Rate our recruiting class

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,189
90,336
113
We know Flood was terrible. Is it supposed to make us feel better that going into year 3 Ash hasn’t done any better with these kids?
I am a reformed Floodie, but was he really terrible, or just put in a position to fail from the beginning?
Guy was being paid peanuts as it was (which was appropriate), but if anything, RU should have ponied up some serious cash for OC and DC. But no, other than Fridge, with what RU was paying and the huge question mark as head coach, RU's assistant pool was not impressive. While not an excuse for his dumb mistakes, one could see why he went to the lengths he did to try to keep Barnwell on the team and was letting drug tests slide. Guy not playing with a full deck to begin with had the deck stacked against him, and the results followed.
OTOH, Ash has been given everything. This year and next it is time to put up or shut up.
 

RUScrew85

Heisman
Nov 7, 2003
30,054
16,939
0
The problem is while we get (slightly) better, our yearly competitors got MUCH better. Yes Ohio State has always and will always be solid, and Michigan is Michigan, but MSU and Maryland have now done really well and PSU is top 5 in the country. We don’t have to be the best, but need to be closer

Not sure they GOT much better or just STAYED much better.
 

Perricone7

All-Conference
Jan 26, 2015
1,509
2,137
113
Oh for goodness freaking sake. Take out Ohio State and I can guarantee you recruiting rankings DO NOT CORRELATE to the B1G Standings. THEY DO NOT. GO CHECK IT. We've gone over this a billion times.

Stars only matter if you want to get to Ohio State's level (or Clemson, Florida State, Alabama, etc).

To get to Wisconsin, Nebraska, Iowa, Michigan State's level, you don't need stars. What you need are players that fit the systems.

Do you really think if we recruited based on stars, we wouldn't have a higher stars ranking? We could if we wanted to. We could have gotten Clement instead of Pacheco. Leary instead of Chatman. We could have gotten one of the MANY 3 star DE from Florida who wanted to come here instead of this no name no star kid from Sweden.

Besides, how much more evidence do you need that Ash can identify talent, stars be damned?

And again, I repeat, our two lowest rated classes, 2010 and 2005 produced the most RU contributors and NFL talent - this isn't opinion, it is FACT. So, stars don't even correlate to results on the field for Rutgers. So, why the hell are you so hung up on stars???

You people hung up on stars really have no clue. No clue at all. It is unbelievable how clueless some of you guys truly are.

If you are going to attack people at least bring accurate facts to the table. The 2010 class produced one NFL player (who was also the highest rated recruit) and a few decent college players. It pales in comparison to 2009 and even 2008.
 

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
If you are going to attack people at least bring accurate facts to the table. The 2010 class produced one NFL player (who was also the highest rated recruit) and a few decent college players. It pales in comparison to 2009 and even 2008.

First of all I said CONTRIBUTORS and NFLrs. Second, Jameson was drafted, so that's 2 NFLers. Third I didn't compare it to just 2008 and 2009 - point was 2010 was a very low rated class but produced players anyway - that's the point. Starters - Deering, Waters, Thompson, Kirksey, Glashen, Milewski, Mera, Bujari and Alexander were all starters from that 2010 class. Compare 2010 to a couple of our highest rated classes in 2011 AND 2012 - did the rankings reflect in terms of how many contributors and NFLrs came from those classes compared to 2010? 2012 was a top 25 class. And lastly, nice of you to omit 2005.
 

RUich

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2001
13,552
4,003
0
Other than those who think that the star system is bogus, we are next to last in the league. More importantly, we are way down the food chain in the BIG East and that means continued dominance by them. Cannot see us really being anything but a pretender until, and if, we can significantly upgrade our recruiting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Caliknight

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
Since 2002, Rutgers 4 and 5 star recruits:

Randi Boxill
Ron Green
Berkeley Hutchinson
William Beckford
Nate Robinson - Remember Nate and the "excitement" he cause the fanbase?!
Dwayne Jones
Jerome Messam
Kenny Britt
Kordell Young
Anthony Davis
Mason Robinson
Manny Abreu
Keith Stroudt
Scott Vallone
Isaac Homes
De'Antwan "ROCKET" Williams - oh yes, the famous ROCKET!!!
Logan Ryan
Tom Savage
Brandon Coleman

Rashad Knight
Marquis Wright
Savon Huggins
Miles Shuler
Dywany Mera
Darius Hamilton
JJ Denman
Chris Muller
Leonte Carroo
Quanzell Lambert
Nadir Barnwell
Marquis Ford

Tyshon Fogg
Micah Clark
Bo Melton
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,189
90,336
113
Since 2002, Rutgers 4 and 5 star recruits:

Randi Boxill
Ron Green
Berkeley Hutchinson
William Beckford
Nate Robinson - Remember Nate and the "excitement" he cause the fanbase?!
Dwayne Jones
Jerome Messam
Kenny Britt
Kordell Young
Anthony Davis
Mason Robinson
Manny Abreu
Keith Stroudt
Scott Vallone
Isaac Homes
De'Antwan "ROCKET" Williams - oh yes, the famous ROCKET!!!
Logan Ryan
Tom Savage
Brandon Coleman

Rashad Knight
Marquis Wright
Savon Huggins
Miles Shuler
Dywany Mera
Darius Hamilton
JJ Denman
Chris Muller
Leonte Carroo
Quanzell Lambert
Nadir Barnwell
Marquis Ford

Tyshon Fogg
Micah Clark
Bo Melton

Is there a point? Players not in bold are what?
 

Panthergrowl13

All-Conference
Nov 11, 2002
13,332
1,718
0
Interesting discussion and I will side more with RU2055.

There is no question that if a team recruits a majority of Rivals 5/4 Star players your odds of winning increase significantly.

However, most programs cannot recruit like Ohio State, Alabama, Florida State etc.

Wisconsin is a good example of a program that Rutgers (Pitt included) need to emulate.

Wisconsin went 13-1 this year but they only finished recruiting ranked #38. Wisconsin does not recruit particularly well but will field a competitive team capable of playing with anyone. Why because they have a good HC/staff, can evaluate talent and have a great player development program.

Will Ash be the Paul Chryst of Wisconsin.

Jury is still out.

HAIL TO PITT!!!!
 

shu2x79

Sophomore
Apr 28, 2006
870
120
43
The problem appears to me to be that while this years class is okay, the differential between RU and the rest of the Big Ten East is glaring. The rest of the East has 60 or so 5 and 4 star recruits and RU has none. It will take a great deal of coaching to overcome that disparity.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,189
90,336
113
The problem appears to me to be that while this years class is okay, the differential between RU and the rest of the Big Ten East is glaring. The rest of the East has 60 or so 5 and 4 star recruits and RU has none. It will take a great deal of coaching to overcome that disparity.
Are we playing the rest of the B1G East all at once?
Let's not get carried away. 40% of those 4-5 stars are at Ohio State. 30% are at Penn State.
Nebraska has 9, and Michigan 7, adding up to another 26%. I am assuming your numbers are right. That is 96% of the recruits.
To paint such a negative picture comparing our 4-5 star recruiting numbers against the entire B1G East is not a realistic picture.

Again, Wisconsin and NW each have 1 4 star recruit, and they compete well, yes in the West, but Wisconsin has competed against the B1G East elite.

This is not going to be an overnight sensation. Maybe in 3-5 more years, we will be able to at least look competitive against the elites, and sometimes pull an upset.

Will repeat. RU is not, and will likely never be elite. We are not a blue blood. We play in a small stadium in the Northeast where people don't care about college football the way they do in Columbus, Ann Arbor and State College. We will not compete for the CFP on an annual basis. 4 and 5 star players want to play for those kinds of teams. And the ones from NJ seem to want to leave this state.
 
  • Like
Reactions: drewbagel423

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,189
90,336
113
Last edited:

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
Not sure they GOT much better or just STAYED much better.

Several of them improved their recruiting rankings in that time.

The 4 year recruiting class averages for our division (Rivals) for 2014 when we entered the B1G through 2018:
OSU... 5, 5, 4, 4, 4
Michigan... 16, 23, 22, 22, 12
PA St... 39, 34, 26, 18, 16
MSU... 34, 31, 26, 24, 27
Maryland... 41, 44, 45, 41, 30
Rutgers... 40, 45, 58, 58, 56
Indiana... 51, 48, 45, 51, 57

OSU has remained at the top.
Michigan dropped for a few years but has had Top 5 classes the last two years.
PA St climbed out of its sanctions hole with Franklin
MSU improved incrementally
Maryland improved, and has Top 30 classes the last two years
Rutgers regressed
Indiana showed slight improvement, then regressed

When we entered in 2014, our 4-year average recruiting rank was 40th in a fairly tight middle grouping in the division with MSU (34), PA St (39), and Maryland (41)... with our two best classes (2011-12) as upperclassmen.

But the writing was already on the wall, as the 2014 class was just 57th... even as we had entrance into the B1G to sell to recruits. In 2015, we were just 53rd coming off an (8-5) season in our first B1G year with a win over Michigan and rout of UNC in the bowl game.

While Flood was losing ground nationally with recruits, those other three programs were gaining ground. By 2016 when Ash was hired, our 4-year average had slipped to 58th.... while PA St and Michigan had both risen to 26th, and Maryland was still treading water at 45th.

Two years later, and Ash hasn't really moved the needle, still sitting at a 4-year average of 56th. Those schools that had been in the 34-41 range are now 25+ ranks ahead of us... PA St (16th), MSU (27th), Maryland (30th)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: RU old timer

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
This is kind of interesting. If I get time I will compare it with recruiting rankings and see how it matches.


Interesting. Only has P5 teams, though - would be interested to see a true survey that included G5 schools, too.

Looking at current B1G:
2 - OSU
3 - PA St
11 - MSU
16 - Wisconsin
17 - Michigan
21 - Nebraska
39 - Iowa
41 - Maryland
44 - Purdue
45 - Northwestern
51 - Minnesota
57 - Indiana
58 - Rutgers
62 - illinois

A little surprised that Michigan fell out after both Michigan State and Wisconsin.

Also interesting looking at the pre-realignment Big East conference:
7 - Miami
28 - WVU
33 - VTech
54 - Pittsburgh
58 - Rutgers
61 - Syracuse
64 - Boston College
 

SoCalNYC

Junior
Jan 20, 2018
320
204
0
This is a ridiculous survey. I'm not believing any poll that has Bama at #19 for Pete's sake. Kansas State 3rd to last? No way. All sorts of problems with this table.

AMEN. LOL at any survey that has Bama at 19. Get lost with that survey. MSU Wisconsin and UCLA over Bama? LOL

The usual recruiting powers over decades are Bama, USC, OSU, Texas, Florida etc. The sample size is larger and titans of the game.
 
Last edited:

SoCalNYC

Junior
Jan 20, 2018
320
204
0
Also people who follow recruiting know that its best to average a couple of classes to get a sense of the real recruiting prowess/trending. One class is NOT enough.

Franklin, MSU and MD have gotten clumps of 4 stars and highly rated 3 stars recently. According to 247, Franklin has done the average of 15th and 5th. And MSU both are in the 20-25th range in average IIRC.

All rising since 4 years ago.
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,481
13,091
113
Are we playing the rest of the B1G East all at once?
Will repeat. RU is not, and will likely never be elite. We are not a blue blood. We play in a small stadium in the Northeast where people don't care about college football the way they do in Columbus, Ann Arbor and State College. We will not compete for the CFP on an annual basis. 4 and 5 star players want to play for those kinds of teams. And the ones from NJ seem to want to leave this state.

Nobody is asking that Rutgers become an Elite or blue blood program.
However is expecting that we get 3 or 4 Four Star Recruits each Year from our Home State too much to ask ?
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,189
90,336
113
Nobody is asking that Rutgers become an Elite or blue blood program.
However is expecting that we get 3 or 4 Four Star Recruits each Year from our Home State too much to ask ?
As noted above we got from the 247 Ranking of NJ recruits, we got #8, #9 and #17 in NJ. That's 2 top 10's and one top 20. Unfortunately, NJ was not stacked with 4 and 5 star talent this year. Robinson is a 4* according to 247. We had no shot at the top 7.
Setting goals is great, but when the goal is not attainable because the pool is not full of 4 star players, not sure it is productive to complain and wring hands over the result.
 

RUaMoose_rivals

All-American
Oct 31, 2004
17,240
7,062
113
Have a question for all those clamoring that our classes are not on par with PSU, Michigan, tOSU and MSU--what concrete steps does Ash need to take to be a "better recruiter" to convince the top kids that coming to Rutgers is a better option than the aforementioned schools, along with all of the other schools that take the top recruits from New Jersey.

We have been down this road many times before. Would say the large majority of to recruits want to:
1. Leave NJ
2. Play for a storied program
3. Play for a CFP contender.

Once you realize that Ash (or nobody else) can fix those things, the crying game gets old.

No one's suggesting we need to recruit on par with OSU, Michigan or PSU. But I don't think it's asking too much to be there with Iowa, Minnesota and Maryland. No reason we can't be on par with those schools, imo. At the end of the day, recruiting is a sales job. He needs to sell these guys on the future like Schiano and Graber (early on) did but he's come up short so far, big time. Maybe that's because he has no vision other than to say "we're going to work hard and get better everyday"..
 

KnightsofChrome

All-Conference
Sep 20, 2012
3,829
1,076
0
Some posters need a dose of reality. Our classes will never match Ohio State, Penn State, or Michigan. Compete with the rest of the conference, and we may be able to catch lightning in a bottle occasionally.
"Never" now that's a load of crap! That's a word losers use. With the amount of talent that New Jersey has had over the years, and how NJ has supplemented many of these programs, there is NO reason to make stupid statements like this! What's missing is a solid program, coaching, money, and a few winning years. My "reality" may not be set in stone, but I'll be dammed if I roll over for anybody! As apparently, you have.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,189
90,336
113
No one's suggesting we need to recruit on par with OSU, Michigan or PSU. But I don't think it's asking too much to be there with Iowa, Minnesota and Maryland. No reason we can't be on par with those schools, imo. At the end of the day, recruiting is a sales job. He needs to sell these guys on the future like Schiano and Graber (early on) did but he's come up short so far, big time. Maybe that's because he has no vision other than to say "we're going to work hard and get better everyday"..
Putting Maryland aside, because for some reason, kids from Maryland and DC seem to not want to leave NJ, RU is "there" with Iowa and Minnesota.

Looking at the 247 analysis (I don't get hung up on "ranking", I look at the raw numbers, as there is an infinitesimal difference from 8-14):
Iowa: total 23, Zero 4 and 5 stars, 21 3 stars-- average 85.55
RU: total 21, Zero 4 and 5 stars, 20 3 stars, average 84.37
Minnesota: total 26, three 4 stars, 23 3 stars, average 86.17

Minnesota did a bit better than RU, but they had a larger class. As pointed out above, RU got the #8 and #9 kids from NJ according to 247. Unfortunately, there was not a bumper crop of 4 star players in 2018.

This thread keeps going on an on like arguments in the CE board. Some folks want to use the numerical "rank" to claim Rutgers class is not good. But when there is little true separation in the second half of teams in the B1G, I don't see the point of crying about a "ranking."
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
No. Too many whiny fans on this board who are looking at a numerical rank without realizing there is little separation among 8-14.

At least according to Rivals points, there are:
3192 - OSU
2712 - PA St
1872 - Nebraska
1700-1730 - Michigan, Michigan St, Maryland
1550-1590 - Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa
1400-1490 - Indiana, Purdue, Illinois
1250-1260 - Rutgers, Northwestern

If you're going for "little separation", it's really between 7-12, not 8-14, at least according to Rivals. There is just 181 points separating 7 and 12.... but 149 separating 12 and 13.

There's a top tier (OSU, PA St, Nebraska), a second tier (Michigan, Michigan St, Maryland), a third tier (Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, Indiana, Purdue, Illinois), and a fourth tier (Rutgers, Northwestern).
 
  • Like
Reactions: kcg88

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,189
90,336
113
At least according to Rivals points, there are:
3192 - OSU
2712 - PA St
1872 - Nebraska
1700-1730 - Michigan, Michigan St, Maryland
1550-1590 - Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa
1400-1490 - Indiana, Purdue, Illinois
1250-1260 - Rutgers, Northwestern

If you're going for "little separation", it's really between 7-12, not 8-14, at least according to Rivals. There is just 181 points separating 7 and 12.... but 149 separating 12 and 13.

There's a top tier (OSU, PA St, Nebraska), a second tier (Michigan, Michigan St, Maryland), a third tier (Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, Indiana, Purdue, Illinois), and a fourth tier (Rutgers, Northwestern).
Rivals does not make sense because it does not factor in Northwestern's low number of recruits. That would put is in the basement all alone. [roll]

Maybe I am off base on this, but 247's ratings seem to be more granular and accurate.

We are also getting dinged for having a kicker in the class.
Rivals has Abraham as a 2-star, while 247 has him as a 3 star.
Rivals has Izien as a 2-star and he is a 3-star on 247.
Same for Jennings and Kromah.

So, who is more accurate, Rivals or 247?
 

RUforlife

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2002
3,444
4,218
0
. . . .

There's a top tier (OSU, PA St, Nebraska), a second tier (Michigan, Michigan St, Maryland), a third tier (Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, Indiana, Purdue, Illinois), and a fourth tier (Rutgers, Northwestern).
I would be of the same opinion as some on this board that recruiting ratings don't matter if we had Pat Fitzgerald as our HC. There is a guy with a proven track record of getting the most out of his players on a consistent basis. To be honest, I haven't seen any thing close to that from Ash, and that is what is truly concerning. If you are not going to get the most talented recruits, you better have great coaching, otherwise, you are doomed to mediocrity on the field at best.
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
Rivals does not make sense because it does not factor in Northwestern's low number of recruits. That would put is in the basement all alone. [roll]

Maybe I am off base on this, but 247's ratings seem to be more granular and accurate.

We are also getting dinged for having a kicker in the class.
Rivals has Abraham as a 2-star, while 247 has him as a 3 star.
Rivals has Izien as a 2-star and he is a 3-star on 247.
Same for Jennings and Kromah.

So, who is more accurate, Rivals or 247?

Well, an argument can be made that number of recruits also matters - because you'll always have attrition and just percentages of how many players work out, etc.

But if you want to go with 247, there are two clear top programs (OSU, PA St), two second tier programs (Michigan, Nebraska)... then a steady dropoff from 5-10 (dropping about 5-7 points per rank), and a slightly flatter dropoff from 10-14 (dropping about 2-4 points per rank). It's not that there's "little separation" per se, but there aren't as clearly defined tiers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,189
90,336
113
I would be of the same opinion as some on this board that recruiting ratings don't matter if we had Pat Fitzgerald as our HC. There is a guy with a proven track record of getting the most out of his players on a consistent basis. To be honest, I haven't seen any thing close to that from Ash, and that is what is truly concerning. If you are not going to get the most talented recruits, you better have great coaching, otherwise, you are doomed to mediocrity on the field at best.
Fitzgerald was 4-8/2-6 in his first year after taking over when the previous coach suddenly passed away. He was not in a total rebuild mode. In his eighth season, he went 5-7 and 1-7, and went 5-7 in his 9th season.

Haven't seen anything close to that from Ash? I have on defense. Offense has been a **** show for sure, but is that really on him with the players we had left in the skill positions?

Maybe we can wait to see how years 3 and 4 go before declaring Ash a good or a bad game day coach?
 

Panthergrowl13

All-Conference
Nov 11, 2002
13,332
1,718
0
AMEN. LOL at any survey that has Bama at 19. Get lost with that survey. MSU Wisconsin and UCLA over Bama? LOL

The usual recruiting powers over decades are Bama, USC, OSU, Texas, Florida etc. The sample size is larger and titans of the game.


I also don't think this perception survey has much merit/value based on the comments of 224 recruits.

Pitt perception #54 while Pitt Rivals recruiting ranking #36.

HAIL TO PITT!!!!
 

RUforlife

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2002
3,444
4,218
0
Fitzgerald was 4-8/2-6 in his first year after taking over when the previous coach suddenly passed away. He was not in a total rebuild mode. In his eighth season, he went 5-7 and 1-7, and went 5-7 in his 9th season.

Haven't seen anything close to that from Ash? I have on defense. Offense has been a **** show for sure, but is that really on him with the players we had left in the skill positions?

Maybe we can wait to see how years 3 and 4 go before declaring Ash a good or a bad game day coach?
Don't worry, I don't make the personnel decisions so you will get at least three more years of Mr.Ash. Sorry, but I haven't seen anything to give me confidence that Mr. Ash is the right man for the job, from recruiting, to running a staff, to game day coaching,I haven't been impressed. But again, just my humble opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

REDRICH65

All-Conference
Aug 9, 2010
2,772
2,183
113
Still not good enough to win minimum of 6/7 games several years in a row while in B1G East. Have to get used to being mediocre, at best, for quite a while.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,749
151,581
113
The problem appears to me to be that while this years class is okay, the differential between RU and the rest of the Big Ten East is glaring. The rest of the East has 60 or so 5 and 4 star recruits and RU has none. It will take a great deal of coaching to overcome that disparity.

This is the bottom line. Unfortunately, Ash isn’t Saban, who still needs the studs to compete.

Wisconsin is an anomaly. Football at RU seems like it’s on life support until another coach can be had. Ash just isn’t it. Not at this level.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball routs Delaware State after slow quarter for historic start
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Penn State
  5. 05 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central