IHSA is playing Chess while everyone else plays checkers

mc140

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
8,781
2,830
113
The IHSA wants nothing to do with organizing districts. They put this out there to get enough people riled up to get a repeal vote on the ballot this November. The long game will be everyone gets in the playoffs instead of districts. Not sure if it will start week 9 or we start a week earlier, still play 9 and playoffs still end Thanksgiving weekend.
 

Irish LB

All-Conference
Apr 11, 2006
1,466
1,260
0
The IHSA wants nothing to do with organizing districts. They put this out there to get enough people riled up to get a repeal vote on the ballot this November. The long game will be everyone gets in the playoffs instead of districts. Not sure if it will start week 9 or we start a week earlier, still play 9 and playoffs still end Thanksgiving weekend.
Should have done everyone gets in the playoffs a long time ago and just been done with it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ignazio

JCHillmen

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
3,377
1,350
0
Should have done everyone gets in the playoffs a long time ago and just been done with it.
The more I see, the more confident I am that we will never see districts.

Likely to see a doubling of the playoff field, 64 teams per class, and an 8 week regular season.

Would prefer to see multiplying playoffs times 1.5 only. 48 teams per class. 384 total. 8 week regular season. Everyone with 3 wins gets in. Some 1 and 2 win teams may even get in. The non qualifiers can end their season after 8 weeks or play a final game against another non qualifier. Top 16 teams in each class get a round 1 bye.

This eliminates the worst of the mismatches in round 1 and still includes just about everyone. And if you go 0-8, you dont feel bad being left out. Plus it gives 8-0 and 7-1 teams a bye, which is big.

I think if it comes to a revote and schools are offered the district option or the current format just with an expanded playoff field, I think the expanded playoff field wins easily. I know they were voted down before, but given the either/or choice now, I think It wins hands down.
 

ejande

Redshirt
Jan 5, 2008
570
19
18
I agree that going to a 48 team playoff for each class is the best way to go.

-I think it would stop the conference jumping since I think even your worst programs would be able to get to 3 wins every few years.
-It would still keep some value in the regular season as getting a bye would be a very nice prize for a good season.
-It would eliminate the worst of the worst playoff blowouts. No reason for 9-0's to be playing 0-9's.
-The 8 game regular season would mean one less game for your odd number conferences to have to schedule
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alexander33

woody6

Junior
Jun 24, 2016
673
280
0
I know the following is a 1st Round blow-out exception from another sport, but check this result from yesterday's 4A baseball regional semi-final: #17 Romeoville edging #1 seeded LWE (26-5 going into the game) 2-1.
 

mc140

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
8,781
2,830
113
I know the following is a 1st Round blow-out exception from another sport, but check this result from yesterday's 4A baseball regional semi-final: #17 Romeoville edging #1 seeded LWE (26-5 going into the game) 2-1.

One good pitcher in baseball gives below average teams a chance vs anyone in one game.
 

woody6

Junior
Jun 24, 2016
673
280
0
Playoff blowouts? I just counted 22 games from today's baseball regional semifinals in 3A and 4A that had 10-run margins of victory. Many scores have yet to be reported, so that number should increase.