Why are there so many posters who become active when we lose? It always seems there are one or two when we win don't have a lot to say but when we lose they know exactley what the problem is. What motivates people like that? I know it sudden really bother me but it does. What are they like in real life away from the board? Sometimes I question if they are Duke fans. It's like they may be a troll and mess with us. I'm trying so hard to ignore them. Am I the only one here that those posters bother? OFC
I can't speak for others but I get hyped when we win and love to post about the positives of the team.
In fact, I had been saying most of the year that I thought we would be a FF team with the defense we showed the first two months of the season. But, I've always sought to be as honest as possible - positively and negatively. And I don't see us getting there unless somehow everyone gets hot and K changes things around.
I think myself and Koach Q and others have been pretty fair. When Duke has a talented team - more so than the team's they play - and they lose, there's a reason and coaching has to take part of the responsibility. When they win, there's a reason and coaching has to take part of the glory. I'm fine with handing out both honor and critique. But, when you beat a team that has a losing record by 20, well, that's what you expect from a top 5-10 team. When you lose to a team like that, it's not a game you should lose.
And, to be fair, there are those on the other side for whom K or players can do no wrong (like those who defended - probably still do defend (!)

- Greg Paulus' play).
It's not that fans don't root for the team, or for K, and cheer for them. I root for them all the way through their careers (which is why I also post in the NBA thread) and sweat bullets when they play in the NCAAs. I've cried when we won and cried when we lost. I will always be in K's corner as a person and arguably the greatest coach of all-time but that doesn't mean he's above reproach as a coach. Bobby Knight was the greatest Xs and Os coach in history, imo, but he was not above reproach (and I'm not just referring to the super negative stuff).