Toggle sidebar

Geo Baker

R

rpiseman

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2004
2,152
3,585
98
I wonder if the current state of college basketball is what Geo and the kid from Iowa envisioned? Kids jumping from school to school every year for a “bag”. I understand the free market aspects of introducing NIL, but college basketball is effectively unrecognizable and has changed for the worse.

Maybe this was Geo’s plan, would love to hear his perspective.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jvgrad02, malaka27 and bac2therac
R

RUsojo

Heisman
Dec 17, 2010
28,058
26,457
113
Everyone is benefiting from NIL. Parity has never been better. Kids have never had more money. Rating have never been better. Rutgers basketball hasn’t been better in decades. Etc etc.

Lot of guards were in the mix next year, should help to move us along for 2024. With cliffs decision looming next year could be a wash even before this announcement but that’s not definitive. Just what I’m thinking about as I think about the team right now.

More rules would be better and I’m sure they’ll come down the line.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MiloTalon13, malaka27, Fat Koko and 1 other person
A

anon_0k9zlfz6lz9oy

Guest
It’s not what they envisioned because they were too young/naive and didnt understand things.

They were college kids with little real life experience when they advocated for this. When youre in college you usually are narrow minded. We all were.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: o_Mb5789, mikeylew1992, RU2131 and 12 others
P

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,306
23,009
0
kyk1827 said:
It’s not what they envisioned because they were too young/naive and didnt understand things.

They were college kids with little real life experience when they advocated for this. When youre in college you usually are narrow minded. We all were.
Click to expand...
But not all of us led a charge that messed up a sport.
 
  • Like
Reactions: knight82 and bac2therac
ScarletDave

ScarletDave

Heisman
Oct 7, 2010
34,377
14,981
85
It’s not NIL in a vacuum causing the problem. It’s NIL + the transfer rules. They need to bring back you can transfer 1 time, and sit out a year if you transfer twice, after that you lose your eligibility. If a head coach leaves, you can transfer freely. But if the head coach is still there, you can transfer once. That would put an end to free agency. Not even the pros are this unregulated.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rubigtimenow, #1 RUFan, RU2131 and 10 others
G

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
In a perfect world I’d like players to make a choice whether they are professionals or amateurs. While they are amateurs they can not be compensated at all based on NIL.

However while they are amateurs they get a healthy stipend while they are in college and a significant percentage of the revenue that was earned from their sport gets placed in a trust for dispursement in the future.

On top of all this the NBA taking a bigger role in players development and dropping the age requirement. NBA franchises need to be on the hook and have to take risks.
 
N

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
13,604
12,367
0
Rutgers uses the transfer portal and NIL to steal a player from a lower level team: Great!
The same player then uses the portal and NIL to leave Rutgers: the system sucks and I'm not fan anymore!

Sounds about right for around here.
Where are all the threads from last off season saying "We shouldn't be poaching Cam. Think of how the Loyola fanbase is going to feel."
 
  • Like
Reactions: rutgersguy1_rivals, TRU2RU_rivals, RUDiddy777 and 9 others
G

GORU2014

All-Conference
Sep 4, 2013
2,638
4,668
113
If we had a team of Geo Bakers we wouldn’t have collapsed and missed the tournament in epic fashion last year, so let’s redirect this toward the person making a choice to leave or the people making a choice to pay a probably obscene amount for him to play for a year
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigEastPhil, czxqa, #1 RUFan and 2 others
K

kcg88

Heisman
Aug 11, 2017
10,862
17,230
0
NickRU714 said:
Rutgers uses the transfer portal and NIL to steal a player from a lower level team: Great!
The same player then uses the portal and NIL to leave Rutgers: the system sucks and I'm not fan anymore!

Sounds about right for around here.
Where are all the threads from last off season saying "We shouldn't be poaching Cam. Think of how the Loyola fanbase is going to feel."
Click to expand...
A player going from the Patriot League to the Big Ten in mid April is very different from a player leaving the Big Ten to go to some other high major in mid May.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rutgers36, bigmatt718, malaka27 and 2 others
R

RUby RED

All-Conference
Aug 9, 2010
1,857
2,683
0
GRU23 said:
Lol NIL was a human right that was passed unanimously in Supreme Court. Your complaints about how it affects your favorite teams literally means jack squat. Geo did everything right.
Click to expand...
Thank you! NIL at its most fundamental level was long overdue and Geo & co should be commended in advocating for it. The unintended consequences of NIL lie firmly in the hands of governing bodies and their lack of control / oversight. Tracing everything that is wrong with NIL back to Geo is reductionist and points to an infantile understanding of the world
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: BillyC80, rurichdog, TRU2RU_rivals and 6 others
N

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
13,604
12,367
0
kcg88 said:
A player going from the Patriot League to the Big Ten in mid April is very different from a player leaving the Big Ten to go to some other high major in mid May.
Click to expand...

Tell that to the Patriot League fans.

So if Spencer goes to Kentucky or Kansas or UConn - everyone will be fine?
 
S

scarlet night

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2004
3,129
1,621
66
RUby RED said:
Thank you! NIL at its most fundamental level was long overdue and Geo & co should be commended in advocating for it. The unintended consequences of NIL lie firmly in the hands of governing bodies and their lack of control / oversight. Tracing everything that is wrong with NIL back to Geo is reductionist and points to an infantile understanding of the world
Click to expand...
Exactly this
 
  • Like
Reactions: MiloTalon13 and Loyal-Son
N

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
13,604
12,367
0
kcg88 said:
You're being intentionally obtuse. Hundreds of players did what Cam did last season. How many high major double digit scorers have entered the portal this week?
Click to expand...

Oh. So your problem is the timing? Not that he's transferring for NIL considerations.
Okay - then undate the transfer window dates. Who cares.

But this thread is about NIL and Transfers.
So you're fine with Cam transferring for NIL reasons - just wanted it to be a month ago?
Just making sure I understand your point so I'm not being "intentionally" obtuse. And merely accidentally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUsojo
K

kcg88

Heisman
Aug 11, 2017
10,862
17,230
0
NickRU714 said:
Oh. So your problem is the timing? Not that he's transferring for NIL considerations.
Okay - then undate the transfer window dates. Who cares.

But this thread is about NIL and Transfers.
So you're fine with Cam transferring for NIL reasons - just wanted it to be a month ago?
Just making sure I understand your point so I'm not being "intentionally" obtuse. And merely accidentally.
Click to expand...
I'm okay with NIL but the current format is clearly broken. I don't think baseball should bring back the reserve clause but I also don't want every baseball player to be a free agent every offseason.

To be clear the blame rests at the feet of the NCAA who blinded themselves to the inevitable and hardly even tried to put a framework in. I don't blame Geo one bit for fighting for NIL but I do reject the notion that Geo's interests and fans' interests are aligned. They aren't.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LETSGORU91, GM and NickRU714
N

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
13,604
12,367
0
kcg88 said:
I'm okay with NIL but the current format is clearly broken. I don't think baseball should bring back the reserve clause but I also don't want every baseball player to be a free agent every offseason.

To be clear the blame rests at the feet of the NCAA who blinded themselves to the inevitable and hardly even tried to put a framework in. I don't blame Geo one bit for fighting for NIL but I do reject the notion that Geo's interests and fans' interests are aligned. They aren't.
Click to expand...

Why would players interests and fans interests be aligned?
I would agree - who ever said that is fooling themselves.

It's simple:
Fans want good players to be forced to stay but also have the ability for bad players to be pushed out the door.
Oh and they also want good players from other schools to be able to transfer in.
But our good players can't transfer out.

Players want to be the best possible situation at that time.

Ace Bailey: Fans - forced to stay for 4 years, Player - able to go straight to NBA
Cam Spencer: Fan - forced to stay 4 years at Loyola (unless Rutgers wants him - then he should be able to transfer to us. screw those Loyola fans and what they wnat). Player - ability to transfer and get NIL from the highest bidder

Jalen Miller, Dean Reiber, Oskar Palmquist: Fans - able to force out when the staff wants so make room for higher rated recruits.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rutgersguy1_rivals and RUsojo
P

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,306
23,009
0
Greene Rice FIG said:
In a perfect world I’d like players to make a choice whether they are professionals or amateurs. While they are amateurs they can not be compensated at all based on NIL.

However while they are amateurs they get a healthy stipend while they are in college and a significant percentage of the revenue that was earned from their sport gets placed in a trust for dispursement in the future.

On top of all this the NBA taking a bigger role in players development and dropping the age requirement. NBA franchises need to be on the hook and have to take risks.
Click to expand...
That ship sailed. Ncaa could have handled this years ago . Literally years ago.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RutgersNo1
N

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
13,604
12,367
0
Greene Rice FIG said:
In a perfect world I’d like players to make a choice whether they are professionals or amateurs. While they are amateurs they can not be compensated at all based on NIL.

However while they are amateurs they get a healthy stipend while they are in college and a significant percentage of the revenue that was earned from their sport gets placed in a trust for dispursement in the future.

On top of all this the NBA taking a bigger role in players development and dropping the age requirement. NBA franchises need to be on the hook and have to take risks.
Click to expand...

This doesn't work for basketball like other sports though.
NBA teams would love to lower the age requirement.
It's the NBA players that don't want it (more kids taking their jobs).

NBA would immediately take roughly the top 20 HS recruits right off the top every year.
Harper, Bailey and other elite HS players would never even consider Rutgers.
Fans would have to drastically lower their expectations around incoming talent.
 
R

RUBOB72

All-American
Aug 5, 2004
23,385
7,924
0
It is not just losing Cam Spencer… it’s that our podcast predictors didn’t have a clue. Every speculation was that Mawot Mag was the guy, and he still might leave along with Cliff , Paul and whomever else takes the money and runs. Don’t blame the players . Blame the F’d up NCAA who did absolutely nothing prior to this. I don’t blame SP at all but Rutgers better be ready to be the feeder program to many other institutions of HIGHER learning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fat Koko and Plum Street
G

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
RUBOB72 said:
It is not just losing Cam Spencer… it’s that our podcast predictors didn’t have a clue. Every speculation was that Mawot Mag was the guy, and he still might leave along with Cliff , Paul and whomever else takes the money and runs. Don’t blame the players . Blame the F’d up NCAA who did absolutely nothing prior to this. I don’t blame SP at all but Rutgers better be ready to be the feeder program to many other institutions of HIGHER learning.
Click to expand...
How can you blame them. It is impossible to know what the price of a player will be in the future.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUnTeX
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom