I don't believe a person who is formerly physically a guy should compete in women's spsorts, regardless of the hormones. Disgraceful, though, I'm not sure. We've got to start somewhere in helping transgender people find their identity. Like it or not, this is a real thing. What about the reverse, transgender men (formerly women) competing in men's sports, is that okay?
Definitely a real thing. just not as prevalent as the media might suggest. No one should feel excluded from society due to race, gender, class, etc. That’s easy enough to see.
But the question about the Thomas issue is whether her needs as a trans athlete take precedence over the needs of biological female athletes when the trans athlete is very, very clearly the minority segment. It’s a equity issue, but one that needs to be flipped over from the typical Progressive stance.
The answer is obvious: it’s not fair to the biological female athletes. Thomas does not need to compete against biological females to express herself as a female. She has many other avenues to so, and hopefully as a competitor can find her way into open competitions of mixed gender, which I think would be the best solution.
Unfortunately some state legislators are taking this into their own hands. I would rather not have a legal remedy, as it is very polarizing. I wish the NCAA, USOC, and high school sport’s governing bodies would grow some balls (yes I wrote that) and address it without cowing to the Woke Left.