For Those Who Want Stoops Fired

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,713
0
Stoops gets 5 years period and he should. Coaches will get better as we add better players and a deeper roster. Stoops and company have done a great job of recruiting and if he gets fired after 5 years he will leave a good roster of players, GO CATS
Golly gee you're an optimist. Good on you for that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,713
0
I do not want to see Stoops fired. I want him to get at a minimum five years. But, I do want to see him stop making basic coaching mistakes at critical junctures in winnable games.
Why? The second part of your post is exactly why he should be let go. 4 years in and this is still a problem. Why?
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

ScrewDuke1

Hall of Famer
Jul 29, 2016
41,033
152,423
113
Stoops sounded like he knew he was done during the post game presser. He sounded very mellow. You could tell he was thinking that his chances of turning this around are about dead now.
 

Big John Stud

All-American
Jan 14, 2003
23,281
8,876
0
All of you who want Stoops fired after year #3, ask yourself a question, where is UK in the pecking order of South Carolina and Missouri?

Some need a shot of reality in the arm. UK is 3rd in the pecking order of South Carolina and Missouri. With all these openings that happened this off season South Carolina hired a proven loser who hired the same OC that he had at Florida, and everyone turned down the Missouri job and so they had to hire the DC as the head coach. Seriously, do you people want DJ Eliot or Shannon Dawson as your head coach? That's the equivalent that you'd get if you fired Stoops right now.

People saying that not firing Stoops is delaying the inevitable, but what do you do when you have an offseason with the most openings that FBS has seen and schools in a higher pecking order than you fail to make a splash hire. Logic will tell you that the inevitable would be that you hire someone with a fraction of the coaching ability as Stoops, and you would hire then for a 3 year period where recruiting wouldn't be nearly as good, thus delaying anything that the next Head Coach could do with a talent deficient roster like the one Stoops inherited. Which means you begin the circle of failure again.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

For those who said Stoops doesn't know what he's doing, ask yourself this question... Why did he figure it out for the first half of the season 2 years in a row, but not the 2nd half?

Another shot of reality needs to be given to some. Starting 4-1 this season, and starting 5-1 last season obviously shows that Stoops has figured it out enough to have his team playing competitively and inspired for the first half of the season. For those who is comparing Stoops to Joker, ask yourself when did Joker do that? I like Joker and know him, but the staff and the head coach from that era to this era is night and day. Joker had an issue with assembling a team, let alone even playing a game. Stoops' problem is figuring out how to get his players to sustain the energy and competitiveness that they start the season with. That's a far cry from Joker!

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Do any of you realize that Mark Stoops inherited the worst roster of any team in a P5 conference? That's not just me saying it, several pundits have said that and continue to say that. It was remarkable that Stoops even began last season with a 5-1 record. For those who think James Franklin did a remarkable job, go and look at how many Vandy players he inherited sniffed the NFL. I'll give you a hint, it was more than he inherited at Penn State. The outcome of his lack of success at Penn State compared to when he was at Vandy is no coincidence. So don't compare what James Franklin did at Vandy to what Mark Stoops is doing at UK. Bottom line is the NFL players Stoops inherited are Avery Williamson and Bud Dupree, the rest he's recruited himself or converted from a WR to a LB and developed them himself. Crazy thing is Bud Dupree said himself that he developed more under Stoops in 1 year than he did his entire time under Joker. I really believe you guys think UK is in a better position than we really are.

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Another dose of reality needs to be given to fans who think they'll pull another successful head coach from another team at this level. Mark Stoops was a coordinator, Joker was a coordinator, Rich Brooks was former NFL DC who was out of work, Guy Morris was an OLine coach off of a staff that left because of NCAA infractions, Hal Mumme was a D3 head coach, Bill Curry was a head coach who was about to be let go..... News flash all UK is going to be able to get from a high level school is a coordinator, and as long as that is the case, we will have to deal with a HC who is learning on the job. Sure we can go get Mark Hudspeth, but recruiting will severely suffer, I'm talking someone who is struggling to land Joker like recruits. If you look at the SEC's history of HC's coming in without any prior HC experience it ain't good. For every Philip Fulmer there are like 10 Will Muschamp's. Unless UK suddenly jumps up in stature, its best Head Coaches will always be coordinators. That unfortunately comes with a learning curve and it will always take them some years to get over that learning curve. Yeah you could find a James Franklin, but that's rare. Are you willing to fire the next 5 or 10 HC's to find a James Franklin who inherits a nice roster, or will you let a coordinator go through his pains of being a first time HC while showing competence and recruiting the best in program history and let him build something out of what was previously nothing?
Yeah, we cant find a dynamic up and coming coach to take our $4 million a year. Impossible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

AlbanyWildCat

All-Conference
Mar 18, 2009
6,895
2,694
0
The last time we had some consistency in a head coach, we seemed to do OK. I think the same crowd on this thread clamoring for Stoops to be canned were probably the same clowns calling for Brooks' head as well.

Allow the guy five years and then evaluate. He has not embarrassed the program in any way off the field or done anything to warrant being fired.

Yes, we all would love a winning program, but we are UK Football at the end of the day. When does basketball season start?
 

Yahtzee43

Junior
Sep 2, 2014
321
218
0
I keep seeing all these posts and threads about Defensive schemes, asst coaches, special teams, Defensive Coordinator. Let's change something, anything that will mix things up and tell the AD and fans that change is coming. Like a politician that keeps promising change but it never comes but the lemmings keep waiting.

You know what ?? Everything starts with the head coach. The leadership, the vision, the ability to finish a game. The toughness to be tougher in the 3rd and 4th quarter than your opponent. That is all instilled by the culture and direction of head coach.

We don't have that. The solution is always, fire the OC, move on to the next assistant, let's try an assistant from Louisville, new coordinators, new whistles, new schemes.

Guess what ? The only thing that is not changing is Stoops is still the head coach and we are still performing the same way. How many games over the last 3 years have we lost the game in 3rd or 4th quarter, what abotu 4th quarter ? I count at least 12-13 games.

That comes from the leadership, or lack thereof from the head coach. Big Blue Nation, we need to wake up and realize now that this guy is not the right fit for our team and program. It will not get better, but worse.
 

BlueBallz_rivals30790

All-Conference
Mar 26, 2003
5,688
1,812
0
I've gone from not wanting to see Stoops fired to not caring if he's fired. The bad taste of last season just came back. There's no doubt he gets out coached. USM is a good, not great, team. He's been there long enough, this shouldn't happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

TBCat

Heisman
Mar 30, 2007
14,317
10,331
0
All of you who want Stoops fired after year #3, ask yourself a question, where is UK in the pecking order of South Carolina and Missouri?

Some need a shot of reality in the arm. UK is 3rd in the pecking order of South Carolina and Missouri. With all these openings that happened this off season South Carolina hired a proven loser who hired the same OC that he had at Florida, and everyone turned down the Missouri job and so they had to hire the DC as the head coach. Seriously, do you people want DJ Eliot or Shannon Dawson as your head coach? That's the equivalent that you'd get if you fired Stoops right now.

People saying that not firing Stoops is delaying the inevitable, but what do you do when you have an offseason with the most openings that FBS has seen and schools in a higher pecking order than you fail to make a splash hire. Logic will tell you that the inevitable would be that you hire someone with a fraction of the coaching ability as Stoops, and you would hire then for a 3 year period where recruiting wouldn't be nearly as good, thus delaying anything that the next Head Coach could do with a talent deficient roster like the one Stoops inherited. Which means you begin the circle of failure again.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

For those who said Stoops doesn't know what he's doing, ask yourself this question... Why did he figure it out for the first half of the season 2 years in a row, but not the 2nd half?

Another shot of reality needs to be given to some. Starting 4-1 this season, and starting 5-1 last season obviously shows that Stoops has figured it out enough to have his team playing competitively and inspired for the first half of the season. For those who is comparing Stoops to Joker, ask yourself when did Joker do that? I like Joker and know him, but the staff and the head coach from that era to this era is night and day. Joker had an issue with assembling a team, let alone even playing a game. Stoops' problem is figuring out how to get his players to sustain the energy and competitiveness that they start the season with. That's a far cry from Joker!

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Do any of you realize that Mark Stoops inherited the worst roster of any team in a P5 conference? That's not just me saying it, several pundits have said that and continue to say that. It was remarkable that Stoops even began last season with a 5-1 record. For those who think James Franklin did a remarkable job, go and look at how many Vandy players he inherited sniffed the NFL. I'll give you a hint, it was more than he inherited at Penn State. The outcome of his lack of success at Penn State compared to when he was at Vandy is no coincidence. So don't compare what James Franklin did at Vandy to what Mark Stoops is doing at UK. Bottom line is the NFL players Stoops inherited are Avery Williamson and Bud Dupree, the rest he's recruited himself or converted from a WR to a LB and developed them himself. Crazy thing is Bud Dupree said himself that he developed more under Stoops in 1 year than he did his entire time under Joker. I really believe you guys think UK is in a better position than we really are.

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Another dose of reality needs to be given to fans who think they'll pull another successful head coach from another team at this level. Mark Stoops was a coordinator, Joker was a coordinator, Rich Brooks was former NFL DC who was out of work, Guy Morris was an OLine coach off of a staff that left because of NCAA infractions, Hal Mumme was a D3 head coach, Bill Curry was a head coach who was about to be let go..... News flash all UK is going to be able to get from a high level school is a coordinator, and as long as that is the case, we will have to deal with a HC who is learning on the job. Sure we can go get Mark Hudspeth, but recruiting will severely suffer, I'm talking someone who is struggling to land Joker like recruits. If you look at the SEC's history of HC's coming in without any prior HC experience it ain't good. For every Philip Fulmer there are like 10 Will Muschamp's. Unless UK suddenly jumps up in stature, its best Head Coaches will always be coordinators. That unfortunately comes with a learning curve and it will always take them some years to get over that learning curve. Yeah you could find a James Franklin, but that's rare. Are you willing to fire the next 5 or 10 HC's to find a James Franklin who inherits a nice roster, or will you let a coordinator go through his pains of being a first time HC while showing competence and recruiting the best in program history and let him build something out of what was previously nothing?


You post some good things at times but this is as silly a post as I've seen. So because South Carolina did a bad job we are now to believe there is no such thing as a good hire? South Carolina was higher than Houston at one point. How did they get a better coach?

And right now I'd take Muschamp. Stoops has never beaten him and probably will lose this year. Besides USC won their opener. And they didn't look like half the dumpster fire that we look like right now. We embarrassed not only ourselves last night but the entire league. That was an absolutely shameful performance last night. The sad thing is that it's not the first time we've pulled that crap under Stoops. It seems to be repetitive.
 

GoCatsForever2k15

All-Conference
Jun 7, 2015
3,082
1,895
0
Side note: USM was an awful team to put on the schedule. I get that our options were limited, but was Southern Miss really the best (or worst, depending on how you look at it) we could do?
 

ukdesi

Junior
Dec 17, 2002
2,924
376
0
Year 1....Game 1....lost to W. Kentucky by 9
Year 4....Game 1....loses to S. Mississippi by 9

Defense hasn't improved in year 4. Starting to think....this is who we are.....under Stoops
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

Jamal Mercer

Heisman
Feb 7, 2008
10,805
23,536
0
Kinda feel bad for the OP.

Spent a good 2 hours on this post.

Luckily I've grown to be apathetic toward UK football. I slept just fine last night after one of the most embarrassing nights in our history.
 

gamalielkid

All-American
Mar 21, 2002
6,072
6,573
113
If we fail to make a bowl game next year, Stoops should be fired. It's highly unlikely that he will due to his contract, but he should be based on performance. This is essentially year three based on how bad we were when he took over.

That said, the cupboard is not bare. If we don't make a bowl game next year, it is 100% on coaching. He doesn't have Joker recruits anymore. These are Stoops guys. Well over the majority of the players will have played at least one year of SEC football. We will certainly have the talent and experience for a bowl game. If he can't do it, bring in a coaching staff that can coach up the talent we have.

So, yes, I absolutely want him fired if we do not make a bowl game next year.

The only problem with this is Coach Stoops. He said it on his radio post game show last night. He doesn't know what to do! I appreciate him taking the blame - but if he can't fix it - then he needs to go - NOW! He needs to coach the Florida game like this is his last game! Forget all the basic rules - go for broke. Never punt, do onside kicks, fake field goals, etc. Show the team he is going to try to win - and either they buy in or go home!

I guess the question of when to change coaches is more about philosophy than winning football. I will phrase it in a different manner. If you were a doctor and you had a patient that was dying, would you make him comfortable and let him die and live a bed ridden life for 18 months or would you try a treatment that has been successful with other patients that would save his life? This is how I feel about UK football and Mark Stoops now. Continuing with Mark Stoops now is just prolonging the inevitable. We waited an extra year on Joker - when most everyone knew it wasn't going to work - how did that work out for us? We went from having a .500 record to back to back 2-10 seasons and the program in a shambles. Do you really think that Mark Stoops will turn it around? If so, then ok. But if you think that we have to "honor" our commitment and give him 5 or more years just because - then I would highly disagree with you.

Southern Mississippi was a good team IMO, but it isn't the loss here that was so bothersome - it is how it happened. Just think, if we had been behind 44 to 0 and came back to lose by this score - how different the feelings of the fans would have been. We would have been going into the Florida game thinking we might have turned the corner - this is why you have to change coaches NOW. Just think - 6 of the last 7 games we have played the team totally collapsed late in the first half and the entire second half???!!!!!!! You can't blame that on Shannon Dawson now!

Now ask yourself this question, since your brought it up as a positive for Mark Stoops. How many Joker recruits started last night? How many are in the two deep? How many players on the roster didn't play for Joker? I think this argument doesn't hold any water. This IS Stoops team! If you remember, it took a fan boycott to to boot Joker. The fans are or soon will be doing it again. I have never seen such much unhappiness on the football boards as is the case right now. It was probably just as bad with the end of Joker's era - but this seems worse. I think this is because we have made so much commitment to football now. The difference this time in hiring a coach is you can't tell me that a Coaching prospect can question the commitment that UK has made to football. Mark Stoops has done for UK what John Ray did - get us some competitive facilities - now we need to repeat history and to go hire another Fran Curci - and win some games! By the way, what Curci was accused of then, wouldn't even get a look from the NCAA today.

It is time we go after a winner. I think I would go after Jeff Brohm right now. He has proven himself as a head coach - something as other posters have mentioned - we haven't hired recently - a current successful HEAD coach. Some people don't think Jeff Brohm would come to UK - but for $ 4 million a year - I think you are wrong. He knows Kentucky and this area , he can point to his success and he has to believe that Petrino is going to be at Louisville for a long, long time and that job may not open up for at least a decade. Even if UL opens up, if he is doing well at UK, I don't think he would leave - but if he did - so what- it isn't like we have had great stability with coaches here is it? He is winning with much less talent than is on this football team now! I know it is not the same schedule - but you have to say he has been around winning football coaches and programs. He is probably going to be a winner in the long run - and has a great family background. If you think he is cocky, which I don't know anything about - that is ok. Name me one successful head coach who isn't cocky - just think about Coach Cal - do you think he is cocky - I do. Heck, those great Trinity players might just become very interested in UK instead of UL for a change!

Go Big Blue!
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe
Dec 6, 2004
3,317
812
0
I see there are some posters in this thread that keep saying Stoops is unfireable due his buyout. Wait until that stadium has about 15,000 in it for a game(like Vandy a few years ago)and we shall see if that Buyout comes to fruition.
 

AlbanyWildCat

All-Conference
Mar 18, 2009
6,895
2,694
0
I see there are some posters in this thread that keep saying Stoops is unfireable due his buyout. Wait until that stadium has about 15,000 in it for a game(like Vandy a few years ago)and we shall see if that Buyout comes to fruition.

As previously mentioned, the money UK gets from the SEC Network makes the attendance from game day less of an issue to deal with.
 

UKWildcats#8

All-American
Jun 25, 2011
30,327
9,337
0
Kinda feel bad for the OP.

Spent a good 2 hours on this post.

Luckily I've grown to be apathetic toward UK football. I slept just fine last night after one of the most embarrassing nights in our history.

I've become apathetic towards sports' losses in general for the most part as I have gotten older. I didn't get that upset at all after the IU game this year in b-ball either. Now Wisconsin the year before? Uh yeah. I guess it is relative to expectations. I am also a Titans' fan and certainly am used to them losing. It just is what it is...life goes on. Ultimately it is just a game we watch for entertainment, nothing more, nothing less.
 
  • Like
Reactions: domino79

Randy Bob

All-Conference
Jun 14, 2009
7,199
3,909
113
Stoops is payed alot of money to win, need to get someone one else, if fans quit going to the games he will be got rid of..
 
Last edited:

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,170
0
The difference in Missouri / USC and UK football is the administration and fans. They won't accept this, period. They are willing to not only invest but hire winners and demand excellence.

If we fall short while doing those things, fine. I can live with that. But we are not doing that. We are content, willing to give dumpster fire hires half a decade or more, willing to hire no name coordinators, willing to accept mediocrity.

Until we have an AD That demands excellence, DEMANDS IT, our fans won't believe and our team will be the doormat.

You don't need intelligence or a 10 page post to understand this.
 

rjr

Sophomore
Oct 14, 2003
1,990
176
0
I hope stoops turns this around, but it seems clear to me he is in over his head. Time and time again he loses the second half- when coaching really matters. He gets out coached - time and again at the half.

Look- I was for Petrino and I get that his ship has sailed. So lets talk about what we can hire- we don't need a big name. But we need a winner. I'm tired of people like Matt Jones acting like Stoops is the best we can get. No, Stoops had never been a head coach before and its clear he is in over his head. Joker had never been a head coach before and he was in over his head.

So go down to Division 2 and hire a proven winner- a proven HEAD COACH. Go hire Appalachian State's head coach. Just get someone with proven head coach experience who has won- even if at a different level.

Barnhart screwed up another hire- let him go too so he doesn't mess up the next one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,170
0
I hope stoops turns this around, but it seems clear to me he is in over his head. Time and time again he loses the second half- when coaching really matters. He gets out coached - time and again at the half.

Look- I was for Petrino and I get that his ship has sailed. So lets talk about what we can hire- we don't need a big name. But we need a winner. I'm tired of people like Matt Jones acting like Stoops is the best we can get. No, Stoops had never been a head coach before and its clear he is in over his head. Joker had never been a head coach before and he was in over his head.

So go down to Division 2 and hire a proven winner- a proven HEAD COACH. Go hire Appalachian State's head coach. Just get someone with proven head coach experience who has won- even if at a different level.

Barnhart screwed up another hire- let him go too so he doesn't mess up the next one.

You didn't mention morals tho. We've got them.
 

UKFBALLER

Redshirt
Nov 23, 2012
513
24
0
That sounds great in theory. Let's see what happens when they lose that money and look like laughing stocks.

This is actually true...sadly. Most of the major revenue UK brings in is from season tickets and donations, which are already a sunk cost at this point. The single game sales and concessions honestly doesn't bring in as much money as one would think. The only way to make a big dent is by not renewing season tickets, not donating, or big donors not funding facility projects.
 

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,170
0
As previously mentioned, the money UK gets from the SEC Network makes the attendance from game day less of an issue to deal with.

This is flat out false. In all walks. I don't know who's repeating this, but it's a complete lie.

Divide ticket sales by 60'000 and multiply it times 6 or 7. If you think that doesn't add up and play a huge role, you're living on Neptune
 

katfanuno

All-Conference
Apr 15, 2008
1,634
1,036
113
He's no better coach than joker, he has some recruiters but otherwise he's a dumpster fire and so is Elliot.
 

ukalum1988

Heisman
Dec 21, 2014
12,158
31,403
113
I really enjoy people doing the deep research, going into the archives to pull out the old threads and making them relevant to current events.

Sadly we are no better off now than where we last December.
 

CatsCats78

Junior
Jun 17, 2016
122
244
0
I'll give Stoops credit for his recruiting his first couple years. The Boom, Barker, Elam, etc commits were HUGE. But unfortunately recruiting and performance on the field go hand in hand. You can only sell "come help us turn this thing around" to recruits for so long before the smoke and mirrors game is caught on to by future recruits. When you only win 4-5 games a year, every year it's only a matter of time before the recruiting starts to level off. Then you're left with midocre players and a coach and staff that can't coach. Not a good recipe in the SEC. We need to get out ahead of this situation early before Mizzou/SC regain the momentum they've lost. JMO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe

louisvillesux

Junior
Feb 22, 2008
1,134
324
0
nobody "wants" to fire stoops. but damn, if its proven that he cant coach thats what has to happen. non of us "want" to be in this position, having this discussion.