Name a player you were totally wrong about regarding NFL career.

[WKU Toppers]

I thought Reggie bush and Darren McFadden would be stars.

I'm a colts fan and was mad the colts drafted Peyton instead of Ryan leaf, then was mad they drafted edgerrin James instead of Ricky Williams. Glad I'm not GM!

 

[rmattox]

There have been several but E Manning stands out in my mind. Maybe it was comparing him to big brother, but I never saw him with the skills to make it big. Interestingly, I still don't think he compares to Peyton, but then look at his numbers. They tell a different story.
Maybe my view is tainted because in both college and pros he's had to wear the most awful uniforms in the history of organized Football. Everything he did looked (s) ugly.