No. Not at all. In 2008 when they won state the kids on that team were almost all from Elmhurst, Bensenville, with some Melrose and Berkley mixed in. Lots of legacies.
Times have changed.
Montini used to be mostly Lombard, Villa Park, Downers and some Oak Brook.
Driscoll was Addison, Wood Dale, Bloomingdale, and some Itasca/Roselle.
Marmion was heavy Aurora, St. Charles, Geneva.
St. Francis was almost all Wheaton, We-go, and Glen Ellyn.
Marian Central had a monopoly on McHenry County so kids drove a little further to get there.
Your "homeless" point means that some school registrars aren't doing their jobs.