Blem,
I have no problem with you disagreeing with me ... ever. It makes for better "discussion" and besides, most peeps eventually do.
I also appreciate that you have as good an insight into Miami as anyone I've ever seen post on the USC boards, and so I'm comfortable that you can speak with an usually high level of authority on the Canes.
Maybe where we first part on MC is where you're assuming Cristobal would still want Donte at his side. Given that DW recently bolted on him, I'm not ready to make that assumption. Actually, I was thinking that hiring MC might be one sure way to guaranty Donte would bail, or be jettisoned ... which is, in turn, one reason not to hire Cristobal.
That said, I'm personally against Cristobal because I don't like the idea of poaching another P12 coach to jump ship for USC by our encouragement. Maybe I'd feel different if Mario made the initial contact-of-interest to Bohn, but I don't see that happening. I which case, he'd be looking at it as mostly a money-opportunity thrown at him by USC in near desperation and, I think, Uncle Phil would outbid even USC to keep Mario. In truth, I think UO would do just about anything to keep him.
I also don't believe Cristobal would leave Oregon for another P12 school, even USC. He would leave, however, for a quality team in the South with tradition, a pro (vs. con) football culture and bouquet-piles of money, especially such a school in the state of Flodido ... since that's home for him, not LA. I know you know he played and started his coaching career at Miami. All thing's being equal, don't you think Mario to Miami is a much more likely move than Mario to Los Angeles? It'd be a grand thing, IMO, for him to return in triumph to Miami and complete the full circle in his coaching career.
Yes, I agree he's a very good coach and I recognize Oregon's current success is much the result of Mario Cristobal, but I don't think he's the
best candidate for USC by a long shot. He'd be another lazy hire. The last head coach we poached from a P12 school came in with all the promise of success but didn't turn out so swell (Cutty Sark).
If we do in fact conduct a full, broad and thoughtful professional search for our new HC, then I'll agree MC's name should probably be somewhere on the master list, 'cuz "if you don't ask, you don't get." And if all the nuts have been shaken from the tree and he's the best we can find then I'd support him, but with one-eye-open and on him all the time for the NFL to come calling and lure him away. (Personally, I think Mario's next move is to take a stab at the NFL, not any other D1 college program that's not Miami, FSU or the Gators - and the Gators aren't looking right now.
Finally, as USC fans we see USC as head and shoulders above Oregon in all regards, but the Duck program is his baby, his creation. I think he'd be loath to give it up for what he may very likely see as pretty-much only a lateral move.
None of those may be fair or accurate, but it's how I see things with him. Even if I were wrong on all accounts, I still think we should
aim higher.
USC need lots off things in a new coach that not Clay, Sark or the Lane Train ever offered but, among those things, I'd consider the stability of a sincere long-term commitment to USC an extremely important consideration. After the constant hire-n-fire revolving door at USC ever since Pete left, we desperately need someone qualified, capable and
committed to stick with USC all the way back to the pinnacle. I don't think Cristobal would provide that.
And stop being a racist.
View attachment 153983