic he was. That really helped him as a defender. Gaines I think has of late got the love he deserves on offense with high assist output. (The man can slash pretty well too. Just that's all you have to defend since he won't shoot the 3.) Benson as of late is showing flashes of where I see his potential and others where I pray he works super hard this off-season. The man needs to get stronger in the post and learn to keep his arms straight up. Ik I'm missing others out this post is long enough.

Just want to say one of my needs for improvement for last season not repeating this season was pardon learning to pass out the post and since double teams. He's so good at that now it's one of strengths, never would have guessed that watching junior year tape.

Edit to say hitting a PG in previous class would have helped a lot with that depth so if that's the argument I get it. Also we still really need to hit on one or two guards capable of distributing in this class.
 

Medill90

Junior
Jan 30, 2011
6,910
321
0
Don't know why people think it was so easy to recruit a PG that would have gotten splinters in the bench waiting behind BMac for his turn. Kids who are good want to actually play..

As for Lathon, it should not not be rocket science to figure out what he did. And the fact that he only received ONE offer to play with his resume-- from an abolutely desperate dumpster fire of a UTEP team-- should also let you know all that you need to about the seriousness of what he did...

I'd rather CC NOT solve a roster problem by bringing on guys who physically and skill-wise cannot compete night in and night out in the Big Ten.

NU's margin of error is thin, thin, thin. 11th hour upset on Jordan Goodwin, Isiah Brown turns out to not be a good fit for Collins, Lathon's on boarding gets reversed and we are where we are. Which, I'd argue, is better than filling the bench with a guy or two who is outclassed against the majority of the Big Ten.

NU has a lot to sell a point guard....the most attractive selling point is that you come in and get major minutes right away.

The pg thing is not a disaster this year. The team is competitive and could surprise if it gels.

I am just not on board with sentiments such as Collins screwed up the guard recruiting....Collins needs to prove this year he can recruit with a huge class.....or, NU recruits poorly and can't develop players (Rap, Vassar, Brown).

The bald fact remains that we've not had talent come in as consistently at this high a level.

The other thing missing from this discussion is that recruiting is very different today than five years ago in terms of the mix of transfers with regular recruits. Collins has gotten better with transfers which is why this is not a hugely down year. Sans Taylor and Turner, this team is sub .500.
 

Jeffrey Cat

Redshirt
Jan 29, 2005
604
10
0
I really like your optimism about the recruits, but it sounds a lot like what we expected from Kopp and Nance (combined 8.3 ppg, 3.8 rpg, 2.1 apg on 39% shooting in 30 mpg) 12 months ago. Stepping in as a freshman is *hard*.

Also, based on your description that you ran into your acquaintance at your home while working out, I have surmised that your home is a gym. I hope you offered him something from the juice bar.
I agree about the freshmen coming in but these recruits are a step ahead of what we have seen in the Carmody era. Our problems in the recently recruiting years has been injuries and personalities, although in the case of the personalities I think those involved think they are a lot better than they are and the staff made a mistake recruiting them in the first place.

I’m sorry for the confusion on the other part. I have lived in Northbrook 40 plus years, been a NU season ticket holder for 30+ years and now live in Florida in the winter. The workout was at the Park Center in Glenview. My son played the 30 years ago version of AAU basketball in the group two years behind Chris Collins, so we all know each other from those games of long ago.

I’m looking forward to the Illinois game and I really think when the smoke has cleared from this season we’ll have about 17 or 18 regular season wins and then hope for some more in the conference tournament. Another guard in next years class will be helpful too.
 
Last edited:

mikewebb68

Senior
Oct 24, 2009
9,811
501
113
Uhhh guys this was only our 2nd game where we looked over matched. I swear reading this thread makes it look like we need to totally revamp the program.

Collins better stick with man 2 man. That's the best defense there is. We have the athletes to play it.

Freshman will be freshman unless we get a 1 and done. Kopp has looked extremely promising. We knew (at least should have... Some people had inflated expectations) Nance would need some polishing and was a high potential developmental prospect. I still believe he is. Greer actually has come out more solid than I expected for moving up a class he's played really well. We have also have 3 pretty good recruits waiting.

Just compare this loss to Oklahoma last year. Great team and future nba player who has a super hot game. Pardon played some perfect D and (a couple times by Benson) and he just hit the shot. Pardon did the same thing a few times. Good offense just beats good defense on a play to play basis.

Our transfers are getting a lot of crap but Turner played well yesterday and I don't get all the hate towards him. He distributes decently. Unless we had a really good PG I don't see all the yelling about need a PG he's distributes fine. If he didn't we would be seeing Greer pressed into action a lot more. Taylor I more so understand the frustration because he hasn't beem hitting shots as much as expected, but he is our third leading scorer behind law and pardon. My problem with Taylor his he fades a little and doesn't square up enough and step into catch and shoot opportunities. When he squares up and steps into confidentiality I haven't seen one miss.

We all know how good Pardon and Law are so I won't rehash that. Ash is obviously injured which sucks for a guy who's best pro was how athletic he was. That really helped him as a defender. Gaines I think has of late got the love he deserves on offense with high assist output. (The man can slash pretty well too. Just that's all you have to defend since he won't shoot the 3.) Benson as of late is showing flashes of where I see his potential and others where I pray he works super hard this off-season. The man needs to get stronger in the post and learn to keep his arms straight up. Ik I'm missing others out this post is long enough.

Just want to say one of my needs for improvement for last season not repeating this season was pardon learning to pass out the post and since double teams. He's so good at that now it's one of strengths, never would have guessed that watching junior year tape.

Edit to say hitting a PG in previous class would have helped a lot with that depth so if that's the argument I get it. Also we still really need to hit on one or two guards capable of distributing in this class.
Well stated. We've been boatraced the same number of times as well, Iowa, who nearly lost to one OK f the worst teams int the country (Bryant). Doubt anyone at Iowa is pressing the panic button (they'ye been in and out of the top-25), and neither should we.Let's see how the real season plays out...
 

mikewebb68

Senior
Oct 24, 2009
9,811
501
113
Well, I'm a Polymer Scientist and I can't figure out what he did. Can you enlighten me?

I don't have direct knowledge of course, but when you read all the reports on the issue, they are strangely silent as to details. And others have already stated it was not academics or a criminal matter such as drug possession. So what is the one remaining issue that could get a kid kicked out of school and blacklist a kid from most other schools about which one people be vary careful to leak details about to protect the privacy of certain individuals? Fairly obvious to me...
 

Medill90

Junior
Jan 30, 2011
6,910
321
0
I don't have direct knowledge of course, but when you read all the reports on the issue, they are strangely silent as to details. And others have already stated it was not academics or a criminal matter such as drug possession. So what is the one remaining issue that could get a kid kicked out of school and blacklist a kid from most other schools about which one people be vary careful to leak details about to protect the privacy of certain individuals? Fairly obvious to me...

Falsified transcript?
 

mikewebb68

Senior
Oct 24, 2009
9,811
501
113
Falsified transcript?

That would fall under academics, and it was previously stated by someone with knowledge of the situation that it was not that. I think if you go back and read those posts (though some of them are on the Rock) it is fairly obvious what the man did, or was at least accused of doing....
 

NJCat

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2016
21,326
1,501
113
That would fall under academics, and it was previously stated by someone with knowledge of the situation that it was not that. I think if you go back and read those posts (though some of them are on the Rock) it is fairly obvious what the man did, or was at least accused of doing....
Well, it isn't obvious to at least two of us! Can you give me a hint? What is the first letter of the alleged offense?
 

Mr Wickerpark

Redshirt
Dec 28, 2016
2,864
33
0
Don't know why people think it was so easy to recruit a PG that would have gotten splinters in the bench waiting behind BMac for his turn. Kids who are good want to actually play..

As for Lathon, it should not not be rocket science to figure out what he did. And the fact that he only received ONE offer to play with his resume-- from an abolutely desperate dumpster fire of a UTEP team-- should also let you know all that you need to about the seriousness of what he did...
it isnt fair to him for you to be suggesting he did something really bad. He didnt. In fact it wasnt even a crime. It wasnt some Ray Rice thing. It was all about being politically correct. As it turned out, it was nothing.
 

Mr Wickerpark

Redshirt
Dec 28, 2016
2,864
33
0
I really like your optimism about the recruits, but it sounds a lot like what we expected from Kopp and Nance (combined 8.3 ppg, 3.8 rpg, 2.1 apg on 39% shooting in 30 mpg) 12 months ago. Stepping in as a freshman is *hard*.

Also, based on your description that you ran into your acquaintance at your home while working out, I have surmised that your home is a gym. I hope you offered him something from the juice bar.
Kopp already looks very good.
Im not too worried about recruiting a top point guard next year and pushing him to start immediately. We have done it before, with no problem, having B Mac and Dave Sobs
 

mikewebb68

Senior
Oct 24, 2009
9,811
501
113
it isnt fair to him for you to be suggesting he did something really bad. He didnt. In fact it wasnt even a crime. It wasnt some Ray Rice thing. It was all about being politically correct. As it turned out, it was nothing.
He did slmething bad enough that no other school but UTEP would offer a guy who previously was in demand by most everyine It's not trashing the kid, it is stating a fact.
 
May 29, 2001
45,734
386
0
He did slmething bad enough that no other school but UTEP would offer a guy who previously was in demand by most everyine It's not trashing the kid, it is stating a fact.
Wickerdude is right. I guess nobody can stop you from trashing a guy. No. It wasn't so bad. As it turned out, it wasn't even a crime. UTEP got a goodie and , as it turned out risked NOTHING. Good for them.

Not saying NU did wrong, I think NU did right. But unlike you, NU doesn't go public and trash a player.

Let me recommend that you do this on the Rock page, which isn't public.
 

mikewebb68

Senior
Oct 24, 2009
9,811
501
113
Wickerdude is right. I guess nobody can stop you from trashing a guy. No. It wasn't so bad. As it turned out, it wasn't even a crime. UTEP got a goodie and , as it turned out risked NOTHING. Good for them.

Not saying NU did wrong, I think NU did right. But unlike you, NU doesn't go public and trash a player.

Let me recommend that you do this on the Rock page, which isn't public.
I don't think rhe term "trashing" means what you think it means. A highly rated recruit eho had many offers gets kicked out of our school. If he did nothing wrong, other schools would be absolutely salivating over him. Imstead, only UTEP, an absolite dumpster fire of a program, was the only one to offer him. Do you think the reaskn is because he got a parking ticket? But hey don't let facts get in the way of your accusung me of teashing a player, though.
 

xxxbobxxx

Sophomore
Mar 12, 2005
10,806
163
43
Don't know why people think it was so easy to recruit a PG that would have gotten splinters in the bench waiting behind BMac for his turn. Kids who are good want to actually play..

As for Lathon, it should not not be rocket science to figure out what he did. And the fact that he only received ONE offer to play with his resume-- from an abolutely desperate dumpster fire of a UTEP team-- should also let you know all that you need to about the seriousness of what he did...

A. No one said easy. But folks have said CCC is a great recruiter so...

2. How many schools in the B1G alone have a starting LG and a competent backup seeing decent minutes?
 

mikewebb68

Senior
Oct 24, 2009
9,811
501
113
A. No one said easy. But folks have said CCC is a great recruiter so...

2. How many schools in the B1G alone have a starting LG and a competent backup seeing decent minutes?
As for the answer to #2, I actually can't think of one team off the top of my head. Can you?
 

Max_Power

Junior
May 29, 2001
2,947
214
51
I don't blame you, The C. "Creep" is a good word for where my head is going also.

As I said previously, I'm not expecting a lot out of this season. I've seen this act in the past. Excitement about a string of "close losses" suddenly turns into horror halfway through the season when the team never gets over the hump.

There have also been a slew of signals that an MSU-like performances will be the norm this year against very good teams. The board can tell me all it wants about wins against mediocre teams, but each of those games had a bad stretch that you can't get away with against good teams.

I've seen that story in the past also.

Then, like you, C, I start to take a macro view of the program. I'm having some of the same questions about where this is going. But you might consider your list doesn't have a whole lot of pros to go with the cons.

Here's an attempt to show where I am, and also talk about a few of your concerns.

Cons
  • Lead guard, point guard, lead guard - Yes, it's a mess. And I agree that Collins gets a bit of a pass for Lathon. However, this isn't a one year thing. There hasn't been a - let's set the bar low - acceptable replacement for BMac for three years. It's not simply that there's no starting point guard this year. There also hasn't been that Greer-like-talent backup who would have been developing and a sixth-man on a good team. That would have provided a starter and a good system guy on this team.
  • Second and third options - This is what really worries me. This is where some of the creep is for me. The ongoing NU problem through coach after coach is that you see lineups with key players who are your second and third recruiting options at various positions with HUGE, one-dimensional holes in their game. I'm not talking about the 12th or 13th man on a roster. Those guys shouldn't be playing and don't matter. It's a problem at both guard spots this year. It's a problem with the guards off the bench also, and so far there's only one possible change to it next year.
OTOH, there are some pros you're ignoring.
  • Last year, but ... - Yes, last year was a disaster. Collins admitted as much and said he did a poor job having the team prepared. But in our macro view, NOBODY expected 16-17 team to be the year it was. It's obvious 17-18 was planned to be THE year, but you can't ignore why expectation were so high. That's a good thing.

  • Four-star "busts" - You can't talk about the "busts" and ignore the three-star (at-best) guys who have played at an all-conference level. We're not really going to leave BMac and Pardon out of the discussion, are we? But yes, CC needs more of those guys.

  • Obviously addressing some problems - I've said in the past, the size of this team has always been a problem for me. Tell me all you want about positionless basketball, but you need a mismatch at one of the five for that to work. Otherwise, you're just undersized. It's pretty obvious the staff has acknowledged that and addressed it well.
This year and next year are going to be tough, so I've purchased the matches to fire up the hot seats. But I'm not nearly ready to light them them yet.

This is still Northwestern, and getting guys in the school is a problem. Every NU coach deserves a long string. I'm with LoyolaCat. I'm cautiously hopeful. I want to see where this is in Nance and Kopp's junior and senior years.

I’m on record of my concern for next year. That said there is hope. Assuming all stay healthy NU and at (committed to) NU - in two years Collins will have 3 top 100 bigs and one former top 100 after injury big in two years. Plus a very athletic 5th big (wearing a boot today). There will be two point guards and a veteran shooting guard.

The team for two years from now needs shooting guards and small forwards.

One more observation - until a few months ago - Like Carmody, O’Neill, Foster, Byrdsong and Falk before him, Collins has had to deal with the worst facilities in the conference and certainly bottom 20% in power five. Starting with the 2019 class that changes. For the first time any NU coach will have top hoops facilities. Let’s see what Collins can do with the same tools as his peers before we give up.
 

Jeffrey Cat

Redshirt
Jan 29, 2005
604
10
0
I’m on record of my concern for next year. That said there is hope. Assuming all stay healthy NU and at (committed to) NU - in two years Collins will have 3 top 100 bigs and one former top 100 after injury big in two years. Plus a very athletic 5th big (wearing a boot today). There will be two point guards and a veteran shooting guard.

The team for two years from now needs shooting guards and small forwards.

One more observation - until a few months ago - Like Carmody, O’Neill, Foster, Byrdsong and Falk before him, Collins has had to deal with the worst facilities in the conference and certainly bottom 20% in power five. Starting with the 2019 class that changes. For the first time any NU coach will have top hoops facilities. Let’s see what Collins can do with the same tools as his peers before we give up.
Who is in a boot
 

Max_Power

Junior
May 29, 2001
2,947
214
51
Maybe not but why was the offer pulled so late in the recruiting cycle? If Collins and the administration aren't to blame, then who is?

Collins and NU did nothing wrong in this situation. They learned a recruit had acted improperly and acted in a timely manner. Kids, lets all move on. Greer had a solid game yesterday and looks like he can contribute for four years.