Check out how far WE ARE behind with NIL
- Thread starter PSUJam
- Start date
No Bama, Michigan, Clemson, or Georgia. This is why Saban is crying so much. NIL has helped a few schools (Tennessee, Miami, ATM) but it hasn’t hurt the big dogs yet. Curious to see if it ever will.
Cmon Penn St fans- give at least $10 per month to a favorite sport or 3. You get what u pay for (or don’t pay for). Cheap bastards
Michigan and Georgia are 13 and 14 in the article. Clemson and tOSU are "honorable" mentions. I think the big dogs are still using the brown paper bag technique and supplementing with NIL.
Yet not one of those schools in the Top10 are currently ranked ahead of PSU in the 2024 247 recruting rankings.
Yet. It'll take a few years to see who's who.
Couple of issues with this "reception::"
1. "Lions Legacy Club" has been replaced by "Happy Valley United" although the reality is in name only;
2. guessing that the goal of the reception is to raise money which will be distributed to athletes. If so
a. is this for football only?
b. there is supposed to be a quid-pro-quo relationship between the sponsor/donor and the athlete. Not abundantly clear that one exists here. If that's the case:
i. how does the money get distributed? Coaches' decision? Probably not the greatest idea.
ii. there may be some unforeseen tax implications for the sponsors/donors.
But why am I worrying? Kraft has this fixed.
I believe Lions Legacy Club is the football arm of Happy Vally United. Have to assume the money will be to support football only. Sport specific donations can be made on the HVU website. The rest is for lawyers to figure out, of which former player Stank is one.
I hate NIL.
Get a f*cking education and do the work.
Get a f*cking education and do the work.
I'm getting older, dumber, less interested, and won't even try to understand it.
Not sure that Stankewicz is an attorney, but, on further reflection, probably doesn't matter. Appears that PSU has decided that it's just going to outright pay players.
Actually, they are asking fans to outright pay the players. They keep the football money for themselves.
From a thread in the Den, it sounds like we'd be in great shape if we sold out to the Saudis.
I lowered my standards from making the playoffs to making a NY6 bowl when they started with NIL. This model of fan’s or boosters paying the tab is unsustainable. Until profit sharing is adopted, I will keep lowering my interest
F me. I had never given this any thought but it’s clear that it’s just a matter of time.
I give to psu but right now I give more to the north Myrtle beach high school. Go chiefs!
Not really. When revenue sharing comes, and it is in the near future, NIL isn't going away. So the Universities will be paying the players and there will still be a huge push for fans to contribute to NIL.
Except that NIL requires a quid pro quo i.e. the recipient has to provide something of value to the payor. So if a collective is simply pooling money and paying players based on instructions from a coach with nothing of commensurate value flowing back to the donor its the same as if donations to the athletic department were simply handed over to the players.
dude, if I could afford $10/month, I’d buy an On3 premium subscription
I hadn’t either. A school can go as far as their imagination takes with this stuff.
If it's deemed legal then why not? The boosters know where their money is going.
Why worry about NIL? All recruits care about is that you talk about ‘something’ and put people in the league….
Last edited:
Why worry about NIL? All recruits care about is that you talk about ‘something’ and put people on the league….
Oh dear.
I saw this yesterday morning. Can't read it because of the paywall but the headline is frightening.
Read it. It’s purely hypothetical and speculative. Not to say it couldn’t happen, but seems like most Saudi investment in sports is in teams/franchises - not players (save C. Ronaldo). They could be a massive disruptor but I don’t see them being interested unless maybe Notre Dame or USC. They’re not gonna want to watch their investments in Tuscaloosa.
NIL is purported to allow student-athletes to make money by allowing their names, likeness, etc. in endorsements, etc.
Hell! With tuition, room & board, fees, health insurance, Pell Grants, etc., they make more than I ever did in year working! And I paid for my own education at PSU.
Exactly why I've given up on trying to understand NIL.
Latest
-
01
BWI Football
Penn State has an identity problem. Matt Campbell knows fixing it starts with him
-
02
BWI Football
First Impressions from Penn State's embarrassing 34-13 loss at Northwestern
-
03
BWI Football
Penn State Defensive Film Thread: Reviewing the Gory Details of a 400-Yard Rushing Performance
-
04
BWI Football
How did Penn State's players perform vs. Northwestern? PFF Snap Counts & Grades
-
05
BWI Football
9 things I think after Penn State fails from start to finish at Northwestern: Will it somehow get worse before it gets better?