Immaculate Conception 33, Byron 14, FINAL

eaglepwr47

Freshman
Sep 19, 2026
84
94
18
I 100% agree with this sentiment. If you wanna be thought of as the best overall, then you can’t be slumming down in 3A or 4A.
Byron Vs IC is 2-3 all time. I don’t know why this is a debate of slumming it down in a smaller class. IC was far and away better this year but it was quite the contrary last year in favor of Byron. If IC was located in the same location as Rockford Lutheran or Sterling Newman would there be as much outrage over the boys from the city winning?
 

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
726
367
51
Byron Vs IC is 2-3 all time. I don’t know why this is a debate of slumming it down in a smaller class. IC was far and away better this year but it was quite the contrary last year in favor of Byron. If IC was located in the same location as Rockford Lutheran or Sterling Newman would there be as much outrage over the boys from the city winning?
Yeah, permanently move em to 4A because, uh, they’re a dynasty that’s won one title in the last seven seasons. Yeah but they’ve been to the finals in that same time… oh that would be one time also. But what about vs Byron? Well that would be 1-2 in the same time. Uh, but they were real good ten years ago. Okay, but they’re really good this year and they are winning a bunch of games and I think they are being mean to the other teams. Isn’t that enough reason to move em?
 

UIUC 17

Sophomore
Sep 20, 2018
231
197
40
Byron Vs IC is 2-3 all time. I don’t know why this is a debate of slumming it down in a smaller class. IC was far and away better this year but it was quite the contrary last year in favor of Byron. If IC was located in the same location as Rockford Lutheran or Sterling Newman would there be as much outrage over the boys from the city winning?
You don’t even have to go that far. No one seems to care that Aurora Christian is having success in 2A as a private. Surely the group also thinks they should’ve known they had a good team before the season started and should’ve petitioned up
 

Doctor_D

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2016
3,413
3,027
113
Byron Vs IC is 2-3 all time. I don’t know why this is a debate of slumming it down in a smaller class. IC was far and away better this year but it was quite the contrary last year in favor of Byron. If IC was located in the same location as Rockford Lutheran or Sterling Newman would there be as much outrage over the boys from the city winning?
Nah no outrage over this. I’ve been around long enough. IC is a pretty awesome team with a bunch of players that are fun to watch. There was some chatter in the past (mostly from fans) about teams like IC and/or Montini being one of the best regardless of class. In that case, you gotta move up and run that gauntlet and prove it.
I don’t blame them at all for playing in the class they’ve been assigned. It’s what 99% of all schools do. I have said that it would be more interesting to see them in 4A, but that should be obvious.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UIUC 17
Aug 7, 2024
1,209
756
113
I've noticed a few articles on Facistbook about the Private school situation in Illinois... They are rattling the sabers!!! But for a school like ICC, which plays 8A schools, its a complete joke to be in the 3A playoffs...
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4Afan

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,194
4,597
113
I've noticed a few articles on Facistbook about the Private school situation in Illinois... They are rattling the sabers!!! But for a school like ICC, which plays 8A schools, its a complete joke to be in the 3A playoffs...
I say we bring back football enrollment to determine classes for the playoffs. That would solve a lot of this.
 
Aug 7, 2024
1,209
756
113
I say we bring back football enrollment to determine classes for the playoffs. That would solve a lot of this.
I see what you are saying but private schools have 30 miles to recruit...There can't be an even playing field with the privates unless all are moved up into the 6A-8A classification. I personally think there will be a playoff separation soon! Schools that play 8A schools and then accepting to play in the 3A playoffs shows a lack of respect and gamesmanship!!!
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,194
4,597
113
I see what you are saying but private schools have 30 miles to recruit...There can't be an even playing field with the privates unless all are moved up into the 6A-8A classification. I personally think there will be a playoff separation soon! Schools that play 8A schools and then accepting to play in the 3A playoffs shows a lack of respect and gamesmanship!!!
There won't ever be a split. People from both sides will talk about it, people from both sides will demand it, but at the end of the day things will remain the same.
 
Aug 20, 2026
585
299
63
I see what you are saying but private schools have 30 miles to recruit...There can't be an even playing field with the privates unless all are moved up into the 6A-8A classification. I personally think there will be a playoff separation soon! Schools that play 8A schools and then accepting to play in the 3A playoffs shows a lack of respect and gamesmanship!!!
In order to send their kids to private schools, parents have to pay five figures per year on top of paying for the public schools that their kids don't attend. Each type of school has its own advantages.
 
  • Like
Reactions: k1867 and Colin2299

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,194
4,597
113
I'm curious about your use of "bring back." Was there a time that playoff classes were determined by football participation?
Football enrollment was whichever number was greater, your actual enrollment or the average enrollment of all of your opponents. That number determined your class for the playoffs. So teams like IC likely would have been playing in 5A or higher.

For a few years Morris was in a weird conference and despite an enrollment of around 900 they were in 6A due to playing larger schools all year.
 
Aug 20, 2026
585
299
63
Football enrollment was whichever number was greater, your actual enrollment or the average enrollment of all of your opponents. That number determined your class for the playoffs. So teams like IC likely would have been playing in 5A or higher.

For a few years Morris was in a weird conference and despite an enrollment of around 900 they were in 6A due to playing larger schools all year.
That's interesting. When did it stop?
 
Aug 20, 2026
585
299
63
Not about parents or money, its about 30 mile radius to recruit from...
Yes, for some people, it is very much about money. Despite what a lot of people on this board seem to believe, not all families have an extra $15,000 per child sitting around every year. They act like every family in a thirty-mile radius can go to any given private school, but for most of them, it isn't an option.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave Brody

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,194
4,597
113
Oh, bank on a separation... Like a freight train through a tunnel!!!
Hasn't happened in 50+ years of bickering, won't happen now. Here's why, no one cares what idiots like us on a message board think.

Coaches and administrators from both sides have had decades to submit some sort of a separation proposal, whether for playoffs or a complete break and no one has done it.
 
Aug 20, 2026
585
299
63
Hasn't happened in 50+ years of bickering, won't happen now. Here's why, no one cares what idiots like us on a message board think.

Coaches and administrators from both sides have had decades to submit some sort of a separation proposal, whether for playoffs or a complete break and no one has done it.
I just don't know how separation could ever be viable for private schools. There are (I'm guessing) roughly fifty private schools that play 11-man football in Illinois. It really limits the options to have more than a couple playoff classes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4Afan

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,194
4,597
113
I just don't know how separation could ever be viable for private schools. There are (I'm guessing) roughly fifty private schools that play 11-man football in Illinois. It really limits the options to have more than a couple playoff classes.
That's exactly what most people don't think about. How do teams like AC, Ottawa Marquette, and every other private school outside of Chicagoland play a full schedule? Then there's always every other sport to consider which no one ever does.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DirtySixThirty

Leggo24

Sophomore
Oct 6, 2018
218
125
31
You mean to tell me a school that recruits football players from all over the state beat a group of kids that reside in a town of 3,700 total people ?! Insane !!!
 
Aug 20, 2026
585
299
63
You mean to tell me a school that recruits football players from all over the state beat a group of kids that reside in a town of 3,700 total people ?! Insane !!!
Byron doesn't cost $15,000-$20,000 to attend, and it doesn't have to compete with several other schools for the football talent of its area. I'm not naïve enough to think private schools have no advantages, but it's disingenuous to imply that they have all the advantages.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
199
186
31
Byron doesn't cost $15,000-$20,000 to attend, and it doesn't have to compete with several other schools for the football talent of its area. I'm not naïve enough to think private schools have no advantages, but it's disingenuous to imply that they have all the advantages.

IC has to compete with Montini, Naz, st Francis and Fenwick. They also have overlap with some other ccl schools. People act like they can just get whatever kid they want. Between the cost of tuition, property tax and competition for kids it’s not that easy. That’s not even mentioning it the public schools they have to compete with. If IC was able to get whatever kid they wanted how did Joe Reif and Owen Roberts end up at York.


at the same time I don’t think it’s a flex to beat 3a schools if you are ic or Montini. You get getting kids from all over and are beating up on farm towns.
 

Doctor_D

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2016
3,413
3,027
113
Team like IC simply have much higher ceilings than the 3A publics; not to mention the rural private schools. I mean, I suppose it’s theoretically possible that some farm town of 4000 people is gonna produce a half dozen D1 football players that are all the same age, but it’s not exactly likely. If they did, there would probably be some kind of secret government laboratory nearby.

Anyway, every so often, the private school will put together a roster that approaches the ceiling, and that’s when even the top tier small town schools start receiving drubbings, and then things get testy. Althoff a couple years ago is a good example of this. They put together a squad of some dudes that were gonna play next level, including at least one who will probably be in the NFL soon. They proceeded to lap the field and then rubbed Lena’s nose in it over and over in the title game. So it certainly does happen to teams outside the CCL as far as “outrage”, to go back to a previous question.

With all that said, IC is perfectly fine playing in 3A because that’s where the rules say they belong. Maybe some schools will want to change the rules again… tbd. I have noticed more and more poster that identity as CCL fans remark that maybe some of their teams shouldn’t be in the smaller classes though.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SouthofI80Fan
Aug 20, 2026
585
299
63
Team like IC simply have much higher ceilings than the 3A publics; not to mention the rural private schools. I mean, I suppose it’s theoretically possible that some farm town of 4000 people is gonna produce a half dozen D1 football players that are all the same age, but it’s not exactly likely. If they did, there would probably be some kind of secret government laboratory nearby.

Anyway, every so often, the private school will put together a roster that approaches the ceiling, and that’s when even the top tier small town schools start receiving drubbings, and then things get testy. Althoff a couple years ago is a good example of this. They put together a squad of some dudes that were gonna play next level, including at least one who will probably be in the NFL soon. They proceeded to lap the field and then rubbed Lena’s nose in it over and over in the title game. So it certainly does happen to teams outside the CCL as far as “outrage”, to go back to a previous question.
That year, did Althoff win the recruitment battle with East St. Louis?
 
Aug 7, 2024
1,209
756
113
Hasn't happened in 50+ years of bickering, won't happen now. Here's why, no one cares what idiots like us on a message board think.

Coaches and administrators from both sides have had decades to submit some sort of a separation proposal, whether for playoffs or a complete break and no one has done it.
You have representatives chiming in on this... The state realizes multiplying schools hasn't helped!~ The days of burying one's head in the sand are over!~
 
Aug 7, 2024
1,209
756
113
Yes, for some people, it is very much about money. Despite what a lot of people on this board seem to believe, not all families have an extra $15,000 per child sitting around every year. They act like every family in a thirty-mile radius can go to any given private school, but for most of them, it isn't an option.
Hmmmmm Well its like the tribes in Africa... Until we got them to move out of the desert to where the food was, thousands died! Nothing grows in sand! You get it??? What does families and money have to to with private schools and a 30 mile radius and sports? Your statement belongs on Reddit not here son!~
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,194
4,597
113
Hmmmmm Well its like the tribes in Africa... Until we got them to move out of the desert to where the food was, thousands died! Nothing grows in sand! You get it??? What does families and money have to to with private schools and a 30 mile radius and sports? Your statement belongs on Reddit not here son!~
angry adam sandler GIF
 
  • Like
Reactions: DirtySixThirty

STIX815

Sophomore
Oct 4, 2021
110
114
43
Byron doesn't cost $15,000-$20,000 to attend, and it doesn't have to compete with several other schools for the football talent of its area. I'm not naïve enough to think private schools have no advantages, but it's disingenuous to imply that they have all the advantages.
Yes, they have to compete with other schools in their area, both public and private, I totally agree with that. Do you think that all 40-50 football players on the IC roster are paying for tuition?? If you think that the private schools aren't helping kids with tuition, that's incredibly naive.
 
Jul 3, 2025
817
785
93
Non-boundaried schools should be assigned the same class as the public district they reside in. They are pulling from the same pool of kids. In most cases a larger pool of kids than the public district. From there they can go up based on success. If non-boundaried thinks that’s too high a class they can petition down and let IHSA hear their case and decide. But you shouldn’t have non-boundaries playing in lower classes than the public district they are in.

Are you saying IC should be in class 8?
And QND should be in 6A/7A!?!?
Routt to 5A?!?!?
BCC to 7A?!?!

Get f***ed :LOL:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colin2299
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football Class 8A Semifinal Strengths/Question
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football Class 7A Semifinal Strengths/Question
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football Class 6A Semifinal Strengths/Question
  4. 04 Edgy Tim Football Class 5A Semifinal Strengths/Question
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football Class 4A Semifinal Strengths/Question