Joe Sealey

Anon733544

Redshirt
Jan 6, 2026
1
0
0
How do we fit him and the lineup and if not do you guys think he transfers this offseason? Feel like Taylor will go after him.
 

Kingslayer

Sophomore
Nov 3, 2016
55
141
33
How do we fit him and the lineup and if not do you guys think he transfers this offseason? Feel like Taylor will go after him.
Was a big fan when he was in high school and still a big fan. Don’t see a way for him to fit in him in and if he decides to transfer will root for him. Hope he sticks around since you never know how folks will grow or get injured- it is brutal and great if we can keep that quality of a wrestler around.
 

Random4598375

Junior
Jan 10, 2020
143
354
63
How do we fit him and the lineup and if not do you guys think he transfers this offseason? Feel like Taylor will go after him.
It depends on James. If James comes in at 157 or 165 then Sealy could be permanently blocked by Kasak, Duke, and James, but if neither James nor Duke can hold 157 and Sealy can, there is a spot there after Kasak graduates, but only for a year since Kasak has two more left. He's in a tough spot. If he really wants to start and compete for AA honors, then he'll have to go, and I'll wish him well at his next stop (hopefully Lehigh or Penn or somewhere in-state like that). I'm not too concerned from a PSU perspective about guys who can't crack the lineup threatening us by going elsewhere.
 

Psalm 1 guy

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2019
561
1,841
93
He’ll have to compete against Robideau and Lockett if he becomes behatted

It depends on James. If James comes in at 157 or 165 then Sealy could be permanently blocked by Kasak, Duke, and James, but if neither James nor Duke can hold 157 and Sealy can, there is a spot there after Kasak graduates, but only for a year since Kasak has two more left. He's in a tough spot. If he really wants to start and compete for AA honors, then he'll have to go, and I'll wish him well at his next stop (hopefully Lehigh or Penn or somewhere in-state like that). I'm not too concerned from a PSU perspective about guys who can't crack the lineup threatening us by going elsewhere.
I would doubt James can make 157. He wrestled 165 recently at Super 32 and is entered at 168 at the Doc Buchanan tournament coming up in a few days. Also, he won't be 18 until June, so I think he still has some good weight to put on.
 

Hockeygod11

Sophomore
Jan 29, 2006
92
168
33
Bad take. Except for figs......none of them have lost a single match all year.
Steve Brule GIF by MOODMAN
 

El_Jefe

All-American
Oct 11, 2021
2,158
7,205
113
I know cruisliner means Rutgers on this board and my understanding is it has something to do w/ Suriano but what is the actual background on cruiseliner being Rutgers?
During an offseason, Rutgers nutjob poster RUCreedo claimed on their board that they were gonna land a PSU transfer, a big enough name that would make Cael "sh** a cruiseliner."

First he claimed it was Cenzo, who actually denied it publicly. Then it was Cassar. Then it was anybody whose name ended in a vowel. Eventually, anybody whose name contained a vowel. Obviously none of them happened.

Suriano arrived on campus that summer, but was still at Bergen Catholic at the time. So it wasn't him.

Fast forward a year, and Suriano left for Rutgers. We started calling him Cruiseliner Nick. And of course Creedo took credit for it (though to their credit, nobody on the Rutgers board believed him.)
 
Jun 26, 2025
146
316
63
I think Sealey will transfer out this offseason. He has no clear path to the lineup next year (or the year after) and he is clearly too good to not get a shot as a starter. And since he was such a high recruit I think he is less likely to take the Bearclaw/Evans path and wait for 1 last year. I would guess Sealey ends up in the ACC or EIWAS
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dogwelder

ScottishSteel

Freshman
Oct 18, 2021
52
77
18
During an offseason, Rutgers nutjob poster RUCreedo claimed on their board that they were gonna land a PSU transfer, a big enough name that would make Cael "sh** a cruiseliner."

First he claimed it was Cenzo, who actually denied it publicly. Then it was Cassar. Then it was anybody whose name ended in a vowel. Eventually, anybody whose name contained a vowel. Obviously none of them happened.

Suriano arrived on campus that summer, but was still at Bergen Catholic at the time. So it wasn't him.

Fast forward a year, and Suriano left for Rutgers. We started calling him Cruiseliner Nick. And of course Creedo took credit for it (though to their credit, nobody on the Rutgers board believed him.)
Appreciate the clarification
 
  • Like
Reactions: BriantheLion

BriantheLion

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2023
1,131
1,515
113
During an offseason, Rutgers nutjob poster RUCreedo claimed on their board that they were gonna land a PSU transfer, a big enough name that would make Cael "sh** a cruiseliner."

First he claimed it was Cenzo, who actually denied it publicly. Then it was Cassar. Then it was anybody whose name ended in a vowel. Eventually, anybody whose name contained a vowel. Obviously none of them happened.

Suriano arrived on campus that summer, but was still at Bergen Catholic at the time. So it wasn't him.

Fast forward a year, and Suriano left for Rutgers. We started calling him Cruiseliner Nick. And of course Creedo took credit for it (though to their credit, nobody on the Rutgers
Wow… that’s even bigger than a brick!
 

McScoreley

All-Conference
Oct 31, 2021
245
1,220
93
Obviously this can change but Willie said on Baschamania "Sealey isn't leaving until he graduates if he does at all"

Very similar to the statement the Mirasolas made as well.

The only school that he probably sees as a worthwhile similar training situation is Oklahoma State and like others pointed out, they have their guys also at the weights!

It sounds crazy but maybe the kid is happy and loves the school and team, sees the connection to Cael being worthwhile to keep and there's more to his life than wrestling as many NCAAs as possible (he's very active in freestyle in the offseason and I'm sure he views the US Open as just as good of a prize). He also knows he could be the guy at anytime since injuries always happen in wrestling.
 
Last edited:

Roar More

All-Conference
Oct 30, 2021
663
1,588
93
Obviously this can change but Willie said on Baschamania "Sealey isn't leaving until he graduates if he does at all"

Very similar to the statement the Mirasolas made as well.

The only school that he probably sees as a worthwhile similar training situation is Oklahoma State and like others pointed out, they have their guys also at the weights!

It sounds crazy but maybe the kid is happy and loves the school and team, sees the connection to Cael being worthwhile to keep and there's more to his life than wrestling as many NCAAs as possible (he's very active in freestyle in the offseason and I'm sure he views the US Open as just as good of a prize). He also knows he could be the guy at anytime since injuries always happen in wrestling.
Or, as Cael said in today's presser, our guys come to train for world and Olympic championships.
 

kingstown

Junior
Dec 7, 2025
108
314
63
Or, as Cael said in today's presser, our guys come to train for world and Olympic championships.
I think Joe and Conner are two guys that have a chance to actually become World or Olympic champions at the senior level. They are in the best place to chase the biggest dream, so leaving to wrestle a College season or even 3 college seasons probably hurts them in the pursuit of that goal. I could see a case where either one of them or somebody else leaves for a year or two and then returns to train senior level at the NLWC. Cael cares about these guys and I'm guessing plenty of honest talks between the wrestlers and coaches are happening. It does suck for the great wrestlers that aren't competing and for us fans who would get to watch them compete.
 

Goggles Paisano

All-Conference
Feb 6, 2018
503
1,215
93
It sounds crazy but maybe the kid is happy and loves the school and team, sees the connection to Cael being worthwhile to keep and there's more to his life than wrestling as many NCAAs as possible (he's very active in freestyle in the offseason and I'm sure he views the US Open as just as good of a prize). He also knows he could be the guy at anytime since injuries always happen in wrestling.
Well it sure sounds like PSU is getting close to 30 scholarships. I suspect all the are getting some NIL icing on top. If your ultimate dream is olympic and world freestyle medals, then 5 years under Cael and the NLWC is indeed the best place to be. A nice sprinkling of starts and opens here and there, being a member of the greatest program potentially ever, plus a fist full of NC rings ain't so bad.

The lure of starting somewhere has to be strong, but how bitter sweet to face off against one of your brothers in blue and white, while in some other singlet, only to lose and miss out on all of the lifetime benefits of staying under Cael. All this has to make the decision far from a slam dunk even for the most competitive dispositions. Not to mention injuries in wrestling are real, and any kid could be called upon at any time.
 

McScoreley

All-Conference
Oct 31, 2021
245
1,220
93
Well it sure sounds like PSU is getting close to 30 scholarships. I suspect all the are getting some NIL icing on top. If your ultimate dream is olympic and world freestyle medals, then 5 years under Cael and the NLWC is indeed the best place to be. A nice sprinkling of starts and opens here and there, being a member of the greatest program potentially ever, plus a fist full of NC rings ain't so bad.

The lure of starting somewhere has to be strong, but how bitter sweet to face off against one of your brothers in blue and white, while in some other singlet, only to lose and miss out on all of the lifetime benefits of staying under Cael. All this has to make the decision far from a slam dunk even for the most competitive dispositions. Not to mention injuries in wrestling are real, and any kid could be called upon at any time.
I think it's been mentioned that Cael didn't want any revenue share but he was promised he can give 30 scholarships if he needs it. He won't give out 30 (he still adds walk on wrestlers and you know some kids already are heavily discounted due to having family that works at the school, both of Casey's sons and Dalton Perry) but if there is a top kid who can be sold with it, he can commit to it even if it's not endowed.

Cassar mentioned before he almost left because he was taking a lot of loans to stay at Penn State and he couldn't really afford it anymore, Cael found him something (and we're all glad he did!)
 

Sportfan2017

Junior
Jun 28, 2017
71
221
33
When are people gonna learn they need to be in their toes when they dispute something you've said? Lol
It baffles me too. I've got 3 paid writers and 4 research assistants so they should learn soon. :)_

The truth of the matter is that I'm just a dumb idiot who like to have fun. How dumb? I couldn't spell cat if you spotted me the k and the a.
 

PSUAllTheWay

All-Conference
Jan 18, 2015
2,034
4,119
213
I think Sealey will transfer out this offseason. He has no clear path to the lineup next year (or the year after) and he is clearly too good to not get a shot as a starter. And since he was such a high recruit I think he is less likely to take the Bearclaw/Evans path and wait for 1 last year. I would guess Sealey ends up in the ACC or EIWAS
I'm not so sure of this. It really depends on what his goals are. Cael has changed the game. The kids coming to PSU are not coming to be AA's or National Champs. It is World Champ or bust, and any kid with that overriding goal is going to think long and hard about leaving Penn State right now. PSU is likely the best place in the world to try and achieve that goal .
 

Lil Nicky Scarfo

All-Conference
Jul 1, 2025
873
2,097
93
Well it sure sounds like PSU is getting close to 30 scholarships. I suspect all the are getting some NIL icing on top. If your ultimate dream is olympic and world freestyle medals, then 5 years under Cael and the NLWC is indeed the best place to be. A nice sprinkling of starts and opens here and there, being a member of the greatest program potentially ever, plus a fist full of NC rings ain't so bad.

The lure of starting somewhere has to be strong, but how bitter sweet to face off against one of your brothers in blue and white, while in some other singlet, only to lose and miss out on all of the lifetime benefits of staying under Cael. All this has to make the decision far from a slam dunk even for the most competitive dispositions. Not to mention injuries in wrestling are real, and any kid could be called upon at any time.
If you use Dan Gable Math, those 30 scholarships actually equate to 67 scholarships, give or take 1 or 2
 

mcpat

All-Conference
Mar 12, 2021
1,129
3,499
113
During an offseason, Rutgers nutjob poster RUCreedo claimed on their board that they were gonna land a PSU transfer, a big enough name that would make Cael "sh** a cruiseliner."

First he claimed it was Cenzo, who actually denied it publicly. Then it was Cassar. Then it was anybody whose name ended in a vowel. Eventually, anybody whose name contained a vowel. Obviously none of them happened.

Suriano arrived on campus that summer, but was still at Bergen Catholic at the time. So it wasn't him.

Fast forward a year, and Suriano left for Rutgers. We started calling him Cruiseliner Nick. And of course Creedo took credit for it (though to their credit, nobody on the Rutgers board believed him.)
He did it again last year as RUCrackers and no one transferred in.

I believe he’s gone away and reappeared as different user names.
 
Last edited:

Sandy2176

Redshirt
Nov 1, 2025
23
32
13
How do we fit him and the lineup and if not do you guys think he transfers this offseason? Feel like Taylor will go after him.
He won't go to ok state he'll compete against Robideau. They have their horses already on team. They may take him just so no one else can have him
 
  • Like
Reactions: RS54

Sandy2176

Redshirt
Nov 1, 2025
23
32
13
He won't go to ok state he'll compete against Robideau. They have their horses already on team. They may take him just so no one else can have him
He has a path to start if he can maintain 57 he'll have his Sr year to be the starter. Question is would you wait to start one year on the best wrestling team or 2-3 years starting on runner-up team's I know what I would do
 

El_Jefe

All-American
Oct 11, 2021
2,158
7,205
113
I'm not so sure of this. It really depends on what his goals are. Cael has changed the game. The kids coming to PSU are not coming to be AA's or National Champs. It is World Champ or bust, and any kid with that overriding goal is going to think long and hard about leaving Penn State right now. PSU is likely the best place in the world to try and achieve that goal .
True, though the one hitch is the number of guys at his weight who will be at NLWC. He might not be staying without outside funding, and even then it's not a given. Strategically, he might stay at PSU as long as possible and then do a 1-yr grad transfer to his eventual post-grad RTC.

But he's only a RSFR. Lots can change in the next 3 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Psalm 1 guy