UK football can't be a training ground for new coaches.

zcats

Heisman
May 29, 2001
37,919
39,980
98
I agree with the OP. This job is too difficult for a first time HC unless he is really gifted. Over the past 50 years the only success UKFB had was under guys who were already successful HC's elsewhere with the exception of Mumme who was visionary but a weird bird. Look back: Curci, Claiborne and Brooks are the only guys who built the program up for a few years of success. They were all successful HC's at D1 level teams. I like Stoops but he was one of the only coordinators hired as a HC by a FBS level school the year we hired him. I really hope Stoops succeeds but if he doesn't we need to go find a guy like Brooks or Spurrier, past their prime but with a lot of juice and knowledge left in the tank.
 

Robcatt24

Heisman
Sep 17, 2005
17,932
16,767
113
What experienced coaches do you think we could have hired that are better?

Forgot the other guy on my list was Tommy Tuberville.

A proven winner in the SEC. Is doing well at Cincinnati.

Put Tuberville, Hudspeth, and Dykes names in a hat, and I would've been thrilled with whoever's name you pulled out.
 

LowCountryCat

Heisman
Apr 17, 2010
117,188
22,769
0
The 2 coaches I wanted were Mark Hudspeth and Sonny Dykes.

Hudspeth has several years under his belt as a head coach. He did 7 years at North Alabama, and has been the head man at UL Lafayette since 2011. He has intimate knowledge of the Deep South. Love his offense.

Sonny Dykes doesn't have the number of years as head coach as Hudspeth But he is an offensive minded coach, and I think that is the type of coach UK needs to win with.

And so far, he is doing well at California.

Yeah, I know. The head coaching experience these guys have is at non power 5 schools. But I think that experience is invaluable. Knowing how to be the guy in charge, running the program, making all the decisions. Very different world than being a coordinator. I think that would have benefitted Joker greatly, if he could have done some time as a head coach at somewhere like an OVC school.

Look, I know UK football doesn't have proven head coaches with winning records at the power 5 level beating down their door. And Stoops does have a great football pedigree. And Stoops may very well turn out to be a great head coach. Hope he does.

But you're seeing the result of his growing pains, on and off the field.

What is so deflating, is that with the level of excitement that Stoops' improved recruiting and the upgrade in the facilities has brought, losses like this one become even more of a gut punch.

I'm in no way advocating for Stoops to be fired. But I'm very interested in seeing if Stoops will act like more of a head coach after this season. By that I mean, shaking up his staff. I'm looking at Eliot and Schlaraman. The defense and OL have been putrid. And unlike most fans, I think there is more talent there than the performance has shown.

I'll say this. Losing close games to Florida and Auburn, while gut wrenching, is one thing. Looking like we did in Starkville. Like we don't even belong in the SEC. That will kill the support from this fanbase quicker than anything.
It was the last two Florida losses that did it for me. We almost had them last year, and we should have beaten them this year. Beating Florida is going to be the bellweather for this program actually turning the corner.
 

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,713
0
The 2 coaches I wanted were Mark Hudspeth and Sonny Dykes.

Hudspeth has several years under his belt as a head coach. He did 7 years at North Alabama, and has been the head man at UL Lafayette since 2011. He has intimate knowledge of the Deep South. Love his offense.

Sonny Dykes doesn't have the number of years as head coach as Hudspeth But he is an offensive minded coach, and I think that is the type of coach UK needs to win with.

And so far, he is doing well at California.

Yeah, I know. The head coaching experience these guys have is at non power 5 schools. But I think that experience is invaluable. Knowing how to be the guy in charge, running the program, making all the decisions. Very different world than being a coordinator. I think that would have benefitted Joker greatly, if he could have done some time as a head coach at somewhere like an OVC school.

Look, I know UK football doesn't have proven head coaches with winning records at the power 5 level beating down their door. And Stoops does have a great football pedigree. And Stoops may very well turn out to be a great head coach. Hope he does.

But you're seeing the result of his growing pains, on and off the field.

What is so deflating, is that with the level of excitement that Stoops' improved recruiting and the upgrade in the facilities has brought, losses like this one become even more of a gut punch.

I'm in no way advocating for Stoops to be fired. But I'm very interested in seeing if Stoops will act like more of a head coach after this season. By that I mean, shaking up his staff. I'm looking at Eliot and Schlaraman. The defense and OL have been putrid. And unlike most fans, I think there is more talent there than the performance has shown.

I'll say this. Losing close games to Florida and Auburn, while gut wrenching, is one thing. Looking like we did in Starkville. Like we don't even belong in the SEC. That will kill the support from this fanbase quicker than anything.
Very well said. Stoops needs to shake up his staff. Almost 600yards to any team is unacceptable
 

zcats

Heisman
May 29, 2001
37,919
39,980
98
I don't see a staff shakeup again. I think Stoops works with what he has or changes a position coach or two. He is on a 3 year clock. Elliot may move to the NFL or something like that but I don't see Stoops moving either coordinator out at this point.
 

Robcatt24

Heisman
Sep 17, 2005
17,932
16,767
113
You're totally right. We should have hired somebody who had a history of winning in a major conference. There were plenty to pick from. We didn't have to pick an up and comer with no high level experience or a veteran who'd failed. We just passed up all those proven winners who wanted the Kentucky job.

Tommy Tuberville was available.

Was hired by Cincinnati the same year we hired Stoops.

Of course, this is unsubstantiated, but there was supposedly talk behind the scenes that Tuberville was interested in the UK job. He wanted back in the SEC.

All water under the bridge. Stoops is our guy.

I do believe he needs to shake up his coaching staff.
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
19,284
38,796
113
Tommy Tuberville was available.

Was hired by Cincinnati the same year we hired Stoops.

Of course, this is unsubstantiated, but there was supposedly talk behind the scenes that Tuberville was interested in the UK job. He wanted back in the SEC.

All water under the bridge. Stoops is our guy.

I do believe he needs to shake up his coaching staff.
The same Tubberville who was out scored 28-7 against BYU in the second half two weeks ago? And the same Dykes who gave up 40 points and almost 600 yards to UCLA in blowout loss this week ?
 

Robcatt24

Heisman
Sep 17, 2005
17,932
16,767
113
The same Tubberville who was out scored 28-7 against BYU in the second half two weeks ago? And the same Dykes who gave up 40 points and almost 600 yards to UCLA in blowout loss this week ?

Compared to the same Stoops who lost to WKU? The same Stoops who Mississippi State gained the their second most yards ever against?

The same Stoops who didn't even force Georgia to punt last season? The same Stoops who had to fight for his life against UL Lafayette and EKU?

Do you realize how idiotic it makes you look when you pick one game, or in the Tuberville example you gave, one half to hold against a coach?

Weak.
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
19,284
38,796
113
Compared to the same Stoops who lost to WKU? The same Stoops who Mississippi State gained the their second most yards ever against?

The same Stoops who didn't even force Georgia to punt last season? The same Stoops who had to fight for his life against UL Lafayette and EKU?

Do you realize how idiotic it makes you look when you pick one game, or in the Tuberville example you gave, one half to hold against a coach?

Weak.
Tubberville has had many blowout losses at Cincy and his recruiting blows. Get a damn clue.
 

Robcatt24

Heisman
Sep 17, 2005
17,932
16,767
113
Tubberville has had many blowout losses at Cincy and his recruiting blows. Get a damn clue.

Yeah, he's only went 9-4 his first 2 seasons and is on track for another bowl this season.

And you don't want to get into an argument discussing blowout losses and UK football.
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
19,284
38,796
113
Compared to the same Stoops who lost to WKU? The same Stoops who Mississippi State gained the their second most yards ever against?

The same Stoops who didn't even force Georgia to punt last season? The same Stoops who had to fight for his life against UL Lafayette and EKU?

Do you realize how idiotic it makes you look when you pick one game, or in the Tuberville example you gave, one half to hold against a coach?

Weak.
A three week stretch last year for Bear Bryant Tubberville- 50-28 loss to OSU, a 41-14 loss to Memphis and a 55-34 loss to a crappy Miami team. Yeah, he is who UK needs. [laughing]
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
19,284
38,796
113
Yeah, he's only went 9-4 his first 2 seasons and is on track for another bowl this season.

And you don't want to get into an argument discussing blowout losses and UK football.
Anyone could win with his lame schedule at Cincy. It's a total joke.
 

Robcatt24

Heisman
Sep 17, 2005
17,932
16,767
113
A three week stretch last year for Bear Bryant Tubberville- 50-28 loss to OSU, a 41-14 loss to Memphis and a 55-34 loss to a crappy Miami team. Yeah, he is who UK needs. [laughing]

And last season UK lost...

LSU 41-3

Georgia 63-28

Tennessee 50-16

And just got reamed by Mississippi State.

Keep digging that hole. You're doing great.
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
19,284
38,796
113
Forgot the other guy on my list was Tommy Tuberville.

A proven winner in the SEC. Is doing well at Cincinnati.

Put Tuberville, Hudspeth, and Dykes names in a hat, and I would've been thrilled with whoever's name you pulled out.
Let's look at Dykes- he is even better!!!! 11-20 at Cal and 5-17 in the conference. This brilliant record includes such losses as 52-34, 55-16, 49-17, 62-28, and 63-13. I got to hand it to ya, you know coaching when you see it!!!!
 

Robcatt24

Heisman
Sep 17, 2005
17,932
16,767
113
Let's look at Dykes- he is even better!!!! 11-20 at Cal and 5-17 in the conference. This brilliant record includes such losses as 52-34, 55-16, 49-17, 62-28, and 63-13. I got to hand it to ya, you know coaching when you see it!!!!

LOL.

Dykes was 1-11 his first season. Went 5-7 in his second. Now at 5-2.

Yeah, I do know coaching.

You are making this too easy.

And that 11-20 you laughed at Dykes about? Same as Stoops. And Stoops has one less conference win than Dykes.

You're a lightweight. Move along. I need some heavy lifting.
 

englishmajor

All-Conference
Jan 2, 2007
5,358
1,167
0
The OP bolted after loss to Florida and said he wouldn't be back until an 8 win season...yet here the d-bag is again
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
19,284
38,796
113
LOL.

Dykes was 1-11 his first season. Went 5-7 in his second. Now at 5-2.

Yeah, I do know coaching.

You are making this too easy.

And that 11-20 you laughed at Dykes about? Same as Stoops. And Stoops has one less conference win than Dykes.

You're a lightweight. Move along. I need some heavy lifting.
What you can't wrap your mind around is the coaches you mentioned are no better than our current coach. Which clearly shows your knowledge of football is lacking- severely.
 

Robcatt24

Heisman
Sep 17, 2005
17,932
16,767
113
What you can't wrap your mind around is the coaches you mentioned are no better than our current coach. Which clearly shows your knowledge of football is lacking- severely.

You mean Tuberville, who has lead 3 different programs to bowl games?

You mean Hudspeth, who came into Lexington with a non power 5 team, and forced a more talented UK team to have to fight for its life right to the end?

You mean Dykes, who had California in the top 25 at one point this season, just 2 years after going 1-11?

You mean those coaches that I mentioned?
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
19,284
38,796
113
You mean Tuberville, who has lead 3 different programs to bowl games?

You mean Hudspeth, who came into Lexington with a non power 5 team, and forced a more talented UK team to have to fight for its life right to the end?

You mean Dykes, who had California in the top 25 at one point this season, just 2 years after going 1-11?

You mean those coaches that I mentioned?
Tubberville has done nothing at Cincy except benefit from a joke schedule. He also can't recruit jack. Hudspeth? Lol. So using your logic, UK should hire the EKU coach. As far as Dykes, he has won one more game this year than Stoops and has had mutilple blowout losses in his time at Cal. Face it- your list of coaches are no better than what UK has at the moment. That's the bottom line.
 

Robcatt24

Heisman
Sep 17, 2005
17,932
16,767
113
Tubberville has done nothing at Cincy except benefit from a joke schedule. He also can't recruit jack. Hudspeth? Lol. So using your logic, UK should hire the EKU coach. As far as Dykes, he has won one more game this year than Stoops and has had mutilple blowout losses in his time at Cal. Face it- your list of coaches are no better than what UK has at the moment. That's the bottom line.

If that's all you can come up with, then I win by TKO in the second round.

Still the defending champ.
 

Robcatt24

Heisman
Sep 17, 2005
17,932
16,767
113
I've changed my mind on my OP.

I don't think years of experience would help this coaching staff.