I think you should include Gavin Mottl from St. Rita. Humble kid that flew below the radar on some Rita teams that struggled a bit. He's just starting his college career but here's some of his HS accomplishments:
- 4 Year Varsity starter at Rita.
- 99%+ successful PATs all 4 years.
- 85%+ successful FGs all 4 years.
- All State, All Area, All Conference CCL Blue (3x).
- Top 50 Illinois Player Sun Times (only K/P selected).
- Athlete of the Week Tribune NBC Sports.
- Game Winning final play FG made against Mount Carmel with .06 seconds left.
- Game Winning final play FG made against Marmion with 1.7 seconds left.
- Game Tying final play FG made against Providence with 2.3 seconds left.
- Lefty Punter with field flipping distance.
- Pinpoint corner placement on punts.
- Many successful onside kicks.
- HS National Honor Society & St. Rita Honor Roll.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.chicagotribune.com/suburbs/daily-southtown/sports/ct-sta-spt-football-st-rita-st-0821-story.html?outputType=amp