you're making an assumption there
Messed up? If it's not Fenchak, then it is somewhat messed up. But I don't have the tools to determine who registered the handle. And if I did find out it was not Fenchak, that by itself does not warrant a banning. There are a lot of people that have registered handles over the years that were of famous celebs, former PSU players, etc. None of them were banned for impersonating somebody else. So if anything, the tradition that has been established is that adopting a handle of someone you are not is not something that gets you in trouble.
A bad look on my part? You're way, way, way ahead of things. Again, I don't know who the poster is. With the move of the board to On3, there are a whole lot of posters that I don't know who they are, even if they are long-term posters. Folks changed handles, either because they wanted a change or because their handle was already taken, etc. It takes time to learn a poster's tendencies, interests, patterns of misbehavior, etc. I had 20 years to collect that info at the former site. I've been on this site for 7 days.
If the individual in question misbehaves, then it will likely require action on my part. But except in situations where the handle is offensive, or the majority of posts by an individual are offensive, I like to give posters a long leash, and see how they act.
I'm happy to stand on the reputation I've built over 25 years of running a PSU board. I'm quite certain that I'm an honorable person, and one that does the right thing in moderating the board 99% of the time.
Again, somebody has to make a really offensive post, or make repeated posts that cause more problems for me as the moderator, and the board community as readers, before they get banned. I appreciate your thoughts on how you would handle the situation, even if I'm not in agreement with taking such actions at this time.