IowaLaw's Objective Post Game Analysis: Iowa State

IowaLaw

Senior
Nov 28, 2023
109
557
93
It wasn't pretty, but the #21 ranked Hawkeyes hit a last second field goal to beat an Iowa State team that lost its coach and 50+ guys off its roster...a team picked to finish 16th out of 16 teams in the Big 12. The 16-13 score tells us the Hawkeye offense could be problematic again this year after getting our hopes up with last week's 40 point scoring frenzy.

Why is Brown Locked in as Starter? Iowa's QB play was decent. Brown went 21 of 30 for 191 yards and 0 touchdowns. Solid stats for Iowa...but mediocre for a Big 10 QB. His lack of leg strength on QB sneaks and his tendency to lock in on his intended receiver from the moment he hikes the ball are signs that we've got another game manager leading the team who probably won't be winning games on his own. Brown did hit on one deep ball, which Hawk fans aren't accustomed to, but he mostly relied on check downs, with Moulton alone accounting for 6 catches. So what about Heck? It was just a month ago that he was head and shoulders above Brown, going 17-25 for 205 yards and 5 touchdowns while Brown went 9 for 21 for 41 yards. Was Heck really given a fair shot here?

Running Game Sputters After Dominating Last Week. Going into the season, the run game was supposed to be the team's strength. But against Iowa State's rag tag group of random transfers, the "elite" OL got virtually no push and the RBs looked slow and unable to break tackles. X Williams, who IowaLaw was high on last year, averaged just 1 yard per carry while Moulton averaged just 3.8 yards per carry with a long of just 7 yards. Basically the same kind of production he was putting up last year when Kirk opted to go to the portal to find someone better.

Vander Zee Still Returning Punts? IowaLaw was the only one complaining last week when the coaches trotted out Iowa's 6'4 possession receiver / borderline tight end to replace all-world 5'8 Wetjen at punt returner. Against NIU, Vander Zee seemed content to either fair catch despite plenty of running room or simply let the punt roll and roll. This week, RVZ was back there again (still no Lutmer or the kid who returned one for a TD last week?) it was more of the same. On the two punts he did return against ISU, he showed zero shiftiness or lateral quickness leaving IowaLaw perplexed why the staff wouldn't at least give some of the team's younger speedy WRs or DBs a shot to show their stuff.

Parker's Defense Dominates. After shutting out Northern Illinois 40–0 last week, Iowa's defense again carried the team. The Cyclones managed only 255 total yards and nine first downs, and the D allowed just eight yards in the fourth quarter when it counted. Buffington was an absolute beast and will be Iowa's next all-Big 10 LB. He finished with a career best 15 tackles. Underclassmen Jaylen Watson had his coming out party this week after being a highly touted recruit. He seemed to be in on every pass play and finished with 5 tackles and at least 1 deflection, if not 2 or 3.

DJ V Another Non-Factor Game. If you think it's weird for a coaching staff to put a 6'4 possession receiver back to return punts, how about running reverses to your 4.7 40 running tight end? Well, that's exactly the kind of randying around Lester pulled from his bag of tricks for a gain of 2 yards. The WRs, on the other hand, had zero carries on jet sweeps or counters. Like last week, DJ V had another 3 drops (one was tipped but still hit his hand) and just 2 receptions for 25 yards. Clearly Iowa's TEs the past few years have not been the caliber they had been the previous 20 years of building TE University.

Buhr & His Holder Clutch for the Hawks. Not only was walk-on Buhr a perfect 3/3 in field goals and 1/1 on PATs, but he was extremely clutch, nailing two high pressure 4th quarter field goals in an extremely close game. I've seen close ups of the snap on that game winning kick and it was so bad. I don't know how the holder had the reflexes he did to reach has far as he could to catch the snap then got the ball down lightning quick so Buhr was able to kick it in stride.
 

RagnarLothbrok

Heisman
Jun 11, 2025
6,328
16,592
113
It wasn't pretty, but the #21 ranked Hawkeyes hit a last second field goal to beat an Iowa State team that lost its coach and 50+ guys off its roster...a team picked to finish 16th out of 16 teams in the Big 12. The 16-13 score tells us the Hawkeye offense could be problematic again this year after getting our hopes up with last week's 40 point scoring frenzy.

Why is Brown Locked in as Starter? Iowa's QB play was decent. Brown went 21 of 30 for 191 yards and 0 touchdowns. Solid stats for Iowa...but mediocre for a Big 10 QB. His lack of leg strength on QB sneaks and his tendency to lock in on his intended receiver from the moment he hikes the ball are signs that we've got another game manager leading the team who probably won't be winning games on his own. Brown did hit on one deep ball, which Hawk fans aren't accustomed to, but he mostly relied on check downs, with Moulton alone accounting for 6 catches. So what about Heck? It was just a month ago that he was head and shoulders above Brown, going 17-25 for 205 yards and 5 touchdowns while Brown went 9 for 21 for 41 yards. Was Heck really given a fair shot here?

Running Game Sputters After Dominating Last Week. Going into the season, the run game was supposed to be the team's strength. But against Iowa State's rag tag group of random transfers, the "elite" OL got virtually no push and the RBs looked slow and unable to break tackles. X Williams, who IowaLaw was high on last year, averaged just 1 yard per carry while Moulton averaged just 3.8 yards per carry with a long of just 7 yards. Basically the same kind of production he was putting up last year when Kirk opted to go to the portal to find someone better.

Vander Zee Still Returning Punts? IowaLaw was the only one complaining last week when the coaches trotted out Iowa's 6'4 possession receiver / borderline tight end to replace all-world 5'8 Wetjen at punt returner. Against NIU, Vander Zee seemed content to either fair catch despite plenty of running room or simply let the punt roll and roll. This week, RVZ was back there again (still no Lutmer or the kid who returned one for a TD last week?) it was more of the same. On the two punts he did return against ISU, he showed zero shiftiness or lateral quickness leaving IowaLaw perplexed why the staff wouldn't at least give some of the team's younger speedy WRs or DBs a shot to show their stuff.

Parker's Defense Dominates. After shutting out Northern Illinois 40–0 last week, Iowa's defense again carried the team. The Cyclones managed only 255 total yards and nine first downs, and the D allowed just eight yards in the fourth quarter when it counted. Buffington was an absolute beast and will be Iowa's next all-Big 10 LB. He finished with a career best 15 tackles. Underclassmen Jaylen Watson had his coming out party this week after being a highly touted recruit. He seemed to be in on every pass play and finished with 5 tackles and at least 1 deflection, if not 2 or 3.

DJ V Another Non-Factor Game. If you think it's weird for a coaching staff to put a 6'4 possession receiver back to return punts, how about running reverses to your 4.7 40 running tight end? Well, that's exactly the kind of randying around Lester pulled from his bag of tricks for a gain of 2 yards. The WRs, on the other hand, had zero carries on jet sweeps or counters. Like last week, DJ V had another 3 drops (one was tipped but still hit his hand) and just 2 receptions for 25 yards. Clearly Iowa's TEs the past few years have not been the caliber they had been the previous 20 years of building TE University.

Buhr & His Holder Clutch for the Hawks. Not only was walk-on Buhr a perfect 3/3 in field goals and 1/1 on PATs, but he was extremely clutch, nailing two high pressure 4th quarter field goals in an extremely close game. I've seen close ups of the snap on that game winning kick and it was so bad. I don't know how the holder had the reflexes he did to reach has far as he could to catch the snap then got the ball down lightning quick so Buhr was able to kick it in stride.
Iowa State was committed to stopping the run. So, I don’t think you can take away much from that anymore than the dominant performance vs NIU.

The biggest issue I see with Brown is him locking into Diaz. He’s lucky he didn’t get a couple passes picked off and heading the other direction yesterday. With more experience, Brown will be better.

I don’t understand the negativity toward DJV anymore than fans blasting Lutmer yesterday for being overrated. A lot of things happen in a football game, and many moving parts have to be in sync for individual players to stand out and be successful. Both players should have good seasons.

My biggest concern from yesterday was the uninspiring body language from the players and the lack of imagination from the coaches. This is a rivalry game, you have lost two in a row, and it felt like you were watching Iowa about as hyped up for the game as they would be to play spin the bottle with a couple homily chicks and their first cousin.

Where’s the passion? Where’s the killer instinct? Iowa State had no business being in that game, but they brought it and Iowa ho hummed their way into a game winning field goal. The talent is there—on both sides of the ball. But they gotta show up every week, or they will end up losing 1-2 games to teams they shouldn’t. A 9-3 season can derail into 7-5 real quick like.
 
Feb 25, 2008
32,170
31,092
113
It wasn't pretty, but the #21 ranked Hawkeyes hit a last second field goal to beat an Iowa State team that lost its coach and 50+ guys off its roster...a team picked to finish 16th out of 16 teams in the Big 12. The 16-13 score tells us the Hawkeye offense could be problematic again this year after getting our hopes up with last week's 40 point scoring frenzy.

Why is Brown Locked in as Starter? Iowa's QB play was decent. Brown went 21 of 30 for 191 yards and 0 touchdowns. Solid stats for Iowa...but mediocre for a Big 10 QB. His lack of leg strength on QB sneaks and his tendency to lock in on his intended receiver from the moment he hikes the ball are signs that we've got another game manager leading the team who probably won't be winning games on his own. Brown did hit on one deep ball, which Hawk fans aren't accustomed to, but he mostly relied on check downs, with Moulton alone accounting for 6 catches. So what about Heck? It was just a month ago that he was head and shoulders above Brown, going 17-25 for 205 yards and 5 touchdowns while Brown went 9 for 21 for 41 yards. Was Heck really given a fair shot here?

Running Game Sputters After Dominating Last Week. Going into the season, the run game was supposed to be the team's strength. But against Iowa State's rag tag group of random transfers, the "elite" OL got virtually no push and the RBs looked slow and unable to break tackles. X Williams, who IowaLaw was high on last year, averaged just 1 yard per carry while Moulton averaged just 3.8 yards per carry with a long of just 7 yards. Basically the same kind of production he was putting up last year when Kirk opted to go to the portal to find someone better.

Vander Zee Still Returning Punts? IowaLaw was the only one complaining last week when the coaches trotted out Iowa's 6'4 possession receiver / borderline tight end to replace all-world 5'8 Wetjen at punt returner. Against NIU, Vander Zee seemed content to either fair catch despite plenty of running room or simply let the punt roll and roll. This week, RVZ was back there again (still no Lutmer or the kid who returned one for a TD last week?) it was more of the same. On the two punts he did return against ISU, he showed zero shiftiness or lateral quickness leaving IowaLaw perplexed why the staff wouldn't at least give some of the team's younger speedy WRs or DBs a shot to show their stuff.

Parker's Defense Dominates. After shutting out Northern Illinois 40–0 last week, Iowa's defense again carried the team. The Cyclones managed only 255 total yards and nine first downs, and the D allowed just eight yards in the fourth quarter when it counted. Buffington was an absolute beast and will be Iowa's next all-Big 10 LB. He finished with a career best 15 tackles. Underclassmen Jaylen Watson had his coming out party this week after being a highly touted recruit. He seemed to be in on every pass play and finished with 5 tackles and at least 1 deflection, if not 2 or 3.

DJ V Another Non-Factor Game. If you think it's weird for a coaching staff to put a 6'4 possession receiver back to return punts, how about running reverses to your 4.7 40 running tight end? Well, that's exactly the kind of randying around Lester pulled from his bag of tricks for a gain of 2 yards. The WRs, on the other hand, had zero carries on jet sweeps or counters. Like last week, DJ V had another 3 drops (one was tipped but still hit his hand) and just 2 receptions for 25 yards. Clearly Iowa's TEs the past few years have not been the caliber they had been the previous 20 years of building TE University.

Buhr & His Holder Clutch for the Hawks. Not only was walk-on Buhr a perfect 3/3 in field goals and 1/1 on PATs, but he was extremely clutch, nailing two high pressure 4th quarter field goals in an extremely close game. I've seen close ups of the snap on that game winning kick and it was so bad. I don't know how the holder had the reflexes he did to reach has far as he could to catch the snap then got the ball down lightning quick so Buhr was able to kick it in stride.
Nothing to report on Tony Diez?............Is he still on the team?
 

joelbc1

All-American
Sep 5, 2007
4,555
5,935
113
Personally anyone who “draws conclusions” based on Iowa’s games vs. ISU over the past 20 years has to be some kind of a fool.
This game is generally low scoring, boring, smash-mouth football that usually gets decided in the last 5 minutes of the fourth quarter. When these two teams play each other, there ain’t a lick of difference in the two……Sit back and enjoy the frustration because “frustration with the fan base(s) is the only real constant this game produces.
I am just glad the Hawks pulled this one out.
 
Feb 25, 2008
32,170
31,092
113
Personally anyone who “draws conclusions” based on Iowa’s games vs. ISU over the past 20 years has to be some kind of a fool.
This game is generally low scoring, boring, smash-mouth football that usually gets decided in the last 5 minutes of the fourth quarter. When these two teams play each other, there ain’t a lick of difference in the two……Sit back and enjoy the frustration because “frustration with the fan base(s) is the only real constant this game produces.
I am just glad the Hawks pulled this one out.
Well I mean in all but one season under KF, an Iowa win over ISU guarantees us at least 8 wins on the season, so there's that...................
 

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,000
3,914
113
Iowa State was committed to stopping the run. So, I don’t think you can take away much from that anymore than the dominant performance vs NIU.

The biggest issue I see with Brown is him locking into Diaz. He’s lucky he didn’t get a couple passes picked off and heading the other direction yesterday. With more experience, Brown will be better.

I don’t understand the negativity toward DJV anymore than fans blasting Lutmer yesterday for being overrated. A lot of things happen in a football game, and many moving parts have to be in sync for individual players to stand out and be successful. Both players should have good seasons.

My biggest concern from yesterday was the uninspiring body language from the players and the lack of imagination from the coaches. This is a rivalry game, you have lost two in a row, and it felt like you were watching Iowa about as hyped up for the game as they would be to play spin the bottle with a couple homily chicks and their first cousin.

Where’s the passion? Where’s the killer instinct? Iowa State had no business being in that game, but they brought it and Iowa ho hummed their way into a game winning field goal. The talent is there—on both sides of the ball. But they gotta show up every week, or they will end up losing 1-2 games to teams they shouldn’t. A 9-3 season can derail into 7-5 real quick like.
Every team that plays Iowa is committed to stopping the run. As much as they were playing downhill on defense you cannot expect the o line to win that battle. Announcers said so as well. I’m a huge fan of Lester but we should have been able to utilize the tight ends over the middle way more the way they were playing. D was stout as usual after we gave up that TD. And I couldn’t agree more about finding a true punt returner. We’ve had game changers back there for quite awhile. With the way we play you need to be able to do more than just catch the ball.
 

HAWKNESS

Senior
Jul 6, 2025
234
441
63
It wasn't pretty, but the #21 ranked Hawkeyes hit a last second field goal to beat an Iowa State team that lost its coach and 50+ guys off its roster...a team picked to finish 16th out of 16 teams in the Big 12. The 16-13 score tells us the Hawkeye offense could be problematic again this year after getting our hopes up with last week's 40 point scoring frenzy.

Why is Brown Locked in as Starter? Iowa's QB play was decent. Brown went 21 of 30 for 191 yards and 0 touchdowns. Solid stats for Iowa...but mediocre for a Big 10 QB. His lack of leg strength on QB sneaks and his tendency to lock in on his intended receiver from the moment he hikes the ball are signs that we've got another game manager leading the team who probably won't be winning games on his own. Brown did hit on one deep ball, which Hawk fans aren't accustomed to, but he mostly relied on check downs, with Moulton alone accounting for 6 catches. So what about Heck? It was just a month ago that he was head and shoulders above Brown, going 17-25 for 205 yards and 5 touchdowns while Brown went 9 for 21 for 41 yards. Was Heck really given a fair shot here?

Running Game Sputters After Dominating Last Week. Going into the season, the run game was supposed to be the team's strength. But against Iowa State's rag tag group of random transfers, the "elite" OL got virtually no push and the RBs looked slow and unable to break tackles. X Williams, who IowaLaw was high on last year, averaged just 1 yard per carry while Moulton averaged just 3.8 yards per carry with a long of just 7 yards. Basically the same kind of production he was putting up last year when Kirk opted to go to the portal to find someone better.

Vander Zee Still Returning Punts? IowaLaw was the only one complaining last week when the coaches trotted out Iowa's 6'4 possession receiver / borderline tight end to replace all-world 5'8 Wetjen at punt returner. Against NIU, Vander Zee seemed content to either fair catch despite plenty of running room or simply let the punt roll and roll. This week, RVZ was back there again (still no Lutmer or the kid who returned one for a TD last week?) it was more of the same. On the two punts he did return against ISU, he showed zero shiftiness or lateral quickness leaving IowaLaw perplexed why the staff wouldn't at least give some of the team's younger speedy WRs or DBs a shot to show their stuff.

Parker's Defense Dominates. After shutting out Northern Illinois 40–0 last week, Iowa's defense again carried the team. The Cyclones managed only 255 total yards and nine first downs, and the D allowed just eight yards in the fourth quarter when it counted. Buffington was an absolute beast and will be Iowa's next all-Big 10 LB. He finished with a career best 15 tackles. Underclassmen Jaylen Watson had his coming out party this week after being a highly touted recruit. He seemed to be in on every pass play and finished with 5 tackles and at least 1 deflection, if not 2 or 3.

DJ V Another Non-Factor Game. If you think it's weird for a coaching staff to put a 6'4 possession receiver back to return punts, how about running reverses to your 4.7 40 running tight end? Well, that's exactly the kind of randying around Lester pulled from his bag of tricks for a gain of 2 yards. The WRs, on the other hand, had zero carries on jet sweeps or counters. Like last week, DJ V had another 3 drops (one was tipped but still hit his hand) and just 2 receptions for 25 yards. Clearly Iowa's TEs the past few years have not been the caliber they had been the previous 20 years of building TE University.

Buhr & His Holder Clutch for the Hawks. Not only was walk-on Buhr a perfect 3/3 in field goals and 1/1 on PATs, but he was extremely clutch, nailing two high pressure 4th quarter field goals in an extremely close game. I've seen close ups of the snap on that game winning kick and it was so bad. I don't know how the holder had the reflexes he did to reach has far as he could to catch the snap then got the ball down lightning quick so Buhr was able to kick it in stride.
Some points are valid but I'd really like to hear an alternative to Vander Zee returning punts. He's fielded every realistic punt and mostly gets north to south immediately. Iowa gave James a shot last night and he didn't field it which was easily something he could of and ball rolled 15 more yards in a tough tight contested battle in which every yards important. James wont see the daylight he did against NIU again. I think Vander Zees is less of a risk which matters in close games we figure to play. His problem regards to returning punts Is that he's not Wetjen or cooper. Unfortunately that's the statical norm.
 

HMB Trumpet

Senior
Mar 19, 2018
565
664
93
DJ V Another Non-Factor Game. If you think it's weird for a coaching staff to put a 6'4 possession receiver back to return punts, how about running reverses to your 4.7 40 running tight end? Well, that's exactly the kind of randying around Lester pulled from his bag of tricks for a gain of 2 yards. The WRs, on the other hand, had zero carries on jet sweeps or counters. Like last week, DJ V had another 3 drops (one was tipped but still hit his hand) and just 2 receptions for 25 yards. Clearly Iowa's TEs the past few years have not been the caliber they had been the previous 20 years of building TE University.
I guess you tuned in late. On the first play of the opening series Tony Diez (sic) got the ball on a jet sweep for a six-yard gain. It was technically a pass rather than a handoff because Brown flipped the ball up for him to grab. Many teams are doing that so any flub is an incomplete pass rather than a fumble. IIRC they ran this play again in the second half, but for a loss.

NFL teams run the TE reverse, and DJ is a good enough athlete to give it a try. I wouldn't be surprised to see it again later this season.
 

uihawk82

All-Conference
Nov 17, 2021
2,714
4,114
113
It wasn't pretty, but the #21 ranked Hawkeyes hit a last second field goal to beat an Iowa State team that lost its coach and 50+ guys off its roster...a team picked to finish 16th out of 16 teams in the Big 12. The 16-13 score tells us the Hawkeye offense could be problematic again this year after getting our hopes up with last week's 40 point scoring frenzy.

Why is Brown Locked in as Starter? Iowa's QB play was decent. Brown went 21 of 30 for 191 yards and 0 touchdowns. Solid stats for Iowa...but mediocre for a Big 10 QB. His lack of leg strength on QB sneaks and his tendency to lock in on his intended receiver from the moment he hikes the ball are signs that we've got another game manager leading the team who probably won't be winning games on his own. Brown did hit on one deep ball, which Hawk fans aren't accustomed to, but he mostly relied on check downs, with Moulton alone accounting for 6 catches. So what about Heck? It was just a month ago that he was head and shoulders above Brown, going 17-25 for 205 yards and 5 touchdowns while Brown went 9 for 21 for 41 yards. Was Heck really given a fair shot here?

Running Game Sputters After Dominating Last Week. Going into the season, the run game was supposed to be the team's strength. But against Iowa State's rag tag group of random transfers, the "elite" OL got virtually no push and the RBs looked slow and unable to break tackles. X Williams, who IowaLaw was high on last year, averaged just 1 yard per carry while Moulton averaged just 3.8 yards per carry with a long of just 7 yards. Basically the same kind of production he was putting up last year when Kirk opted to go to the portal to find someone better.

Vander Zee Still Returning Punts? IowaLaw was the only one complaining last week when the coaches trotted out Iowa's 6'4 possession receiver / borderline tight end to replace all-world 5'8 Wetjen at punt returner. Against NIU, Vander Zee seemed content to either fair catch despite plenty of running room or simply let the punt roll and roll. This week, RVZ was back there again (still no Lutmer or the kid who returned one for a TD last week?) it was more of the same. On the two punts he did return against ISU, he showed zero shiftiness or lateral quickness leaving IowaLaw perplexed why the staff wouldn't at least give some of the team's younger speedy WRs or DBs a shot to show their stuff.

Parker's Defense Dominates. After shutting out Northern Illinois 40–0 last week, Iowa's defense again carried the team. The Cyclones managed only 255 total yards and nine first downs, and the D allowed just eight yards in the fourth quarter when it counted. Buffington was an absolute beast and will be Iowa's next all-Big 10 LB. He finished with a career best 15 tackles. Underclassmen Jaylen Watson had his coming out party this week after being a highly touted recruit. He seemed to be in on every pass play and finished with 5 tackles and at least 1 deflection, if not 2 or 3.

DJ V Another Non-Factor Game. If you think it's weird for a coaching staff to put a 6'4 possession receiver back to return punts, how about running reverses to your 4.7 40 running tight end? Well, that's exactly the kind of randying around Lester pulled from his bag of tricks for a gain of 2 yards. The WRs, on the other hand, had zero carries on jet sweeps or counters. Like last week, DJ V had another 3 drops (one was tipped but still hit his hand) and just 2 receptions for 25 yards. Clearly Iowa's TEs the past few years have not been the caliber they had been the previous 20 years of building TE University.

Buhr & His Holder Clutch for the Hawks. Not only was walk-on Buhr a perfect 3/3 in field goals and 1/1 on PATs, but he was extremely clutch, nailing two high pressure 4th quarter field goals in an extremely close game. I've seen close ups of the snap on that game winning kick and it was so bad. I don't know how the holder had the reflexes he did to reach has far as he could to catch the snap then got the ball down lightning quick so Buhr was able to kick it in stride.
Well you certainly didnt read or listen to too much scouting info about the ISU defense. I have heard they are very experienced and thought to be very good. Rogers brought 15 players with him from WA ST, not sure how many were starters but they were probably mostly were. Fifteen is 3/4 of the starters on both sides of the ball.

Iowa's run game needs to improve against big 10 defenses and maybe they will mix in more types of runs rather than the very vanilla up the middle runs they used against ISU.
 

Sett1997

All-Conference
Oct 23, 2025
859
2,724
93
Some points are valid but I'd really like to hear an alternative to Vander Zee returning punts. He's fielded every realistic punt and mostly gets north to south immediately. Iowa gave James a shot last night and he didn't field it which was easily something he could of and ball rolled 15 more yards in a tough tight contested battle in which every yards important. James wont see the daylight he did against NIU again. I think Vander Zees is less of a risk which matters in close games we figure to play. His problem regards to returning punts Is that he's not Wetjen or cooper. Unfortunately that's the statical norm.
Less risk? Zee is not the answer at punt returning. How much more less risk can we take. James won't see the daylight again that he did against NIU? He's had 2 returns, one for a td, the other he backed off of, like Zee has on a few. James is so much more explosive than Zee it's laughable as far as punt returns. He also had the catch on the short side where he did everything possible to stay in bounds but wasn't given the space. Kid is a baller.
How do you know he's not Wetjen or Cooper? He's had 2 opportunities. Did Wet or Coop return their first opportunity for a 57 yard td?
 

oldxbbc

All-American
Sep 19, 2013
1,843
7,392
113
I think we need to wait until the three games after UNI to see if certain players are "right for the role" from our "coaching seats". lol
 

kmurpny

Sophomore
Jul 22, 2006
155
163
43
Well you certainly didnt read or listen to too much scouting info about the ISU defense. I have heard they are very experienced and thought to be very good. Rogers brought 15 players with him from WA ST, not sure how many were starters but they were probably mostly were. Fifteen is 3/4 of the starters on both sides of the ball.

Iowa's run game needs to improve against big 10 defenses and maybe they will mix in more types of runs rather than the very vanilla up the middle runs they used against ISU.
Looking at the ISU depth chart, they only lose four guys off this defense, so they should be even better next year. Based on what Lester has done vs ISU so far it looks like it will be up to the defense to try to win it next year.
 

Titanhawk

Senior
Jul 14, 2011
621
641
93
It wasn't pretty, but the #21 ranked Hawkeyes hit a last second field goal to beat an Iowa State team that lost its coach and 50+ guys off its roster...a team picked to finish 16th out of 16 teams in the Big 12. The 16-13 score tells us the Hawkeye offense could be problematic again this year after getting our hopes up with last week's 40 point scoring frenzy.

Why is Brown Locked in as Starter? Iowa's QB play was decent. Brown went 21 of 30 for 191 yards and 0 touchdowns. Solid stats for Iowa...but mediocre for a Big 10 QB. His lack of leg strength on QB sneaks and his tendency to lock in on his intended receiver from the moment he hikes the ball are signs that we've got another game manager leading the team who probably won't be winning games on his own. Brown did hit on one deep ball, which Hawk fans aren't accustomed to, but he mostly relied on check downs, with Moulton alone accounting for 6 catches. So what about Heck? It was just a month ago that he was head and shoulders above Brown, going 17-25 for 205 yards and 5 touchdowns while Brown went 9 for 21 for 41 yards. Was Heck really given a fair shot here?

Running Game Sputters After Dominating Last Week. Going into the season, the run game was supposed to be the team's strength. But against Iowa State's rag tag group of random transfers, the "elite" OL got virtually no push and the RBs looked slow and unable to break tackles. X Williams, who IowaLaw was high on last year, averaged just 1 yard per carry while Moulton averaged just 3.8 yards per carry with a long of just 7 yards. Basically the same kind of production he was putting up last year when Kirk opted to go to the portal to find someone better.

Vander Zee Still Returning Punts? IowaLaw was the only one complaining last week when the coaches trotted out Iowa's 6'4 possession receiver / borderline tight end to replace all-world 5'8 Wetjen at punt returner. Against NIU, Vander Zee seemed content to either fair catch despite plenty of running room or simply let the punt roll and roll. This week, RVZ was back there again (still no Lutmer or the kid who returned one for a TD last week?) it was more of the same. On the two punts he did return against ISU, he showed zero shiftiness or lateral quickness leaving IowaLaw perplexed why the staff wouldn't at least give some of the team's younger speedy WRs or DBs a shot to show their stuff.

Parker's Defense Dominates. After shutting out Northern Illinois 40–0 last week, Iowa's defense again carried the team. The Cyclones managed only 255 total yards and nine first downs, and the D allowed just eight yards in the fourth quarter when it counted. Buffington was an absolute beast and will be Iowa's next all-Big 10 LB. He finished with a career best 15 tackles. Underclassmen Jaylen Watson had his coming out party this week after being a highly touted recruit. He seemed to be in on every pass play and finished with 5 tackles and at least 1 deflection, if not 2 or 3.

DJ V Another Non-Factor Game. If you think it's weird for a coaching staff to put a 6'4 possession receiver back to return punts, how about running reverses to your 4.7 40 running tight end? Well, that's exactly the kind of randying around Lester pulled from his bag of tricks for a gain of 2 yards. The WRs, on the other hand, had zero carries on jet sweeps or counters. Like last week, DJ V had another 3 drops (one was tipped but still hit his hand) and just 2 receptions for 25 yards. Clearly Iowa's TEs the past few years have not been the caliber they had been the previous 20 years of building TE University.

Buhr & His Holder Clutch for the Hawks. Not only was walk-on Buhr a perfect 3/3 in field goals and 1/1 on PATs, but he was extremely clutch, nailing two high pressure 4th quarter field goals in an extremely close game. I've seen close ups of the snap on that game winning kick and it was so bad. I don't know how the holder had the reflexes he did to reach has far as he could to catch the snap then got the ball down lightning quick so Buhr was able to kick it in stride.
Moulton has averaged over 5 yards per carry the past two seasons. Perhaps other PR's are dropping them in practice
 

HAWKNESS

Senior
Jul 6, 2025
234
441
63
Less risk? Zee is not the answer at punt returning. How much more less risk can we take. James won't see the daylight again that he did against NIU? He's had 2 returns, one for a td, the other he backed off of, like Zee has on a few. James is so much more explosive than Zee it's laughable as far as punt returns. He also had the catch on the short side where he did everything possible to stay in bounds but wasn't given the space. Kid is a baller.
How do you know he's not Wetjen or Cooper? He's had 2 opportunities. Did Wet or Coop return their first opportunity for a 57 yard td?
I was saying VZ isn't cooper or Wetjen. I have no problems with how he's done returning punts. He catches it and goes right upfield. He's less explosive than we have had which should be expected. James could be good but they implied on broadcast that he has had issues fielding them in practice. Then Saturday he did the same thing and Iowa lost 15-20 yards. It was a ball I think VZ fields too. I think if James becomes better at that aspect it's a conversation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Burgers

IowaLaw

Senior
Nov 28, 2023
109
557
93
Iowa State was committed to stopping the run. So, I don’t think you can take away much from that anymore than the dominant performance vs NIU.

The biggest issue I see with Brown is him locking into Diaz. He’s lucky he didn’t get a couple passes picked off and heading the other direction yesterday. With more experience, Brown will be better.

I don’t understand the negativity toward DJV anymore than fans blasting Lutmer yesterday for being overrated. A lot of things happen in a football game, and many moving parts have to be in sync for individual players to stand out and be successful. Both players should have good seasons.

My biggest concern from yesterday was the uninspiring body language from the players and the lack of imagination from the coaches. This is a rivalry game, you have lost two in a row, and it felt like you were watching Iowa about as hyped up for the game as they would be to play spin the bottle with a couple homily chicks and their first cousin.

Where’s the passion? Where’s the killer instinct? Iowa State had no business being in that game, but they brought it and Iowa ho hummed their way into a game winning field goal. The talent is there—on both sides of the ball. But they gotta show up every week, or they will end up losing 1-2 games to teams they shouldn’t. A 9-3 season can derail into 7-5 real quick like.
You do realize after watching Iowa football for more than 1 game that EVERY team who plays the Hawkeyes is committed to stopping the run? It doesn't matter which statue has played QB for the Hawks the past decade, one thing is consistent: teams not respect Iowa's pass offense. That has carried over to Lester's term as O/C. Hell, even with Gronk, Iowa's prize portal recruit, the Hawks ranked a lousy 129th nationally last year in passing offense. So you're going to have to come up with a better excuse for a lousy running game because "the opponent committed to stopping the run and that's why we sucked." That's like saying opponents are committed to scoring points. Duh. Until we get a QB who can throw for 200+ yards per game like every other Big 10 team always seems to have, opponents will load the box against our run game.

The negativity toward DJV is that he was touted as a pre-season all American by every Iowa media source out there and fans were quick to jump on the bandwagon because the 2** recruit with no other offers had a couple big games last year when the Hawks lacked a receiving threat. But the fact is, DJV has more drops this season than catches. It's certainly possible that he has some big games later this season and could have a breakout year...but clearly he hasn't lived up to the hype thus far and has been a below average starting TE.

I agree on the lack of inspiration. Hell, watching the OL drop the trophy after the game was kind of indicative of how they played. That falls on the coaching staff. If you can't motivate your kids for a huge rivalry game played at night in your home stadium, you can't motivate them for anything.
 

WeBeHerkin

All-American
Aug 5, 2016
4,884
5,536
113
Looking at the ISU depth chart, they only lose four guys off this defense, so they should be even better next year. Based on what Lester has done vs ISU so far it looks like it will be up to the defense to try to win it next year.
Unless they hit the portal.
 

RagnarLothbrok

Heisman
Jun 11, 2025
6,328
16,592
113
You do realize after watching Iowa football for more than 1 game that EVERY team who plays the Hawkeyes is committed to stopping the run? It doesn't matter which statue has played QB for the Hawks the past decade, one thing is consistent: teams not respect Iowa's pass offense. That has carried over to Lester's term as O/C. Hell, even with Gronk, Iowa's prize portal recruit, the Hawks ranked a lousy 129th nationally last year in passing offense. So you're going to have to come up with a better excuse for a lousy running game because "the opponent committed to stopping the run and that's why we sucked." That's like saying opponents are committed to scoring points. Duh. Until we get a QB who can throw for 200+ yards per game like every other Big 10 team always seems to have, opponents will load the box against our run game.

The negativity toward DJV is that he was touted as a pre-season all American by every Iowa media source out there and fans were quick to jump on the bandwagon because the 2** recruit with no other offers had a couple big games last year when the Hawks lacked a receiving threat. But the fact is, DJV has more drops this season than catches. It's certainly possible that he has some big games later this season and could have a breakout year...but clearly he hasn't lived up to the hype thus far and has been a below average starting TE.

I agree on the lack of inspiration. Hell, watching the OL drop the trophy after the game was kind of indicative of how they played. That falls on the coaching staff. If you can't motivate your kids for a huge rivalry game played at night in your home stadium, you can't motivate them for anything.
Yes, I very much realize how pedestrian to awful the Iowa passing game has been since Nate Stanley. Yes, I am aware that every defense Iowa has faced has been committed to stopping the run. I was not trying to be profound. The point is Iowa State really sold out to stop the run, and Iowa was too committed to trying to establish the run to adjust accordingly. And with Iowa’s passing game still not being very good, Iowa State had no reason to respect their putrid aerial attack.

What was the overall point, though, Law? It’s that you can’t take away much from the performance anymore than the dominance against NIU. Until Iowa shows a willingness to commit to passing when teams are stacking the box and selling out to stop the run, this is going to be a problem all year. Iowa no longer has the wrinkle of Mark Gronowski being able to make plays with his legs that made Iowa a little less one-dimensional last season. Imagine if Tony Diaz was not in the wide receiver room right now? Iowa could have Brian Ferentz offensive numbers right now.

The bottom line is Iowa cannot be balanced on offense until opposing defenses respect their passing game. It was obvious on Saturday Iowa State wasn’t concerned about it in the least. That trend is going to continue when Iowa starts playing teams like Michigan and Ohio State. I mean, it’s going to be downright ugly. And that is not going to be the fault of the run game per se. It’s going to be the fault of whoever is responsible for not putting together a more lethal, consistent aerial attack. Yeah, sometimes you do have to throw to set up the run. So, it’s not all on the run game.
 

trfhawk

Junior
Jul 10, 2020
187
361
63
It wasn't pretty, but the #21 ranked Hawkeyes hit a last second field goal to beat an Iowa State team that lost its coach and 50+ guys off its roster...a team picked to finish 16th out of 16 teams in the Big 12. The 16-13 score tells us the Hawkeye offense could be problematic again this year after getting our hopes up with last week's 40 point scoring frenzy.

Why is Brown Locked in as Starter? Iowa's QB play was decent. Brown went 21 of 30 for 191 yards and 0 touchdowns. Solid stats for Iowa...but mediocre for a Big 10 QB. His lack of leg strength on QB sneaks and his tendency to lock in on his intended receiver from the moment he hikes the ball are signs that we've got another game manager leading the team who probably won't be winning games on his own. Brown did hit on one deep ball, which Hawk fans aren't accustomed to, but he mostly relied on check downs, with Moulton alone accounting for 6 catches. So what about Heck? It was just a month ago that he was head and shoulders above Brown, going 17-25 for 205 yards and 5 touchdowns while Brown went 9 for 21 for 41 yards. Was Heck really given a fair shot here?

Running Game Sputters After Dominating Last Week. Going into the season, the run game was supposed to be the team's strength. But against Iowa State's rag tag group of random transfers, the "elite" OL got virtually no push and the RBs looked slow and unable to break tackles. X Williams, who IowaLaw was high on last year, averaged just 1 yard per carry while Moulton averaged just 3.8 yards per carry with a long of just 7 yards. Basically the same kind of production he was putting up last year when Kirk opted to go to the portal to find someone better.

Vander Zee Still Returning Punts? IowaLaw was the only one complaining last week when the coaches trotted out Iowa's 6'4 possession receiver / borderline tight end to replace all-world 5'8 Wetjen at punt returner. Against NIU, Vander Zee seemed content to either fair catch despite plenty of running room or simply let the punt roll and roll. This week, RVZ was back there again (still no Lutmer or the kid who returned one for a TD last week?) it was more of the same. On the two punts he did return against ISU, he showed zero shiftiness or lateral quickness leaving IowaLaw perplexed why the staff wouldn't at least give some of the team's younger speedy WRs or DBs a shot to show their stuff.

Parker's Defense Dominates. After shutting out Northern Illinois 40–0 last week, Iowa's defense again carried the team. The Cyclones managed only 255 total yards and nine first downs, and the D allowed just eight yards in the fourth quarter when it counted. Buffington was an absolute beast and will be Iowa's next all-Big 10 LB. He finished with a career best 15 tackles. Underclassmen Jaylen Watson had his coming out party this week after being a highly touted recruit. He seemed to be in on every pass play and finished with 5 tackles and at least 1 deflection, if not 2 or 3.

DJ V Another Non-Factor Game. If you think it's weird for a coaching staff to put a 6'4 possession receiver back to return punts, how about running reverses to your 4.7 40 running tight end? Well, that's exactly the kind of randying around Lester pulled from his bag of tricks for a gain of 2 yards. The WRs, on the other hand, had zero carries on jet sweeps or counters. Like last week, DJ V had another 3 drops (one was tipped but still hit his hand) and just 2 receptions for 25 yards. Clearly Iowa's TEs the past few years have not been the caliber they had been the previous 20 years of building TE University.

Buhr & His Holder Clutch for the Hawks. Not only was walk-on Buhr a perfect 3/3 in field goals and 1/1 on PATs, but he was extremely clutch, nailing two high pressure 4th quarter field goals in an extremely close game. I've seen close ups of the snap on that game winning kick and it was so bad. I don't know how the holder had the reflexes he did to reach has far as he could to catch the snap then got the ball down lightning quick so Buhr was able to kick it in stride.
Two words for you: Oregon and Michigan. **** happens in a football game. Iowa's offense will take a little time and is not as bad as it looked Saturday. ISU? Who gives a ****?
 

trfhawk

Junior
Jul 10, 2020
187
361
63
Looking at the ISU depth chart, they only lose four guys off this defense, so they should be even better next year. Based on what Lester has done vs ISU so far it looks like it will be up to the defense to try to win it next year.
They lose their qb who has started about 50 games in his career. They will be breaking in a newby and Iowa will have a vet.
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
6,218
12,836
113
Looking at the ISU depth chart, they only lose four guys off this defense, so they should be even better next year. Based on what Lester has done vs ISU so far it looks like it will be up to the defense to try to win it next year.
It is up to the defense every year, so....
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Hawkeye Report Football The latest Iowa basketball recruiting rundown
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Kirk Ferentz talks injuries, previews UNI game
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football Hank Brown continue to work on improvement
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Basketball Recruiting '27 four-star forward Khalia Hartwell breaks down her recruitment and her Iowa official visit
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Football Boston Everitt gets comfortable with college punting