How about Ben’s

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,291
5,213
113
I think its stupid that you only get 2 challenges for a game. If you are right,you should not be limited.
You nailed it. You should retain a challenge as long as you keep being right. Why the hell should Iowa--or any other team--be further penalized because the refs continue to make bad calls? That's just ridiculous.

And, of course, in the days before challenges, those two incorrect calls would have cost Iowa the win and allowed Florida to move on because of the refs' incompetence.
 

Jayb01

Senior
Jul 3, 2025
306
652
93
Same guy made both calls. Neither should have been a challenge. They were slam dunks. He was ducking and already turned away before the florida guy touched it last on the first one. Literally couldn't see it but he assumed and made the (wrong) call anyways. The second one was just a bad call. You know florida fans think they got hosed in that game by the refs? Lol.
 

Herky T Hawk

All-Conference
Feb 5, 2003
429
1,010
93
First one was ridiculous that another ref didn't come in and fix it. The only reason that ball got sent right at the ref's face was because the Florida player hit it that way. Second one is one that I could see being an in game miss as it happened so fast and the ball didn't change direction.

We lose that game if either of those calls aren't overturned. And it is absolutely dumb that we get penalized by referee incompetence if we successfully challenge twice and can no longer challenge the rest of the game. The challenge is a last ditch effort to overrule the potential for corruption in referees and limiting it is dumb.
 

HAWKNESS

Senior
Jul 6, 2025
262
495
63
Use of the challenges in that game! Both were somewhat close, at least at full speed anyway. And he nailed the challenge call on both of them.

They were huge in the Hawks being able to just get by Florida.
The first one wasn't close at all. It was pathetic the one who didn't see it made the call with no help
 
  • Like
Reactions: DukeSlater

Smigamorski

Sophomore
Mar 4, 2019
83
124
33
There was another opportunity for a challenge the play when the Florida player threw it off Kombs (who was out of bounds) and Florida was rewarded the ball. The challenge rule should always be unlimited challenges until you get one wrong.
 

SoonerBeAHawk

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2005
514
1,085
93
Heard the IA video guy made the call to challenge the second one.
Good teamwork goes beyond players and coaches...
What a huge responsibility for some kid, I'm guessing, who happens to be good with video? Probably a little more nuanced than that but yeah, great teamwork.

Too late to nominate Video Guy for MVP?
 

SoonerBeAHawk

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2005
514
1,085
93
Btw, did the automatic review of out-of-bound plays under 2 minutes disappear with the ability for the very limited coaches challenges?

I'm thinking that's right and if so what kind of trade-off is that? Not being able to challenge a late o-o-b for lack of a challenge is ridiculous.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DukeSlater

DukeSlater

All-American
Jul 2, 2023
2,291
5,213
113
Same guy made both calls. Neither should have been a challenge. They were slam dunks. He was ducking and already turned away before the florida guy touched it last on the first one. Literally couldn't see it but he assumed and made the (wrong) call anyways. The second one was just a bad call. You know florida fans think they got hosed in that game by the refs? Lol.
Maybe it shouldn't come as a surprise what residents of Florida believe. And maybe somebody should point out that the calls were reviewed and the evidence showed the original calls were wrong. You don't have to like the fact that the sun rises in the East, but that doesn't change the fact . . . not even in Florida.

BTW: Why would a #1 seed from the mighty SEC need excuses after facing a lowly #9 seed from the little ol' Big Ten? :unsure:
 

TheGuy9

Sophomore
Mar 25, 2016
85
119
33
The automatic review must still exist at least for some things. The Referees literally stopped the game with 4 seconds left to review how much time was on the clock. Talk about a game buster. Gave Florida time to set up a play. They need to change that rule in the last minute of the game, and instead of stopping the clock after a made shot, the clock should continue to run unless there is a foul or a time out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BroncHawk
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Basketball Iowa Men's Basketball Fearless Forecast
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Basketball Four stats to watch for Iowa men's basketball
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Iowa coaches hit the recruiting trail during bye week
  4. 04 Rivals Basketball Recruiting 5-star RJ Evans discusses Kentucky, Louisville, and his NBA ambitions
  5. 05 On3 Football College Football Playoff nearing deal to expand to 24 teams