Hoosiers humiliate Illinois — and force college football to take notice

On a snowy night last December in South Bend, Curt Cignetti delivered a line that has clung to his program like a shadow.

“We beat the s*** out of top-25 opponents,” Indiana’s head coach declared — only to watch his team shoved out of the College Football Playoff hours later by eventual runner-up Notre Dame.

For nine months, that line hung over Indiana, easy ammunition for skeptics who believed last season’s breakthrough was illusion, not foundation. On Saturday night, the No. 19 Hoosiers finally offered a counterpoint.

Indiana didn’t just beat a ranked opponent. It eviscerated one, dismantling No. 9 Illinois 63-10.

The Hoosiers scored more points than any Big Ten team ever has against an AP top-10 opponent. They outgained the Illini 579–161, sacked quarterback Luke Altmyer seven times and allowed just two rushing yards. What began as a referendum on staying power became a spectacle of dominance.

“Dominant performance,” Cignetti said postgame. “They couldn’t stop us. They couldn’t match up on the perimeter. We broke their will and just pounded them … There’s no let-up in these guys.”

This time, it wasn’t bravado. It was reality.

Quarterback Fernando Mendoza looked like a star on a national stage, completing 21 of 23 passes for 267 yards and five touchdowns — the kind of line that plants a flag in the Heisman race.

Across the field, Illinois coach Bret Bielema could only shake his head.

“I’ve never really been a part of anything like that,” Bielema said. “We didn’t have any answers and they kept pouring it on.”

That it came against Illinois mattered. This was the first ranked meeting between these programs since 1950, hyped as a chance for the Illini to stake their own claim as a Big Ten dark horse.

ESPN’s “College GameDay” panel mostly picked Illinois. Analysts called the Illini the more physical team. The Hoosiers didn’t have to look far for fuel.

“Of course we know,” wideout Elijah Sarratt said. “People are always going to doubt. At the end of the day, we know what we’re capable of.”

The capability was evident before halftime. Indiana led 35-10 at the break. By the end, Illinois was finished in every way a football team can be finished.

When the rain came down in the second half — a sudden September downpour that soaked the 56,000 packed into Memorial Stadium — the crowd didn’t scatter. It sang. Towels and T-shirts spun in the floodlights. Fans roared with the delirium of people discovering not just joy, but permanence.

That’s what makes this different from last season. A year ago, Indiana crashed the playoff as a novelty act, dismissed as the product of a soft schedule. Then came the playoff loss, and the narrative hardened: fun while it lasted, not built to last.

Saturday night, that story cracked.

Illinois was no unprepared victim. Ranked ninth, fresh off a 10-win season, the Illini had circled this date for months. Indiana stripped them bare. No tricks, no miracles — just a methodical dismantling of a team touted as a contender.

For longtime IU fans, the symmetry was cruel. Bielema’s Wisconsin teams once hung 83 and 62 points on Indiana, dark markers of irrelevance. This time, the shoe fit the other foot.

The transformation under Cignetti is staggering. Twenty-two months ago, Indiana looked every part the nation’s losingest program. Now it is something else entirely: confident, physical, unrelenting.

“It just proves we can do a lot this year,” Sarratt said. “As long as we keep on doing what we do, the sky is the limit.”

“Nobody’s shocked with that result at all,” linebacker Aiden Fisher added. “We know we’re an elite football team.”

Cignetti, for once, didn’t need to say much. The man who last year styled himself as college football’s quote machine — “Google me,” “We’re the emerging superpower,” “Purdue sucks” — was measured Saturday.

Asked about the message his team sent to the nation, he shrugged.

“[The media] controls all that stuff,” he said. “I just got to get them ready and then we all play our games and see what shakes out at the end of the year.”

Then, glancing at his sports information director, he grinned.

“I want to, but I won’t.”

Restraint suited the moment. After all, the scoreboard had already spoken.

Before Saturday, Ohio State held the Big Ten record for most points against a top-10 team. Now Indiana does. Before Saturday, critics could still say Cignetti’s Hoosiers hadn’t beaten anyone of consequence. Now they can’t.

As fans streamed out into the Bloomington night — soaked, elated, loud — the warning was unmistakable.

Last December, Cignetti’s words rang hollow. Saturday night, they didn’t need to be spoken at all.

Not yet a member of TheHoosier?  Join our community for Just $1 for your first week and get a complimentary year of The Athletic included with your membership. Join here!

Use the code “IND20” on Rhoback.com for a generous 20% off for all new customers through the end of this week. Rhoback — Best Fit, Best Feel.