Thx. Always looking for value, especially in Rye for Manhattan’s. Been on a kick for a month or so to perfect my recipient to my taste. Templeton’s pretty good too but it’s at $49.
Here is a review I found online: Rittenhouse Rye is solid quintessential rye whiskey with a balanced blend of honey, licorice, anise, dill, oak, spice, bread, and fruit. It’s not spectacular or unique, but it carries itself well enough to sip neat or mix into a cocktail. Given what else is out there in the price range (Old Overhold Bonded,
Old Forester Rye), it’s a pretty good option.
If you haven’t had any or much rye whiskey before, Rittenhouse Rye is a good rye whiskey to use as your introduction, or another stepping store to learn more about rye, because there’s a lot more rye whiskey out there…it just often happens to be more expensive.
Now if you’re looking for a more unique, intense, or complex experience, I recommend
Pikesville Rye (also from Heaven Hill), which is 2 years older, 10 proof higher, and leaps and bounds more mature. This is assuming that you’re willing to pay an extra $20-30. I will say that Pikesville is a huge upgrade, but again everyone’s budget is different.
Fun fact, I picked Pikesville over Thomas Handy Sazerac in a
head to head comparison, so that’s high praise. If you are looking to get into rye whiskey or need something on-hand for cocktails, then Rittenhouse is a great bottle to buy.
BTW: if you’re into Irish Whisky I would also suggest Powers Three Swallows. It’s a good bit cheaper than Green Spot and an excellent sipper and sells for around $40.