Anthony Davis or DeMarcus Cousins?

ORCAT

Heisman
Jan 6, 2003
24,802
12,253
113
Cousins is way too strong and moves very well for such a big man. Can also shoot from outside decently. Gotta go with him even though I love AD too.
 

kentucky_wildcat_#1

All-Conference
Aug 23, 2003
33,780
1,041
0
As much as i love Davis and his skillset on the basketball court, if we're talking a game of OneonOne with Cousins, i would probably have to give the knod to Cousins. Davis is a great defender and can handle the ball well, but even with Davis's elite defense in the post, no man alive is stopping Cousins when he has the ball in the paint. You can slow a guy like Cousins down inside, but you will never completely stop him. It's impossible. It would probably end up being a pretty close game. I just believe OneonOne Cousins would do a better job of slowing down Davis than Davis slowing down Cousins. It would be a lot of fun to watch!
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,602
7,295
113
Cousins,he is the Wilt ,Shaq combo that we haven't seen before.
Uh...no. Just no.

Cousins is a huge talent. But he's not even one of the ten best players in the league. So calling him a Wilt/Shaq combo is getting into the realm of the absurd.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,602
7,295
113
He is one of the ten best. He is probably the best big man in the NBA
LeBron, Curry, Durant, Westbrook, Chris Paul, Kawhi Leonard, James Harden, Blake Griffin, AD, Paul George. You take him over which of those guys (maybe Griffin, I'd say)? And that's not including other good players on successful teams (or teams that have been successful), like Draymond Green, Klay Thompson, Kyle Lowry, LaMarcus Aldridge, John Wall, Jimmy Butler, and Damian Lillard. And big guys like Marc Gasol and Al Horford have actually helped teams win. And Karl Towns looks likely to leap past him in terms of overall effectiveness, if not next year, very, very soon.

A lot of people on here want to just fall back on the "poor DeMarcus Cousins, stuck on a terrible franchise" stuff. But right now, Cousins puts up numbers on a terrible team- a team that's shown precious little improvement at any time during the 6 seasons Cousins has been there- while being one of the sloppiest players in the league. Spectacular at times? Yes. Dominant at times? Yes. But also a guy who turns it over a ton, fouls like crazy, takes a lot of bad shots, and has some huge defensive lapses. If he fixes some of that, then yeah, definitely top 10. But he hasn't yet.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dvillecatfan

wentzel25

Senior
Feb 13, 2006
3,896
560
0
LeBron, Curry, Durant, Westbrook, Chris Paul, Kawhi Leonard, James Harden, Blake Griffin, AD, Paul George. You take him over which of those guys (maybe Griffin, I'd say)? And that's not including other good players on successful teams (or teams that have been successful), like Draymond Green, Klay Thompson, Kyle Lowry, LaMarcus Aldridge, John Wall, Jimmy Butler, and Damian Lillard. And big guys like Marc Gasol and Al Horford have actually helped teams win. And Karl Towns looks likely to leap past him in terms of overall effectiveness, if not next year, very, very soon.

A lot of people on here want to just fall back on the "poor DeMarcus Cousins, stuck on a terrible franchise" stuff. But right now, Cousins puts up numbers on a terrible team- a team that's shown precious little improvement at any time during the 6 seasons Cousins has been there- while being one of the sloppiest players in the league. Spectacular at times? Yes. Dominant at times? Yes. But also a guy who turns it over a ton, fouls like crazy, takes a lot of bad shots, and has some huge defensive lapses. If he fixes some of that, then yeah, definitely top 10. But he hasn't yet.
I'd take him over Griffin, Paul and Harden, easily. It's hard to think of many more overrated players than CP3 in the past few years.
 

dallasg23

All-Conference
Aug 15, 2013
3,527
4,546
113
He is by far better than Griffin. Outside of being an good athlete, Blake Griffin isn't anything special as a basketball player. Paul George is washed up.
Chris Paul is a "has been". James Harden is the worst defensive guard in the league. I'm say he is a top 10 league player but your list isn't impressing much of any one. I'd take wade, and kyrie over Chris Paul and harden. Just based on the fact that there are several teams that have tried to get him through a trade shows that he is probably the most desired true 5 in the NBA. Very rarely is a true center ever going to be a top 10 player. There isn't a center in 10 you listed. I would say he is the best 5 in the game today
 

BBUK_anon

Hall of Famer
May 26, 2005
52,358
124,843
0
LeBron, Curry, Durant, Westbrook, Chris Paul, Kawhi Leonard, James Harden, Blake Griffin, AD, Paul George. You take him over which of those guys (maybe Griffin, I'd say)? And that's not including other good players on successful teams (or teams that have been successful), like Draymond Green, Klay Thompson, Kyle Lowry, LaMarcus Aldridge, John Wall, Jimmy Butler, and Damian Lillard. And big guys like Marc Gasol and Al Horford have actually helped teams win. And Karl Towns looks likely to leap past him in terms of overall effectiveness, if not next year, very, very soon.

A lot of people on here want to just fall back on the "poor DeMarcus Cousins, stuck on a terrible franchise" stuff. But right now, Cousins puts up numbers on a terrible team- a team that's shown precious little improvement at any time during the 6 seasons Cousins has been there- while being one of the sloppiest players in the league. Spectacular at times? Yes. Dominant at times? Yes. But also a guy who turns it over a ton, fouls like crazy, takes a lot of bad shots, and has some huge defensive lapses. If he fixes some of that, then yeah, definitely top 10. But he hasn't yet.

Dang...
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,602
7,295
113
He is by far better than Griffin. Outside of being an good athlete, Blake Griffin isn't anything special as a basketball player. Paul George is washed up.
Chris Paul is a "has been". James Harden is the worst defensive guard in the league. I'm say he is a top 10 league player but your list isn't impressing much of any one. I'd take wade, and kyrie over Chris Paul and harden. Just based on the fact that there are several teams that have tried to get him through a trade shows that he is probably the most desired true 5 in the NBA. Very rarely is a true center ever going to be a top 10 player. There isn't a center in 10 you listed. I would say he is the best 5 in the game today
How many top 10 players have never played on a team that's won more than 33 games? People are way, way, way too hung up on scoring and rebounding averages. How good did Kevin Love look statistically when he was playing on a sh** team in Minnesota? How good does he look now? 3 years ago, everyone would have said "hell yeah, Love is a top 10 guy", and now no one even considers him.

And of the main guys I listed, not one of their teams would trade that player straight -up for Cousins. He has a ton to prove.
 

OldEvilleCat

Heisman
Mar 1, 2009
4,851
22,003
0
Ima go with AD... better shooter, better defender...unless you're gonna let DMC bull his way down on the block. AD's got no chance if that happens.

How can you not go with AD....he took the fourth most shots on the 2012 team and was STILL the No. 1 pick!! (at least that's whut I heard)
 
  • Like
Reactions: LeonThe Camel

Aike

Heisman
Mar 17, 2002
75,464
46,468
90
He is by far better than Griffin. Outside of being an good athlete, Blake Griffin isn't anything special as a basketball player. Paul George is washed up.
Chris Paul is a "has been". James Harden is the worst defensive guard in the league. I'm say he is a top 10 league player but your list isn't impressing much of any one. I'd take wade, and kyrie over Chris Paul and harden. Just based on the fact that there are several teams that have tried to get him through a trade shows that he is probably the most desired true 5 in the NBA. Very rarely is a true center ever going to be a top 10 player. There isn't a center in 10 you listed. I would say he is the best 5 in the game today

This is a bizarre collection of takes. Chris Paul is still playing at an elite level, and Paul George is a long way from washed up.

I'm not even getting into the rest of it.
 

Shaudylo

Heisman
Apr 2, 2011
11,557
26,023
112
He is by far better than Griffin. Outside of being an good athlete, Blake Griffin isn't anything special as a basketball player. Paul George is washed up.
Chris Paul is a "has been". James Harden is the worst defensive guard in the league. I'm say he is a top 10 league player but your list isn't impressing much of any one. I'd take wade, and kyrie over Chris Paul and harden. Just based on the fact that there are several teams that have tried to get him through a trade shows that he is probably the most desired true 5 in the NBA. Very rarely is a true center ever going to be a top 10 player. There isn't a center in 10 you listed. I would say he is the best 5 in the game today
Paul George is washed up ? Ummm what?
 
  • Like
Reactions: GonzoCat90

LeonThe Camel

Senior
May 3, 2016
1,896
717
0
LeBron, Curry, Durant, Westbrook, Chris Paul, Kawhi Leonard, James Harden, Blake Griffin, AD, Paul George. You take him over which of those guys (maybe Griffin, I'd say)? And that's not including other good players on successful teams (or teams that have been successful), like Draymond Green, Klay Thompson, Kyle Lowry, LaMarcus Aldridge, John Wall, Jimmy Butler, and Damian Lillard. And big guys like Marc Gasol and Al Horford have actually helped teams win. And Karl Towns looks likely to leap past him in terms of overall effectiveness, if not next year, very, very soon.

A lot of people on here want to just fall back on the "poor DeMarcus Cousins, stuck on a terrible franchise" stuff. But right now, Cousins puts up numbers on a terrible team- a team that's shown precious little improvement at any time during the 6 seasons Cousins has been there- while being one of the sloppiest players in the league. Spectacular at times? Yes. Dominant at times? Yes. But also a guy who turns it over a ton, fouls like crazy, takes a lot of bad shots, and has some huge defensive lapses. If he fixes some of that, then yeah, definitely top 10. But he hasn't yet.
For comparison sake, his productivity is much like Kevin Love's. On a bad team, he is putting up all-star numbers.
 
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
This would be modern day Russell vs Wilt.

If there is no official, I'll go with Boogie, as I think he would bully his way to the rim. If there was an official, I might go with Davis.
In either case it is close, 51/49.
 

ScrewDuke1

Hall of Famer
Jul 29, 2016
41,589
155,854
113
He is by far better than Griffin. Outside of being an good athlete, Blake Griffin isn't anything special as a basketball player. Paul George is washed up.
Chris Paul is a "has been". James Harden is the worst defensive guard in the league. I'm say he is a top 10 league player but your list isn't impressing much of any one. I'd take wade, and kyrie over Chris Paul and harden. Just based on the fact that there are several teams that have tried to get him through a trade shows that he is probably the most desired true 5 in the NBA. Very rarely is a true center ever going to be a top 10 player. There isn't a center in 10 you listed. I would say he is the best 5 in the game today
Paul George washed up? I'm a pacers fan but thats definitely not true. That said, DeMarcus is a better player than Paul George, at least for right now he is.
 

Panthur

Heisman
Aug 5, 2008
9,225
12,782
0
Cousins is EASILY one of the ten best in the league. EASILY.

That said, Cousins complained in summer play before AD's freshman year that AD was blocking all his shots. It probably wasn't 1 on 1 and he was probably being complimentary. But as we all got to see shortly thereafter, he probably wasn't being all THAT complimentary.

I'm definitely not saying AD would surely take Boogie. I just wouldn't be too confident about counting AD out with that nasty defense and lately a little beef too, not even in a best of ten.
 

fatguy87

All-American
Oct 8, 2004
13,764
9,093
0
For comparison sake, his productivity is much like Kevin Love's. On a bad team, he is putting up all-star numbers.

They were both prodigious on the glass and in scoring per game, but Love was more efficient. Love turned it over less times per 48 and had a better shooting efficiency.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,602
7,295
113
For the record:

DeMarcus Cousins, 2015-16.

Real Plus/Minus- 14th in average, 15th in wins
PER- 12th in PER, 15th in value added, 15th in wins added

Probably because of these things:

Cousins led the league in fouls.
Cousins was 5th in the league in TO's, behind only Harden, Westbrook, Wall, and Rondo. All guys who, I think it's safe to say, handle the ball a hell of a lot more than Cousins.
Cousins had an effective FG% that was good for 96th in the league, which sandwiches him in between De'Angelo Russell and Deron Willliams, and puts him a few spots ahead of Carmelo Anthony (another guy who's spent his career putting up stats). That's while being a 6'11" tank who led the entire league in FG attempts per game (more than Harden, which doesn't seem possible, but is true. And Harden, BTW, shot .493 from 2 pt range compared to Cousins' .473. And hit 3 threes a game. And dished out 7.5 assists per game). Cousins did that on a 33 win team.

Cousins was named 2nd team All-NBA, which could be translated into him being viewed as a top 10 player, except for this interesting fact: DeAndre Jordan (a guy I haven't even mentioned) was named to the 1st team, ahead of Cousins. What does that tell you? People see the word "team" and usually take that to mean that they're naming the best guy at each position, even if those guys aren't really part of the top 5, or top 10 players in the league.

People act like I'm throwing out some huge insult to Cousins by saying I don't think that he's one of the 10 best players in the world. That's just wrong. I don't question that he's an all-star. I don't question that he has the capability to be the best big guy in the league. I just don't think you grant him that status because of his scoring and rebounding average without looking at the things he does that might help explain why Sacramento hasn't even come within 15 games of a .500 record while he's been there.

And please remember how this started. Someone said that DeMarcus Cousins, 2nd team All-NBA, never received an MVP vote in his life, was a combination of Wilt and Shaq.
 

Blueaz

Heisman
Jul 7, 2009
28,072
30,262
113
LeBron, Curry, Durant, Westbrook, Chris Paul, Kawhi Leonard, James Harden, Blake Griffin, AD, Paul George. You take him over which of those guys (maybe Griffin, I'd say)? And that's not including other good players on successful teams (or teams that have been successful), like Draymond Green, Klay Thompson, Kyle Lowry, LaMarcus Aldridge, John Wall, Jimmy Butler, and Damian Lillard. And big guys like Marc Gasol and Al Horford have actually helped teams win. And Karl Towns looks likely to leap past him in terms of overall effectiveness, if not next year, very, very soon.

A lot of people on here want to just fall back on the "poor DeMarcus Cousins, stuck on a terrible franchise" stuff. But right now, Cousins puts up numbers on a terrible team- a team that's shown precious little improvement at any time during the 6 seasons Cousins has been there- while being one of the sloppiest players in the league. Spectacular at times? Yes. Dominant at times? Yes. But also a guy who turns it over a ton, fouls like crazy, takes a lot of bad shots, and has some huge defensive lapses. If he fixes some of that, then yeah, definitely top 10. But he hasn't yet.
wow...what did he do to you?
every NBA expert I have seen speak on him and his talent, would disagree with you.
but you keep hatin...
 

fatguy87

All-American
Oct 8, 2004
13,764
9,093
0
wow...what did he do to you?
every NBA expert I have seen speak on him and his talent, would disagree with you.
but you keep hatin...

There is no question that Cousins is a top 10 talent. Top 10 in production is an entirely different matter.
 

Gary4UK

All-American
Jun 20, 2004
27,816
6,385
0
LeBron, Curry, Durant, Westbrook, Chris Paul, Kawhi Leonard, James Harden, Blake Griffin, AD, Paul George. You take him over which of those guys (maybe Griffin, I'd say)? And that's not including other good players on successful teams (or teams that have been successful), like Draymond Green, Klay Thompson, Kyle Lowry, LaMarcus Aldridge, John Wall, Jimmy Butler, and Damian Lillard. And big guys like Marc Gasol and Al Horford have actually helped teams win. And Karl Towns looks likely to leap past him in terms of overall effectiveness, if not next year, very, very soon.

A lot of people on here want to just fall back on the "poor DeMarcus Cousins, stuck on a terrible franchise" stuff. But right now, Cousins puts up numbers on a terrible team- a team that's shown precious little improvement at any time during the 6 seasons Cousins has been there- while being one of the sloppiest players in the league. Spectacular at times? Yes. Dominant at times? Yes. But also a guy who turns it over a ton, fouls like crazy, takes a lot of bad shots, and has some huge defensive lapses. If he fixes some of that, then yeah, definitely top 10. But he hasn't yet.
You place those guys in the middle and if Cousins were in there, I wouldn't want to be them.... They wouldn't want to be them... Cousins is the best center in the world right now, you can't talk that off.... Davis is another, but a different kind.... He is the best center when it comes to team basketball.... Davis will get you a championship.....
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,602
7,295
113
You place those guys in the middle and if Cousins were in there, I wouldn't want to be them.... They wouldn't want to be them... Cousins is the best center in the world right now, you can't talk that off.... Davis is another, but a different kind.... He is the best center when it comes to team basketball.... Davis will get you a championship.....
Let me get this straight. Cousins is the best center in the world right now- but he doesn't really help you win games?

I swear to God, some people completely lose sight of what a basketball player's #1 goal should always be: To help his team win. Period. Not to score the most points, or get the most rebounds, or lead the league in any specific thing. And yes, scoring a lot of points and grabbing a lot of rebounds can contribute towards winning, but turning the ball over, fouling a lot, and taking a lot of crap shots tends to contribute to losing. So that stuff counts just as much.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,602
7,295
113
You said James Harden was better and he wasn't on the 1st 2nd or 3rd team this year so what is your point ?
10 guys received at least 1 top 5 vote in the 2015-16 NBA MVP voting. James Harden was one of them (he finished 9th overall in the voting), DeMarcus Cousins was not. And of course, there was 14-15 (still pretty relevant to discussing a player's value, unless you have the attention span of a gnat), when Harden finished 2nd behind Curry.

The guy I responded to said that pretty much anyone who knows anything about the NBA thinks Cousins is a top 10 player. My point is that there's no evidence that they think that, especially not when they name DeAndre Jordan first team All-NBA ahead of him, and when Cousins has never received a single MVP vote (while every single one of the guys I mentioned has). I tend to believe they think of Cousins the same way I do- a huge talent with huge flaws that need fixed (or at least amended) before anyone can seriously discuss him as being among the absolute best player in the game.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR KSR Staff Predictions: Kentucky vs. Indiana
  2. 02 KSR Around the SEC Kentucky vs. Missouri will Determine Final SEC Championship Game
  3. 03 KSR Women's Basketball PREVIEW: Kentucky WBB hosts familiar face as Marshall comes to HMC
  4. 04 KSR KSR Show, 11/20: Live from the Lexington Marriott City Center
  5. 05 KSR Basketball KSR GAMEDAY: Kentucky takes on Indiana in must-win for Wildcats