I agree on Seinfeld. The only drama that I have watched several times, and it isn't really a TV series, is Band of Brothers.
I'm the same way. Shows I loved like Justified and The Americans i just can't restart, again. Even Criminal Minds that you didn't necessarily have to watch in order or you'd miss a major plot twist, I used to watch some reruns, just can't do it. I did watch The Punisher on Netflix twice, but it was only 2 seasons and they are small seasons.
Seinfeld is pretty much the only TV show I'll re-watch over and over, again.