BB: Minimum Results that will make you Happy or content

How far does UK basketball have to go in the NCAA Tournament to make you feel happy or content with


  • Total voters
    129

JayEzzy

Junior
Oct 31, 2023
186
299
61
With Noah hurt I think the best case scenario is just making the tournament as an 12th seed. I'm a huge critic of Pope and didn't like the injury excuse the past two seasons but if Noah is out an extended period of time I think you'd have to give Pope another year.
Depends on the injury. If it’s something that lingers and looks like it will drag into next year, go ahead and give him a couple extra years. Not difficult to squint your eyes and imagine a world where everyone stayed healthy and pope is gunnin for his third straight title in 2027.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: RunninRichie

0r1c

Senior
Jan 4, 2026
294
708
93
It wasn’t a strawman argument or an argument at all but an example of how ridiculous some of you are. There is no lowering of standards.

A poll from twenty years ago wouldn’t look any different than it does today. Maybe a little worse.
"Championship or bust every year, or I'm going to a message board to whine like a baby."

Painting the people you oppose as whining babies because we don't win a title every year is the definition of a straw man.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Son_Of_Saul

SenseMaker_Cats

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,250
6,604
113
The amount of people putting sweet sixteen is very concerning. Nobody should be happy or content with sweet sixteens, especially in Pope's third year.
I think the part you’re not grasping is that for the standards to be lowered, they would have had to be higher in the past. Those poll numbers would look like that most any year.

Even going into years we think we’ll be elite, there would still be folks voting sweet sixteen. That’s how it’s always been.
 

Son_Of_Saul

Hall of Famer
Dec 7, 2007
45,946
102,121
113
My benchmark may be a little too low, but I'm a realist in the NIL era. Too much turnover, too many kids playing for the money and not the university, the fans or their teammates. That said...

I expect, at a minimum:
An Elite 8, once every FOUR years
An SEC Regular Season Championship, once every FOUR years and Top Five in the SEC EVERY year
An SEC Tournament Championship, once every FOUR years and to make the weekend EVERY year
At least a 4 seed entering the NCAA tournament EVERY year
To land a consensus Top 10 HS player, once every TWO years
To land a consensus Top 20 Portal player EVERY off-season

I don't think a singular outlier means mash the "Burn it to the ground and start over" button if those goals aren't reached, but they create cause for concern. Start stacking them up together, for a couple seasons in a row, then the panic is warranted. Regardless of who the coach is, whether we are a one and done NBA farm club or a transfer portal payday stop or something in between, we have to be consistent. A mediocre program doesn't sell itself well to recruits regardless of the history if they can't win games year after year.

We are UK, championship or bust every year or I’m going to a message board and whine like a baby all day. Who’s with me?

63%
11 years
He’s 54
Mark Poop

Let’s go guys. If we don’t repeat this in every thread our standards are DONE!!
Did you guys know that from 1939 (the first NCAA tourney) until 2019, UK went to 38 Elite Eights in 80 years. That's an Elite Eight almost half the time. That's the historic average before Cal's last few years.

That's not an unreasonable standard for an 80 year sample size. So UK fans expecting an Elite Eight every other year is actually the UK standard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chroix and BBUK

Cattorney

Senior
Dec 2, 2024
493
403
63
The expectation for this specific season is not the same as the expectation for the program in general. If you can't wrap your head around that it's on you.
But that's literally the standard you've set now. Setting it for 1 is literally lowering the standard. And it hasn't just been 1 season.
 

SenseMaker_Cats

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,250
6,604
113
Did you guys know that from 1939 (the first NCAA tourney) until 2019, UK went to 38 Elite Eights in 80 years. That's an Elite Eight almost half the time. That's the historic average before Cal's last few years.

That's not an unreasonable standard for an 80 year sample size. So UK fans expecting an Elite Eight every other year is actually the UK standard.
I agree. Which I why I was making fun of the below statements:

“But it does keep getting lowered when fans become happy or content with an E8. You're saying we are okay with that. That's who we are now. UK 20 years ago would have never been okay with E8s.”

“We are UK, where E8s are the standard!”

To that dude, that means that’s all you WANT.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Son_Of_Saul

Cattorney

Senior
Dec 2, 2024
493
403
63
Did you guys know that from 1939 (the first NCAA tourney) until 2019, UK went to 38 Elite Eights in 80 years. That's an Elite Eight almost half the time. That's the historic average before Cal's last few years.

That's not an unreasonable standard for an 80 year sample size. So UK fans expecting an Elite Eight every other year is actually the UK standard.

I agree. Which I why I was making fun of the below statements:

“But it does keep getting lowered when fans become happy or content with an E8. You're saying we are okay with that. That's who we are now. UK 20 years ago would have never been okay with E8s.”

“We are UK, where E8s are the standard!”

To that dude, that means that’s all you WANT.
That makes an E8 the minimum expectation, not the standard.

We didn't get 8 NC and 17 F4 appearances on having an E8 standard.
 

PastorofMuppets82

All-Conference
Mar 4, 2025
739
1,607
93
Did you guys know that from 1939 (the first NCAA tourney) until 2019, UK went to 38 Elite Eights in 80 years. That's an Elite Eight almost half the time. That's the historic average before Cal's last few years.

That's not an unreasonable standard for an 80 year sample size. So UK fans expecting an Elite Eight every other year is actually the UK standard.
I mean it is splitting hairs but there were only 8 teams in the NCAA tournament from 1939 - 1950 so you were automatically in the Elite 8 (it actually wasn't even called that yet, but semantics) if you made the tournament. 4 of those "Elite 8's" were during this time and two of our National Titles. Then it expanded to 22 teams in 1953, Then fluctuated between 22 and 25 teams (1962) until it was expanded to 32 teams in 1972. 1985 it expanded again to 64 teams. 2011 it expanded again to 68 teams. And now we are up to 76 teams.

The run you have to go on to get to the Elite 8 is getting more and more convoluted as the field continues to expand. The chances you run into a team built the right way to give you problems is higher and get bumped earlier. I'm super proud of our past, but Rupp's ghost isn't landing us recruits and Joe B isn't coaching the defense down the stretch. Mitch fought the NIL change so hard that he put us well behind the 8-ball and it will take a very concerted effort to play catch up, regardless of the money we have available.

The date everyone needs to give an HONEST look at is June 30th, 2021 when NIL went into effect. It changed the game, and it changed what UK was. We haven't won a Regular Season SEC Title, an SEC Tournament Title, or made it past the Sweet 16 since NIL went into effect. We have two first round exits, two second round exits, and a sweet 16.

I'm also a realist, as I stated, my minimum requirements aren't that high of a bar. And neither Cal nor Pope has reached it since NIL started at UK. If we can consistently make my bare minimum requirements, then I'll raise the bar to something closer to what the UK standard is. Cause whatever we are currently, is neither.
 

SteamboatStoops

Sophomore
Jul 12, 2023
48
193
33
I have seen the future and it's the year 2200 and robo Mark Pope has won 150 titles in a row. Just gotta give him more time guys dont be so negative!
 

PoopiusMaximus

Redshirt
Sep 18, 2026
3
4
0
The days of UK's glory are fleeting. Soon, they will be butt a distant memory. Very sad.

***
I am Poopius Maximus. commander of my own faculties, and a loyal servant to the pangs of my arse. Farter of a massive turd, ****-stained for a miserable life. And I will keep shitting my pants, in this life or the next.
 

SenseMaker_Cats

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,250
6,604
113
The days of UK's glory are fleeting. Soon, they will be butt a distant memory. Very sad.

***
I am Poopius Maximus. commander of my own faculties, and a loyal servant to the pangs of my arse. Farter of a massive turd, ****-stained for a miserable life. And I will keep shitting my pants, in this life or the next.
I don’t think they’re banning anyone anymore. Honest question. Why create yet another account?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: chroix

SenseMaker_Cats

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,250
6,604
113
Gotta admit this made me laugh but also gave me a hint of who you are or were before turning into the professional account creator.

You didn’t answer my question though.

LOL. Reverse Blumpkin was a hilarious story told on the old site circa 2007 or so.
 

Wayne Dougan

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2025
463
1,329
93
It depends.

Go like 27-4 in the regular season and just have a real off shooting night in the sweet 16 and lose -> I'll be fine. I'll be pissed but fine.

Go like 24-7 in the regular season and lose a squeaker to the 1-seed in the elite 8 -> I'll be fine. Also pissed, but fine.

Go like 22-9 and then route teams on your way to the Final Four and lose on a buzzer beater in semis? -> I'll reluctantly say it was slightly below fine. But still pissed.

Go 18-14 and win the finals by 15. -> I'll take the banner but I'll still be pissed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chroix

CRZ4UK

Heisman
Jun 6, 2008
5,295
10,486
103
Elite Eight or Pope needs to be relieved of his duties. If you can't do that in 3 years at UK with our resources then you're never going to be good enough to be here long term.
With our resources?? That myth was busted yesterday with the article saying we have no resources. That’s why Mitch is gone and J Batt is here. Mitch never attempted to raise money for NIL. He didn’t believe in it. We are so far behind we can see our own butts.
 

CRZ4UK

Heisman
Jun 6, 2008
5,295
10,486
103
I’m tired of Mark Pope always having double figure losses! He had a handful of games where he completely got blown out that Nashville game was embarrassing.
Calipari had double digit loses every year since NIL began except one. Since NIL took effect. UK has one season without double digit loses except one 8 loss season. Thank Mitch Barnhart and his NIL stance for that. Not the coaches.
We haven’t been able to recruit difference makers since NIL began.
 
Last edited:

ORCAT

Heisman
Jan 6, 2003
24,745
12,149
113
Put me in the "it's more about the season than the tournament," crowd. Crazy things happen in the tournament. Gotta be good during the season and look like an SEC contender.
Championship titles mean the most to me. For those of you saying you don't care about the tournament but more about the regular season I truly question why. We never add any more titles to our current total of 8 by not caring about the tournament. The tournament is the only determining factor to add championships. Guess I care more about championships than all time wins total. Please explain why you don't.
 

ORCAT

Heisman
Jan 6, 2003
24,745
12,149
113
Damn, I never knew UK played for E8s. I seem to remember that exact argument when Cal would lose in the E8. Seems like it's safe to say the standard has officially been lowered by the fans.
The question by OP was the "minimum". Of course we want championships but no school gets them every year other than UCLA in the 60's. Minimum of Elite 8 at least gets us in the area of winning more titles.
 

Cattorney

Senior
Dec 2, 2024
493
403
63
The question by OP was the "minimum". Of course we want championships but no school gets them every year other than UCLA in the 60's. Minimum of Elite 8 at least gets us in the area of winning more titles.
Minimum results that will make you happy or content.

If snd E8 is that, the UK fans are now content with E8's. That's the standard now then.
 

ORCAT

Heisman
Jan 6, 2003
24,745
12,149
113
Minimum results that will make you happy or content.

If snd E8 is that, the UK fans are now content with E8's. That's the standard now then.
Sorry, seems like you just don't understand. No one is happy if all we ever get to in Elite 8 but if we were to get to Elite 8 this year I would say that is the minimum people would be satisfied with for this year. I didn't take the OP's post as a question for all time moving ahead, just this season for Pope and crew. That's my final attempt to explain this to you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SenseMaker_Cats

Feral Manatee

Sophomore
Sep 27, 2022
54
118
32
I would just like to get back to watching enjoyable basketball. Something that hasn't occurred in several years. Basketball, college and pro, has been damn near unwatchable lately. Too many threes, poor defensive play and inconsistant officiating has really dragged basketball down.
I was hopeful after Pope's first season that we would have a specific approach and offensive and defensive philosophy that used metrics and data analysis to maximize efficiency. A modern approach that would be at the cutting edge of modern basketball. For year two, either he wasn't able to successfully recruit the players that would fit this approach or he bewilderingly chose a bunch of square pegs for round holes. Regardless, it was a lost season. This year he has assembled a roster that seems to be closer to a right "fit" for what I thought was his philosophy, but it's still probably short of what is needed to succeed at the level we expect at UK. I'll hope that we significantly outperform expectations this year, but I think it's more likely that we're going to be facing some serious soul searching late April of 2027 about the future of this program.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football SEC Availability Report: Kentucky will be without DL Jamarrion Harkless vs. Texas A&M
  2. 02 KSR Cats in the NBA A former Kentucky MBB staff member is now the Cleveland Cavaliers GM
  3. 03 KSR Basketball Big Blue Madness tickets sold out in less than 30 minutes
  4. 04 KSR Podcasts 11 Personnel: Luckett's Play Sheet for Texas A&M
  5. 05 KSR Football Kentucky vs. Texas A&M: National Media Takes