Personally, my money would be on some consolidation at the elementary level but not a consolidated county high school.
I would agree with that, I think there will be more consolidation on the elementary and K thru 8 front. The closing of Marble Elementary was a start, but there are still too many elementary and K thru 8 schools in the county, given the population.
From a fiscal standpoint, Martins Creek (K thru 8) and Peachtree Elementary should probably close and I wouldn't be surprised if those two schools were the sacrificial lambs (so to speak) in this next phase of potential consolidation. The Peachtree kids are all close enough to Murphy Elementary for it to be a non issue. The Martins Creek kids are all close enough to either Ranger or Murphy Elementary and Middle for it to be a non issue for them as well. Of course if you added Peachtree and Martins Creek kids to those schools, there would have to be expansion at Ranger and Murphy to accommodate them. But over the long haul it would definitely save the county money, despite the cost to upgrade those facilities.
I think Hiwassee Dam Elementary/Middle will be spared in consolidation but only because Hiwassee Dam is home to the high school in the far western end of the county and their schools are all on the same complex. That fact is also the only reason a Hiwassee Dam Elementary/Middle makes any sense moving forward. I frame it that way because if school plans were being drawn up now based on population centers and efficiency, it would be Ranger (not Hiwassee Dam) as the location of the high school on that end of the county. The kids zoned to Hiwassee Dam Elementary/Middle would have a minimal commute to Ranger.
I think if you were to look at Cherokee County schools without any sort of community or alma mater bias, the best setup in my opinion would probably be a two high school, two middle school, three elementary school system. The construction of a western high school and middle school in the Ranger area and the construction of an eastern high school and middle school around the Tomatla area. The three elementary schools would be located in Ranger, Murphy and Andrews (using the elementary schools currently in place in those areas, with expansion as necessary).