Newsstand: Where ESPN ranks Notre Dame QB CJ Carr among other freshman signal callers

There might not be a better first-year starting quarterback in college football than Notre Dame signal-caller CJ Carr. At least that’s what ESPN believes.
On Thursday, ESPN senior national recruiting analyst Tom Luginbill ranked the top freshmen (including redshirts) quarterbacks. Carr checked in at the top of the list.
“Carr is one of college football’s most poised quarterbacks regardless of class,” Luginbill said. “The redshirt freshman wasn’t the reason Notre Dame lost to Miami or Texas A&M — in fact, he kept the Irish in contention.
“Carr ranks seventh nationally in QBR (86.3) because of his decision-making and accuracy. He has lost just 25 yards on negative plays through five weeks and has done a remarkable job protecting the football, tossing 11 touchdowns to just two interceptions.
“The 6-foot-3, 210-pounder has the size and arm talent to make every throw, plus terrific mental toughness and competitiveness. The former No. 2 pocket passer in the ESPN 300, has the makings of a future top-five NFL draft pick.”
Luginbill’s review of Carr is the latest honor for the Irish passer from Saline, Mich. On Tuesday, he was selected to the Shaun Alexander Freshman of the Year Watch List. He is also climbing in the Heisman Trophy odds, tying for ninth according to BetMGM as of Wednesday.
Through five games, Carr has completed 88-127 passes for 1,280 yards and 11 touchdowns, while throwing just 2 interceptions. His 177.9 passer rating is also 10th in the nation.
Notre Dame Posts of the Day
The NC State vs. Notre Dame is a sellout.
Irish coach Marcus Freeman complimented redshirt freshman wide receiver Matt Jeffery in Thursday’s news conference.
Top 10
- 1Breaking
Schrauth injury
Notre Dame guard Billy Schrauth to miss multiple weeks with knee injury
- 2Hot
Behind The Ballot
As Notre Dame and Marcus Freeman ascend, Brian Kelly smolders
- 3
Media reaction
What they’re saying about Notre Dame’s 34-24 win against USC
- 4
Report Card
Grading Notre Dame football in 34-24 Irish victory over USC
- 5
Riley talks ND loss
Everything USC coach Lincoln Riley said after losing to Notre Dame football
Get the Daily On3 Newsletter in your inbox every morning
By clicking "Subscribe to Newsletter", I agree to On3's Privacy Notice, Terms, and use of my personal information described therein.
Irish redshirt sophomore defensive end Boubacar Traore is having a great bounce-back season after a torn ACL ended his 2024 campaign.
Notre Dame Quote of the Day
“I’m naming a lot of guys, but the reason why I got away from scout team player of the week, and really, player of the week, for our team is, I know I said this previously, it was just, continue to promote team. Like team glory, right? And it’s hard to just justify choosing one person that represents the player of the game or player of the week.”
— Freeman on why he does not give scout team player of the week and player of the game awards anymore.
Notre Dame Headlines of the Day
- Lucky Charms: Predicting a four-star pass catcher to ND
- Transfer tracker: Former ND OL Rocco Spindler one of the Big Ten’s best in Week 6
- Thursday Takeaways: ND’s Marcus Freeman applauds transfer portal revisions
- Continuity will only get ND men’s basketball so far
- Four questions with Lamar Mickey, father of former ND CB Jaden Mickey
- ND injury report: WR Jaden Greathouse downgraded to OUT vs. NC State
- Who will kick field goals for ND vs. NC State? Everything coach Marcus Freeman said Thursday
- ‘We’re starting to get home’: How ND pass rush broke through against Boise State
- ND keeping in close contact with 2027 four-star DL Tolo Tuihalamaka
- ND’s freshmen wide receivers still playing the waiting game
- Three Keys to the Game: Can ND avoid trap game against NC State?
- Country music star Luke Combs to hold concert at ND Stadium in 2026
- Irish Intel: Reflecting on ND QB battle, Cooper Flanagan impact, more
- Exclusive: Why five-star recruit Jacy Abii chose ND over Texas, LSU and other powers
- ND cornerback Leonard Moore wins multiple national awards for 2-INT game vs. Boise State
- Newsstand: ND hockey opens 2025-26 season at IceBreaker Tournament in Arizona