I think part of it is that Benson has practically never played significant minutes on a regular basis. He can hit the weight room hard and practice well, but it's just not the same as game experience. Pardon has averaged 30+ minutes during Benson's entire career, except for a brief stretch when he was injured.
Also, calling him out against Michigan State of all teams is a bit unfair.
Don't think that's quite it.
Pardon was red-shirting until injuries forced burning his shirt and while inconsistent, Pardon showed flashes of his potential.
Davide played fewer minutes than Benson had during his first 2 seasons and yet Davide had some big games for the 'Cats; not coincidentally, against MSU.
If Benson had shown more, he would have gotten more playing time.
This just shows that while it's great to get excited about * ratings, better to wait until the player hits campus and at least hear what is coming out of practice.
Despite Benson being the 4* recruit, was more excited about Pardon when he came in as a frosh (based on what was said about Pardon's game in HS and the scuttle-butt that came out of practice).