Alright, let's take the athleticism debate. Here are Cook and Paige's combine results.
Standing vert:
Cook - 24.5
Paige - 33.5
Max vert:
Cook - 31"
Paige - 39.5"
Lane agility:
Cook - 11.28
Paige - 10.82
Shuttle run:
Cook - 3.41
Paige - 2.69
Three quarter sprint
Cook - 3.38
Paige - 3.15
Paige did indeed win a couple games with big plays in crunch time. Video evidence:
As far as him being a better driver and finisher, that is indeed subjective, I reckon. But I don't think analysts would disagree with me. And someone (I think it was dukedevils) mentioned yesterday that Cook was better in the pick-n-roll. I can't refute he was "better" but I can say that Bilas last night spit a stat when he was discussing how good Paige was in P&R situations. I'm sure y'all DVR'd the draft so you can go back and hear the high praise he had for Marcus.
And as far as my comment that Paige was better at his best than Cook was at his best, we can just look at their best years...or their top games. And again, I would like to stress...