IowaLaw's Objective Post Game Analysis: Northwestern

IowaLaw

Senior
Nov 28, 2023
141
721
93
The Hawks moved to 7-2 with their 24-10 win over a short-handed Northwestern minus their star QB. This was the Hawks’ fifth straight in the series and the Wildcats’ first loss at beautiful new Ryan Field. Just like against Washington, the Hawks went up big early in the game, then the offense entered the witness protection program. Kirk's same ol’ pattern of playing not to lose will cost the team some style points when it comes to playoff selection season.
  1. Hank Brown’s 76% Is Fool’s Gold. Brown had another good game percentage wise, going 16 of 21 (76.2%) for just 126 yards, 1 TD and 1 INT. While some were quick to pat him on the back, completion percentage is misleading when your QB lives on short, high-percentage throws and looks off open WRs down field to avoid making a mistake. Brown averaged just 6.0 yards per attempt...with most of those yards being RBs and TEs gaining them after catch. By comparison, Northwestern's injured QB averages 9.5 yards per attempt. Guys were open down field but Brown kept taking the safe throws underneath. Want proof that the number is empty? Northwestern’s backup, Marchiol, also completed 75% of his passes, but did so against Iowa's elite defense. He threw for 181 yards compared to Brown's 126 yards. His passer rating was 132.83. Brown’s was 132.78. Yet nobody would say Marchiol had a good game.
  2. When Brown Threw Down Field, It Was Ugly. Brown completed just 5 passes to WRs. Why? RVZ and Diaz were open. When balls went their way, they often had to slow down and fight for the ball instead of catching it in stride. In the 3rd quarter. after too much randying around at the line of scrimmage, Brown let the play clock expire (a boneheaded mistake you never see at this level) then badly underthrew the next pass to DJV. Obviously Brown has a good arm, as evidenced by his TD pass to Diaz...he's just terrified of making a mistake and aims it rather than leading his receivers.
  3. Jayden Montgomery Earning that Scholly. For his first 3 years at Iowa, 2 star legacy recruit Montgomery was a nepotism scholarship who didn't belong in D1 football. Undersized and zero stats of any kind. But in year 5 under Phil Parker, he's finally playing like he belongs. 9 tackles, a sack and a TFL vs. a 6-2 Big 10 program. Sure, Cam Buffington led the team with 12 tackles and made a huge 4th-and-1 stop. He's obviously a future superstar. When the offense was playing not to lose and Northwestern had just cut it to 14-3. Montgomery threw a key block on Braeden Jackson’s 96-yard kickoff return. Then, on Northwestern’s next drive, he sacked Marchiol on 4th down, setting up Buhr’s 52-yarder.
  4. L.J. Phillips: IowaLaw Rests His Case. Six weeks ago, IowaLaw asked why the best back on the team wasn’t getting more carries behind a lesser back in Moulton. Finally, Phillips got 21 carries in a game and rewarded the team with 128 yards (6.1 a carry) and a season-long 45-yarder. His underutilization was apparent, as he came into the game with just 34 carries all year.
  5. Defense Bails Us Out Again. Northwestern went just 1 for 11 on 3rd down, 1 for 4 on 4th down. They ran for 2.8 yards a carry! That's elite. Why didn't we blow them out, again? Six sacks, and the Wildcats didn’t get inside the Iowa 26 until the 4th quarter. Marchiol still completed 75% of his throws and Northwestern still had 19 first downs to Iowa’s 14. Against better teams, we'll need to clean that up.
  6. Ball Security and Discipline Becoming Problematic. The Hawks had two big second half turnovers. Phillips also put it on the ground but was fortunate enough to recover it. On the day, the normally disciplined Hawks were minus-2 in turnovers and had 5 penalties for 45 yards, including Drew Campbell's targeting penalty that got him tossed for targeting. You get away with that against a backup QB but not against the Minnesotas of the world.
 

JerseyCityHawk

All-Conference
Jul 6, 2025
1,592
2,621
112
The Hawks moved to 7-2 with their 24-10 win over a short-handed Northwestern minus their star QB. This was the Hawks’ fifth straight in the series and the Wildcats’ first loss at beautiful new Ryan Field. Just like against Washington, the Hawks went up big early in the game, then the offense entered the witness protection program. Kirk's same ol’ pattern of playing not to lose will cost the team some style points when it comes to playoff selection season.
  1. Hank Brown’s 76% Is Fool’s Gold. Brown had another good game percentage wise, going 16 of 21 (76.2%) for just 126 yards, 1 TD and 1 INT. While some were quick to pat him on the back, completion percentage is misleading when your QB lives on short, high-percentage throws and looks off open WRs down field to avoid making a mistake. Brown averaged just 6.0 yards per attempt...with most of those yards being RBs and TEs gaining them after catch. By comparison, Northwestern's injured QB averages 9.5 yards per attempt. Guys were open down field but Brown kept taking the safe throws underneath. Want proof that the number is empty? Northwestern’s backup, Marchiol, also completed 75% of his passes, but did so against Iowa's elite defense. He threw for 181 yards compared to Brown's 126 yards. His passer rating was 132.83. Brown’s was 132.78. Yet nobody would say Marchiol had a good game.
  2. When Brown Threw Down Field, It Was Ugly. Brown completed just 5 passes to WRs. Why? RVZ and Diaz were open. When balls went their way, they often had to slow down and fight for the ball instead of catching it in stride. In the 3rd quarter. after too much randying around at the line of scrimmage, Brown let the play clock expire (a boneheaded mistake you never see at this level) then badly underthrew the next pass to DJV. Obviously Brown has a good arm, as evidenced by his TD pass to Diaz...he's just terrified of making a mistake and aims it rather than leading his receivers.
  3. Jayden Montgomery Earning that Scholly. For his first 3 years at Iowa, 2 star legacy recruit Montgomery was a nepotism scholarship who didn't belong in D1 football. Undersized and zero stats of any kind. But in year 5 under Phil Parker, he's finally playing like he belongs. 9 tackles, a sack and a TFL vs. a 6-2 Big 10 program. Sure, Cam Buffington led the team with 12 tackles and made a huge 4th-and-1 stop. He's obviously a future superstar. When the offense was playing not to lose and Northwestern had just cut it to 14-3. Montgomery threw a key block on Braeden Jackson’s 96-yard kickoff return. Then, on Northwestern’s next drive, he sacked Marchiol on 4th down, setting up Buhr’s 52-yarder.
  4. L.J. Phillips: IowaLaw Rests His Case. Six weeks ago, IowaLaw asked why the best back on the team wasn’t getting more carries behind a lesser back in Moulton. Finally, Phillips got 21 carries in a game and rewarded the team with 128 yards (6.1 a carry) and a season-long 45-yarder. His underutilization was apparent, as he came into the game with just 34 carries all year.
  5. Defense Bails Us Out Again. Northwestern went just 1 for 11 on 3rd down, 1 for 4 on 4th down. They ran for 2.8 yards a carry! That's elite. Why didn't we blow them out, again? Six sacks, and the Wildcats didn’t get inside the Iowa 26 until the 4th quarter. Marchiol still completed 75% of his throws and Northwestern still had 19 first downs to Iowa’s 14. Against better teams, we'll need to clean that up.
  6. Ball Security and Discipline Becoming Problematic. The Hawks had two big second half turnovers. Phillips also put it on the ground but was fortunate enough to recover it. On the day, the normally disciplined Hawks were minus-2 in turnovers and had 5 penalties for 45 yards, including Drew Campbell's targeting penalty that got him tossed for targeting. You get away with that against a backup QB but not against the Minnesotas of the world.
Well said IL… mostly agree with a lot of your opinions
 

IowaLaw

Senior
Nov 28, 2023
141
721
93
Moulton led the BIG in rushing yards when he went down.
How many fumbles for moulton/ carry vs Phillips?
Season long 45 yds for phillips vs season long for moulton?

Iowa leads all power conference teams in points allowed/game at 11....but lots to clean up,right?
LOL I can't tell if you're a homer who doesn't know better or are just trying to be argumentative for the sake of being argumentative.

While it's true Moulton was dominant against the likes of 0-9 Northern Illinois...when our OLine was blowing open holes the size of a barn (Jackson, who was Iowa's 5th string RB at the time, averaged 10 ypc that day) and the Hawks won the game with one hand tied behind their back 40-0.

The problem is, against Ohio State, the biggest game of the season in Iowa City, Moulton averaged a horrific 2.5 ypc. Against Minnesota, he was even worse and averaged just 2 ypc. We lost by a field goal...would there have been a different result if Moulton performed like a starting RB? Against Michigan, in an incredibly tight game, it was 3.4 ypc. What about the nail biter against Iowa State? 3.8 ypc.

The fact is, Moulton is a solid backup RB on most rosters. You might love him because he's a Hawk, but he should not have been starting at Iowa and his stats against Big 10 defenses back that up.
 
Last edited:

RagnarLothbrok

Heisman
Jun 11, 2025
6,892
18,126
113
The Hawks moved to 7-2 with their 24-10 win over a short-handed Northwestern minus their star QB. This was the Hawks’ fifth straight in the series and the Wildcats’ first loss at beautiful new Ryan Field. Just like against Washington, the Hawks went up big early in the game, then the offense entered the witness protection program. Kirk's same ol’ pattern of playing not to lose will cost the team some style points when it comes to playoff selection season.
  1. Hank Brown’s 76% Is Fool’s Gold. Brown had another good game percentage wise, going 16 of 21 (76.2%) for just 126 yards, 1 TD and 1 INT. While some were quick to pat him on the back, completion percentage is misleading when your QB lives on short, high-percentage throws and looks off open WRs down field to avoid making a mistake. Brown averaged just 6.0 yards per attempt...with most of those yards being RBs and TEs gaining them after catch. By comparison, Northwestern's injured QB averages 9.5 yards per attempt. Guys were open down field but Brown kept taking the safe throws underneath. Want proof that the number is empty? Northwestern’s backup, Marchiol, also completed 75% of his passes, but did so against Iowa's elite defense. He threw for 181 yards compared to Brown's 126 yards. His passer rating was 132.83. Brown’s was 132.78. Yet nobody would say Marchiol had a good game.
  2. When Brown Threw Down Field, It Was Ugly. Brown completed just 5 passes to WRs. Why? RVZ and Diaz were open. When balls went their way, they often had to slow down and fight for the ball instead of catching it in stride. In the 3rd quarter. after too much randying around at the line of scrimmage, Brown let the play clock expire (a boneheaded mistake you never see at this level) then badly underthrew the next pass to DJV. Obviously Brown has a good arm, as evidenced by his TD pass to Diaz...he's just terrified of making a mistake and aims it rather than leading his receivers.
  3. Jayden Montgomery Earning that Scholly. For his first 3 years at Iowa, 2 star legacy recruit Montgomery was a nepotism scholarship who didn't belong in D1 football. Undersized and zero stats of any kind. But in year 5 under Phil Parker, he's finally playing like he belongs. 9 tackles, a sack and a TFL vs. a 6-2 Big 10 program. Sure, Cam Buffington led the team with 12 tackles and made a huge 4th-and-1 stop. He's obviously a future superstar. When the offense was playing not to lose and Northwestern had just cut it to 14-3. Montgomery threw a key block on Braeden Jackson’s 96-yard kickoff return. Then, on Northwestern’s next drive, he sacked Marchiol on 4th down, setting up Buhr’s 52-yarder.
  4. L.J. Phillips: IowaLaw Rests His Case. Six weeks ago, IowaLaw asked why the best back on the team wasn’t getting more carries behind a lesser back in Moulton. Finally, Phillips got 21 carries in a game and rewarded the team with 128 yards (6.1 a carry) and a season-long 45-yarder. His underutilization was apparent, as he came into the game with just 34 carries all year.
  5. Defense Bails Us Out Again. Northwestern went just 1 for 11 on 3rd down, 1 for 4 on 4th down. They ran for 2.8 yards a carry! That's elite. Why didn't we blow them out, again? Six sacks, and the Wildcats didn’t get inside the Iowa 26 until the 4th quarter. Marchiol still completed 75% of his throws and Northwestern still had 19 first downs to Iowa’s 14. Against better teams, we'll need to clean that up.
  6. Ball Security and Discipline Becoming Problematic. The Hawks had two big second half turnovers. Phillips also put it on the ground but was fortunate enough to recover it. On the day, the normally disciplined Hawks were minus-2 in turnovers and had 5 penalties for 45 yards, including Drew Campbell's targeting penalty that got him tossed for targeting. You get away with that against a backup QB but not against the Minnesotas of the world.
I agree with the majority of your opinions, although I could quibble with one or two minor points.

1. I have already said my piece about the quarterback position and my opinion that Iowa should have tried to bring in a portal quarterback in the offseason given this team has the potential to earn a playoff spot this year. Not getting a quarterback quite possibly will cost Iowa a playoff appearance since quarterback play is what ultimately lost Iowa the Minnesota game.

2. Agreed, but unfortunately Brown is their best option this season.

3. I thought Montgomery got better last year. At this point, there have been too many 2 and 3 star success stories at Iowa, at least on defense, that no one should question a scholarship offer Kirk/Phil extend to any “project.”

4. When healthy, Phillips is unquestionably the best “every-down” back Iowa has on the roster. Moulton has the best breakaway speed of the three who have actually been in the mix (Moulton, Williams, Phillips), though, and coulda/shoulda been the “change of pace” back. I would like to see Iowa make a better effort to get Jackson more involved in the offense, particularly with screen passes and touches out in space.

5. Nothing new.

6. It definitely needs “cleaned up.”
 

RagnarLothbrok

Heisman
Jun 11, 2025
6,892
18,126
113
Moulton led the BIG in rushing yards when he went down.
How many fumbles for moulton/ carry vs Phillips?
Season long 45 yds for phillips vs season long for moulton?

Iowa leads all power conference teams in points allowed/game at 11....but lots to clean up,right?
Depends what the goal is.

If Iowa sees themselves as a playoff contender, yes. If Iowa is content just to bully the Big Ten West and has no loftier goals beyond that, not really.
 

7and5baby

Junior
Sep 22, 2018
129
214
43
Brown isn't great, but he's playing within the system and Lester has been great lately. Yes we let the air out of the ball once we had a 3-score lead. I have a lot more confidence in Hank now than earlier in the season. Not sure if the 'benching' motivated him
 

The Big Z

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
2,329
4,495
113
This game was never in doubt, and the Jackson kick return to make it 21-3 just allowed Kirk to sit on the lead because he knew with a backup QB they had zero chance of coming back. Hank looked really good early, but yes, it's pretty worrisome that he doesn't look to go down the field more. We clearly got ultra conservative at 21-3 and I think Hank got out of rhythm because he didn't want to make a mistake, which was the only thing that could beat us. His pick he threw was clearly terrible. After that he looked pretty gun shy. Would we all have liked to see us get another 10-14 pts? Of course. We went into a total shell because again, we know we have Phil Parker. I'd just like to see us continue to play like the game is on the line a bit to because I'm guessing the Illinois game we are going to need to be aggressive the entire game.
 

AndreTheHawk

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
1,251
2,598
113
The Hawks moved to 7-2 with their 24-10 win over a short-handed Northwestern minus their star QB. This was the Hawks’ fifth straight in the series and the Wildcats’ first loss at beautiful new Ryan Field. Just like against Washington, the Hawks went up big early in the game, then the offense entered the witness protection program. Kirk's same ol’ pattern of playing not to lose will cost the team some style points when it comes to playoff selection season.

  1. Jayden Montgomery Earning that Scholly. For his first 3 years at Iowa, 2 star legacy recruit Montgomery was a nepotism scholarship who didn't belong in D1 football. Undersized and zero stats of any kind. But in year 5 under Phil Parker, he's finally playing like he belongs. 9 tackles, a sack and a TFL vs. a 6-2 Big 10 program. Sure, Cam Buffington led the team with 12 tackles and made a huge 4th-and-1 stop. He's obviously a future superstar. When the offense was playing not to lose and Northwestern had just cut it to 14-3. Montgomery threw a key block on Braeden Jackson’s 96-yard kickoff return. Then, on Northwestern’s next drive, he sacked Marchiol on 4th down, setting up Buhr’s 52-yarder.
I've definitely been critical of Montgomery coming into this year, and the overall Linebacker play last year was underwhelming to my eyes. But credit where credit is due, Montgomery has been solid and delivered several big and timely stops this year. Good to see. Buffington will play on Sunday's.

L.J. Phillips is a hammer. Runs downhill and always forward. He's got to be better with the football, no question. He's the Thunder, no Lightning has emerged, obviously Jackson could be that guy but isn't there yet for whatever the reason.

It didn't hurt Iowa that Chiles was out, but I thought their backup played well overall. He ran decent, threw the ball pretty well too I thought. His biggest problem was Iowa's Defense was outstanding on stuffing them on 3rd and 4th down, otherwise this game gets closer than it needed to be. Northwestern could win some games with him, just not against a team with a Defense as good as the Hawks (Thank You Phil Parker!).
 

TRHawkeye28

Senior
Jan 1, 2023
407
908
93
It's 24-3 with a high chance to go up 31-3 if not for the Diaz fumble

Or you could point to the series that Hank threw the pick.... or Meyer drops an easy throw where you most likely score to go up 28-3

The offense in the 2nd half was fine. There's been plenty of games in the past to question 2nd half conservative play calling...but not this game. You execute on 3 of those plays and it's another blowout win by 30

This team is clicking at the right time... and couldn't ask for a better CFP chance after that Minny game
 

Titanhawk

Senior
Jul 14, 2011
693
694
93
The Hawks moved to 7-2 with their 24-10 win over a short-handed Northwestern minus their star QB. This was the Hawks’ fifth straight in the series and the Wildcats’ first loss at beautiful new Ryan Field. Just like against Washington, the Hawks went up big early in the game, then the offense entered the witness protection program. Kirk's same ol’ pattern of playing not to lose will cost the team some style points when it comes to playoff selection season.
  1. Hank Brown’s 76% Is Fool’s Gold. Brown had another good game percentage wise, going 16 of 21 (76.2%) for just 126 yards, 1 TD and 1 INT. While some were quick to pat him on the back, completion percentage is misleading when your QB lives on short, high-percentage throws and looks off open WRs down field to avoid making a mistake. Brown averaged just 6.0 yards per attempt...with most of those yards being RBs and TEs gaining them after catch. By comparison, Northwestern's injured QB averages 9.5 yards per attempt. Guys were open down field but Brown kept taking the safe throws underneath. Want proof that the number is empty? Northwestern’s backup, Marchiol, also completed 75% of his passes, but did so against Iowa's elite defense. He threw for 181 yards compared to Brown's 126 yards. His passer rating was 132.83. Brown’s was 132.78. Yet nobody would say Marchiol had a good game.
  2. When Brown Threw Down Field, It Was Ugly. Brown completed just 5 passes to WRs. Why? RVZ and Diaz were open. When balls went their way, they often had to slow down and fight for the ball instead of catching it in stride. In the 3rd quarter. after too much randying around at the line of scrimmage, Brown let the play clock expire (a boneheaded mistake you never see at this level) then badly underthrew the next pass to DJV. Obviously Brown has a good arm, as evidenced by his TD pass to Diaz...he's just terrified of making a mistake and aims it rather than leading his receivers.
  3. Jayden Montgomery Earning that Scholly. For his first 3 years at Iowa, 2 star legacy recruit Montgomery was a nepotism scholarship who didn't belong in D1 football. Undersized and zero stats of any kind. But in year 5 under Phil Parker, he's finally playing like he belongs. 9 tackles, a sack and a TFL vs. a 6-2 Big 10 program. Sure, Cam Buffington led the team with 12 tackles and made a huge 4th-and-1 stop. He's obviously a future superstar. When the offense was playing not to lose and Northwestern had just cut it to 14-3. Montgomery threw a key block on Braeden Jackson’s 96-yard kickoff return. Then, on Northwestern’s next drive, he sacked Marchiol on 4th down, setting up Buhr’s 52-yarder.
  4. L.J. Phillips: IowaLaw Rests His Case. Six weeks ago, IowaLaw asked why the best back on the team wasn’t getting more carries behind a lesser back in Moulton. Finally, Phillips got 21 carries in a game and rewarded the team with 128 yards (6.1 a carry) and a season-long 45-yarder. His underutilization was apparent, as he came into the game with just 34 carries all year.
  5. Defense Bails Us Out Again. Northwestern went just 1 for 11 on 3rd down, 1 for 4 on 4th down. They ran for 2.8 yards a carry! That's elite. Why didn't we blow them out, again? Six sacks, and the Wildcats didn’t get inside the Iowa 26 until the 4th quarter. Marchiol still completed 75% of his throws and Northwestern still had 19 first downs to Iowa’s 14. Against better teams, we'll need to clean that up.
  6. Ball Security and Discipline Becoming Problematic. The Hawks had two big second half turnovers. Phillips also put it on the ground but was fortunate enough to recover it. On the day, the normally disciplined Hawks were minus-2 in turnovers and had 5 penalties for 45 yards, including Drew Campbell's targeting penalty that got him tossed for targeting. You get away with that against a backup QB but not against the Minnesotas of the world.
"By comparison, Northwestern's injured QB averages 9.5 yards per attempt"

181 yards, 32 attempts - that's 5.6 yards per attempt. Sorry, Brown wins. Brown also higher yards per completion.
 
Feb 4, 2004
210
461
63
Then why open the thread and respond?
Trap Thirst GIF by Nate Makuch
 

BlIIlken2

All-Conference
Dec 4, 2021
1,795
4,771
112
It's 24-3 with a high chance to go up 31-3 if not for the Diaz fumble

Or you could point to the series that Hank threw the pick.... or Meyer drops an easy throw where you most likely score to go up 28-3

The offense in the 2nd half was fine. There's been plenty of games in the past to question 2nd half conservative play calling...but not this game. You execute on 3 of those plays and it's another blowout win by 30

This team is clicking at the right time... and couldn't ask for a better CFP chance after that Minny game
This Up Here GIF by Chord Overstreet

People thinking the 2nd half offense was turtle mode is hilarious. Just miscues that killed drives.
 

r_desihawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
3,761
5,433
112
"By comparison, Northwestern's injured QB averages 9.5 yards per attempt"

181 yards, 32 attempts - that's 5.6 yards per attempt. Sorry, Brown wins. Brown also higher yards per completion.
i haven’t checked but if true not bad at all. chiles though has the reputation for being far more dangerous with his legs— any chance stats show that hank is comparable there as well ?
 

whynot?

Senior
Aug 31, 2025
689
970
93
The Hawks moved to 7-2 with their 24-10 win over a short-handed Northwestern minus their star QB. This was the Hawks’ fifth straight in the series and the Wildcats’ first loss at beautiful new Ryan Field. Just like against Washington, the Hawks went up big early in the game, then the offense entered the witness protection program. Kirk's same ol’ pattern of playing not to lose will cost the team some style points when it comes to playoff selection season.
  1. Hank Brown’s 76% Is Fool’s Gold. Brown had another good game percentage wise, going 16 of 21 (76.2%) for just 126 yards, 1 TD and 1 INT. While some were quick to pat him on the back, completion percentage is misleading when your QB lives on short, high-percentage throws and looks off open WRs down field to avoid making a mistake. Brown averaged just 6.0 yards per attempt...with most of those yards being RBs and TEs gaining them after catch. By comparison, Northwestern's injured QB averages 9.5 yards per attempt. Guys were open down field but Brown kept taking the safe throws underneath. Want proof that the number is empty? Northwestern’s backup, Marchiol, also completed 75% of his passes, but did so against Iowa's elite defense. He threw for 181 yards compared to Brown's 126 yards. His passer rating was 132.83. Brown’s was 132.78. Yet nobody would say Marchiol had a good game.
  2. When Brown Threw Down Field, It Was Ugly. Brown completed just 5 passes to WRs. Why? RVZ and Diaz were open. When balls went their way, they often had to slow down and fight for the ball instead of catching it in stride. In the 3rd quarter. after too much randying around at the line of scrimmage, Brown let the play clock expire (a boneheaded mistake you never see at this level) then badly underthrew the next pass to DJV. Obviously Brown has a good arm, as evidenced by his TD pass to Diaz...he's just terrified of making a mistake and aims it rather than leading his receivers.
  3. Jayden Montgomery Earning that Scholly. For his first 3 years at Iowa, 2 star legacy recruit Montgomery was a nepotism scholarship who didn't belong in D1 football. Undersized and zero stats of any kind. But in year 5 under Phil Parker, he's finally playing like he belongs. 9 tackles, a sack and a TFL vs. a 6-2 Big 10 program. Sure, Cam Buffington led the team with 12 tackles and made a huge 4th-and-1 stop. He's obviously a future superstar. When the offense was playing not to lose and Northwestern had just cut it to 14-3. Montgomery threw a key block on Braeden Jackson’s 96-yard kickoff return. Then, on Northwestern’s next drive, he sacked Marchiol on 4th down, setting up Buhr’s 52-yarder.
  4. L.J. Phillips: IowaLaw Rests His Case. Six weeks ago, IowaLaw asked why the best back on the team wasn’t getting more carries behind a lesser back in Moulton. Finally, Phillips got 21 carries in a game and rewarded the team with 128 yards (6.1 a carry) and a season-long 45-yarder. His underutilization was apparent, as he came into the game with just 34 carries all year.
  5. Defense Bails Us Out Again. Northwestern went just 1 for 11 on 3rd down, 1 for 4 on 4th down. They ran for 2.8 yards a carry! That's elite. Why didn't we blow them out, again? Six sacks, and the Wildcats didn’t get inside the Iowa 26 until the 4th quarter. Marchiol still completed 75% of his throws and Northwestern still had 19 first downs to Iowa’s 14. Against better teams, we'll need to clean that up.
  6. Ball Security and Discipline Becoming Problematic. The Hawks had two big second half turnovers. Phillips also put it on the ground but was fortunate enough to recover it. On the day, the normally disciplined Hawks were minus-2 in turnovers and had 5 penalties for 45 yards, including Drew Campbell's targeting penalty that got him tossed for targeting. You get away with that against a backup QB but not against the Minnesotas of the world.
Totally agree on Hank Brown! If only we had a qb that can win big 10 games on the road. Why can’t we ever go on 98 yd. drives and cap with a touchdown once in a while!
We need a starting qb that can go like 6-1 in 7 games, hmmmm.
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,670
5,347
113
Agreed.

Care to discuss any points raised?
I will discuss a point as in after Deacon Hill and a bunch of QBs that completed 45-50-55% of their passes for a so called fan to get all grumpy and bent out of shape about how our qb completed 76% of his passes is a ridiculous complaint.

I have not seen many replays showing other receivers running open 40 yards down field against jNW. Plus if you do not know what play is called and what order the primary receiver fits into getting open and a pass thrown to them then just shut up about it. Chuck Long probably didnt throw to some open receivers as he already saw an open man and Chuck-ed it so to speak.

Does Lester script his first 15 plays? Not sure. But the first pass was a quick stop pattern to RVZ who made a move and got 13 yards. RVZ was probably primary on that play and it worked great.

I think IowaLaw protests too much. The only thing I have been protesting in the last two games is losing that offensive edge in the later parts of the game. Even at that the hawks did grind out a few 1st downs mid to late 4th qtr before Diaz fumbled.
 

Rambler Hawk

All-Conference
Oct 10, 2001
3,102
4,143
113
It's 24-3 with a high chance to go up 31-3 if not for the Diaz fumble

Or you could point to the series that Hank threw the pick.... or Meyer drops an easy throw where you most likely score to go up 28-3

The offense in the 2nd half was fine. There's been plenty of games in the past to question 2nd half conservative play calling...but not this game. You execute on 3 of those plays and it's another blowout win by 30

This team is clicking at the right time... and couldn't ask for a better CFP chance after that Minny game
I'd agree, I was never thinking 'turtle mode' while watching the second half. As you said, that is Kirk's MO 90% of time, but not this game IMHO. In fact, dare I say I saw glimpses of Kirk 2.0? 🤔
 

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,599
5,123
113
LOL I can't tell if you're a homer who doesn't know better or are just trying to be argumentative for the sake of being argumentative.

While it's true Moulton was dominant against the likes of 0-9 Northern Illinois...when our OLine was blowing open holes the size of a barn (Jackson, who was Iowa's 5th string RB at the time, averaged 10 ypc that day) and the Hawks won the game with one hand tied behind their back 40-0.

The problem is, against Ohio State, the biggest game of the season in Iowa City, Moulton averaged a horrific 2.5 ypc. Against Minnesota, he was even worse and averaged just 2 ypc. We lost by a field goal...would there have been a different result if Moulton performed like a starting RB? Against Michigan, in an incredibly tight game, it was 3.4 ypc. What about the nail biter against Iowa State? 3.8 ypc.

The fact is, Moulton is a solid backup RB on most rosters. You might love him because he's a Hawk, but he should not have been starting at Iowa and his stats against Big 10 defenses back that up.
Lol, I can't tell if you do not understand math or just a hater of kf..:

Moulton vs BIG+ ISU....4.8 yds/ carry
Phillips vs niu, BIG ........4.4yds/ carry
Phillips was injured in niu game and was not available til OSU game.

Do you know how gimpy Phillips has been the last 2 months w nagging ankle injury?

No, you don't but I bet his coaches know.
You think an injured Phillips should have played ahead of moulton in the toughest road test of year in Seattle where moulton had 208 yards?
Right.

You have zero objectivity proven by you ignoring the numbers and advocating for player with lesser yards per carry because you have an anti- kf agenda

Try using data when.posting your opinions.
 

IowaLaw

Senior
Nov 28, 2023
141
721
93
I'd agree, I was never thinking 'turtle mode' while watching the second half. As you said, that is Kirk's MO 90% of time, but not this game IMHO. In fact, dare I say I saw glimpses of Kirk 2.0? 🤔
You do understand that Hank Brown played the entire second half and threw for...checks notes...24 yards!

I get that Thomas Meyer dropped a check down in the half, but 12 yards passing per quarter is Kirk 2.0 and you mean that in a positive way, what was Kirk 1.0?
 
Last edited:

WeBeHerkin

All-American
Aug 5, 2016
5,732
6,494
113
LOL I can't tell if you're a homer who doesn't know better or are just trying to be argumentative for the sake of being argumentative.

While it's true Moulton was dominant against the likes of 0-9 Northern Illinois...when our OLine was blowing open holes the size of a barn (Jackson, who was Iowa's 5th string RB at the time, averaged 10 ypc that day) and the Hawks won the game with one hand tied behind their back 40-0.

The problem is, against Ohio State, the biggest game of the season in Iowa City, Moulton averaged a horrific 2.5 ypc. Against Minnesota, he was even worse and averaged just 2 ypc. We lost by a field goal...would there have been a different result if Moulton performed like a starting RB? Against Michigan, in an incredibly tight game, it was 3.4 ypc. What about the nail biter against Iowa State? 3.8 ypc.

The fact is, Moulton is a solid backup RB on most rosters. You might love him because he's a Hawk, but he should not have been starting at Iowa and his stats against Big 10 defenses back that up.
Came to **** in your stew.

Moulton has carried against 15 current Big Ten teams. Here they are, sorted by total rushing yards. This covers 2023 through the Oct. 31, 2026 Wisconsin game, using cfbstats.com game logs.


OpponentSeasonsCarriesYardsYards/carry
Washington2024, 2026282278.11
Wisconsin2024, 2025241707.08
Penn State2023, 2025231175.09
Michigan State2023, 2024, 2025301163.87
Maryland2024121149.50
Minnesota2025, 202625973.88
USC202515906.00
Nebraska2024, 202521894.24
Oregon202523873.78
Indiana202518754.17
Rutgers202514684.86
Michigan202613443.38
Ohio State2024, 202613332.54
Northwestern20246244.00
UCLA2024372.33
All Big Ten2681,3585.07
 

WeBeHerkin

All-American
Aug 5, 2016
5,732
6,494
113
Iowa had 8 pass attempts and 19 rush attempts in the second half against Northwestern (Iowa won 24-10 on Nov. 7). That’s 17 designed runs plus two end-of-game kneel-downs.


Rush attemptsPass attempts
3rd quarter46
4th quarter152
Second half198
 

grasshawk40

All-Conference
Iowa Swarm member
Dec 16, 2022
499
1,161
93
The Hawks moved to 7-2 with their 24-10 win over a short-handed Northwestern minus their star QB. This was the Hawks’ fifth straight in the series and the Wildcats’ first loss at beautiful new Ryan Field. Just like against Washington, the Hawks went up big early in the game, then the offense entered the witness protection program. Kirk's same ol’ pattern of playing not to lose will cost the team some style points when it comes to playoff selection season.
  1. Hank Brown’s 76% Is Fool’s Gold. Brown had another good game percentage wise, going 16 of 21 (76.2%) for just 126 yards, 1 TD and 1 INT. While some were quick to pat him on the back, completion percentage is misleading when your QB lives on short, high-percentage throws and looks off open WRs down field to avoid making a mistake. Brown averaged just 6.0 yards per attempt...with most of those yards being RBs and TEs gaining them after catch. By comparison, Northwestern's injured QB averages 9.5 yards per attempt. Guys were open down field but Brown kept taking the safe throws underneath. Want proof that the number is empty? Northwestern’s backup, Marchiol, also completed 75% of his passes, but did so against Iowa's elite defense. He threw for 181 yards compared to Brown's 126 yards. His passer rating was 132.83. Brown’s was 132.78. Yet nobody would say Marchiol had a good game.
  2. When Brown Threw Down Field, It Was Ugly. Brown completed just 5 passes to WRs. Why? RVZ and Diaz were open. When balls went their way, they often had to slow down and fight for the ball instead of catching it in stride. In the 3rd quarter. after too much randying around at the line of scrimmage, Brown let the play clock expire (a boneheaded mistake you never see at this level) then badly underthrew the next pass to DJV. Obviously Brown has a good arm, as evidenced by his TD pass to Diaz...he's just terrified of making a mistake and aims it rather than leading his receivers.
  3. Jayden Montgomery Earning that Scholly. For his first 3 years at Iowa, 2 star legacy recruit Montgomery was a nepotism scholarship who didn't belong in D1 football. Undersized and zero stats of any kind. But in year 5 under Phil Parker, he's finally playing like he belongs. 9 tackles, a sack and a TFL vs. a 6-2 Big 10 program. Sure, Cam Buffington led the team with 12 tackles and made a huge 4th-and-1 stop. He's obviously a future superstar. When the offense was playing not to lose and Northwestern had just cut it to 14-3. Montgomery threw a key block on Braeden Jackson’s 96-yard kickoff return. Then, on Northwestern’s next drive, he sacked Marchiol on 4th down, setting up Buhr’s 52-yarder.
  4. L.J. Phillips: IowaLaw Rests His Case. Six weeks ago, IowaLaw asked why the best back on the team wasn’t getting more carries behind a lesser back in Moulton. Finally, Phillips got 21 carries in a game and rewarded the team with 128 yards (6.1 a carry) and a season-long 45-yarder. His underutilization was apparent, as he came into the game with just 34 carries all year.
  5. Defense Bails Us Out Again. Northwestern went just 1 for 11 on 3rd down, 1 for 4 on 4th down. They ran for 2.8 yards a carry! That's elite. Why didn't we blow them out, again? Six sacks, and the Wildcats didn’t get inside the Iowa 26 until the 4th quarter. Marchiol still completed 75% of his throws and Northwestern still had 19 first downs to Iowa’s 14. Against better teams, we'll need to clean that up.
  6. Ball Security and Discipline Becoming Problematic. The Hawks had two big second half turnovers. Phillips also put it on the ground but was fortunate enough to recover it. On the day, the normally disciplined Hawks were minus-2 in turnovers and had 5 penalties for 45 yards, including Drew Campbell's targeting penalty that got him tossed for targeting. You get away with that against a backup QB but not against the Minnesotas of the world.
yikes.
 

Rambler Hawk

All-Conference
Oct 10, 2001
3,102
4,143
113
You do understand that Hank Brown played the entire second half and threw for...checks notes...24 yards! I get that Thomas Meyer dropped a check down in the half as well, but if that's Kirk 2.0, what was Kirk 1.0?
I said glimpses....Kirk 1.0 runs it up the middle 3 times with the game in hand. Maybe even considers punting it on 3rd down. 😉

Kirk 2.0 runs a jet sweep with the Boogeyman to try and salt the game away. 😎
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
7,615
15,814
113
LOL I can't tell if you're a homer who doesn't know better or are just trying to be argumentative for the sake of being argumentative.

While it's true Moulton was dominant against the likes of 0-9 Northern Illinois...when our OLine was blowing open holes the size of a barn (Jackson, who was Iowa's 5th string RB at the time, averaged 10 ypc that day) and the Hawks won the game with one hand tied behind their back 40-0.

The problem is, against Ohio State, the biggest game of the season in Iowa City, Moulton averaged a horrific 2.5 ypc. Against Minnesota, he was even worse and averaged just 2 ypc. We lost by a field goal...would there have been a different result if Moulton performed like a starting RB? Against Michigan, in an incredibly tight game, it was 3.4 ypc. What about the nail biter against Iowa State? 3.8 ypc.

The fact is, Moulton is a solid backup RB on most rosters. You might love him because he's a Hawk, but he should not have been starting at Iowa and his stats against Big 10 defenses back that up.
Moulton has been easily the best back on the team, but whatever. Your take on running backs reminds me of Duke's take on QB's after the Washington game. That was a horrible Washington defense that Hecklinski played against that day and this was a bad Northwestern run defense last Saturday. NW is ranked 97th in the country in yards allowed per rush. Take out that long run where he was caught from behind and he averaged just over 4 yards per carry, or .6 yards per carry less than NW has given up all year. Moulton likely takes that play to the end zone.

With respect to Brown's performance, I'm inclined to agree. He had multiple opportunities to hit wide open receivers downfield but checked down to the short throws, and then on that one post that he did throw along the sideline it was intercepted on a bad underthrow. He didn't play poorly by any means, but his inability to target receivers downfield was disappointing.
 
Feb 25, 2008
33,157
32,527
113
The Hawks moved to 7-2 with their 24-10 win over a short-handed Northwestern minus their star QB. This was the Hawks’ fifth straight in the series and the Wildcats’ first loss at beautiful new Ryan Field. Just like against Washington, the Hawks went up big early in the game, then the offense entered the witness protection program. Kirk's same ol’ pattern of playing not to lose will cost the team some style points when it comes to playoff selection season.
  1. Hank Brown’s 76% Is Fool’s Gold. Brown had another good game percentage wise, going 16 of 21 (76.2%) for just 126 yards, 1 TD and 1 INT. While some were quick to pat him on the back, completion percentage is misleading when your QB lives on short, high-percentage throws and looks off open WRs down field to avoid making a mistake. Brown averaged just 6.0 yards per attempt...with most of those yards being RBs and TEs gaining them after catch. By comparison, Northwestern's injured QB averages 9.5 yards per attempt. Guys were open down field but Brown kept taking the safe throws underneath. Want proof that the number is empty? Northwestern’s backup, Marchiol, also completed 75% of his passes, but did so against Iowa's elite defense. He threw for 181 yards compared to Brown's 126 yards. His passer rating was 132.83. Brown’s was 132.78. Yet nobody would say Marchiol had a good game.
  2. When Brown Threw Down Field, It Was Ugly. Brown completed just 5 passes to WRs. Why? RVZ and Diaz were open. When balls went their way, they often had to slow down and fight for the ball instead of catching it in stride. In the 3rd quarter. after too much randying around at the line of scrimmage, Brown let the play clock expire (a boneheaded mistake you never see at this level) then badly underthrew the next pass to DJV. Obviously Brown has a good arm, as evidenced by his TD pass to Diaz...he's just terrified of making a mistake and aims it rather than leading his receivers.
  3. Jayden Montgomery Earning that Scholly. For his first 3 years at Iowa, 2 star legacy recruit Montgomery was a nepotism scholarship who didn't belong in D1 football. Undersized and zero stats of any kind. But in year 5 under Phil Parker, he's finally playing like he belongs. 9 tackles, a sack and a TFL vs. a 6-2 Big 10 program. Sure, Cam Buffington led the team with 12 tackles and made a huge 4th-and-1 stop. He's obviously a future superstar. When the offense was playing not to lose and Northwestern had just cut it to 14-3. Montgomery threw a key block on Braeden Jackson’s 96-yard kickoff return. Then, on Northwestern’s next drive, he sacked Marchiol on 4th down, setting up Buhr’s 52-yarder.
  4. L.J. Phillips: IowaLaw Rests His Case. Six weeks ago, IowaLaw asked why the best back on the team wasn’t getting more carries behind a lesser back in Moulton. Finally, Phillips got 21 carries in a game and rewarded the team with 128 yards (6.1 a carry) and a season-long 45-yarder. His underutilization was apparent, as he came into the game with just 34 carries all year.
  5. Defense Bails Us Out Again. Northwestern went just 1 for 11 on 3rd down, 1 for 4 on 4th down. They ran for 2.8 yards a carry! That's elite. Why didn't we blow them out, again? Six sacks, and the Wildcats didn’t get inside the Iowa 26 until the 4th quarter. Marchiol still completed 75% of his throws and Northwestern still had 19 first downs to Iowa’s 14. Against better teams, we'll need to clean that up.
  6. Ball Security and Discipline Becoming Problematic. The Hawks had two big second half turnovers. Phillips also put it on the ground but was fortunate enough to recover it. On the day, the normally disciplined Hawks were minus-2 in turnovers and had 5 penalties for 45 yards, including Drew Campbell's targeting penalty that got him tossed for targeting. You get away with that against a backup QB but not against the Minnesotas of the world.
Reported troll account
 

IowaLaw

Senior
Nov 28, 2023
141
721
93
Came to **** in your stew.

Moulton has carried against 15 current Big Ten teams. Here they are, sorted by total rushing yards. This covers 2023 through the Oct. 31, 2026 Wisconsin game, using cfbstats.com game logs.

Wait...I'm confused. We are going all the way back to look at Moulton's 2023 stats (3 seasons ago, when Erik All was catching passes from Deacon Hill) are relevant to which RB on the 2026 roster is most deserving of carries? That's wild. In 2023, the rest of the backs on Iowa's roster were all in high school. Nice zinger, though. As long as we're looking back, though, maybe we should note that LJ Phillips rushed for over 1900 yards last year and 6.5 yards per carry. But again, not relevant to the topic you're trying to respond to.

Moulton's 2026 stats vs. Big 10 competition are already referenced in this thread. The numbers speak for themselves. He struggled. I'm sure he would tell you the same thing.
 
Last edited:

WeBeHerkin

All-American
Aug 5, 2016
5,732
6,494
113
Wait...I'm confused. Moulton's 2023 stats (3 seasons ago, way back when Erik All was catching passes from Deacon Hill) are relevant to which RB on the 2026 roster is most deserving of carries? In 2023, the rest of the backs on Iowa's roster were all in high school. Nice zinger, though. Shouldn't be a complicated topic.

Unfortunately for your point, Moulton's 2026 stats vs. Big 10 competition are already included in this thread. The numbers speak for themselves. He struggled. I'm sure he would tell you the same thing.
5 yards per carry dipshit. In the Big Ten over his career and yes when Deacon Hill was QB no one respected our pass game so loaded the frick up in the box to stop the run.
 
Feb 25, 2008
33,157
32,527
113
Wait...I'm confused. Moulton's 2023 stats (3 seasons ago, way back when Erik All was catching passes from Deacon Hill) are relevant to which RB on the 2026 roster is most deserving of carries? In 2023, the rest of the backs on Iowa's roster were all in high school. Nice zinger, though. Shouldn't be a complicated topic.

Unfortunately for your point, Moulton's 2026 stats vs. Big 10 competition are already included in this thread. The numbers speak for themselves. He struggled. I'm sure he would tell you the same thing.
I'm gonna create a new account and bait you into finally responding to me. 😁

You'll never know who might actually be me, and since you're so set on playing the role of Hector Salamanca and pretending to ignore me, I guess you just have no choice but to go back to starting threads to troll Iowa fans and never responding to anyone again. :cool:
 

uihawk82

All-American
Nov 17, 2021
3,670
5,347
113
You do understand that Hank Brown played the entire second half and threw for...checks notes...24 yards!

I get that Thomas Meyer dropped a check down in the half, but 12 yards passing per quarter is Kirk 2.0 and you mean that in a positive way, what was Kirk 1.0?
But he didnt throw many passes in the 2nd half and the Meyer drop was probably 15 to 20 yards of potential gain and if Hank leads the TEnd better when he throws the INT and the pass is caught that is another 20+ yards. But that INT pass was a tight window and probably should not have been thrown.

What I am talking about in the 2nd half and really after the 21-3 lead is we could have thrown on 1st down many times to get easy underneath throws for 5 yards, and then after you show them you are going to keep throwing and you spread the field then the running game starts gouging them. I just thought we didnt make jNW guess enough and we didnt use the big lead enough to our advantage
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Latest Recruiting Intel: Where things stand with CJ Rosser, Cayden Daughtry, Paul Osaruyi
  2. 02 On3 Football College Football Rankings: AP Poll Top 25 after Week 11 released
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football The Chuck Long Podcast
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting Inside the rankings on Iowa's 2027 recruiting class
  5. 05 On3 Basketball Women's College Basketball Rankings: AP Poll Top 25 released after Week 2