Over-performed? How so? We were like 5 or 6 in the conference and made a sw16. Was the sw16 an improvement over the last few years...sure! But that really doesn't equal over-performing. We also only beat teams that were seeded lower than us, so we certainly didn't overperform our seeding.
Gutted? Everyone basically has to build a new team annually now, so that really isn't a solid excuse anymore. Not to mention the financial resources he has been given to do so.
We have had several games now under Pope that the team has lacked energy, effort and underwhelmed. I get injuries may cause losses, but they shouldn't limit effort or energy by the healthy players.
I also think Pope tends to underperform in the games we are favored. Last year, early in the season when people were underestimating us, he did well. However, later in the year, as we were viewed more highly, we tended to get tight and lose more often. Injuries are certainly a, or even the, possible factor, but that's been a pattern in Pope's coaching career. So I tend to view it as more of a coaching issue.
I like Pope. Obviously a very nice, relatively young guy. Has a nice and beautiful family. Fans seem to adore him and he seems to respect them. He has a lot of positives and I hope he ends up doing very we'll here and proving me wrong. But I do think there are obvious criticisms and I certainly think it's fair to acknowledge them.