Oops

Mntneer

Sophomore
Oct 7, 2001
10,192
196
0
Damn.... I'm betting there will be video of it actually collapsing. Would be helpful in determining cause.

Reminds me of the Hyatt Regency walkway collapse back in the early '80.
 

bamaEER

Freshman
May 29, 2001
32,435
60
0
We had something like that happen near me in Utica, NY that killed a construction worker. Happened the year before I moved up here.
 

WVUCOOPER

Redshirt
Dec 10, 2002
55,556
40
31
Damn.... I'm betting there will be video of it actually collapsing. Would be helpful in determining cause.

Reminds me of the Hyatt Regency walkway collapse back in the early '80.
I saw on the Twitterer (must be true) this bridge was just recently moved, like over the weekend. Yikes.
 

WVUCOOPER

Redshirt
Dec 10, 2002
55,556
40
31
 

Mntneer

Sophomore
Oct 7, 2001
10,192
196
0
I saw on the Twitterer (must be true) this bridge was just recently moved, like over the weekend. Yikes.

Built off-site and installed a few days back I believe. Hard to tell what could have caused it from the video I've seen so far.
 

DvlDog4WVU

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2008
47,207
3,285
113
Any word on how long it will be before the repubs start blaming the victims?
I don’t know about that but this clearly a case where we need to start outlawing bridges! The founders could have never envisioned a time when bridges would span 8 lane highways. Those bridges are a menace!!!
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,598
814
113
Damn.... I'm betting there will be video of it actually collapsing. Would be helpful in determining cause.

Reminds me of the Hyatt Regency walkway collapse back in the early '80.
Probably wont be hard to determibe the cause. Bridge is new and I donr think even open to pedestrians. Engineers nightmare.
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,598
814
113
Built off-site and installed a few days back I believe. Hard to tell what could have caused it from the video I've seen so far.
In guessing whatever pier or whatever it was sitting on in the middle failed. Either was not placed correctly or the pier shifted. When the walkway at charlotte motor speedway failed it was due to a halfass goyt job to secure the pier.
 
Sep 6, 2013
27,594
120
0
In guessing whatever pier or whatever it was sitting on in the middle failed. Either was not placed correctly or the pier shifted. When the walkway at charlotte motor speedway failed it was due to a halfass goyt job to secure the pier.

There was no middle support, dumbass. It was a single span.

Failure obviously initiated at left end where the green man lift is.
 

Mntneer

Sophomore
Oct 7, 2001
10,192
196
0
I think this could be the failure point. If that column blew through the roof, then it would have lost all structural integrity.

What a nightmare. I bet you Engineers and Contractors are going through their plans and specs with a fine tooth comb now.

 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,598
814
113
I think this could be the failure point. If that column blew through the roof, then it would have lost all structural integrity.

What a nightmare. I bet you Engineers and Contractors are going through their plans and specs with a fine tooth comb now.

We will get a failure report in a few months and it will have recommendations and such. I remember when the Minneapolis bridge failed. Our company had done bridge inspections on it years before it failed. Corporate emails imploring all employees to direct any media contact to PR. Good times.
 
Sep 6, 2013
27,594
120
0
FIGG, the designer, has an impeccable reputation. My money is on either the construction contractor being at fault or a material defect. A lot of post-tensioning strands are failing when they shouldn’t be.
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,598
814
113
FIGG, the designer, has an impeccable reputation. My money is on either the construction contractor being at fault or a material defect. A lot of post-tensioning strands are failing when they shouldn’t be.
I read they had done a stress test on the bridge earlier today. If that is true....
 

Mntneer

Sophomore
Oct 7, 2001
10,192
196
0
FIGG, the designer, has an impeccable reputation. My money is on either the construction contractor being at fault or a material defect. A lot of post-tensioning strands are failing when they shouldn’t be.

Manufacturing defects? Or installation defects?
 

BoremanSouth

Redshirt
Jul 28, 2016
1,715
0
0
I don’t know about that but this clearly a case where we need to start outlawing bridges! The founders could have never envisioned a time when bridges would span 8 lane highways. Those bridges are a menace!!!

I think outlawing bridges is a tad over the top. Think better bridge control.
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,598
814
113
The post-tensioning strands failing are material defects - manufacturing. The steel has a high carbon content and behaves more brittle than ductile.
I would have to read a lot more on that. They should know the properties of the materials specified for the job. If something other than specified is delivered it would be up to the engineers and contractors to identify and rectify the issue before installation.
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,598
814
113
Just read that a FIGG employee, I would suppose an engineer, left a voicemail to a FDOT employee suggesting there were cracks in the structure and that obviously something would need to be done to repair them.

Thats gonna be an expensive phone call.

I wonder how much stress is put on the structure when it is picked up and moved. It would have to be pretty fragile.
 

Mntneer

Sophomore
Oct 7, 2001
10,192
196
0
Just read that a FIGG employee, I would suppose an engineer, left a voicemail to a FDOT employee suggesting there were cracks in the structure and that obviously something would need to be done to repair them.

Thats gonna be an expensive phone call.

I wonder how much stress is put on the structure when it is picked up and moved. It would have to be pretty fragile.

Wow. This is going to be an interesting story to watch.