Tom Brady

LakeCtyNewt

All-Conference
Nov 13, 2002
8,149
4,612
63
He’s been to more conference title games than the Bears have as an organization. Crazy.
 

LTHSALUM76

All-Conference
Aug 27, 2014
2,509
1,955
0
To me, Brady is the best QB ever and I think that science has been settled for a while. To have done it over and over with an ever changing cast is really something special. Don't forget, the Patriots went through the playoffs and won the Super Bowl last year without Gronkowski.

Quickly, name all of the superstar receivers Brady has had during his run. Hard to do isn't it? Name all the superstar RBs they have had. You can look at every great QB and it won't take you very long to think of a great receiver or more who he worked with. Brady wins with a little better than average talent and an outstanding coach and system. But, not any QB could walk in there and do it. Brady is special. Four SB MVP awards and he is the front runner for MVP of the 2017 season as well. He has won two of those.

I can't say enough about the guy and that organization. Brady is going to be playing in his 8th Super Bowl which is insane. He is 5-2 so far. If consistency is the key, Brady's numbers as a QB are very close, whether it is during the season, the playoffs or the SB.

Until someone proves to me that they can beat the Pats, I am picking them again to win the Super Bowl...Gronkowski, or no Gronkowski.
 

LTHSALUM76

All-Conference
Aug 27, 2014
2,509
1,955
0
As great as the New England offense is, and it is the best in the NFL, their defense often gets overlooked. They gave up an average of about 17 points a game during the season. Jacksonville scored an average of 28 points per game. And, the Pats shut them down in the second half yesterday limiting them to two field goals. An interesting note. The Pats defense has averaged giving up 17 points in two playoff games. Consistency.

All four teams that participated in the championship games this past week end have defenses that gave up less than 300 points during the regular season.
 

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,173
2,437
93
Agreed. Brady is great. Best ever? Not so sure. Having the greatest coach and football mastermind of all time definitely helps. I sometimes wonder how Brady would have done in the days of Elway and Montana when Quarterbacks actually got hit.

I wonder how Elway and Montana would have been during the days of leather helmets.
 

greatgig13

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2014
2,369
2,754
0
To me, Brady is the best QB ever and I think that science has been settled for a while. To have done it over and over with an ever changing cast is really something special. Don't forget, the Patriots went through the playoffs and won the Super Bowl last year without Gronkowski.

Quickly, name all of the superstar receivers Brady has had during his run. Hard to do isn't it? Name all the superstar RBs they have had. You can look at every great QB and it won't take you very long to think of a great receiver or more who he worked with. Brady wins with a little better than average talent and an outstanding coach and system. But, not any QB could walk in there and do it. Brady is special. Four SB MVP awards and he is the front runner for MVP of the 2017 season as well. He has won two of those.

I can't say enough about the guy and that organization. Brady is going to be playing in his 8th Super Bowl which is insane. He is 5-2 so far. If consistency is the key, Brady's numbers as a QB are very close, whether it is during the season, the playoffs or the SB.

Until someone proves to me that they can beat the Pats, I am picking them again to win the Super Bowl...Gronkowski, or no Gronkowski.
The offense is a machine and players going down is like replacing parts. It's the system. And does Brady work without Belichick and does Belichick work without Brady? Who knows. I do know it's fun as hell to watch.
 

vinuci31

Redshirt
Nov 28, 2009
65
34
0
Absolutely no doubting Brady's ability and accomplishments as a QB. However, how much of this is attributed to system, system, system?
 

Oddy

Junior
Aug 28, 2008
1,350
396
83
You get no argument from me on Brady being the best. I went into the game pulling for the Jags, just to see someone new in the SB, but after the Gronk head hit (which the safety seemed awfully proud of) I started pulling for the Pats instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LTHSALUM76

Penlight

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
2,091
1,043
113
I for one never found or considered Elway to be a “great” QB. Nor did I consider Phil Sims one either.
After having read an in depth article about Elway as a GM that went into detail about how is/has always been behind the scenes, I am glad I never warmed to Elway the player.
 

Penlight

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
2,091
1,043
113
BTW, I am a glad to see Brady succeed if for no other reason to quell the messiah like adulation for Peyton Manning
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cross Bones

LTHSALUM76

All-Conference
Aug 27, 2014
2,509
1,955
0
I for one never found or considered Elway to be a “great” QB. Nor did I consider Phil Sims one either.
After having read an in depth article about Elway as a GM that went into detail about how is/has always been behind the scenes, I am glad I never warmed to Elway the player.
A guy can be a jag and still be a great player. We have seen several of them. But when it comes to my judging whether a guy was a great player, I check personalities at the door. Being an a-hole is a different and separate conversation.
 

LTHSALUM76

All-Conference
Aug 27, 2014
2,509
1,955
0
You get no argument from me on Brady being the best. I went into the game pulling for the Jags, just to see someone new in the SB, but after the Gronk head hit (which the safety seemed awfully proud of) I started pulling for the Pats instead.
I wasn't pulling for the Jags, but that hit made me pull for NE more.
 

Penlight

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
2,091
1,043
113
A guy can be a jag and still be a great player. We have seen several of them. But when it comes to my judging whether a guy was a great player, I check personalities at the door. Being an a-hole is a different and separate conversation.
I didn’t consider him great when he played and I was in the dark.
Good yes, but not great.
Same as I saw Bob Griese, Jaworksi ...
 

LTHSALUM76

All-Conference
Aug 27, 2014
2,509
1,955
0
Agreed. Brady is great. Best ever? Not so sure. Having the greatest coach and football mastermind of all time definitely helps. I sometimes wonder how Brady would have done in the days of Elway and Montana when Quarterbacks actually got hit.
Can't really compare different eras. I learned to accept that in my Urlacher v Butkus debate. The game has evolved to protect QBs more now. It's impossible to say how Brady would have done back then. Impossible to say how Elway and Montana would do now too. I do know this much. Brady has played in more Super Bowls than Montana and Elway combined and if the Pats win, he will have won as many as the two combined. We won't see this out of another QB in our lifetimes.
 

spaghetti coach

Redshirt
Apr 11, 2017
6
4
0
The 85 Bears D would have Brady for lunch.

If the Bears were playing against the 1985 Patriots with Brady as QB, Bears still win.
If the 1985 Bears were playing against the 2017 Patriots, Patriots win hands down. You can't compare different eras. The 85 Bears defensive front four, with the exception of Perry probably averaged less than 265 pounds. Jay Hilginberg 259 pounds, Dan Hampton 264 pounds, Richard Dent 265 pounds, Wm. Perry 335 pounds.
The current Patriots offensive line averages approx 310 pounds. The current Patriot offensive line would manhandle the 85 Bears.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LTHSALUM76

LakeCtyNewt

All-Conference
Nov 13, 2002
8,149
4,612
63
Please please please stop trying to compare athletes from 30 years ago to the present.
 

jsoulis

Redshirt
Oct 27, 2015
31
15
8
Don't buy the "System" argument. How efficient would your "system" be with say a Jay Cutler quarterbacking it? It is like saying Michael Jordan was great due to the "Triangle Offense" not because of his talent and his will to win being superior to all.
 

vinuci31

Redshirt
Nov 28, 2009
65
34
0
Don't buy the "System" argument. How efficient would your "system" be with say a Jay Cutler quarterbacking it? It is like saying Michael Jordan was great due to the "Triangle Offense" not because of his talent and his will to win being superior to all.
Once again, not taking anything away from Brady, I merely saying he definitely has benefitted from playing in what is more than likely, other than Walsh in Frisco, the greatest "system" in the history of the NFL. No, I do not think Jay Cutler could execute the system. You definitely need a more cerebral QB.
 

greatgig13

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2014
2,369
2,754
0
If the Bears were playing against the 1985 Patriots with Brady as QB, Bears still win.
If the 1985 Bears were playing against the 2017 Patriots, Patriots win hands down. You can't compare different eras. The 85 Bears defensive front four, with the exception of Perry probably averaged less than 265 pounds. Jay Hilginberg 259 pounds, Dan Hampton 264 pounds, Richard Dent 265 pounds, Wm. Perry 335 pounds.
The current Patriots offensive line averages approx 310 pounds. The current Patriot offensive line would manhandle the 85 Bears.
The 85 Bears could do a better Super Bowl Shuffle and ride the gravy train for 30 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bronco man

foosball1

Redshirt
Oct 20, 2017
62
14
0
Can't really compare different eras. I learned to accept that in my Urlacher v Butkus debate. The game has evolved to protect QBs more now. It's impossible to say how Brady would have done back then. Impossible to say how Elway and Montana would do now too. I do know this much. Brady has played in more Super Bowls than Montana and Elway combined and if the Pats win, he will have won as many as the two combined. We won't see this out of another QB in our lifetimes.
I agree with you. I really was not trying to compare, just making the statement of wondering how he would have done with less protection with those QB's in that generation. I think they are all great athletes.
 

foosball1

Redshirt
Oct 20, 2017
62
14
0
I for one never found or considered Elway to be a “great” QB. Nor did I consider Phil Sims one either.
After having read an in depth article about Elway as a GM that went into detail about how is/has always been behind the scenes, I am glad I never warmed to Elway the player.
Simms, I agree. Elway, Disagree!
 

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,173
2,437
93
Lol... Yeah, he's not set up for success at all. Give me a break.

How many different OC’s have they had? If they system is so great? Why the the Coordinators of the system duplicate it where evern they go after leaving NE?