Should Mitch be fired if Stoops fails?

Should Mitch Barnhardt be fired if Stoops fails?


  • Total voters
    0

KumarCat

Junior
Nov 10, 2011
1,823
240
0
So - with all the new facility upgrades and pay raises for coaches, is Mitch doing everything he can to ensure a winning program?

I would argue until I'm blue that he is.

And you'd be wrong. If he had done the facilities 5 years ago like he should have, we wouldn't be here now. He destroyed the football program single handedly.
 

KumarCat

Junior
Nov 10, 2011
1,823
240
0
I'll break it down for you. Through the course of UK fball history there hasn't been many ADs who have hired a winning FB coach. I thought my point was clear.....hope that cleans it up for you.

Which still doesn't answer my point. Previous failure is not an excuse for future failure. If you can't build a football program, then don't take the million dollar salary that goes with it. Million dollar jobs don't get to use excuses. Win or get the hell out of the way.
 

martycat1

Junior
Feb 3, 2010
2,379
228
0
I have read some comments in which Mitch is doing well with the Olympic sports. Where are the banners considering how many Olympic sports team UK has? unless somebody added cheerleading.
 

Shavers48

All-Conference
Sep 2, 2011
2,919
1,345
0
Why - some of our fans think he had nothing to do with hiring Stoops. If he doesn't get credit for hiring Stoops (just like he doesn't get credit for Calipari) then he shouldn't be responsible for the fall out.

Also - name one AD who has hired a successful football coach at KY. (I can name one - Mitch Barnhart's hiring of Rich Brooks).
Brooks a success?? good one. never had a winning record in conference.
 

LowCountryCat

Heisman
Apr 17, 2010
117,188
22,769
0
Why - some of our fans think he had nothing to do with hiring Stoops. If he doesn't get credit for hiring Stoops (just like he doesn't get credit for Calipari) then he shouldn't be responsible for the fall out.

Also - name one AD who has hired a successful football coach at KY. (I can name one - Mitch Barnhart's hiring of Rich Brooks).
There it is - calling Brooks a success. Culture of mediocrity.
 

tntuk

Heisman
Jan 17, 2002
11,470
10,905
113
Brooks a success?? good one. never had a winning record in conference.
Do you call Claiborne, Mumme, Morris a success like Kumar?

Also name one UK coach that took UK to 4 straight bowls? Rich Brooks.
 

LowCountryCat

Heisman
Apr 17, 2010
117,188
22,769
0
Do you call Claiborne, Mumme, Morris a success like Kumar?

Also name one UK coach that took UK to 4 straight bowls? Rich Brooks.
Old, hackneyed argument. Bowls had just inflated like the dollar, there are dozens of them now, any 6-6 rinkydink team can go to a bowl.

The SEC record is a much more accurate measure.
 

tntuk

Heisman
Jan 17, 2002
11,470
10,905
113
There it is - calling Brooks a success. Culture of mediocrity.
Ignore 4 straight bowls his last 4 years....his first three years were rough. No doubt. But he left on a high note at UK (winning season). Most coaches leave this program involuntarily, right?
 

STUCKNBIG10

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2006
7,302
2,861
0
Just stop right there, you're not doing well. Nobody here cares one whit about those sports.

Well, you're not the ruler of the message board, so I'll post as a I please.

With that said, if you read my whole post, I said that football is by far the most important part of an athletic department. I was just disputing WC's claim that Barnhart is pretty much average by all measurements.
 

tntuk

Heisman
Jan 17, 2002
11,470
10,905
113
Old, hackneyed argument. Bowls had just inflated like the dollar, there are dozens of them now, any 6-6 rinkydink team can go to a bowl.

The SEC record is a much more accurate measure.
"Old hackneyed argument"? Really? So you're telling me you'd rather have joker, Stoops, Claiborne, etc, than Brooks?

I'd take Brooks right now in a heart beat. His team's played hard, played with heart, and his players improved individually from their freshman year to their senior year.
 

Fresh Start

Heisman
Sep 13, 2015
12,020
30,134
113
"Old hackneyed argument"? Really? So you're telling me you'd rather have joker, Stoops, Claiborne, etc, than Brooks?

I'd take Brooks right now in a heart beat. His team's played hard, played with heart, and his players improved individually from their freshman year to their senior year.

And in year 3, everyone and I mean everyone wanted him ran out of town. Mark Story waged a personal war against the "Oregon Boys" as he called them. After all, UK should aspire to rise to Oregon's level or anything.
 

Fresh Start

Heisman
Sep 13, 2015
12,020
30,134
113
Barnhart was also roundly criticized for not giving Guy Morriss a multi million dollar deal to match Baylor. Where is Guy these days? Which high school is it?
 

Shavers48

All-Conference
Sep 2, 2011
2,919
1,345
0
Do you call Claiborne, Mumme, Morris a success like Kumar?

Also name one UK coach that took UK to 4 straight bowls? Rich Brooks.
2/3 of all teams make
bowls now because there are so many of them. Brooks, who I like but was so past his prime here, benefitted from dumbing down the schedule coupled with so many new bowls created and a fan base that travels. this is not how I define success. you are free to define it however you like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KumarCat

Jay Mc

Freshman
Feb 5, 2003
1,273
90
0
I am not a huge Barnhart guy, but I don't agree with this analysis. Mitch has built an excellent all-around athletic department. We used to have basketball and not much else. We now have a great women's basketball team, a great volleyball team, soccer, tennis, and so forth. In fact, he probably has the better overall athletic program within the state even though Jurich is the more lauded of the two guys. Also, he did hire Calipari. There are always rumors that it wasn't his call, but he pulled the trigger so he has to be given credit even if it wasn't his call.

My problem with Mitch will be that he has failed to fix football. Brooks was a solid hire, but not spectacular. Joker was a disaster. Stoops is incomplete, but he has nothing to show except better-than-usual recruiting to this point. In the end, football trumps all else so if Stoops fails, then Mitch is on the hot seat.

MB was fortunate to take the AD job at the same time the SEC network came online. That contract has generated millions to the UKAA ($31.2 mm in 2015), which he has used to hire coaches and improve facilities. I know it's impossible to analyze, but imagine for a moment what he would have accomplished with zero SEC network $, as CM Newton was forced to do.
 
Last edited:

Fresh Start

Heisman
Sep 13, 2015
12,020
30,134
113
MB was fortunate to take the AD job at the same time the SEC network came online. That contract has generated millions to the UKAA, which he has used to hire coaches and improve facilities. I know it's impossible to analyze, but imagine for a moment what he would have accomplished with zero SEC network $, as CM Newton was forced to do.

The football program was gutted by scandal during CM's reign.
 

Shavers48

All-Conference
Sep 2, 2011
2,919
1,345
0
Barnhart was also roundly criticized for not giving Guy Morriss a multi million dollar deal to match Baylor. Where is Guy these days? Which high school is it?
Barnhart wanted to put his stamp on things. well, he sure has. Here for nearly 15 years and he still hasn't had a coach produce as good a record as Guy did his last season.
 

Fresh Start

Heisman
Sep 13, 2015
12,020
30,134
113
Barnhart wanted to put his stamp on things. well, he sure has. Here for nearly 15 years and he still hasn't had a coach produce as good a record as Guy did his last season.

You talking about his last year at UK or when he went back to high school? Surely you are not arguing that he should have paid the ransom for Morris
 

Shavers48

All-Conference
Sep 2, 2011
2,919
1,345
0
You talking about his last year at UK or when he went back to high school? Surely you are not arguing that he should have paid the ransom for Morris
im arguing Barnhard doesn't know what the hell he's doing.
 

tntuk

Heisman
Jan 17, 2002
11,470
10,905
113
Do you think Shane Boyd improved under Brooks. How about 4 star receiver John Logan?
Lol. Pick two players out of hundreds that played for Brooks. C'mon - if you don't think Brooks developed players then I don't really know what to tell ya.
 

tntuk

Heisman
Jan 17, 2002
11,470
10,905
113
Barnhart wanted to put his stamp on things. well, he sure has. Here for nearly 15 years and he still hasn't had a coach produce as good a record as Guy did his last season.
Uh - Brooks was 8-5 twice. Morris was 7-5.
 

LowCountryCat

Heisman
Apr 17, 2010
117,188
22,769
0
"Old hackneyed argument"? Really? So you're telling me you'd rather have joker, Stoops, Claiborne, etc, than Brooks?

I'd take Brooks right now in a heart beat. His team's played hard, played with heart, and his players improved individually from their freshman year to their senior year.
Straw man. Brooks was a good coach but he wasn't 'great.' Try reading for comprehension.
 

rmattox

All-Conference
Nov 26, 2014
6,786
4,006
0
Reality....Brooks was the best coach we've had since Blanton Collier. Disagree if you want...it's okay if you insist on being wrong.
 

fabcat

Heisman
Apr 16, 2007
24,189
39,051
113
Brooks was really good. He also surrounded himself with really good coaches. Wished he had the facility upgrades they have now and coach Marrow on his staff. No telling where this program would have gone under him. He was tough as nails and his teams played like it.
 

vhcat70

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
57,418
38,482
0
I am not a huge Barnhart guy, but I don't agree with this analysis. Mitch has built an excellent all-around athletic department.
This is nonsense. The #1 by far revenue generating sport is a turd. The rest is window dressing. It's no wonder he's considered a top AD by others - his football program is no threat to anyone.
 

BlueRaider22

All-American
Sep 24, 2003
15,562
9,058
0
Mitch has done a very good job with just about all aspects of the athletic department.......except for football.

A few notes though:
-Before Brooks, UK was not a "mediocre program." Mediocre implies in the middle or average......basically .500. Since the Bryant era ended UK had won about 4 games a yr on average........that's below mediocre. Brooks winning 7 games a yr.....regardless of how he got the wins was an improvement.
-Sure, the Joker HCIW concept was a bad decision......but Mitch seemed to take care of that in fair time.
-Just about everyone liked the Stoops hire when it was announced. At the time, UK landed a "name" coach who was one of the hottest coordinators in college football. If it doesn't work out, I won't hold it much against Mitch if he handles it well from here on out.
 

J. Shellacque

Junior
Aug 30, 2009
11,348
263
0
On the brink of another UK football fan revolt news is coming out about changes. It's not official yet, but is being heard behind the scenes that current University of Kentucky athletics director Mitch Barnhart is soon to announce to the wildcat faithful that a new state of the art Curling rink is in the works. The location is still undecided, however it has also been leaked that it will be located adjacent to two other fantastic campus additions. The new Table Tennis and Rhythmic gymnastics forums. Nose plugs are apparently expensive so the synchronized swimming team is on hold.
 

LowCountryCat

Heisman
Apr 17, 2010
117,188
22,769
0
On the brink of another UK football fan revolt news is coming out about changes. It's not official yet, but is being heard behind the scenes that current University of Kentucky athletics director Mitch Barnhart is soon to announce to the wildcat faithful that a new state of the art Curling rink is in the works. The location is still undecided, however it has also been leaked that it will be located adjacent to two other fantastic campus additions. The new Table Tennis and Rhythmic gymnastics forums. Nose plugs are apparently expensive so the synchronized swimming team is on hold.
I only watch women's curling. And women's volleyball, although I can't figure out why. Can I score some tickets?
 

LowCountryCat

Heisman
Apr 17, 2010
117,188
22,769
0
Reality....Brooks was the best coach we've had since Blanton Collier. Disagree if you want...it's okay if you insist on being wrong.
Nobody's disagreeing with that, but that doesn't make him 'great.' He never did better than 4-4 in the SEC, and only did that once.
 

Shavers48

All-Conference
Sep 2, 2011
2,919
1,345
0
On the brink of another UK football fan revolt news is coming out about changes. It's not official yet, but is being heard behind the scenes that current University of Kentucky athletics director Mitch Barnhart is soon to announce to the wildcat faithful that a new state of the art Curling rink is in the works. The location is still undecided, however it has also been leaked that it will be located adjacent to two other fantastic campus additions. The new Table Tennis and Rhythmic gymnastics forums. Nose plugs are apparently expensive so the synchronized swimming team is on hold.
there goes the rest of the blue lot.