OT: 2026 Coaching Carousel

dconifer0

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2004
4,471
3,451
113
Huff or Kelly, who do you prefer?
If it was just on personality, I love the current interim coach. But that's not how you get over the mountain these days.

I don't doubt Huff's competence, but I think that success in the places he's been doesn't automatically translate to success at Maryland in the B1G.

I don't know much about Kelly, but I know he's "Big Time" and I think that at this point, programs like Maryland and Rutgers should try a reset with a coach like that. It's pretty tough to find the next Cignetti, I think. So I'll choose Kelly...
 
Last edited:

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,216
17,017
113
If it was just on personality, I love the current interim coach. But that's not how you get over the mountain these days.

I don't doubt Huff's competence, but I think that success in the places he's been doesn't automatically translate to success at Maryland in the B1G.

I don't know much about Kelly, but I know he's "Big Time" and I think that at this point, programs like Maryland and Rutgers should try a reset with a coach like that. It's pretty tough to find the next Cignetti, I think. So I'll choose Kelly...
It is a crapshoot for sure.
Do you go with a name that has proven to have been a winner every place he went, but might have lost a little of his touch based on how his last program felt he couldn't get them to the top and let him go despite having to pay a lot to dump him
Or go with an up and coming G-6 ( or FCS) HC that looks ready to be a winner at the P-4 level , but there's no way to be sure he will.
Even great coordinators have been known to crash and burn when given the top spot.

I feel Kelly has had his time in the sun and his star might be fading.
If Schiano wasn't coming back I'd go for the up and coming talent or a sure fire Coordinator pick rather than a retread kike Kelly no matter how his overall W-L record looks like .

I believe thought Kelly's recruiting as the LSU HC was considered good, LSU felt due to their "illustrious" history and being a top destination, Kelly's recruiting there was felt a little underwhelming when compared to the expectations the School and fanbase felt it should have been

If course the Turtles might strike paydirt like North Carilina did when they hired Mack Brown after he was kicked out of Texas .
But Mack was familure with the Tar Heels haveing left them for the Longhorns
 

dconifer0

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2004
4,471
3,451
113
It is a crapshoot for sure.
Do you go with a name that has proven to have been a winner every place he went, but might have lost a little of his touch based on how his last program felt he couldn't get them to the top and let him go despite having to pay a lot to dump him
Or go with an up and coming G-6 ( or FCS) HC that looks ready to be a winner at the P-4 level , but there's no way to be sure he will.
Even great coordinators have been known to crash and burn when given the top spot.

I feel Kelly has had his time in the sun and his star might be fading.
If Schiano wasn't coming back I'd go for the up and coming talent or a sure fire Coordinator pick rather than a retread kike Kelly no matter how his overall W-L record looks like .

I believe thought Kelly's recruiting as the LSU HC was considered good, LSU felt due to their "illustrious" history and being a top destination, Kelly's recruiting there was felt a little underwhelming when compared to the expectations the School and fanbase felt it should have been

If course the Turtles might strike paydirt like North Carilina did when they hired Mack Brown after he was kicked out of Texas .
But Mack was familure with the Tar Heels haveing left them for the Longhorns
Agree with all of that.

And my heart isn't in my choice of Kelly at all. I'd be at least as happy with taking a chance on a young dude...
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,184
90,330
113
Bielema....
Its Over Aww GIF by Blake Lively Fan
 

rutgersguy2

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
5,703
2,819
112
Not sure what he’s done to go from Nebraska to A&M to potentially Michigan. Getting it done this fast before the president officially takes over Dec 1 gives the impression Whittingham will be one and done though.

Last two A&M ADs would be the ADs at Michigan and OSU if this happens. OSU AD is the one who extended Fisher’s already ridiculous initial A&M contract iirc.



 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,184
90,330
113


I’d have to see it to believe it and think it’s very unlikely and no other CFB media is reporting such a possibility at the moment.

Great minds think alike. I posted the same two followups in the the separate thread on this topic. It's worth of a separate thread. People's heads would explode on this forum if this actually happened for Maryland. Good for them if they are reaching for the stars.
 
  • Like
Reactions: M.Sherrane

rutgersguy2

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
5,703
2,819
112
IDK why you are keen on the current Toledo Coach.


I don't follow the NFL much at all but so don't know how Monken is doing other than seeing his record at the Browns. But part of his quote is why I was mentioning Eck last year and potentially Jacobs this year.

I think it's especially true for a lower status program. Obviously, there's more risk when you act a little earlier than you'd like without the track record at this level.

Either you might to take a chance somewhat early like Eck, Jacobs or way late like Cignetti, Fritz. Monken's cousin at Army would be a way late kind of option but no one wants to give him a shot to see if he's got it.

quote:
Monken said Macdonald told him that when building a staff, you have to fight to get the coaches you want, and sometimes you have to hire rising stars a year earlier than you otherwise would. “Because if you wait, you won’t get them.”

He also acknowledged the inevitable growing pains: “We’re human and we’re going to fail, but we’re gonna fight like hell to fix it. We’re always under construction.”
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,184
90,330
113
Been wondering about Chesney, the reporting is that UCLA and him are close to extension. It's been about a week. The longer it goes, you wonder if Chesney is waiting to see what jobs might open (Michigan, maybe even USC)...kind of slow playing it.
Heard from Richard Kent on Twitter, Chesney is waiting for the Rutgers job to open up. Shout out to @-RUFAN4LIFE- and @kupuna133 for confirmation. 😂
 
  • Like
Reactions: -RUFAN4LIFE-

Rutgers Chris

All-American
Nov 29, 2005
6,057
7,398
97
And to think that idiot teaches sports law and claims to be an expert on NIL. There is only one other poster that gets more things wrong than Richard Kent.
He posted the spread for our basketball game versus Houston using the line from when we played them in the ncaa tournament years ago. It’s the second or third time he did it. Can’t beat it
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Knight Shift

Rutgers Chris

All-American
Nov 29, 2005
6,057
7,398
97
Been wondering about Chesney, the reporting is that UCLA and him are close to extension. It's been about a week. The longer it goes, you wonder if Chesney is waiting to see what jobs might open (Michigan, maybe even USC)...kind of slow playing it.
Definitely wouldn’t shock me if he’s holding out for the Michigan job. UCLA needs to move faster if they haven’t actually put something on the table yet
 

rutgersguy2

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
5,703
2,819
112
Definitely wouldn’t shock me if he’s holding out for the Michigan job. UCLA needs to move faster if they haven’t actually put something on the table yet
More than likely they have put something on the table, if anything is holding things up it’s likely Cheaney’s end.

Heard a pod just recently about Dickert and his extension. If a coach wants to be there then both sides will get it done fairly quickly and easily. Basically, if Dickert was interested in Wisc or FSU it would be on the table unsigned. He wanted to be there so it got done.

I’m sure UClLA has given Chesney a good contract and probably his staff too but maybe promises on things like the Rose Bowl vs SoFi and infrastructure and things of that nature could hold it up (those are things on a larger scale) and/or also he may just be slow playing it to see if anything else opens like USC or Michigan.

Supposedly they say he’s not a one and done type but who knows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rutgers Chris

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,184
90,330
113
More than likely they have put something on the table, if anything is holding things up it’s likely Cheaney’s end.

Heard a pod just recently about Dickert and his extension. If a coach wants to be there then both sides will get it done fairly quickly and easily. Basically, if Dickert was interested in Wisc or FSU it would be on the table unsigned. He wanted to be there so it got done.

I’m sure UClLA has given Chesney a good contract and probably his staff too but maybe promises on things like the Rose Bowl vs SoFi and infrastructure and things of that nature could hold it up (those are things on a larger scale) and/or also he may just be slow playing it to see if anything else opens like USC or Michigan.

Supposedly they say he’s not a one and done type but who knows.
Dickert may not be a job hopper/money and glory chaster like Lane Kiffin. Some of these guys don't have to have their ego stroked by getting new and purportedly "better" jobs at "top" schools.

Have had this conversation with people in my profession based on advise that was given to me many years ago- the job at the bigger/"better" company for more money may not be the "best" job for every individual. More money, bigger programs comes with more pressure and bigger expectations.

Wake Forest seems like the type of place that will tolerate a couple of bad years. Can only guess what Dickert is making since WF is private, but he was making $2.55M at Washington State. Safe to say he is making at least $4M/year. If a person cannot be happy on $4M/year living in a low cost of living area where Wake Forest is located, they may never be happy.
 

rutgersguy2

All-Conference
Jul 9, 2025
5,703
2,819
112
Dickert may not be a job hopper/money and glory chaster like Lane Kiffin. Some of these guys don't have to have their ego stroked by getting new and purportedly "better" jobs at "top" schools.

Have had this conversation with people in my profession based on advise that was given to me many years ago- the job at the bigger/"better" company for more money may not be the "best" job for every individual. More money, bigger programs comes with more pressure and bigger expectations.

Wake Forest seems like the type of place that will tolerate a couple of bad years. Can only guess what Dickert is making since WF is private, but he was making $2.55M at Washington State. Safe to say he is making at least $4M/year. If a person cannot be happy on $4M/year living in a low cost of living area where Wake Forest is located, they may never be happy.
Not only all that but with the 24 team CFP and more parity these days, you can accomplish a lot no matter where you are and without the pressure or fishbowl if you don't want to deal with that. Every person is different. If you can accomplish high level career goals where you are and are happy, you don't necessarily have to leave.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

M.Sherrane

Sophomore
Sep 10, 2026
111
116
43
Great minds think alike. I posted the same two followups in the the separate thread on this topic. It's worth of a separate thread. People's heads would explode on this forum if this actually happened for Maryland. Good for them if they are reaching for the stars.
My head didn't explode when I read that, but I nearly had a stroke. :) My first thought was "Fire Schiano now and jump the line to get ahead of Maryland for Urban".
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Knight Shift
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference