I will repost what I said in another thread as to why improvement could be argued although the record in year 2 and 3 remained the same:
I have stated this before, and I understand where you are coming from, but I could argue that even though we didn't improve in the win column, that not losing more than last year was was a positive.
When you consider that we lost 2 NFL guys on defense and it didn't fall off that much, and was actually pretty good at times and considering the issues with the offense, that that showed improvement in itself. In years past, those losses would have killed us. Then, take into consideration that Hatcher was hurt/injured a good portion of the year, Lewis being lost for over half the season, Flannigan being hurt to start, and Reggie Meant missing significant time, then then it looks even better that we didn't digress defensively from last year, and could argue that that shows improvement in developing other guys.
When you look at the offensive side of the ball, consider the fact that we lost a really good OLineman, and a tackle where we have struggled at that in Miller, lost Hurd as a top RB, Demarco Robinson, Javiss Blue, and then throw in a new OC, surely one could see where they might struggle to find their way a little, and would take a step back. The offensive side of the ball lost a TON of experience and leaders along with their OC and was replaced by all young guys. We had Towles, Toth, and Swindle that are older than a sophomore that were starting and the only other ones in the 2 deep were JoJo, Timmons, and Horton. Now, I didn't foresee taking that big of a step back, but I think this is where Towles failed the most. He needed to be that unquestioned leader, but never asserted himself as that IMO. Of course, that is the outside looking in perspective, but I just didn't see it.
Now, with all that said, there are definitely things Stoops has to correct on many ends, including decision making. But, I think there was still improvement in some areas, and some steps taken backward in some areas. But overall, I see improvement. The second half downfalls I contribute more to lack of depth and on field leadership as much as anything. But, again, Stoops has to make some changes as well.