Strong could have succeeded at Texas (I still think he might, getting rid of Watson was a GREAT first step). He just picked the worst possible time to take the job. He's a Southern guy who took over a Texas program that hasn't been good for years and he takes over at a time where TCU, A&M and Baylor all have top 10 programs and head coaches that have been in place a while and have been VERY successful. There's already established relationships between these coaches and the local high schools and Charlie is an outsider to them to boot. He's from SEC country.
I still really hope Charlie gets Texas back to their elite status and I don't blame him for taking the job. Texas is the biggest and best job in college football. Charlie is probably slowly learning that the grass isn't always greener on the other side. He was set up beautifully to come in and really battle with FSU and Clemson as the elite top dogs of the ACC. He has his recruiting bases down, his relationships in place, he had the Sugar Bowl success, the NFL Draft success...and he did all of that without the benefit of being in the ACC. His success would have drastically increased by being in the ACC.
I'm extremely happy and feel very fortunate to have gotten Petrino back once Strong left. He was my first choice and I never wavered on that thought...and he's actually recruited better and done better than I thought he would in the short time he's been here. But had Strong never left...there's no doubt that UL would be a top 15 team. There's a lot of things about Strong that I disliked..he never seemed to have a mean streak, he never seemed to like to have fun or let the players have fun...his play calling was ALWAYS conservative...and weirdly, Petrino is the complete opposite in all of those aspects. He embraces the weird uniforms, he tries to curb stomp opponents, his playcalling is typically aggressive...
We're lucky to have Petrino and I really, honestly wish all the best in the world to Charlie Strong and I hope he brings Texas back to elite status but I'm starting to have my doubts.