Toggle sidebar

OT: Motown vs Stax/Memphis Soul - which is your preference?

G

gamecockcat

New member
Oct 29, 2004
10,524
13,500
0
I'm pretty much conceding that both produced an enormous amount of great music. Love both, actually. But, push comes to shove, which style/studio's music is your preference?

Motown: Smoky, Temptations, Stevie Wonder, The Supremes, Marvin Gaye, Jackson 5, et al
Stax: Booker T, Otis Redding, Sam & Dave, Clarence Carter, Eddie Floyd, Albert King, et al

Tough call for me but I'd probably lean towards Stax. Love Motown but Stax has just a bit more grit and soul to my ear.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chroix, WTF Cat, CaptainBoogerBuns and 1 other person
UK 82

UK 82

Well-known member
Feb 27, 2015
11,305
80,497
113
gamecockcat said:
I'm pretty much conceding that both produced an enormous amount of great music. Love both, actually. But, push comes to shove, which style/studio's music is your preference?

Motown: Smoky, Temptations, Stevie Wonder, The Supremes, Marvin Gaye, Jackson 5, et al
Stax: Booker T, Otis Redding, Sam & Dave, Clarence Carter, Eddie Floyd, Albert King, et al

Tough call for me but I'd probably lean towards Stax. Love Motown but Stax has just a bit more grit and soul to my ear.
Click to expand...
I'll call it a tie, for me anyways. I still have multiple albums (vinyl and CD) by many of the artists. Great time for music.

Gotta add The Staple Singers to your Stax list.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: gamecockcat
S

sluggercatfan

New member
Aug 17, 2004
35,953
29,630
0
gamecockcat said:
I'm pretty much conceding that both produced an enormous amount of great music. Love both, actually. But, push comes to shove, which style/studio's music is your preference?

Motown: Smoky, Temptations, Stevie Wonder, The Supremes, Marvin Gaye, Jackson 5, et al
Stax: Booker T, Otis Redding, Sam & Dave, Clarence Carter, Eddie Floyd, Albert King, et al

Tough call for me but I'd probably lean towards Stax. Love Motown but Stax has just a bit more grit and soul to my ear.
Click to expand...
Love blues and Motown, but in a have to chose situation ...it'd be Motown.
 
Last edited:
G

GeraldV

Well-known member
Aug 4, 2019
2,463
4,425
113
gamecockcat said:
Care to elaborate why - just curious.
Click to expand...
Not sure how to put it into words, but I think Otis and then Sam and Dave are my favorites from the Stax side but I prefer literally every group you listed from the Motown list to either of the two from Stax. Not to mention other Motown acts like the Tops that you didn’t mention.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sluggercatfan and gamecockcat
R

rudd1

New member
Oct 3, 2007
14,419
21,101
0
-stax.

-Otis Redding is on my Mt Rushmore of musicians.

-motown has great production value...memphis/stax is "greasy" perfection.

-if you don't know Carol Kaye...she's the white lady that wrote/played/invented the funky bass lines that defined the motown sound. Also played a major role in Brian Wilson's pet sounds production.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecockcat and Deeeefense
S

sluggercatfan

New member
Aug 17, 2004
35,953
29,630
0
rudd1 said:
-stax.

-Otis Redding is on my Mt Rushmore of musicians.

-motown has great production value...memphis/stax is "greasy" perfection.

-if you don't know Carol Kaye...she's the white lady that wrote/played/invented the funky bass lines that defined the motown sound. Also played a major role in Brian Wilson's pet sounds production.
Click to expand...
 
CB3UK

CB3UK

Active member
Apr 15, 2012
294,355
71,393
78
rudd1 said:
-stax.

-Otis Redding is on my Mt Rushmore of musicians.

-motown has great production value...memphis/stax is "greasy" perfection.

-if you don't know Carol Kaye...she's the white lady that wrote/played/invented the funky bass lines that defined the motown sound. Also played a major role in Brian Wilson's pet sounds production.
Click to expand...
Don't forget James Jamerson!
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: Deeeefense and rudd1
WTF Cat

WTF Cat

Well-known member
Dec 4, 2022
5,406
24,755
113
gamecockcat said:
I'm pretty much conceding that both produced an enormous amount of great music. Love both, actually. But, push comes to shove, which style/studio's music is your preference?

Motown: Smoky, Temptations, Stevie Wonder, The Supremes, Marvin Gaye, Jackson 5, et al
Stax: Booker T, Otis Redding, Sam & Dave, Clarence Carter, Eddie Floyd, Albert King, et al

Tough call for me but I'd probably lean towards Stax. Love Motown but Stax has just a bit more grit and soul to my ear.
Click to expand...
As you stated, the correct answer is (C) Both
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecockcat
rbs

rbs

Active member
May 29, 2001
23,978
41,221
68
Both groups are phenomenal … love the music of both. I would say, the confluence of the Funk Brothers and singing talent and what songs they created out of one location over a period of time is just incredible … to have that talent all located in one spot is providential.
 
C

cole854

New member
Sep 11, 2012
10,156
22,636
0
They each have their time and place...historic icons in each group and the styles were influential in the music of many of today's greats.
 
S

sluggercatfan

New member
Aug 17, 2004
35,953
29,630
0
I know they are white, but the Righteous Brothers have to be in here somewhere...one of a kind!
 
J

JIMFKFT

Active member
Aug 9, 2003
1,643
286
83
I wouldn't want to choose between the two labels. Motown was a hit machine with all the ingredients -- legendary writers like Holland-Dozier-Holland, charismatic performers, and of course the superb studio band, The Funk Brothers. Stax had those great arrangements and a stable of dynamic stars such as Sam & Dave, Otis, Isaac Hayes and The Staples Singers, also with a great studio band in Booker T. & the MGs. It's all good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecockcat
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom