I was one of those posters, but I didn't realize at the time how bad our depth was. That is a fact I didn't take into consideration so even though I was one of those wrong about "anybody coming in to win 9 games", knowing what I know now you can't dismiss how crappy how depth actually is. Also injuries have played a huge factor.I heard quite often last year that any coach could come in and win 9 games. Now people act like we're at Iowa State's level and are lucky to be 2-3 at this point.
With that being said, Riley isn't and shouldn't be immune to criticism. With the correct decisions at the end of BYU and Illinois our chances of winning increase drastically.
But given the facts of poor depth and injuries (and now wondering if all players have the right mindset) I'm willing to give Riley time before criticizing his every single move like many have done here.