Rate our recruiting class

Sep 15, 2006
12,698
996
0
Fitzgerald was 4-8/2-6 in his first year after taking over when the previous coach suddenly passed away. He was not in a total rebuild mode. In his eighth season, he went 5-7 and 1-7, and went 5-7 in his 9th season.

Haven't seen anything close to that from Ash? I have on defense. Offense has been a **** show for sure, but is that really on him with the players we had left in the skill positions?

Maybe we can wait to see how years 3 and 4 go before declaring Ash a good or a bad game day coach?

Fitz wasn't in a total rebuild mode, but the cupboard was fairly bare, and he was terribly raw as a head coach. The plan had been for Walker to mentor him a few more years and pass the torch to him, but Walker's completely unexpected death put the AD in the difficult position of hiring Fitz a year or two too soon or hiring another guy and taking the chance of Fitz going elsewhere. He chose the former. That turned out to be the right decision, but the first couple of years were rough, indeed. Fitz inherited Walker's defensive coordinator, who was notable for somehow designing a defense that was unable to stop anyone despite two future multi-year NFL players on the defensive line.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
Fitz wasn't in a total rebuild mode, but the cupboard was fairly bare, and he was terribly raw as a head coach. The plan had been for Walker to mentor him a few more years and pass the torch to him, but Walker's completely unexpected death put the AD in the difficult position of hiring Fitz a year or two too soon or hiring another guy and taking the chance of Fitz going elsewhere. He chose the former. That turned out to be the right decision, but the first couple of years were rough, indeed. Fitz inherited Walker's defensive coordinator, who was notable for somehow designing a defense that was unable to stop anyone despite two future multi-year NFL players on the defensive line.

You guys did better than we did with Flood. Maybe he just needed some more years to prove himself.
 

RU old timer

Junior
Feb 26, 2015
594
316
0
There are a ton of “settle for less” members on this Board. 90 per cent loved the Flood hire because he would save the Carroo recruiting class. About the same amount of wisdom as the captain of the Titanic on his fateful voyage.
 

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,171
8,516
113
The best thing one can say about this class is that there are only a few two stars .It kind of reminds me of the 2013 class .
Some of the two stars picked up at the end are under recruited, think Jawaun Harris or Raheem Blackshear. Some are just reaches and are offered to simply fill a class. We see less of those reaches with Ash.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

TheHandOfChaos

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2002
1,406
2,137
113
2

Truth is this is less than a standard deviation above a Flood-esque class.

If we were in the AAC, you can rate it a 7 maybe, but we are at the bottom of the B1G along with northwestern and near the bottom for all p5 schools.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUaMoose_rivals

RUforlife

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2002
3,444
4,218
0
I honestly forget, was Ash supposed to be a great recruiter? If so, I just don't see the evidence. The future under Ash appears to be the Pinstripe bowl, or its equivalent, on an up year and 2-5 wins on average. Which is what it is, as long as people can live with that we should be good.
 

Perricone7

All-Conference
Jan 26, 2015
1,509
2,137
113
It’s interesting to me how this board tends to lean very positive when it comes to recruiting. People were bending over backwards to suggest floods classes were acceptable. “Rutgers guys”.

I understand there is not a drastic difference between 9th and 14th, but why should this fan base be happy about that? This is the state university of New Jersey. I’m tired of trying to sugarcoat low rated classes and hearing “this is a 5-7 year rebuild”. Just do it.
 

RUSK97

All-American
Dec 28, 2007
10,460
6,551
0
2

Truth is this is less than a standard deviation above a Flood-esque class.

If we were in the AAC, you can rate it a 7 maybe, but we are at the bottom of the B1G along with northwestern and near the bottom for all p5 schools.
There are 65 P5 schools. How is our 42nd ranking near the bottom? Bottom of our conference? Yes, can’t argue that.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,745
151,579
113
And that’s all that matters. If we can’t win in our conference, well..

From a recruiting perspective, the delta seems to get wider every year in our division, instead of shrinking.
Our peers are crushing the recruiting game.
 

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,171
8,516
113
There are 65 P5 schools. How is our 42nd ranking near the bottom? Bottom of our conference? Yes, can’t argue that.
According to Rivals we are ranked 56. That's near the bottom. It's not a good class according to all the major recruiting services. That's not to say the class won't outperform it's ranking. Ash's 3 classes (if you count 2016) are not really much of an improvement over Flood if you look at the recruiting rankings of these services. I DO think that the attrition of these classes will be much lower.

Ash is really going to have to show something this year to have a good 2019 class. If he fails to recruit a top 50 class again, I just can't see him being successful.
 

SoCalNYC

Junior
Jan 20, 2018
320
204
0
This is the bottom line. Unfortunately, Ash isn’t Saban, who still needs the studs to compete.

Wisconsin is an anomaly. Football at RU seems like it’s on life support until another coach can be had. Ash just isn’t it. Not at this level.

Many posters have brought up Wisconsin. And this myth never dies.

Once again, they actually do recruit VERY well. There is some very in depth stuff about this online.

In short, the recruiting analysts have no time to analyze/rate 4 star Wisc recruits in the cold brutal and vast Wisc state. The state does recruit 4 star lineman and it shows but they are underrated being in Wisc. and known as 3 stars. I have been in touch with some analysts and that is a the real problem.

Cali, Texas, GA, FL, NJ, DMV do not have this problem with camps and concentrate talent pool.
 

Fzacsattac

Junior
Sep 22, 2013
1,064
254
0
On a scale of 1-10, how do posters rate this class? I'd give it a 7, but would rate it higher if we had picked up more quality DTs and OLs.

This question is very weak and should have been more specific.

You can't look at this as compared to past classes that is the mistake a lot of people do. One class can be better than another but when compared to our league it may be worse.

You can compare it to the rest of the league or our division but even this is not a true indicator. On class may have a lot of studs but maybe that year our league had a banner year in recruiting.

You have to look at this class compared to all the schools in P5 conferences if you want to rank this class. That will give you a true indication of where our recruiting class is.
 
Jul 1, 2010
938
688
0
Say what you want - this class is rated lower on 247 than any Flood class, including the 2014 disaster. Hopefully, the addition of McNulty and Campanile(s) will let CA finally “fence the garden”.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheHandOfChaos

TheHandOfChaos

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2002
1,406
2,137
113
Fence the garden? The gate is open and Ash is using repellent to chase NJ recruits away!

0 of the top 15 in NJ
Only 2 of the top 30. From our home state.....

Worst NJ recruiting results I remember seeing ever since the year 2000
 

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
Pin this thread, so that four/five years from now, when some of these kids' names are being called on NFL draft day, we can look back and see how foolish some of you are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Loyal-Son

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0
Pin this thread, so that four/five years from now, when some of these kids' names are being called on NFL draft day, we can look back and see how foolish some of you are.

Got no problem pinning . But the judgement will be on the colllege record, not draft picks.
 

Panthergrowl13

All-Conference
Nov 11, 2002
13,332
1,718
0
Many posters have brought up Wisconsin. And this myth never dies.

Once again, they actually do recruit VERY well. There is some very in depth stuff about this online.

In short, the recruiting analysts have no time to analyze/rate 4 star Wisc recruits in the cold brutal and vast Wisc state. The state does recruit 4 star lineman and it shows but they are underrated being in Wisc. and known as 3 stars. I have been in touch with some analysts and that is a the real problem.

Cali, Texas, GA, FL, NJ, DMV do not have this problem with camps and concentrate talent pool.


Actually, I agree with your comments with respect to Wisconsin (follow them somewhat since Paul Chryst took over as HC).

Just looking at the Rivals (2018) recruiting ranking for Wisconsin (#38) most people would conclude that they did OK but not great. However, I think they did very well (1-4 star 19-3 star). Most of their 3-star recruits had multiple offers from other P-5 programs. 7 of their 3-star player had a rating of 5.7 ( Rival 4-star players start at 5.8). Wisconsin does a great job in evaluating and developing talent.

HAIL TO PITT!!!!
 

ponyfoot19

Senior
Dec 19, 2007
2,596
509
0
The quality of a recruiting class can't really be determined until they've had three years or so in the program. That said, I think you need to look at what schools 'heavily' recruited the guys that signed with RU? You don't always need to beat out an OSU, but you do need to win at the very least, your fair share of battles with conference mates and those other P5 schools recruiting the same players you are.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
For the naysayers. You know who you are.

December 7, 2015:
"I have a message for fans, supporters, administrators, players, basically anybody that loves this program: We need to create some positive energy around this program. It's going to take an extreme amount of work. It's going to take a lot of the right people going in the same direction."

“We're not going to make a lot of goals that talk about results with winning games and championships. We're going to worry about making goals that make us better tomorrow than we were today. That's all it's going to be about.

“The wins will come. Hopefully championships will come. But that's not my focus. That's not going to be the program's goal, at least early on. It's about getting better every single day.’’

"I want to build a first-class program that the university and the state and the people that live here and support us are happy and proud to say they are part of the Rutgers football program," Ash said.

"That's what I want at the end of the day. If I can do that, the wins will come, a ranking will come, all of those things that everybody wants, and how I'm going to ultimately be measured here will come. But there's a process to get to that."

"I think it's about being yourself, being honest, being straightforward, building a connection and really selling what you're trying to do, what your vision of the program is and what you want to try to accomplish. But it's about the people more so than anything, and the way that we take care of our players."


Nov. 20, 2016:
"I came here with a plan, came here with a vision," Ash said. "You go back to the opening press conference that I had standing right here in this room, I never told anybody it was going to be easy. It's going to be difficult; we've got a lot of challenges that lay ahead, but we'll get there. And I'm not going to make any predictions on when, but we'll be there; I can promise you that."
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,186
90,333
113
Go check out the 2019 team rankings on 247. We are at #36 one spot ahead of Ohio State! :)
Georgia already has 3 five stars and four 4 stars.
Wisconsin has 4 four stars--who is the idiot who keeps saying Wisconsin does not get four stars?

For 2020, Miami has 2 five stars and 3 four stars.
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,481
13,091
113
Georgia already has 3 five stars and four 4 stars.
Wisconsin has 4 four stars--who is the idiot who keeps saying Wisconsin does not get four stars?

For 2020, Miami has 2 five stars and 3 four stars.

The same clowns who say Stars don’t matter in our Recruiting.
 

RUSK97

All-American
Dec 28, 2007
10,460
6,551
0
He made it up because he wanted to up his post numbers! Our class was not ranked that high! Lol
I don't give a rat's *** about my post numbers. I do however acknowledge that the ranking in my post was wrong. I was looking at a pre-final ranking number. Yeah, 42 would've been nothing to complain about, but 57 is not so hot.
 

SoCalNYC

Junior
Jan 20, 2018
320
204
0
Actually, I agree with your comments with respect to Wisconsin (follow them somewhat since Paul Chryst took over as HC).

Just looking at the Rivals (2018) recruiting ranking for Wisconsin (#38) most people would conclude that they did OK but not great. However, I think they did very well (1-4 star 19-3 star). Most of their 3-star recruits had multiple offers from other P-5 programs. 7 of their 3-star player had a rating of 5.7 ( Rival 4-star players start at 5.8). Wisconsin does a great job in evaluating and developing talent.

HAIL TO PITT!!!!

Wisc recruits very well. The myth has to die. Their O-line is no joke and can stand with any elite power. It is all 4 and 5 star lineman...rated as 3stars
 

SC1221

All-Conference
Oct 8, 2007
75,077
3,825
113
Georgia already has 3 five stars and four 4 stars.
Wisconsin has 4 four stars--who is the idiot who keeps saying Wisconsin does not get four stars?

For 2020, Miami has 2 five stars and 3 four stars.
To be fair this is a historic class for Wisconsin so far. They've never recruited this well ever in their history and usually do not have classes in the top 30.
 

SoCalNYC

Junior
Jan 20, 2018
320
204
0
To be fair this is a historic class for Wisconsin so far. They've never recruited this well ever in their history and usually do not have classes in the top 30.

Again: Many posters have brought up Wisconsin. And this myth never dies.

Once again, they actually do recruit VERY well. There is some very in depth stuff about this online.

In short, the recruiting analysts have no time to analyze/rate 4 star Wisc recruits in the cold brutal and vast Wisc state. The state does recruit 4 star lineman and it shows but they are underrated being in Wisc. and known as 3 stars. I have been in touch with some analysts and that is a the real problem. That line has ALWAYS been 5 star and 4 star recruits and hold their own vs the elites. But Wisc does not have skill players and that could change.

Cali, Texas, GA, FL, NJ, DMV do not have this problem with camps and concentrated talent pool. Analysts can easily rate them
 
Last edited:

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
Again: Many posters have brought up Wisconsin. And this myth never dies.

Once again, they actually do recruit VERY well. There is some very in depth stuff about this online.

In short, the recruiting analysts have no time to analyze/rate 4 star Wisc recruits in the cold brutal and vast Wisc state. The state does recruit 4 star lineman and it shows but they are underrated being in Wisc. and known as 3 stars. I have been in touch with some analysts and that is a the real problem. That line has ALWAYS been 5 star and 4 star recruits and hold their own vs the elites. But Wisc does not have skill players and that could change.

Cali, Texas, GA, FL, NJ, DMV do not have this problem with camps and concentrated talent pool. Analysts can easily rate them

I get what you're saying about there being diamond-in-the-rough linemen in WI that the recruiting services don't find... but Wisconsin doesn't recruit a ton of guys from their own state, and few of them are linemen. Of the 108 guys they've gotten in the last 5 years, just 27 were from WI (25%)... and just 15 were linemen (7 OL, 8 DL... and 2 of those OL were already rated four-stars).

2018: 20 guys, 4 from WI... 2 DE
2017: 18 guys, 7 from WI... 3 OL (1 four-star), 1 DT
2016: 25 guys, 4 from WI... 1 DE, 1 DT
2015: 19 guys, 5 from WI... 1 OL, 1 DE
2014: 26 guys, 7 from WI... 3 OL (1 four-star), 2 DE
 

newwavedave1

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2006
3,982
3,522
0
The players coming here, and the new offers, have stated their interest in Rutgers was/is based on them seeing positive things going on with the program. That tells me all I need to know, as they have much more interaction with the coaches and current players than any of the "experts" on this board.
 

RUbacker

Heisman
Dec 5, 2014
16,232
23,249
108
The players coming here, and the new offers, have stated their interest in Rutgers was/is based on them seeing positive things going on with the program. That tells me all I need to know, as they have much more interaction with the coaches and current players than any of the "experts" on this board.
I think the class has more talent than people think. It's not all about stars.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Penn State
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod