Update on Smoot & DB Position

dawgs.sixpack

Redshirt
Oct 22, 2010
1,395
0
0
Questions: what happens with Smoot if Mullen leaves after next season? He pretty clearly would not be a hire that Mullen would make if he was not an MSU football alum. So would the AD push for the next coach to keep him on? Is that the kind of hire we need to be making when looking longer term? Just curious what yall think.
when most coaches leave, there is usually a total staff turnover unless someone from within in promoted. but even then there is usually a little turnover. for years msu fans have wanted a coach with msu ties, that loves msu, and would rather coach at msu than texas or florida or bama or whatever powerhouse program might come calling if he succeeds. now we are worrying about a potential position coach because he's a die hard bulldog, alum, a vocal supporter of the program, and a former NFL star, because hypothetically, what happens when the HC may or may not leave? i get that there might be some concerns over hiring smoot (is he willing to put in the hours? would his camp performance translate to full time coaching? etc), but worrying about what would happen if/when mullen may or may not leave in the future shouldn't even be a concern.also, those worrying about his motivation, there are tons of former NFL players who made millions who have gone on to be very hard working dedicated coaches. from the HC level in the NFL down to HS assistant coaches. if a guy is interested in coaching and wants it, the amount of $$ he has in the bank isn't going to change his dedication to the job.
 

DerHntr

All-Conference
Sep 18, 2007
16,209
3,714
113
when most coaches leave, there is usually a total staff turnover unless someone from within in promoted. but even then there is usually a little turnover. for years msu fans have wanted a coach with msu ties, that loves msu, and would rather coach at msu than texas or florida or bama or whatever powerhouse program might come calling if he succeeds. now we are worrying about a potential position coach because he's a die hard bulldog, alum, a vocal supporter of the program, and a former NFL star, because hypothetically, what happens when the HC may or may not leave? i get that there might be some concerns over hiring smoot (is he willing to put in the hours? would his camp performance translate to full time coaching? etc), but worrying about what would happen if/when mullen may or may not leave in the future shouldn't even be a concern.also, those worrying about his motivation, there are tons of former NFL players who made millions who have gone on to be very hard working dedicated coaches. from the HC level in the NFL down to HS assistant coaches. if a guy is interested in coaching and wants it, the amount of $$ he has in the bank isn't going to change his dedication to the job.

My point about what you do with him if Mullen leaves is valid because this is MSU we are talking about. We have a tendency to let coaches become bigger than the program and an alum like Smoot is a great candidate for that to happen. A good ol boy hire has its negatives and Smoot is no exception.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

JacobMc

Junior
Dec 16, 2012
257
254
63
We need a coach (I don't care if it's a DB coach or a mexican shortstop!) who brings REAL experience to our defense and can recruit football players with speed and the skill set to defend the spread...we obviously suck at that! Smoot is a "sizzle" choice...we need the steak too! If Dan wants to bring Smoot in as a GA to rev up the team with all his smack and swagger, fine, but we need to revamp this defense! I would have put Wilson IN THE ROAD! Texas A & M, Ole Miss and now Auburn are going to be running the spread (with others to follow!) and we presently look silly defending it!!
 

LTblows

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
1,902
22
38
Well we'll consider it a move to unite both fanbases then. Smoot's hire will be a win-win for the State. Thanks for your support.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
My point about what you do with him if Mullen leaves is valid because this is MSU we are talking about. We have a tendency to let coaches become bigger than the program and an alum like Smoot is a great candidate for that to happen. A good ol boy hire has its negatives and Smoot is no exception.

So what if Mullen leaves?

Did we let Melvin Smith become "bigger than the program" because he got to stay @ MSU on multiple staffs? Maybe you can link me to another assistant that has undergone this phenomenon of being bigger than the program? So, ultimately -- you are afraid of his potential success here. After all, the coaches that "became bigger than the program" were our ALL TIME GREATEST COACHES -- and they certainly didn't ascertain that status overnight. So, let's be gunshy about Smoot if chosen...because he's a popular choice and 10 years down the road we "may" be afraid to get rid of him? A good ole boy hire? Really?

I can only imagine what some here would have reacted as a fan when Dana Holgersen brought in a 28 year-old Kliff Kingsbury to Houston -- with nothing but a failed professional career on his resume. Oh, but he's 33 now and head coach at his alma mater Texas Tech -- the youngest HC in bigtime college football -- after putting together 3 straight lights-out nationally prominent offenses in three vastly different styles of play and recruiting as well as anyone in the country.

Fact - We can hire NO ONE that would have a greater immediate impact with recruits than Fred Smoot would.
Fact - We can hire NO ONE that would love MSU more -- and be able to sell that love better than Fred Smoot.
Fact - We can hire NO ONE who can coach emotion and effort better than Fred Smoot -- something everyone complained about us lacking this year. Who out there would be better in this regard?
Fact - Losing Melvin appears nationally to be a huge blow to us. Banks and Slay give Melvin the credit for their development. You've now got Auburn thinking they have shots at all our CB recruits(Ramsey and Alexander) -- as well as Conner and Kailo. Seriously. Go check their boards. The best possible way to offset this perception is to bring in his biggest and best protege.

I'll trust Mullen to make the best possible hire for MSU with whatever he chooses to do -- He's the only one that has all the information at hand.
 

DerHntr

All-Conference
Sep 18, 2007
16,209
3,714
113
So what if Mullen leaves?

Did we let Melvin Smith become "bigger than the program" because he got to stay @ MSU on multiple staffs? Maybe you can link me to another assistant that has undergone this phenomenon of being bigger than the program? So, ultimately -- you are afraid of his potential success here. After all, the coaches that "became bigger than the program" were our ALL TIME GREATEST COACHES -- and they certainly didn't ascertain that status overnight. So, let's be gunshy about Smoot if chosen...because he's a popular choice and 10 years down the road we "may" be afraid to get rid of him? A good ole boy hire? Really?

I can only imagine what some here would have reacted as a fan when Dana Holgersen brought in a 28 year-old Kliff Kingsbury to Houston -- with nothing but a failed professional career on his resume. Oh, but he's 33 now and head coach at his alma mater Texas Tech -- the youngest HC in bigtime college football -- after putting together 3 straight lights-out nationally prominent offenses in three vastly different styles of play and recruiting as well as anyone in the country.

Fact - We can hire NO ONE that would have a greater immediate impact with recruits than Fred Smoot would.
Fact - We can hire NO ONE that would love MSU more -- and be able to sell that love better than Fred Smoot.
Fact - We can hire NO ONE who can coach emotion and effort better than Fred Smoot -- something everyone complained about us lacking this year. Who out there would be better in this regard?
Fact - Losing Melvin appears nationally to be a huge blow to us. Banks and Slay give Melvin the credit for their development. You've now got Auburn thinking they have shots at all our CB recruits(Ramsey and Alexander) -- as well as Conner and Kailo. Seriously. Go check their boards. The best possible way to offset this perception is to bring in his biggest and best protege.

I'll trust Mullen to make the best possible hire for MSU with whatever he chooses to do -- He's the only one that has all the information at hand.

Fact: we can hire no one with greater impact on recruits? I think you confuse facts with your opinion. No one. Seriously think about that. Smoot is the absolute best recruiter possible to hire for MS kids in your mind and has never done it before. Think about that for a second longer.

I agree he would love coaching at MSU. No doubt there.

Also, no one else can coach emotion as good as Smoot. Ok. Sounds logical.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

skb124

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2008
1,270
0
0
Man I would have loved Joe Lee Dunn as DC this year. The last time we had two lock down corners under him it worked out pretty well for us. When you have lock down corners you gotta trust them and bring pressure. Not sit them in a zone where they can't do anything.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
Fact: we can hire no one with greater impact on recruits? I think you confuse facts with your opinion. No one. Seriously think about that. Smoot is the absolute best recruiter possible to hire for MS kids in your mind and has never done it before. Think about that for a second longer.

I agree he would love coaching at MSU. No doubt there.

Also, no one else can coach emotion as good as Smoot. Ok. Sounds logical.

Until you can name someone that would be better for the role, you are strictly being confrontational for the sake of that alone. So, throw some names out there on who is better and why?

Show me someone who comes in on day 1 with more cache with MS highschool football recruits -- as well as kids around the country? Can you?

Yes, I am positive that Fred Smoot would be an absolute lights-out recruiter. Explain to me why he wouldn't be? Recruiting is no different than building relationships -- also known as the ability to quickly and deeply connect with people. I've never met anyone in my lifetime that is better at that than Fred Smoot -- and it doesn't matter the person either -- black, white, young, old, etc... It's not some entirely different game that he's got to learn to play -- He's just got to be himself, and he would be great at it.

Name someone who you are positive CAN coach emotion better than he would that we can bring in? Name me a player that "coached" it better while he played here? I'll make it easy for you -- there hasn't been any.
 

esplanade91

Redshirt
Dec 9, 2010
5,656
0
0
Fact: we can hire no one with greater impact on recruits? I think you confuse facts with your opinion. No one. Seriously think about that. Smoot is the absolute best recruiter possible to hire for MS kids in your mind and has never done it before. Think about that for a second longer.

I agree he would love coaching at MSU. No doubt there.

Also, no one else can coach emotion as good as Smoot. Ok. Sounds logical.

I don't think anyone can do anything but speculate one way or another. Positive and negative.

But look at Mirando, minus his departure. He was way too young and inexperienced to be a position coach, especially in the SEC. He also didn't play wide receiver. Granted, as a quarterback he knew the position and that's not uncommon (Tee Martin). What Mirando brought was youth and excitement to the WR position. The players loved him. His demise was getting drunk at night in the Cotton District, hitting on 19 year old girls, and telling every Tom, Dick, and Harry MSU's business.

Was it an awful hire? Not really. Here are the facts and you can make whatever conclusion you wish:

Smoot has more knowledge of the position he'd coach for us.

Smoot has played the position he'd coach before at a high level.

Smoot is a figure most 18 year olds we recruit now are familiar with, and Mirando wasn't (it was his first college coaching gig, no knock).

Smoot went to MSU, is older, and has a family... So the likeliness of him going out, getting drunk, hitting on 19 year olds, and telling people who don't need to know our business things and could possibly hurt us by doing so are very low vs. Mirando, who had no emotional connection to MSU.

... I really like the upside of Smoot. We do gamble the downside of him not knowing what the hell hes doing but unless we hit a home run like Brewster I see us just going and getting another young guy like Mirando who gives us the same gamble. Smoot is a good guy, and if he didn't work out I think he'd be ok with leaving. See Felker.
 

Tds & Beer

Redshirt
Jan 26, 2010
1,082
0
0
If Mullen decides that hiring Smoot could possibly be really good for the program, and Smoot is interested, hire him as a GA while he finishes his degree in the Spring. Let him have the title of GA but coach the corners. After the spring, assess the job that he did. How hard is he willing to work? How serious is he about doing a great job. Is he past the wild party days? Sit back, look at the entire semester as a job interview, and go from there.
 

was21

Senior
May 29, 2007
10,013
637
113
Billy Stacy played QB at State back in the '50's or 40's...maybe we could hire him as a QB corch.
 

DerHntr

All-Conference
Sep 18, 2007
16,209
3,714
113
So I have to name potential candidates who in my OPINION refute your FACTS. That is retarded.

Hell Ed Oregeron (in my opinion) is a better, proven recruiter than Smoot. There's a name for you. I like that word proven.
 

was21

Senior
May 29, 2007
10,013
637
113
It means what it says. The ***** incident with whores...great representative of the university...go 17 off.
 
Last edited:

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
So I have to name potential candidates who in my OPINION refute your FACTS. That is retarded.

Hell Ed Oregeron (in my opinion) is a better, proven recruiter than Smoot. There's a name for you. I like that word proven.

So, all you can come up with for a potential candidate is a guy who is DEFENSIVE/RECRUITING COORDINATOR and DL coach at the UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA -- who is making $650k @ USC -- or more than double any of our assistants -- and we should be able to get him to come back to Mississippi as our CORNERBACKS COACH?

Wow. Ed Orgeron. Why don't we bring in Gruden as OC and Saban as DC as well? We like proven around here**

I listed reasons why I think Fred Smoot is the best guy for our spot. You don't like Smoot -- you've disagreed about my opinion -- yet you have named NO ONE that would be better or even anyone whose name should logically be mentioned! Sorry, but that isn't a compelling argument. I'm open to whoever Mullen thinks is best for the program.. But if those here are going to be against Fred Smoot, they should at least look deep enough to support someone else...
 
Last edited:

JJs Frustration

Redshirt
Aug 29, 2012
104
0
0
Yeah you *****

So I have to name potential candidates who in my OPINION refute your FACTS. That is retarded.

Hell Ed Oregeron (in my opinion) is a better, proven recruiter than Smoot. There's a name for you. I like that word proven.

Keep crying a river
 

Koldfire

Redshirt
Sep 15, 2012
558
0
0
Smoot's wife would probably never move to Starkville and smart enough not to send him unaccompanied. I would hope that he recognizes that he would be the star of the minstrel show and find it insulting.
 

DAWG61

Redshirt
Feb 26, 2008
10,111
0
0
When Texas scored 3 td's on long scoring plays because JLD went all out blitz each time I was done with his blitzing schemes. If he was DC this year we wouldn't make a bowl game. We would however save money on socks for coaches.
 

War Machine Dawg

Redshirt
Oct 14, 2007
2,832
24
38
Welcome, Crxxms. Glad to see you're still so concerned with "churructer." Maybe if we'd had a few more characters and a little less "churructer" our D might've actually stopped a JR High offense this year and we could've won more than 8 games.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
It means what it says. The ***** incident with whores...great representative of the university...go 17 off.

Lulz



As position coach:
- just landed the #1 overall JUCO prospect @ DT
- will land the #1 overall HS prospect @ sDE
- MAY land the #1 overall HS wDE
- MAY land the #4 overall HS sDE
- MAY land the #22 overall HS sDE
 

FISHDAWG

Redshirt
Dec 27, 2009
2,077
0
36
yeah ... well we won the game and have not had such a defense since .... it's the opposite of bend but don't break .... haven't had it since , but nice opinion there Nostradamus
 

DAWG61

Redshirt
Feb 26, 2008
10,111
0
0
We won the game? You sure about that Nostradamus? Texas had Ricky Williams and beat our *** in the Cotton Bowl.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
Love to hear the Kang`s take on this. If Jackie says he`d be good I`m in

Wednesdays on head2head isn't it? Would be a good question to ask...

Also, apparently Eric Moulds just finished his degree... keep an eye on that as well. No idea how good Moulds would be as a coach. His time @ MSU was a bit before I became interested as a kid, and I've never met him personally...
 

houstonutsack

Redshirt
Sep 23, 2012
158
8
18
Per Paul (24/7), Smoot has 9 hours from getting his degree and is finishing it up in the spring. Also, as long as a person is en route to getting their degree, they can couch.
I think we need someone who can coach not couch.
 
Nov 12, 2007
26,210
10,364
113
This might be the most ridiculous thread I have read all season. You guys putting down the Smoot act like if we hire him he would be a permanent figure on our team. Like ever other coach on Mullen's staff, he would have to show results to be kept.

As far as ability to coach, I have heard some really good things about what Smoot did during the summer from people who actually have a little bit of perspective and heard nothing but accolades on what he did at our camps.

IF Dan thinks it is a good idea and Smoot is game I would be all behind him getting a position on the staff. I sincerely doubt he would be made a full position coach without a degree unless the people who get paid to run our athletic staff thought there was a good reason to. I would think he would fit more as a good assistant to show what he can contribute and how he can recruit.

Some folks just need the opportunity to show what they really have to offer and what they can really deliver.
 

JJs Frustration

Redshirt
Aug 29, 2012
104
0
0
This might be the most ridiculous thread I have read all season. You guys putting down the Smoot act like if we hire him he would be a permanent figure on our team. Like ever other coach on Mullen's staff, he would have to show results to be kept.

As far as ability to coach, I have heard some really good things about what Smoot did during the summer from people who actually have a little bit of perspective and heard nothing but accolades on what he did at our camps.

IF Dan thinks it is a good idea and Smoot is game I would be all behind him getting a position on the staff. I sincerely doubt he would be made a full position coach without a degree unless the people who get paid to run our athletic staff thought there was a good reason to. I would think he would fit more as a good assistant to show what he can contribute and how he can recruit.

Some folks just need the opportunity to show what they really have to offer and what they can really deliver.

WTF is wrong with you? This post is full of logic. How in gods name could something on this board and on this subject make absolute sense. You should be banned for making a post that goes against the masses and actually makes sense for our program. How dare you.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,551
3,163
113
Hopefully Mullen will give Smoot a try. I'm not sure how he can teach the game, but he certainly could play. In fact, I think he was better at corner than Banks is. But things in the past tend to seem better than current things due to time; that could be affecting my opinion.

And why does a position coach need a degree? Seems the ability to play and teach would be sufficient. It's not like he's teaching nuclear physics .... And I can't think of a person who would be a better recruiter. Smoot has the personality for it.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State PFF Grades from 41-9 loss to Auburn
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Lopsided analytics illustrate Mississippi State's collapse against Auburn
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Not good enough": Jeff Lebby answers questions of performance and job security following blowout loss to Auburn
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Rapid Recap: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State