This is the problem. Wayne Turner is old. He's older than I am, and I'm not that young anymore. Wayne Turner hasn't been at UK for more than a quarter century now. Wayne Turner left Kentucky years before 9/11, just to anchor how long ago it was. If you are a Kentucky fan born in the last 30+ years you don't remember watching him play. What's the plan here, exactly? We shouldn't be waiting 40-50 years to honor these players or the fans who watched them won't be alive and the fans alive won't know who they are.
One of the few things that UNC does right is the way they have a system set up for very specific criteria for a player to get their name in the rafters. I don't necessarily agree with all of their criteria, but then it's not a voting contest. If I were in charge, I would make the following criteria (have to meet 1) that you automatically get your jersey in the rafters at Rupp:
NPOY - any of the recognized NPOY awards
Consensus first team All-American
Consensus SEC POY
If that were the standards, the following guys would have their jersey up:
Ralph Beard
Bob Brannum
Willie Cauley-Stein
Johnny Cox
Anthony Davis
Tony Delk
Leroy Edwards
Jack Givens
Kevin Grevey
Alex Groza
Cliff Hagan
Dan Issel
Kyle Macy
Jamal Mashburn
Ron Mercer
Cotton Nash
Tom Parker
Tayshaun Prince
Pat Riley
Forest Sale
Bill Spivey
Oscar Tshiebwe
Tyler Ulis
Kenny Walker
John Wall
I would also have 1 guy from each decade, as voted on by the players from that decade, have their jersey placed in the rafters that do not meet automatic criteria. These would be guys who either had really good careers or NCAA tournaments. It would look something like:
2010's - Malik Monk (this was the toughest of the group)
2000's - Keith Bogans
1990's - Jeff Sheppard
1980's - Melvin Turpin
1970's - Rick Robey
1960's - Louie Dampier
1950's - Frank Ramsey
1940's - Wah Wah Jones
1930's - John DeMoisey
1920's - Basil Hayden