to help protect student athletes from situations like the UNLV quarterback found himself.
NCAA asking for congressional assistance...
- Thread starter H00SIER-Cat
- Start date
Don’t know who is telling the truth in this situation but the NCAA rules for football naturally led to this. I will say that I am skeptical that the kid transferred based solely on a verbal promise but maybe. Regardless if they couldn’t see this coming with the redshirt rules unique to football, well that’s on them.
Hey NCAA—how about the changing the idiotic redshirt rule for football instead of begging Congress to do your job? So the QB has played 3 games and is getting a non medical redshirt. Make an appearance in a game in baseball or basketball and you are only eligible for a med red. NCAA and football coaches are reaping what they sowed with the ridiculous nature of non med red rules for football. Giving football players an ability to showcase themselves for several games in an attempt to maximize their NIL was a natural outcome.
Hey NCAA—how about the changing the idiotic redshirt rule for football instead of begging Congress to do your job? So the QB has played 3 games and is getting a non medical redshirt. Make an appearance in a game in baseball or basketball and you are only eligible for a med red. NCAA and football coaches are reaping what they sowed with the ridiculous nature of non med red rules for football. Giving football players an ability to showcase themselves for several games in an attempt to maximize their NIL was a natural outcome.
The NCAA + Congress. It's the stuff of nightmares. The end times are upon us. Hug your loved ones.
Things typically improve when the government gets involved. Whatever they help with I have this weird feeling that somehow more taxes are going to be involved.
1. I thought direct pay for play deals with universities was against NCAA rules... so there's that. Maybe I'm wrong... seems to be the norm these days.
2. Setting that aside, if players are indeed going to engage in such deals with universities, or whomever for that matter, they damn well better get a legally enforceable, signed contract. Demand a contract for such offers, and this business of not being paid what you were promised will stop. Frankly, a lot of this is on the players if they just accept someone's promise to pay them. You want to be a professional athlete, well, then start handling your business like a professional athlete.
2. Setting that aside, if players are indeed going to engage in such deals with universities, or whomever for that matter, they damn well better get a legally enforceable, signed contract. Demand a contract for such offers, and this business of not being paid what you were promised will stop. Frankly, a lot of this is on the players if they just accept someone's promise to pay them. You want to be a professional athlete, well, then start handling your business like a professional athlete.
Like Congress has ever improved anything, ever.
One corrupt organization asking for help from another corrupt organization.
I’m sure congress is chomping at the bit to siphon more billions off the top of the NCAA for themselves in the name of helping underprivileged athletes.
The NCAA needs to either do their job or disband. Calling on Congress to act is utter failure and proof they are completely useless. They had the chance to set NIL rules, but weren't smart enough to separate pay for play from NIL. They should've banned schools acting as agents and put the burden on players to make money from their image and likeness, not from sports.
Why is anyone surprised that something like this would happen in of all places Vegas?
Gobermet aweful, says man on way to cash social security check. Goberment awful says man on way to get new teeth with Medicaid payment. Goberment aweful says everybody in Florida, GA, NC and TN sitting on their rooftop waiting for the FEMA man.
Social Security and Dental Medicaid Benefits are two amazing examples of great things from the government
. Good grief.I am sure you won't be hearing much if any anti-socialism rhetoric from that region of the country for a very long time.
If you are receiving government aid, it is great and very much deserved. When someone else receives it, it is socialism and an undeserving handout to lazy people. It is all a matter of perspective. Lol.Social Security and Dental Medicaid Benefits are two amazing examples of great things from the government
Just so you know, I am in favor of our citizens receiving the help that they need. If you have never been in a position of need, keep living and your time will likely come. If you receive help you don't need, karma can be hell.
I’m not at all into politics and have no real interest in this topic. You do you, but as someone that is way more familiar with those programs then I’d like to be they are horribly set up and extremely inefficient and are actually horrible “pro-government” examples. That was the funny part to me. Out of all the positives of a government he could name he came up with those two examples
. Was just funny. Again - have fun with politics talk just not my thing GBB!
Last edited:
Of course you are apolitical. Someone obviously forced you to comment on a post that you have no interest in. It happens all the time. LolI’m not at all into politics and have no real interest in this topic. You do you, but as someone that is way more familiar with those programs then I’d like to be they are horribly set up and extremely inefficient and are actually horrible “pro-government” examples. That was the funny part to me. Out of all the positives of a government he could name he came up with those two examples
Last edited:
You’re obviously agitated about something all good. The part about the NCAA being involved is what I found interesting - not democrat vs Republican vs libertarian vs whatever. Enjoy being one of those people that “follows politics” that seems to constantly be in a bad mood and argumentative and judgmental though.
You are the only one mentioning political parties and trying to argue. You seem to have issues that have caused a considerable amount confusion for you. There is probably a pill you can take for it. Lol
What exactly do they want Congress to do. That seems unclear to me. As for WHY they want help,seems obvious to me. It will help them avoid millions in litigation fees and if something else goes wrong they have someone else to blame
Right? Money I used to have until the government took it from me to "hold" it until I'm old enough to deserve it at which point I may get some of it back if they haven't accidentally spent it on something else first. Thanks, government. What a bargain for me.Social Security and Dental Medicaid Benefits are two amazing examples of great things from the government
Congress should step in. A regulatory authority with higher authority than a confederation of selfish bureaucracies is probably the only solution to the clusterfuck.
Instead, due to NCAA ineptitude and being neutered of any real authority, it's the Justice Dept. is driving huge decisions that impact schools, players and fans nationwide.
And while I get the "gubmint bad" mentality, I think it's important to point out that the NCAA is largely made up of institutions literally funded by taxation and controlled by gubmints. Furthermore, as stated, without congressional action, it's ultimately the Justice Dept. making these decisions.
The path we are on is not sustainable, not just in terms of payments to athletes, but also in terms of the decimation of traditional conferences and the persistent reality that the system is a hodgepodge of rules that are not cohesive whatsoever.
Instead, due to NCAA ineptitude and being neutered of any real authority, it's the Justice Dept. is driving huge decisions that impact schools, players and fans nationwide.
And while I get the "gubmint bad" mentality, I think it's important to point out that the NCAA is largely made up of institutions literally funded by taxation and controlled by gubmints. Furthermore, as stated, without congressional action, it's ultimately the Justice Dept. making these decisions.
The path we are on is not sustainable, not just in terms of payments to athletes, but also in terms of the decimation of traditional conferences and the persistent reality that the system is a hodgepodge of rules that are not cohesive whatsoever.
Last edited:
What should happen is a complete overhaul of the college game that recognizes the reality of player payments and then a redesign of conferences into regional affiliations. Like, that is what has to happen. It's just a matter of being proactive vs letting things evolve slowly due to a subsequent chain of trainwrecks
******* California is in the Atlantic Coast Conference. Let. that. sink. in. Schools have no leverage in terms of payments. Players have no protections.
Truth be told, the programs at the top of the hierarchy want to avoid such reforms for as long as possible. Why is it in a Ohio State's interest to change anything?
******* California is in the Atlantic Coast Conference. Let. that. sink. in. Schools have no leverage in terms of payments. Players have no protections.
Truth be told, the programs at the top of the hierarchy want to avoid such reforms for as long as possible. Why is it in a Ohio State's interest to change anything?
Could Congress put a limit on how much NIL a university can receive. Say 5 mil across the board. Schools have the option to exceed that if they match it and that money would go into a nil fund that other schools can use if they don't reach they 5 mil mark
Problem is they can't. Every time they've tried to make a rule it gets overturned by some state judge in court.